News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by OstiaAntica on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:48PM (#2519212)
This is unethical, basically he calls for jumping off of flights at layovers, which violates the terms of the ticket. There's even a security issue for the airlines, because they need to check if your bags are flying unaccompanied.

Ironic that the NYT cracks down on people evading its paywall but is selling content on doing the same for air travel.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tibbon on Friday May 06, 2011 @09:41AM (#2520881)
Is this any more unethical than ordering a #6 combo at McDonald's and not eating the fries... just because you calculated that for some reason the drink + sandwich cost more than the #6? Even if McDonald's put in big bold letter, "You must eat everything you order or else"?

I don't see why you are obliged to use more of the service than you want to. If I buy a train ticket from DC-Boston and hop off in NYC, no one's going to care. Airlines get special treatment?

What if I had left a bag on the train? There seems to be some issue with leaving it on a plane and losing it. As long as I'm not a terrorist (which I'm not) and they have screened my bags, I don't see the issue. On the flip side, the airline doesn't really care if they lost your bag and don't know where it is. The bag not being tied to you does not put a bomb in it.

Plus, people travel on planes that their bags aren't on all the time and we have no indicator that people doing bad things are more likely to want to be off the plane than on it.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tptacek on Friday May 06, 2011 @11:39AM (#2521246)
It is the same kind of "unethical" as deliberately buying and throwing away food; it's just a large difference of degree.

Incidentally, note that the same airline pricing quirk you'd be exploiting to save ~$100 is also costing other people on the plane; it's not quite a zero sum game, but has some of the same dynamics, as prices rise with occupancy on planes.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tibbon on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:22PM (#2521396)
Wouldn't the real solution however be for the airlines to introduce pricing that didn't take an entire company of smart people (ITA) to understand?
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tptacek on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:52PM (#2521547)
No, because ethically, not liking the way somebody prices a good or service doesn't give you a free pass to abuse other consumers of those goods or services.

If you believe obtaining the best possible price for a service by inconveniencing other consumers is ethical, I can save us a protracted and boring argument by stipulating that there is then nothing unethical about hidden-city itineraries.

But if you don't think that, then let me warn you that the instinct to fob off responsibility for people's actions to the big faceless corporation is natural and understandable, but also very hazardous to your moral health.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tibbon on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:31PM (#2521689)
I'm still not sure why it's a big deal if I get off a plane at a stop, but getting off a train isn't a big deal.

They could always allow some way for you to inform them, "I'm leaving, don't wait for me." (or simply you could just go to that gate and tell them. That way they aren't holding the plane, and no one else is at a loss. You don't inconvenience anyone else, except maybe a few confused people working at the gate.

None of this still solves the issue that airlines don't have transparent pricing. If restaurants acted like airlines, you'd have people in the same place paying anywhere from $5 to $200 for the same meal, and you'd be unsure of one day to the next how much they'll be charging. You could even pay for your meal upfront, only to find that they 'oversold' the meals and you'll have to go hungry.

If you want to talk about unethical, let's talk about inconveniencing customers by overselling flights.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tptacek on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:38PM (#2521720)
You're changing the subject. It can be both bad that airline pricing isn't transparent and bad to exploit it to reduce your own fares at the expense of everyone else on the same route.

However, I will note that as annoying as airline pricing is, particularly to geeks but yes to everyone else too, they do serve a function of capturing revenue from customers who aren't price sensitive (biz travelers) and thus lowering fares for people who are very price sensitive (older leisure travelers). You would not be able to argue that airfares were "unethical" if they simply and "transparently" locked in a constant average fair $150 higher than the current bottom end price on Kayak, but the airlines would be making the same money.

For all the complaining and anger around airline pricing, it's also worth noting that these companies aren't Exxon; they aren't rolling in cash. Airlines go BK all the time. It's a tough business.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by euroclydon on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:52PM (#2522035)
It's a big deal because you are signaling your intention to to fly to destination C, not B, when in fact your hidden intention is only to go to B. This is called lying. Try telling them the truth, either by buying the single A->B flight or by telling the check-in clerk that you have no intention of flying to C, and you won't get the good price and may get banned from the airline.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by tibbon on Friday May 06, 2011 @05:14PM (#2522508)
Again, for some reason no other form of transit seems to really care. Even if you tell them about it. What other businesses do this (really strange) practice? I can buy the entire Microsoft Office and only use Excel and Microsoft doesn't care.

