News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by helsinkiandrew on Monday December 07, 2020 @08:19AM (#25331842)
Split your incoming power to two lines and put the smart meter on one of them and it will register half the power. Route power from your diesel generator through the meter that's meant to be recording your solar generated power.

No amount of private keys and digital block chain security is going to provide physical security

Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by cloudhead on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:16AM (#25332262)
Can’t you do that today though? ie. Circumvent your meter? It’s illegal though.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by helsinkiandrew on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:47AM (#25332550)
Residential its harder but an industrial/commercial property could possibly have multiple power inlines, a diesel generator for emergency power, and perhaps solar panels on the roof and batteries. It may have agreement to use power within specific ranges during the day for different prices and supply power back to a power company or neighbouring businesses.

Under those conditions it's always possible to divert power to 'adjust' the perceived power usage.

My point was that block chain doesn't validate anything - a private key will prove that the data (good or bad) is from the specific user, block chain won't validate that its good.

Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by Apylon777 on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:18PM (#25335957)
In most jurisdictions in the USA renewable energy generators are registered and audited by a third party, (like mrets.org where I work). Anomalies with generation data can be compared directly with data from the grid operators. Utilities will also require these commercial operations to have a "commercial energy meter" which are very expensive.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by robjan on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:19AM (#25332310)
If the only way to cheat is illegal and can be done on the Blockchain anyway then why use a Blockchain rather than a database?
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by coldpie on Monday December 07, 2020 @10:44AM (#25333223)
Apparently was enough to dupe Woz and get this to the front page of HN. Another blockchain success story.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by jpsalm on Monday December 07, 2020 @10:39AM (#25333165)
When a meter company catches someone cheating do we want them to be able to rectify in their database or fork an entire blockchain?
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by samatman on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:32PM (#25336116)
The potential for fraud which may be tried in civil courts is not a slam-dunk argument for mutability.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by lordlimecat on Monday December 07, 2020 @12:51PM (#25334723)
If we're relying on "what is legal" for validating data why do we need a blockchain?
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by DonHopkins on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:45PM (#25336293)
If something being illegal is enough to solve your problem, then why do you need blockchain?
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by fock on Monday December 07, 2020 @07:34PM (#25339850)
oooh, it's illegal! but I thought the libertarian blockchain utopia wanted to get rid of any entities enforcing law because that's soooo socialist?
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by _b8r0 on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:18AM (#25332290)
But in this case the blockchain implementation will provide irrefutable evidence to support any investigation. It's not some magical hand-wavy substitute for investigation, but recording this in a tamper-resistent manner can be useful (although blockchains are far from the only way to do this).
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by joosters on Monday December 07, 2020 @09:30AM (#25332409)
No it won't. All the records will show is that X amount of energy was produced at time T. There's no way of proving that these values were legitimate.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by _b8r0 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:18PM (#25335139)
There's plenty of ways of proving that these values were legitimate, but they're nothing to do with the blockchain element, that's the investigation side. What the blockchain element does is say, "X was definitely recorded by Y at T". It's a tool in the box. It's not the box.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by hannasanarion on Monday December 07, 2020 @11:14AM (#25333507)
Blockchain doesn't provide irrefutable evidence of anything except that the record wasn't tampered with after the fact (and it's a very expensive and wasteful way to do so). Blockchain does nothing to verify the correctness of the data it holds, only its consistency with the history.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by Jimmc414 on Monday December 07, 2020 @01:09PM (#25334987)
You would need control of 51% of the nodes to submit a block with arbitrary data and override consensus. You can’t just add any hash to a block and add it to the network. In order to be the miner to add the next block, you have to win a competition to find a correct hash that solves a difficult math problem. Since there is no way to start with a resulting hash and work backwards to figure out what piece of data gave that hash, the Bitcoin protocol uses this feature to create its difficult math problem. The math problem stipulates that the first miner to produce a hash with a certain amount of leading 0s will be the winner of that block and be able to add it to the network.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by hannasanarion on Monday December 07, 2020 @05:09PM (#25338326)
>You would need control of 51% of the nodes to submit a block with arbitrary data and override consensus

This is only true for corrupted miners. That is not an issue in this case because the company controls 100% of miners (and therefore, you are trusting them not to write bad data).

It is completely irrelevant to the question of corrupted clients, which no blockchain can guarantee against. All you have to do is attach some bypassing wires to the input and output of your "blockchain-enabled smart meter" to write completely fraudulent entries to the history that can never be fixed.

Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by _b8r0 on Monday December 07, 2020 @02:32PM (#25336121)
> Blockchain doesn't provide irrefutable evidence of anything except that the record wasn't tampered with after the fact

> (and it's a very expensive and wasteful way to do so)

No it isn't. You're confusing blockchain (the algorithm) with Proof-of-Work (a method for providing decentralized consensus).

> Blockchain does nothing to verify the correctness of the data it holds, only its consistency with the history.

Correct. Nor does any other data structure. Blockchain is literally just a data structure, nothing more.

Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by DennisP on Monday December 07, 2020 @10:02AM (#25332740)
Generator power is quite expensive, so that particular attack is probably not profitable.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by _visgean on Monday December 07, 2020 @10:49AM (#25333284)
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by DennisP on Monday December 07, 2020 @11:21AM (#25333588)
That's a significantly different attack, with different economics. It involved selling electricity instead of just buying less of it, and profiting from government subsidies. Clearly that can work if the subsidies are high enough.
Re:Steve Wozniak launches Efforce, a blockchain-based energy... by _visgean on Monday December 07, 2020 @03:53PM (#25337348)
> Route power from your diesel generator through the meter that's meant to be recording your solar generated power.

the original comment was about selling mislabeled energy.

Not sure what attack you have in mind.