The goal is never to destroy the company but to simply force them to the bargaining table by reminding them of the economic power workers provide.
A total strike or worse a union quitting a company all together is a nuclear option.
Microsoft improved a lot ever since it dumped stack ranking.
The problem of the effectiveness of Facebook employee walkouts stems from the fact that they aren’t a real union, so the employer can just force them to make it up without providing for any additional compensation.
Any protest is a null option until the whole thing catalyzes and they form a union to address the repeated disregard the company shows them.
The only way for the company to avoid this is to self regulate or at least pay lip service to buy more time.
It doesn't always feel like it when you get an above average salary. Also it really depends on the team, how much the tech lead and the manager can push back to external requests...I don't see how adding even more politics can solve political issues. The fact that it's super easy to move between teams is much more important than anything the union could achieve.
If they truly aren't then you either have to sacrifice your integrity or kick up a fuss. Additionally once her integrity is lost she loses market value.
Her market (whitewashing/signaling of ethical behavior of a large company) is an odd one but she behaved it the most rational manner given the circumstances.
Moreover by kicking up a fuss she probably has sacrificed an non disparagement termination bonus. Real $$$. So she's probably not talking shit.
However it’s also true that they can simply be a reflection of an otherwise unworkable situation.
In a regular employment situation, I think that if you get to the point of wanting to issue an ultimatums, it is just an indication that the company is not a good fit for you any longer. On an individual level it’s better to recognize the signal and leave without burning bridges.
However if you role is ‘ethicist’, it is fundamentally your responsibility not to turn a blind eye to or be complicit in unethical processes, so giving an ultimatum may have been the only option available to retain integrity.
I don’t think we can declare these to be ‘missteps’ given her role. Perhaps Google is simply not capable of being ethical, and is going to fire people who challenge that. What would not be a ‘misstep’ under these circumstances?
Is it a game or is it just a negotiation?
There have been similar recent public statements such as MS workers about use of AI for the pentagon, FB employees on content, etc..
Simply I mean the best way to support a wrongfully ousted ethicist would be to leave yourself, rather than keep getting paid by the execs who wronged her.
The work of AI ethics - especially in the vein of Timnit Gebru - is essential. My statement, was one of support for her.
What are you basing this on? I can think of at least one example where this pressure actually worked (caused google management to reverse course). ICE contracts, I think?
Your strategy would seem to be more in Google management's favor - clearing out all the people who might kick up a fuss when they try to engage in unethical behavior.
A typical onboarding process takes weeks or months of paid employee time.
Employees value to a company increases substantially over time due to knowledge of culture, process, etc.
Executives care a lot when company actions cause employees to leave. Human capital is one of the essential ingredients to a successful company.
These things are real money and execs care about the impact on bottom line.
This is typically the most important aspect of an exit interview. In my experience, the employee's reason for leaving is thoroughly examined.
Does "condemning an action" have the same impact?
I also disagree with the parent. Bringing change is almost always easiest from within. “Don’t like it? Leave.” stances aim to do more to attack the person involved than it does to take a critical look at whatever problem it is that’s being discussed.
But nearly everyone has limits, and the petition signing limit was reached for these 1200 Google employees.
We'll see if the quitting limit is ever reached for any of them.
I feel like signing a letter of protest is doing something “real”. It’s communicating to leadership of the company that you have concerns about what has transpired. It’s not nothing.
Back in my days we would chop off heads and assisinate politicans! These kids can't do anything right!
back in my days, we would unionize and block the factories until the company died or we got what we wanted
They ultimately lost but what happened there led to the sympathetic growth of the AFL and CIO and ultimately to the New Deal and the rise of the middle class.
They say history doesn't repeat but it rhymes. I wouldn't be surprised if the next series of pitched struggles between American owners and labor result in extreme violence also, before giving way to a system that is slightly more egalitarian.
Ironic that guillotine memes are so popular among the kids these days, no?
Personally, I've been a scaredy-cat about this. I actually didn't go to a different FAANG a couple years ago, partly because I anticipated a dilemma: the company had been in the news for some alleged unfairness, and I decided that I could easily imagine being there, and trapped between wanting to speak up on behalf of a fellow employee facing a similar unfairness in the future, and suspecting that I would be terminated if I did. Had I already been there (rather than merely anticipating the situation with a hypothetical) I don't know whether I'd speak up. (Personally, given past battle scars, I'd probably make quiet and delicate internal inquiries, trying to find a sympathetic person in a position to look into and correct or mitigate what seemed to be unfair, while being clear that I'm still a team player.)
So, I do think speaking up in a big-corporate environment, in the public manner these people have done, would tend to come with some personal risk in most companies. When people do it (perhaps) despite a perception of personal risk to themselves in doing so, we should pause and consider what they are saying.