Take a cruise somewhere, stop along the way and you think to stay there for good? They don't care.

Take a Greyhound bus somewhere and stay in the Arby's too long? They don't care if you want to stay in that random town.

Take a train somewhere, and they certainly won't care where you get off.

Buy a commuter rail pass that will get you to Worchester from Boston, tell the attendant that you're going to Worchester and then get off in Newton... they don't care.

And you know when the airline doesn't care? When you buy the ticket and don't show up at all. They'll happily take your cash, but it seems they don't want to take you halfwhere there.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by euroclydon on Friday May 06, 2011 @05:30PM (#2522563)
The concept the airlines are employing is called market segmentation. It's legal and they have the right to do it. The concept you seem to be referencing is some generic measure of product utilization.

The office analogy is wrong. A better one would be the person who tells MS they are a student but uses Excel in their business.

The train analogy is backward, would you intentionally buy a ticket to a more expensive destination if your intention were to get off early?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:08PM (#2519270)
This guy was modded down, but are there ethical issues? If I'm booked through from SFO to DFW to MIA and I vanish at DFW, they're going to be calling my name over the PA system and trying to figure out whether or not to hold the DFW-MIA flight. This is especially true if my SFO-DFW leg is delayed -- my vanishing act might well wind up holding up a planeload of people as the airline figures out what the hell has happened to me and whether they should send the flight off to MIA (and then have to book me on a DFW-MIA plane later in the day) or hold it a few more minutes on the assumption that I'm currently dashing across the terminal to try and make it onboard.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by enjo on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:25PM (#2519323)
Ya there are. I've had planes take off fairly delayed because of folks doing just this. We just sit there as the airline tries to reconcile why the number of checked-in passengers doesn't match their passenger count.

I'm guessing this is some sort of security rule? It doesn't matter tho, it absolutely sucks for everyone else on the flight.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:35PM (#2519361)
I'm guessing this is some sort of security rule?

It's a security rule if you have checked bags. If you're gonna blow up a plane they want to make sure you're at least onboard when you do it. Otherwise it's just a convenience thing -- they don't wanna close the doors and then have you show up two minutes later, because then you're a problem they have to deal with. The one time I actually did miss a connection I wound up with a free night in a very nice hotel, but the whole thing soaked up quite a few man-hours of time at the airline's end.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by jrockway on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:32AM (#2520363)
It's a security rule if you have checked bags.

No it's not. People fly on flights other than their bags all the time. If you check in and miss your flight, your bags often get there before you do and might even take a different routing. I missed a Southwest flight from MDW to PDX once. I ended up flying MDW-OAK-PDX, and my bags were in Portland long before I was.

There may be a rule for international flights, but I can't find a source on this. (The "you must use the lav in the cabin in which you are ticketed" rule only applies on international flights, for example. It may even only apply on international flights to the US, not from the US. After all, the 9/11 planes were international flights to the US. Oh wait...)

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by sliverstorm on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:43PM (#2519381)
Who cares about delaying an entire plane of busy people when you can save $20? [/bitter]
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rdtsc on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:00AM (#2520147)
A lot of people already see traveling as a big hassle and they feel they have been nickel-and-dimed by the airlines (no more hot meals like back in the day), they are groped and blasted with X-rays by TSA as if they are some tiny terrorists. (This is regardless that there are 2 separate entities involved, people see it as just one traveling experience).

So most people will do this ticket hack even if it saves them just $5, or even just out of spite ("You made me jump through hoops? OK, now you sit and wait for me, haha!" kind of reaction). I am not justifying it or saying they are right, just illustrating the possible thought process.

Now from a market point of view, airlines are trying to solve this insanely complicated problem on how to maximize their profits from all these seats on their flights. It is almost like trying to do central planning on an economy of a small country -- this seat on this flight should cost X because we think demand for it is Y, unless demand changes and then we can increase the price, and then there are different legs, through different hubs, other partner airlines that try to do the same, it is just so complicated. So they end up creating these inefficiencies with inadvertent arbitrage possibilities. And people are taking advantage. Apparently they know about it and they are trying to put all kind of threatening legal mumbo-jumbo in their fine print. But they can't enforce it.

