This may be the case for "casual" computer users, but not for "power" users.
that may be true, but businesses would be keen to also give us what we need more than just what we want... thats how you get "faster horses" vs the automobile
For the most part, you are correct. Yes there are design trends, but that isn't the primary factor here. Staff designers have to justify their existence by making changes to established design patterns. They don't have to be good, just different.
Bonus points for following a public design trend, but so long as the visual diff is big enough, you get your pay check.
Yet another example of the bullshit jobs David Graeber warned us about.
> Of course it is. Our phones are intimately close to us. Physically, cognitively, socially and even emotionally. They may be the most widely-owned intimately-connected object humans have ever invented outside religion.
"Phone" =/= "UI"
but that said, I'm actually puzzled as to how "fashion" plays such a central role in your model of human society. Even if UI was the fetish object (which it is not) in what sort of cultural matrix does the core fetish object mutate constantly "like fashion"?
I think the beauty of the iPhone lies in its elegance, but I suspect I'll always code on my Linux computer.
Apple has chosen to make everyone live in its crazy world. Letting users skin the OS would be a better choice.
There's a huge amount of skinning going on with iOS 14 now [1].
[1]: https://mashable.com/article/how-to-customize-ios14-home-scr...
There is an orthogonal axis - which is functionalism. You can continue to make products that are both luxurious and functional. See Olivetti (Sottsass), Braun (Rams), Herman Miller, Vitra, USM, etc. I think they are pretty fashionable products if we considered their popularity and some of them are in MoMA as iconic designs. Apple seems to be going negative on the axis of functionlism past few years. What if I told you that you don't need to make something look ugly to make it functional, utilitarian and usable?
I think they can make UI very marketable + functional if they hired the right folks. In fact, Apple is going back to skeumorphism (hey, its called neuomorphic UI now). Have you seen the battery icon? This kind of trend chasing without any purpose is my main gripe. Also, the windows 95 comment was sort of tongue-in-cheek to exemplify how bloated modern operating systems have become.
Of course it is. Our phones are intimately close to us. Physically, cognitively, socially and even emotionally. They may be the most widely-owned intimately-connected object humans have ever invented outside religion.
Our computers don't occupy as close of a niche. But they're in a similar space.
I agree with your observation that the new OS feels like molasses. I wish they went for a "snappy" feel. (Though keyboard shortcuts get around that.) But ignoring that Macs and iPhones are objects of fashion as well as computing devices misses a deep part of what Jobs saw that technologists missed.