News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
[dead]
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by specialist on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:20PM (#25410398)
Cancel Culture most resembles consumer boycotts, circa 80s and 90s. Both brands and influencers are targets of opportunity, have no real power.

I'll be more impressed when critics target the aggregators, platforms.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by mellosouls on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:14AM (#25418438)
Consumer boycotts tend to target corporations rather than the lives and careers of individuals.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by specialist on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:36PM (#25420413)
Why are they targeting the influencers and not the advertisers? Because that's the only target of opportunity. They'd target the advertisers, eg like the dump Rush campaigns of old, if they could.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by mellosouls on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:55PM (#25420715)
Except they choose to destroy people they disagree with rather than countering their arguments; it's a completely different phenomenon, aptly described in its 50s McCarthyite form in The Crucible, which has little relevance to consumer boycotts then or now, but describes contemporary Cancel Culture perfectly.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by specialist on Monday December 14, 2020 @12:57PM (#25420762)
I agree. I'm explaining, not defending.

How does the counter information strategy work? Anti Limbaugh people have tried fact checking, mocking, discrediting, etc. The only thing that seems to have tempered his show is attacking his advertisers.

Imagine you really oppose Rachel Maddow or Alex Jones. How would you negate their influence?

I don't know any popular new style influencers on the left. So let's say Ben Shapiro and Carlos Masa (because I have no better idea). How would you bounce them?

The only angle of attack I can think of is a smear campaign.

The only successful campaign I know of is Milo. My take is the Mercers got sick of his schtick. So maybe attacking patrons, which are a different kind of advertisers, works too.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by Fauntleroy on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:56AM (#25407940)
Ah, Hacker News. The victim complex runs deep in this gaggle of nerds who have rarely, if ever, been exposed to real hardship or discrimination.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by mellosouls on Monday December 14, 2020 @08:53AM (#25417477)
Ad-hominem attacks: the last refuge of those without actual arguments.

I note also that you know nothing about me; that sort of insult is normally used by those without much actual life experience.

This is because those who know the world is complicated and full of many types of people tend not to assume the background of those they disagree with, and certainly aren't normally arrogant enough to make claims about how hard life is on the other side, excepting perhaps, when they themselves are projecting somewhat.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:50AM (#25407342)
Curious if you include right-wing personalities who try and get "progressives" or "liberals" fired from their jobs in the great group of Cancellers, you may be interested in the doctrine of the preferred first speaker.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by konjin on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:25AM (#25407649)
And if the communists of the 50s ever got in positions of power they would have opened gulags and murdered millions.

The point is that we aught to trust our institutions to keep that from happening without acting like the people who we are supposedly saving society from.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by mellosouls on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:04AM (#25407452)
Oh, there are undoubtedly bad actors on both sides, but I don't think there is reasonable doubt about where the vast majority of contemporary behaviour we are talking about - the pressure to obey the diktats of self-elected social arbiters at risk of career etc - comes from.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by zzzeek on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:17AM (#25407570)
Anytime one starts to type the words "bad actors on both sides" it's time to step back and try to be more honest with oneself. One of the "sides" here has been trying to "cancel" the votes of 80 million Americans to install a permanent autocratic government. If Rosanne losing her tv show is equally concerning to you as that, again, time to step back and think a little more.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by konjin on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:35AM (#25407738)
Taking that to it's logical conclusion, who would you think the good actors were on the Eastern Front.

The Nazis who had just started a genocide of millions or the Soviets, who had just finished their third genocide of millions?

>Side? I am on nobody's side, because nobody is on my side, little orc.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:49PM (#25408407)
That kind of throwing up your hands and exclaiming "they're all corrupt" is a necessary step in the escalation of political violence and the ascendency of authoritarian regimes.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by AnimalMuppet on Sunday December 13, 2020 @02:32PM (#25409379)
No. Not unless you absolutely need one authoritarian to fight another authoritarian, as we needed Stalin to fight Hitler. If you're not in that situation, though... darn right I oppose both Stalin and Hitler.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:39PM (#25410562)
I don't think we needed Stalin to fight Hitler, in many ways the fact that they decided to (euphemistically) 'share a border' helped contribute to the start of WWII. The street combat that led to the NSDAP's seizure of power was closely tied to fear of foreign communist influences. I really don't know how you would argue humanity needed either of them... even one in opposition to the other (with the added caveat, I know, that the Eastern Front was where the substantial proportion of German casualties occurred -- how much is Stalin? Impossible to say, futile to guess in my view).
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by AnimalMuppet on Sunday December 13, 2020 @06:41PM (#25411642)
We didn't need Stalin to fight Hitler in 1936. Maybe not even in 1938. By 1941, we sure did. (If we had stood up to Hitler in 1936, the world would have been a lot better off.)