I think as more people start finding out and doing this they could: 1) ban customers in the future, 2) make them pay a fee next time they purchase, 3) lobby the govt. to declare this a grave security concern and make TSA chase these people down 4) try to adjust their pricing and fair structure to do away with this inefficiency.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by aboodman on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:14PM (#2519466)
The article has an example of saving $189 (about 50% of the published price of the ticket in question), and a post in this thread had an example of saving 500 euro on a transatlantic flight. So it's not always trivial amount of money.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:24PM (#2519508)
How many man-minutes of inconvenience are you willing to create for random strangers for every dollar you can save for yourself?

Come to think of it, this question is about as close to an objective measure of an individual's level of morality as we can get. Screw all theories of moral relativism; I can tell whether you're a good person or not by knowing how much money it would take to tempt you to leave an entire planeload of people sitting on the tarmac for an extra ten minutes.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by kirubakaran on Thursday May 05, 2011 @09:29PM (#2519667)
"Screw all theories of moral relativism; I can tell whether you're a good person or not by knowing how much money it would take to tempt you to leave an entire planeload of people sitting on the tarmac for an extra ten minutes."

Lets consider a few hypothetical scenarios:

1. You can get 50 dollars but it may potentially result in 60 minutes of delay for 100 people. Would you turn it down?

2. You can get 1000 dollars but it may potentially result in 5 minutes of delay for 100 people. Would you turn it down?

3. You can get 10,000 dollars but it can potentially result in 5 minutes of delay for 100 people. Would you turn it down?

4. You can get 100 Million dollars but it can potentially result in 3 minutes of delay for 100 people. Would you turn it down?

5. What if you are broke and have a child to support?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by sliverstorm on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:43PM (#2519922)
$100 Million, 3 minutes, 100 people? I might simply take the $100 Mil, and then track down all 100 people and give them a few tens of thousands.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by kirubakaran on Friday May 06, 2011 @01:13AM (#2520082)
Intent of the hypothetical, addressing its parent's thought about moral relativism, clearly supposes that you are inconveniencing people for monetary gain without possibility of compensating or otherwise being able to undo that.

Your reply is the equivalent of answering "If a genie grants you one single wish, what would it be?" with "I'll wish for a million wishes" :-)

And your reply subscribes to moral relativism too ('If I give them $x each, then it is okay to delay them. What is a few minutes anyway?'). Also note that $x that you are suggesting to give per person times 100 is just 1% of your gain. You don't know how much you cost them with the few minutes of delay that you caused. Perhaps someone missed a connecting flight and lost the chance to see his mom before she passed away.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by salvadors on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:48AM (#2520212)
Yes, but if you base your life on those sorts of hypotheticals you can never do anything.

If you push a button at a pedestrian crossing so you can cross the road, you're stopping potentially hundreds of cars just for your benefit. How much have you cost them? What if one of those is someone who's racing to the airport to catch a flight to see their mom who's about to pass away, and your decision to cross the road then delays them just enough to miss their flight?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by kirubakaran on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:14AM (#2520247)
I agree. That is my point too.

Please note in my first comment I was replying to the statement: "Screw all theories of moral relativism; I can tell whether you're a good person or not by knowing how much money it would take to tempt you to leave an entire planeload of people sitting on the tarmac for an extra ten minutes." I tried to explain that he will become a moral relativist if the 'rewards' are high enough. In the second comment, I tried to explain that handing $10K to each doesn't correct it. It just makes you feel better. Still moral relativism.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by sudonim on Friday May 06, 2011 @08:44AM (#2520765)
At least in NYC, the pedestrian crossing buttons have no effect on the traffic lights. They computerized the traffic grid and them pesky pedestrians screw up the flow. So you can push all you want, but it wont speed things up.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by mavelikara on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:23PM (#2521406)
> Screw all theories of moral relativism; I can tell whether you're a good person or not by knowing how much money it would take to tempt you to leave an entire planeload of people sitting on the tarmac for an extra ten minutes.

