For aspects such as meters or constantly changing physical data, I am not sure if it will ever be possible to ensure the authenticity of physical -> digital touchpoint.
Is this something an embedded processor can help resolve ? In essence eliminating the possibility of fake data emerging from the meters ?
Usually a company will not generate its own energy. Depending on the country, the infrastructure is sometimes publicly owned and managed.
Maybe the physical -> digital touchpoint here could be outside the boundaries of the company. The energy grid should report those numbers as references, to subscribers agreed upon by the company for example. There it could be certified by the government.
Or something like that?
Edit: Well of course now there would be an incentive to burn petrol to run turbines and generate locally, then turn them off to capitalize on a high in the energy efficiency security market...
exactly. Everytime with this smart meter comes up, this is the crucial thing that just doesn't make sense. No replacement for "auditors/inspectors"!
Some people, when confronted with a problem, think "I know, I'll use Oracle." Now they have two problems.
https://blog.codinghorror.com/regular-expressions-now-you-ha...
At the end of the day a subscription model is probably easier.
The step change in software/OS from boxed to subscription will continue to next phase. With AI the current subscription model is probably not granular enough. Every device/robot will switch tasks and capabilities and upgrades/downgrades with such a frequency that traditional subscription breaks (refunds/tax/fees etc) so blockchain subscription per device without human interaction will probably work better. AI is bots learning from bots which is already distributed, so centralizing that may be inefficient (high bandwidth).
(works in progress, some more like app stores)
No amount of private keys and digital block chain security is going to provide physical security
Under those conditions it's always possible to divert power to 'adjust' the perceived power usage.
My point was that block chain doesn't validate anything - a private key will prove that the data (good or bad) is from the specific user, block chain won't validate that its good.
This is only true for corrupted miners. That is not an issue in this case because the company controls 100% of miners (and therefore, you are trusting them not to write bad data).
It is completely irrelevant to the question of corrupted clients, which no blockchain can guarantee against. All you have to do is attach some bypassing wires to the input and output of your "blockchain-enabled smart meter" to write completely fraudulent entries to the history that can never be fixed.
> (and it's a very expensive and wasteful way to do so)
No it isn't. You're confusing blockchain (the algorithm) with Proof-of-Work (a method for providing decentralized consensus).
> Blockchain does nothing to verify the correctness of the data it holds, only its consistency with the history.
Correct. Nor does any other data structure. Blockchain is literally just a data structure, nothing more.
the original comment was about selling mislabeled energy.
Not sure what attack you have in mind.
That's the fallacy of DRM. There's no real way to keep data from a user.
This isn't just a problem with software engineers, but most engineering disciplines. It's impractical to transport logs hundreds of miles for processing, until we create a system that can do it efficiently. It's impractical to keep detailed records of billions of transactions, until we set up a database and reporting infrastructure that can handle that load.
This is your model for securing electric meters?
The first chapter of the whitepaper? [1] There's two sides entering a contractual agreement around energy consumption.
[1] Section 1.2 - https://efforce.io/WP_ENG_V1.pdf
You can use crypto to build communities around a shared incentive, this in itself is an extremely powerful feature which doesn't get anywhere near enough attention considering that every idea these days relies on shared incentives in order to succeed.
Don't think in binary. Think, whether this system provides better validation/certification than where auditors/inspectors come by at the end of the year to check records. Perhaps, it's harder to systematically cheat the system if you have to announce your data to the world daily, then if you wait till the 11th month, and cook your books so everything works out.
I doubt this removes the role of auditors/inspectors, but it might supplement them.
[0] https://www.theregister.com/2019/02/12/intel_sgx_hacked/?utm...
[1] https://blog.quarkslab.com/attacking-the-arms-trustzone.html
How exactly?
I agree with you that use of blockchain on its own is not fully secure, but that can be mitigated for the most part through the same sorts of proof-of-work and proof-of-stake mechanisms and entities that Etherium, etc. use. with adjustments.
This might be exactly the time for Woz and co. to get into this given that there are others handling those problems, right?
None of that does anything to prove that the energy consumption data you are submitting is true.
Nope. No amount of "proof of X" will help if you put false data on the blockchain in the first place. They will do a great job securing the false data though. Good luck with that.
Block chain doesn't validate things happening in the real world (energy saved, KWh consumed) only auditors/inspectors can do that. The data from the smart meter can always be faked before it goes to the blockchain network.
Have I missed something? I'd be inclined to give Woz the benefit of the doubt on most things but I don't get what blockchain gives here apart from marketing BS - for which its a year or two behind the times?