Back to the larger argument. Declaring "they're both corrupt" is appropriate if, in fact, they are both corrupt.

Are they both corrupt? As both mellosouls and throwaway9980 pointed out, the Democrats did their absolute best to cancel the results of the 2016 election. Can we say that both of those are bad? If not, why not?

And if you say that the Republicans are worse because, first, it's now, and second, because they're using more extreme methods, I would agree with you on both grounds. But are you against trying to overturn elections? Or are you against Republicans? Which is it?

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @06:57PM (#25411756)
I must admit I'm a little stymied by your claim that " the Democrats did their absolute best to cancel the results of the 2016 election." Their actions -- if they do indeed rise to the level of "cancel[ing] the results of the... election" pale in comparison to the shenanigans we're witnessing now. Can you please be more specific? I'm against any attempt at overturning elections, and I'm not aware of any such acts by any of the Democratic officials I voted for or follow closely. EDIT: hopefully you remember how quickly Clinton conceded, and how that still has not happened this year. There's evil to see anywhere you look hard enough, but it's a fairly simple task to weigh them.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by AnimalMuppet on Sunday December 13, 2020 @07:24PM (#25411953)
Well, there was "he didn't legitimately win, because Hillary won the popular vote". That's just talk, though, not actual action, but it undermines the legitimacy of the election in peoples' minds. Then there was impeachment on, bluntly, very political grounds rather than legitimate reasons. It wasn't like the beginning of the movement to impeach Nixon during Watergate. This time was just looking for some chance, any chance, to accuse him of something, to try to remove him. That seems to me clearly to be "attempting to cancel the results of the 2016 election".

Yes, I remember that Clinton conceded quickly. Trump should have done so as well, at the latest three days after the election. It's over, it's been over, and it's going to stay over.

But Trump is absolutely making a fool of himself by continuing to fight, and in the process he is damaging the norms that keep this creaking democracy functioning. So far, he hasn't gotten anywhere because people (who nominally should be on his side) haven't gone along with his BS - from the governor of Georgia, to the Supreme Court justices he appointed.

I worry, though, that next time it will be worse - that people will be willing to go along. And I worry about that for the left, not just for the right. In fact, I worry about it somewhat more for the left. The right has (some) people who believe in the rule of law, and things like "originalism". The left has (some) people who believe in the "living" constitution, and judicial activism. I worry that if, say, President Harris tries to follow this same playbook in 2024, some on the left in positions of power will be more willing to go along than some on the right have been in 2020.

On the other hand, there are far too many people who are still following what I can only call a cult of personality around Trump. They worry me on the right. If they haven't come to their senses by 2024, and Trump runs again...

So, yeah. Trump is at the moment worse. I oppose his attempt to remain in power, and I am delighted at how others have refused to play along. But I worry about both the right and the left in the future. Within the next 20 years, I think it's likely that someone will try this again.

Biden has the chance, maybe, to strengthen our institutions and repair some of the damage. Or he has the chance to continue to try to make them more partisan, but in the opposite direction of the last four years. Will he be wise, or just political?

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @07:52PM (#25412104)
"it undermines the legitimacy of the election in peoples' minds" In other words, the EC is sacrosanct and uncriticizable? This statement alone suggests to me that I should stop typing.

Impeachment was on the grounds of national security, not partisan poltics. At least one Republican Senator agreed. You can beg to differ.

Originalism is exclusively a fantasy based in the observer's desires and perceptions of what they think the Framer's would have wanted. It would be better if we prioritized the actual values of liberty, justice, etc, and the real outcomes of government policy we can all observe, instead of what we would like to believe people who have been dead for centuries may have believed. Wouldn't they likewise have worried more about solving the problems they faced in the present?