I hope that the person at the airlines who came up with the pricing model is also bound by the same moral framework. Something like - how big a bonus does it need to tempt you in coming up with a scheme which robs thousands of customers of your employer an extra $5 for the next few years?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by aterimperator on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:08AM (#2519977)
To be fair... money has different value to different people. I doubt any billionaires would care to waste 10 minutes of other people's time to save much money, because money doesn't have that much value to them. On the other hand, college students that eat lots of ramen are already valuing money more than their own health, so it seems natural that they'd place far more value on the money, even if they place the same value on other people's time.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by bad_user on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:10AM (#2520325)
You probably don't know many rich people.

Disregarding the infamous rich brats you see on TV, rich people are in general very frugal and do care about dimes and nickels. That's how many of them got rich in the first place.

And regardless, billionaires are in a minority.

    college students that eat lots of ramen are already 
    valuing money more than their own health
On the contrary, I think college students are the ones that don't care about money.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by aterimperator on Friday May 06, 2011 @10:22AM (#2520993)
Are you really arguing that the marginal value of an extra dollar is more for a billionaire than for a college student who eats ramen?
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by BrandonM on Friday May 06, 2011 @11:07AM (#2521122)
No, he's clearly arguing that the billionaire is more rational with his money. Even though the marginal value is higher for the college student, that student is not as smart might not even see the opportunity for monetary gain.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by sliverstorm on Friday May 06, 2011 @05:30PM (#2522565)
college students that eat lots of ramen are already valuing money more than their own health

Speaking as a college student, college students eat ramen today so they can eat ramen tomorrow instead of eating steak today and not eating tomorrow.

And when I say "tomorrow", I really mean the whole week.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by Jach on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:33PM (#2519900)
For those who like to calculate: valuing one hour at $8, ten minutes is $1.33 that the delay you caused is costing per person on board.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by aterimperator on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:04AM (#2519969)
So with a Full boeing 747 (probably a large overestimate), that's about 366 people (with wikipedia as source). At 10 minutes you're wasting 61 man hours (did I make a mistake? That seems way too large). Taking a low estimate on the value of people's time of about $10 per hour, you should be saving $610 to justify it...

Let's go with a smaller plane... My friend who is into airplanes tells me that 40 is a good estimate for shuttle planes from small cities to bigger hubs (30ish to 50ish, I just averaged them). So every 10 minutes you waste is about 6.5 man hours. Again valuing people's time at $10 per hour, you'd have to save $65 to break even (though that relies on pretty low valuation of the value of people's time).

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:51PM (#2519400)
Sadly this is the attitude that some people really have. And if challenged on it, they'll rationalize it by blaming the airline for setting their prices that way.

It's much like the drug user's rationalization of the fact that the money he spends goes to support organized crime. "Well," he says, "that's the government's fault for not legalizing the drugs I wish to take!"

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by wnoise on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:52PM (#2519576)
In both cases they are right too: the people creating the messed-up market (government via drug laws) and (airlines via schedules) are creating incentives that have built-in externalities.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by aterimperator on Friday May 06, 2011 @12:14AM (#2519988)
I agree with both of you. I'm not entirely sure where that leaves me. Conflicted. On the one hand I fully agree that these markets are kind of silly and incentivize dickish behavior. On the other hand, both the drug users and the time-wasters are knowingly inflicting those evils upon the world and other people through their own behavior.

I think I've decided where it leaves me: upset at both the bad-market creators and at the individuals who make choices knowing the ill-effects of those choices.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by Zak on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:30AM (#2520278)
A potential solution to this is to hand your boarding pass for the next leg to a gate agent as you get off the plane at your intended destination and say that you will not be boarding. The gate agent may threaten you with consequences, but there's really nothing they can do; it's not like the TSA is going to force you on to a plane.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by perlgeek on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:15AM (#2520338)
What about just telling your airline that you won't be on the second flight? Then they don't have to wait for you.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by scdc on Friday May 06, 2011 @09:31AM (#2520859)
No ethical issue-- as kulkarnic said, why not just tell the gate agent, "I'm sorry, I can't fly on the final leg of this flight. Here's my boarding pass."

