You should still do it though, if you can (eg have access to real farmers and enough time). It’s very spiritually rewarding and helps to build communities. Farmers make more per pound at the farm stand and you pay less. It generates less landfill waste and, not sure how to explain it, but it’s very rewarding labor.
I’m headed to the farm stand right now to get some broccoli and brussels sprouts, fresh from the field, to freeze and eat in the spring.
There are a lot of deceptive labeling practices in the food industry. Things like an ingredient list that says your food contains "natural flavors" without saying what they are, or not having an ingredient list at all. When ingredients are listed it's common not to have quantities listed, and virtually never do you see any account of the sources of those ingredients. Of course there's no way to tell whether they're telling the truth either, and no way to know how the food was prepared or how sanitary the preparation or ingredients were, what mistakes or accidents happened during the manufacture, etc.
As to variety, there is usually not very much variety at all in preserved goods at the grocery store. Pickled or fermented goods are packaged at the time of the manufacturer's choosing, so you really have almost no choice as to what stage of ripeness or what flavor the product is to have.
Compare this with preserving your own food, where you have complete control over and knowledge of the ingredients, source of the ingredients, method of preparation, flavor, degree of ripeness, and virtually everything else.
You can completely customize everything to your needs and desires, and don't have to settle for whatever the manufacturer chooses to give you.
It really opens up a whole world of possibilities that store bought food just doesn't offer.
Sure, there's a lot to be said for making things yourself. But people who are hunkering down for economic hard times are not going to suddenly become interested in spending more money on higher quality food. Doing just the opposite of that is more likely.
They're both edible and safe to eat, mind you, but it was much better to get fresh ones. Or not eat candy at all.
edit: I was referring to this joke/quote https://www.brainyquote.com/quotes/annie_dillard_131195
The quality can be hugely higher, though - my wife's applesauce is the best I've ever had, and consistently so.
If you live in an area with local agriculture, it can probably make you more resilient against supply chain failures, too (as long as you keep a good stock of lids on hand).
I wonder if it's simply because she can put more sugar in that any store bought brand. Over here the law limits both the amount of sugar and salt that products can have, so sure, I can make tastier things at home by just using the "proper" sugar and salt amounts. In fact most store bought things are hugely improved by just adding a bit of salt, since they are not allowed to salt them more by law. Most likely not the healthiest thing to do but that's where the taste difference comes from for me.
It's easy to add more sweetness if I want, for example if I mix it with unsweetened plain nonfat yogurt then I will add a bit of maple syrup too - yum!
Same for other similar products. Most fruit jams are way too sweet for my taste. The excessive sugar is probably required by law in order to be called "jam" - yuck! There are some "fruit sweetened" spreads that are sweetened with grape juice, but then the grape dominates the flavor.
We used to be able to get Kozlowski Farms fruit spreads that were sweetened with apple juice - a much better pairing for berries. I haven't seen them in a while locally though.
I think it's also, though, that we pick apples ourselves in local orchards, looking for good ripe ones and processing them within a week or three of picking.
That means we can pick varieties almost exclusively based on their flavor profile. We don't have to worry about how well they survive in transit or sitting in grocery stores.
The big processing operators do have to worry about variables like that, as well as what types they can keep in supply year round for consistency of flavor.
I imagine that cuts down on the varieties they can realistically use.
Something I was surprised to see is in short supply is playing cards.
In times of economic insecurity like the last recession in 2009, when McClellan started her Food in Jars blog, people turned to canning to soothe their fears, and mason jar sales took off.
...
“When there are these big downfalls of trust in systems of government or economy or institutions, there’s this desire to retain control wherever we can find it,” she says.
These bored people forget the cost of electricity to heat water that seals cans, the jars upfront costs, the pressure cooker for the canning, and proper storage. I won't be shocked if these people try turning it into another lululemon type of deal and make another pyramid scheme to not lean into.
There's a much more parsimonious explanation: People are are bored at home and looking for new hobbies. I'm guessing the people who are buying up jars and rings and flats now are mostly the same folks who were buying up flour and yeast back in the spring. I wouldn't be at all surprised if yarn and knitting needles become a scarce commodity this February.