The Constitution is a living document whether we'd like to accept that or not. It is fundamentally not the same as it was in the beginning, and it is a changeable document. Originalism from, my perspective, is almost always leveraged to maintain institutional control in the hands of a small, wealthy, and white group. We'd only have white landowners voting, after all, if the Constitution never changed.

I'm curious if you think that letting the Senate stand as an unchanged institution, for example, without ever adding more states as we have in the past to resolve political impasses, will lead to less of a partisan divide or more. What will happen in 20 years, when government has continued to be paralyzed by an Upper House that will fundamentally not accept the legitimacy of its opposition, as I have seen personally under Mitch McConnell (let's be clear, they cannot be seen to negotiate with a black man, otherwise they will be primaried)?

You keep suggesting that Democrats are somehow going to turn into a different party than they are, while not producing evidence, all the while the GOP continues its slide into rank despotism. The House Minority leader himself signed onto the absurd Texas lawsuit. I have seen no evidence that voters who participate in the Democratic primary will tolerate any degree of the election disruption that GOP leadership repeatedly rams down our throats (again, to save their skins in their gerrymandered districts).

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by konjin on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:09PM (#25409738)
That kind of throwing up your hands and exclaiming my corrupt side is better than your corrupt side is a necessary step in the escalation of political violence and the ascendency of authoritarian regimes.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:35PM (#25410522)
I'll keep that in mind the next time the same party as always tries to invalidate the votes of Detroit and other major metropolitan centers...
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by konjin on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:42PM (#25410590)
I'm not sure why you only want to blame the Democrats:

https://newrepublic.com/article/159946/blue-states-suppress-...

Voter suppression is a two party problem and needs a two party solution.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @05:14PM (#25410901)
It's unfortunate that the article you linked leads with a headline citing vague "blue states" but then only talks about NY's (a single state) parochial, extremely outdated electoral system. If the author was trying to argue that both parties engage in voter suppression on the same scale, they did not provide nearly enough evidence to offset the rampant discrimination GOP state legislatures engage in every cycle.

Yes, NY should update its voting codes. So should nearly every red state (and blue states should get ahead of the curve and implement RCV or other similar measures)

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by gnusty_gnurc on Sunday December 13, 2020 @01:30PM (#25408820)
So we’re told Trump was trying to take over the Supreme Court yet oddly all his appointments dismissed the fraud case. Odd how these monsters seem to have acted completely sanely. It’s almost like they’re judges and liberals are liable to catastrophizing like any human.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @05:16PM (#25410925)
So, if someone says they want to be a tyrant and are unsuccessful, no one should talk about how the wannabe tried in the first place? I don't understand, because to me, the fact that we can speak out in the first place and make noise about it is one of the main reasons tyranny is not likely EDIT: it is as if the miner strikes the canary dead for chirping
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by gnusty_gnurc on Sunday December 13, 2020 @08:55PM (#25412646)
I mean Obama invoked the WWI espionage act more than every president combined before him against journalists.

That’s tyranny too but liberals didn’t make as much noise as they do about Orange Hitler who’s led a pretty typical Republican presidency and managed to continuously piss off the war industry.

The same industry that’s kept us in a constant state of war for near 20 years because of their enormous sway over “respectable” presidents the liberal managerial class fawns over.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Monday December 14, 2020 @10:47AM (#25418840)
This is typical? Out of curiosity, how young are you? If you got an advanced degree, was it in STEM? I'm amazed you can say that. EDIT: to be clear, the Electoral College meets today, some states have to meet in secret because of threats of violence. That is unprecedented in modern history. Only a few nights ago, fascistic street gangs roamed the streets of the nation's capital, vandalizing African American churches and sparking random acts of violence. This is normal for you?
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by gnusty_gnurc on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:29AM (#25419420)
> fascistic street gangs

Are we talking Mussolini? Cause I think invoking fascism is debatable - at best it should be qualified. But the way you’re expressing it is sensational, as though you’re unable to critique your own viewpoint and leave the possibility that you’re wrong.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:44AM (#25419615)
You did your very best to not address anything I said. The fact that we live in sensational times does not make factual descriptions of events sensationalized. This is not normal.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by zzzeek on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:52PM (#25413694)
Trump sold $8bn of weapons to Saudi Arabia, in the face of huge opposition even from congress. Combine that with killing the Iran nuclear deal so the region is vastly less stable, war industry is doing just great.