Now there is no reason to delay the flight.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by Zak on Friday May 06, 2011 @03:37AM (#2520286)
I don't think interfering with someone's business model is inherently unethical. While intentionally booking a flight this way deprives the airline of some opportunities to make money, not boarding the next flight doesn't deprive them of anything. In fact, it saves them a bit on fuel and may even open up a seat on an overbooked flight, saving the airline from paying compensation that usually exceeds the ticket price.

What actually seems unethical to me is that airlines have contract terms forbidding getting off early. An honest and effective, though not profitable means of preventing passengers from doing so would be to charge less for one leg than for two.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by stellar678 on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:18AM (#2520171)
Yet again the word ethics comes up when consumers attempt to act in their own best interest in a given marketplace. Why should it be ethics when it's just economics? The airline isn't chastised for being unethical when they make decisions in their economic interest, why should the consumer be?
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by roel_v on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:58AM (#2520408)
When you buy the ticket, you agree to the conditions of the deal.

When you walk away, you are one-sidedly breaking your agreement.

It's quite easy to see that two parties making a voluntary agreement != unethical, while one party breaking that agreement == unethical.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by salvadors on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:43AM (#2520205)
Whilst I agree with the principle, I think the argument runs quite simply:

When you buy the ticket you agree to a set of accompanying conditions. Doing that knowing you're going to deliberately break some of them is dishonest and immoral.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by georgemcbay on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:53AM (#2520401)
When you buy the ticket you also expect a seat on the plane, but the airline has absolutely no problem with massively overselling a flight and bumping some people because, hey -- nothing personal, just economics!

Why should customers show the airlines any more courtesy than they are shown by the airlines in such matters?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by mseebach on Friday May 06, 2011 @05:42AM (#2520479)
Because two wrongs doesn't make a right and because the terms you agree to allows the airline to overbook giving you a lower fare in return (at least some business class fares guarantee you a seat).
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by kulkarnic on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:56PM (#2519950)
Not so. The specific tactic the NYC recommends is questionable, but it is possible to surrender your boarding pass for the onward flight. (Say you no longer want to fly: there's nothing they can do to stop you).

Note this is also possible if you check luggage: the airline is not obligated to let you get the luggage off the onward flight, but there's no airline that wants to carry baggage for a passenger who's not on the flight anymore (for security reasons).

If you're planning such a stunt (with baggage), try to have around 3 hours hop-time; else you WILL be delaying the onward flight with your luggage.

Layovers > 4 hours are considered as off-the-airport stopovers (domestically, US). That means the fare you'll get for SFO->DFW->BOS = SFO->DFW + DFW->BOS (made up routing). Exceptions: DEN for UA, ORD for AA, SEA and ORD for AS etc ("transit hubs", that is); where stopovers are free.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by donohoe on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:27PM (#2519514)

  Ironic that the NYT cracks down on people evading its paywall but is selling content on doing the same for air travel.
{citation needed}

The NYT has done no such thing. They have gone after people for trademark violation. Big diffence :)

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by r00fus on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:54PM (#2519231)
Unethical? Hardly. It's just against their specific rules (which only exist so they can gouge you on certain fares).

Is it ethical for airlines to charge you more for A->B than a flight going from A->B->C?

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:12PM (#2519285)
Is it ethical for airlines to charge you more for A->B than a flight going from A->B->C?

I don't know. Is it obviously unethical for them to do so?

It's a sensible observation that a subset of X should be priced lower than X, but is it a moral one? Or, if the airline can make more money by charging more for A->B than A->C via B then, heck, it's their airplane, let 'em do what they want!

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:35PM (#2519360)
Why are ethics and morality being discussed in the context of business? They have their pricing strategy, I have mine. It's my travel money, let me do what I want.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by ghshephard on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:04PM (#2519436)
Nobody who is commenting here cares (or I strongly suspect they don't care) about the Airlines and people making money. It's the hundred or so people who are sitting on the airplane that are being inconvenienced - possibly missing their own connections later on, that our concerns are for.

In general, airlines don't like to have people's checked luggage travel separately from them - and they don't know if the missing person checked luggage or not. So, they either have to do a count, get everyone in their correct seat, or delay the plane until the person gets back on.