Also, I don't blame people for not anticipating this situation to which they're objecting (based on the information available I've seen at this point). If the concern had instead been "I'm shocked -- shocked! -- to find the amassing of intimate personal information of Internet users going on here!", then I'd wonder how they couldn't have realized that before going to that company, but I don't think that's the concern.
I'm not taking a position on the concern itself, since the information I have so far is incomplete and complicated -- only suggesting that, when people are saying something at some personal risk, those people and what they're saying shouldn't be dismissed offhand.
If you don’t like a policy, go live somewhere else?
If you find mold in a fruit, go shopping in a different place?
I mean, it’s a valid strategy. But obviously not the only valid one.
It’s not wrong to like the other aspects of the job and try to change the quality that they disagree with.
"Citation: https://old.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/k77sxz/d_t... Sample comment:
Another ex-colleague here. I was not going to participate in the discussions but your post made me realize objective truth should come out. I do believe she actually thinks she is making the world a better place but in reality any interaction with her has been incredibly stressful having to carefully weigh every move made in her presence. When this blows over her departure will be a net positive for the morale of the company.
To give a concrete example of what it is like to work with her I will describe something that has not come to light until now. When GPT-3 came out a discussion thread was started in the brain papers group. Timnit was one of the first to respond with some of her thoughts. Almost immediately a very high profile figure has also also responded with his thoughts. He is not Lecun or Dean but he is close. What followed for the rest of the thread was Timnit blasting privileged white men for ignoring the voice of a black woman. Nevermind that it was painfully clear they were writing their responses at the same time. Message after message she would blast both the high profile figure and anyone who so much as implied it could have been a misunderstanding. In the end everyone just bent over backwards apologizing to her and the thread was abandoned along with the whole brain papers group which was relatively active up to that point. She has effectively robbed thousands of colleagues of insights into their seniors thought process just because she didn't immediately get attention.
The thread is still up there so any googler can see it for themselves and verify I am telling the truth."
"Don’t you see, we SS men were not supposed to think about these things; ... somebody else would have done just as well if I hadn’t"
https://www.facinghistory.org/holocaust-and-human-behavior/c...
I would be extremely cauticous about using the argument of "well If I don't do it, someone else will".
Google went from being a tech darling where their "Don't be evil" motto was taken seriously to "Google employees are like Nazis".
Hope someone in authority at Google is doing some serious soul searching as to why this might be.
Statements like these still put pressure on Google. It's possible to care enough to say something, without caring enough to go beyond talk, but that doesn't necessarily mean it's all performative.
But the fact that it hasn't stopped walkouts is interesting. It means there are influential people within who back the walkouts.
That may play into the company's long term goals to winnow out the people not willing to tow the party line.
Not sure what the best option is, maybe for those that have accrued weeks of PTO they can all take it at the same time.
There is no shortage of engineers who would happily take a job at Google. If the folks raising concerns decided to all leave, isn't the net result that Google would operate much as it does today (maybe a little bit slower to get products to market) but without any internal check on its behavior?
And since the issue under dispute here is AI ethics, shouldn't we the non-Googlers want to make sure people willing to voice concern about unethical behavior remain at Google?
That depends on whether they're actually effective. If their concerns are ignored and they're not able to effect change, then their presence at the company is useless as far as moving Google in an ethical direction is concerned.
Why shouldn't workplaces be more democratic? We got rid of kings everywhere else, why should we keep them around just because they're signing our paychecks?
It's unfortunate that people aren't sufficiently concerned that their employer holds a significant amount of power over them - or at least, not enough that they'll do anything much about it - even if they do happen to have a job that pays higher than average.
Unions can be valuable resources for all workers.
Some of the employees involved are in management (as was Gebru), so they don't have that right, nor would that protect people in positions similar to Gebru's.
Basically if you can be promoted up into a position it can be a union job. If you need a business degree to do it though then it’s non union.
For example foremen hire, train, supervise and evaluate workers. Yet they have a union.
I can’t say for certain if it’s a protected union but it is a large and existent one in the US.
Yes.
> In factories the foreman was considered part of the Union rank and file.
She's not a foreman.
> Basically if you can be promoted up into a position it can be a union job.
That's not how the NLRA works; in plenty of workplaces people can, even if they rarely do, promote without limit and most management positions don't require business degrees, but that doesn't make all those positions NLRA-protected.
The fact that most of these employees could easily get well paying (just not as _ridiculously well paying_) jobs elsewhere to me feels like they are not staying out of necessity, rather they are looking to assuage their conscious through statements like these, and continue collecting their exorbitant pay.