Trump also allowed the Saudis to murder and dismember a US journalist with zero consequences.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by gnusty_gnurc on Monday December 14, 2020 @11:35AM (#25419501)
> Trump also allowed the Saudis to murder and dismember a US journalist with zero consequences.

I mean the Saudis are linked to 9/11 and Bush chose to launch into forever war in Iraq and Afghanistan.

It’s a fundamental element of the populist scepticism that “respectable” politicians are competent at anything.

And something like one murder is precisely the type of sickening academic response about decency that somehow is supposed to shield the decades of foreign policy mishaps, atrocities and incompetence.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by CyberDildonics on Sunday December 13, 2020 @02:12PM (#25409187)
He was very clear in what he was trying to do. Just because it didn't work doesn't mean he didn't try.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by cultus on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:25AM (#25407654)
Great comment. There's a pervasive lack of self-awareness among the right, manifesting as a pathological inability to empathize with individuals in other groups. Introspection can be painful at times, but it's necessary to be a morally full and content person.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by cambalache on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:48AM (#25407849)
Ironic username
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by throwaway9980 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @12:36PM (#25408303)
Yes and what’s described in the comment is what I wanted after the 2016 election! I thought the electoral college should have selected someone else, I thought Trump should not have been sworn in to office, and I wanted him removed on the first day. I honestly believed it might happen because it seemed like the only sensible thing.

This election fraud nonsense is payback. It’s awful that the right can’t see that this is terrible for everyone. It’s terrible that the left can’t admit that the same passions existed on their side after the 2016 election.

I don’t want to argue about which side is worse. I’m not trying to highlight hypocrisy. I’m simply saying that the eye for an eye mentality has us all stuck.

I’m hopeful that Biden does understand all of this. His demeanor throughout all of this inspires some hope. We need more people on both sides to follow his lead.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by mellosouls on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:39AM (#25407762)
it's time to step back and try to be more honest with oneself

I'm a leftist fwiw, so please don't condescend to me about being honest with myself - today's problem is from my wing of the political spectrum. It's shameful.

One of the "sides" here has been trying to "cancel" the votes of 80 million Americans to install a permanent autocratic government.

And the other side has spent 4 years trying to cancel a President they don't like elected by people they don't like.

See how we can both do that?

I think that's a red herring attempt to drag the topic away from the original point of social and cultural persecution.

It's extraordinary the way some people will do everything they can to deny the obvious - that the worst representatives of the left today are doing exactly the same as the right wing McCarthyites of yore.

It's long past time for those of us on the left who genuinely claim liberal values to own it.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by verylittlemeat on Sunday December 13, 2020 @10:54AM (#25407373)
Unfortunately much like the hysteria of "communists" being lost on McCarthyites in the 50s the same is likely for the "far right" on the left now.

They're literal Nazis, don'tcha know.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by lehi on Sunday December 13, 2020 @01:19PM (#25408708)
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by verylittlemeat on Sunday December 13, 2020 @02:21PM (#25409270)
Proud boys are literal nazis?
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by sedachv on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:57PM (#25410196)
Gavin McInnes has described the Proud Boys as a "drinking club," one that happens to march around in specific colored shirts. McInnes literally modeled the Proud Boys on the early years of the Nazi party.
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by jacobwilliamroy on Sunday December 13, 2020 @02:55PM (#25409578)
No not literal nazis. They're just fascist white supremacists. I don't understand why so many people dislike using "nazi" as a shorthand for "fascist white supremacists".
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by verylittlemeat on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:06PM (#25409709)
I'm reading the wiki on them (admittedly not the best or most unbiased source) and I don't really buy that they're white supremacists since among other things their leader is afro-cuban. But fascistic sure, I could see that.

Without playing the enlightened centrist card too strongly I don't see anything particularly more disturbing about the proud boys than I have from antifa. Of course antifa can't be accused of being fascistic since their name is literally "anti-fascism" and if you call yourself anti facist then obviously it is impossible to be a fascist.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by bitwize on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:40PM (#25410025)
What should disturb you is that there were far more deaths caused by right-wing terrorists than by left-wing terrorists in the past year, like, by a factor of 20 or 30.

So no, the violence is not equal on both sides. One side is, objectively, worse. White supremacy and neofascism are the biggest threats to the country right now. It's not Muslims and it's not immigrants. If letting Antifa have their music-festival autonomous zones is the price we must pay to stop nazis from running amok in America's streets, so be it.

Also, I hope Biden restructures the Supreme Court and they overturn Brandenburg v. Ohio, paving the way for criminalizing hate speech in America so law enforcement can finally crack down on these groups.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by opo on Sunday December 13, 2020 @07:05PM (#25411827)
>...Also, I hope Biden restructures the Supreme Court and they overturn Brandenburg v. Ohio, paving the way for criminalizing hate speech in America so law enforcement can finally crack down on these groups.

There are many who would like to criminalize speech they don't like. What they don't realize is that the results likely wouldn't be what they were hoping for.

Brandenburg overturned cases like U.S. v. Schenck which involved whether Schenck could be convicted under the Espionage Act for the crime of writing and distributing a pamphlet that expressed his opposition to the draft. That is the dangerous idea that sent a person to prison.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by jacobwilliamroy on Sunday December 13, 2020 @06:01PM (#25411326)
The law enforcement have always had a weird relationship with white supremacy. For example, The Base is not classified as a terrorist group, despite the fact that their members travel abroad to Ukraine to fight in Donbass, and they explicitly state in captured Telegram(tm) communications that they are training with the paramilitaries so they can more efficiently commit acts of terror when they return to the U.S. Despite that, the FBI still does not designate them as terrorists. The FBI prefers to call them "racially motivated violent extremists" or RMVEs. Still, officially, the FBI considers RMVEs to be equivalent in threat to foreign terrorists, but this was only recently announced in 2019. Progress is slow, but it happens. The whole cyberwar with 8chan has been fascinating to watch and it has given me a lot of hope for the future. I highly recommend reading if you are uninformed.

White supremacist fascist terrorism in the U.S. is real hard to deal with, mostly because it is very well hidden and decentralized. Communications are primarily through private end-to-end encrypted messaging apps. Organizations are more like alliances of isolated autonomous cells rather than one unified structure. Symbols, names and logos are often changed to avoid any association with genocide or fascism. The people who actually commit terrorist acts, such as Patrick Crusius who killed 20 people in an El Paso Walmart, are not publicly associated with any specific group, despite being radicalized through public communication channels appropriated by such groups. The cryptic nature of white supremacist groups also grants them considerable immunity to information war. "Antifa" and "Black Lives Matter" are recognizable brands with icons, logos, flags, colors; anyone can download those symbols and use them to misrepresent and discredit the movement. This in my opinion was the greatest mistake that Black Lives Matter and Antifa made. They underestimated and continue to underestimate the power of the media misinformation machine which is currently targeting them. They still haven't accepted that we are post-truth, post-reality, operating on a purely emotional level. They will find great success when they learn how to use their messaging to connect with Americans on the heart level rather than trying to use shocking slogans to communicate complex high-level intellectual concepts to literal primates. For example, "DEFUND THE POLICE" was a terrible slogan almost perfectly designed to fail, despite the fact that I would not mind defunding the police if it meant we could offer better education to the 40% of American children currently failing school under social distancing.

The world now revolves around memes and emotions, not facts and science. Activism can only succeed if it is adapted to this new era of humanity.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by lock-free on Sunday December 13, 2020 @11:54AM (#25407909)
Forgive me for not pitying the poor conservative, who has controlled the legislature for a decade, the White House for a term, and the Supreme Court for decades to come.

McCarthyism has little bearing on current political realities other than a passing resemblance.

Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by TT3351 on Sunday December 13, 2020 @04:48PM (#25410661)
As well as numerous institutional handicaps that will advantage them for decades (Senate, EC, etc)
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by toiletfuneral on Sunday December 13, 2020 @01:45PM (#25408952)
Well my hometown now has a white nationalist militia that wasn’t there 4 years ago. I guess these are just patriots in your book?
Re:Why I Wrote “The Crucible” (1996) by dnissley on Sunday December 13, 2020 @03:41PM (#25410034)
Wow, where can I read about this?