It's a cute hack, but an annoying one for everyone caught up in it.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by _delirium on Thursday May 05, 2011 @08:41PM (#2519554)
I agree that's one concern, but it's not entirely clear to me what the division of responsibility for those waiting-around passengers is. You might blame the passengers causing the problem, but as a passenger I also expect the airline to anticipate and work around any frequent sources of disruption. If it's something that happens often enough to actually be a problem, then it's an operational problem and they should find some way to mitigate it. For example, they could include it as a factor when evaluating pricing strategies (the likely operations-disrupting effect of certain pricing strategies), or perhaps they could handle check-in and luggage-tracking differently, or they could police their fare rules more stringently to more strongly discourage it.

But they should do something, if indeed it is a problem (I'm not sure it actually is). Creating an obvious arbitrage opportunity and then structuring your operations in a way that isn't robust to some proportion of people exploiting it wouldn't be a very responsible way to run a business.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by ghshephard on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:06PM (#2519730)
In the 15 years I've been flying actively, i've only once been on a plane where I was told to return to my seat so they could do a count. I'm presuming that was a situation where someone hopped off mid travel. So, this is really a rare scenario. I think most people who do this are savvy, which means they realize they are about to screw an entire planeload of people - so it's a fairly rare endeavor.

The fact that the NYT was consulting with Trial Lawyers as to the legality of this, is some indication of how sketchy this behavior is.

BTW - all of this thread applies to layovers where the plane lands, and some people deplane, while others stay in their seats.

None of this applies to the situation where you have to get onto another plane, or, as I've had happen to me a couple times, they require you to exit the plane and then get back on. Particularly if you didn't check luggage. I'm fine with people playing that game - usually only causes a minute or two delay, if that.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by _delirium on Friday May 06, 2011 @08:06AM (#2520693)
Oh, yeah, I didn't even realize the other one happens. I've never had a connection where I didn't have to get off the plane, and usually I have to change planes. I think maybe once out of hundreds of flights have I got lucky enough that the connecting plane was actually the same plane I came in on. So I assumed the hidden-city ticketing was just people skipping the 2nd connecting flight, not literally exiting the plane at a layover.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @09:02PM (#2519594)
Then it's a failure of the pricing strategy, developed by the airline itself, if it encourages people to make a rational choice that delays or affects other passengers.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by yters on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:25PM (#2519766)
So whenever I can get away with crime it's someone else's fault?

So you're the reason the lawyers don't let us do fun stuff in the US anymore!

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rhizome on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:48PM (#2519822)
What's the crime here?
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by yters on Saturday May 07, 2011 @07:30PM (#2524852)
That's an extension of your reasoning.

Nothing is forcing people to minimize costs at the expense of others. There are many things I could do that are not technically illegal, but cause great problems for others. Is the responsibility of corporations to make it costly for me to be immoral? That seems to be what you're saying.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rhizome on Monday May 09, 2011 @07:51PM (#2530666)
It's a perverse incentive, provided by the airline. I don't understand your point otherwise.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by sandipc on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:32PM (#2519351)
"they need to check if your bags are flying unaccompanied"

For those traveling with checked luggage, this "hop off" tactic won't work, unless passengers want to lose their bags.

For those without checked luggage, the airlines have no way of determining whether your carry-on bags are still on the plane or not, short of emptying the plane and reboarding (which I have never seen before).

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by rflrob on Thursday May 05, 2011 @10:14PM (#2519745)
I've only ever had a handful of connections where I'm on the same plane. More often, I have to haul my stuff halfway across the terminal (and the Availability heuristic* tells me that it's almost never the next gate over) to get on a different plane. Thus, if they never scan my boarding pass, they can be pretty sure my luggage isn't on the plane.

* Yes, I'm aware this is a cognitive bias. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Availability_heuristic

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by somebear on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:09PM (#2519856)
The times I've had a multi-leg flight (internationally), it's always been the same plane. The airline still makes everyone get off, bring in new clean blankets and pillows, and ensure that no one left anything behind. Feels a bit annoying when you just go back to the same seat, but I understand why.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by yardie on Friday May 06, 2011 @02:59AM (#2520225)
Its a safety thing. No one (except crew) can be onboard the aircraft while its refueling.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by arethuza on Friday May 06, 2011 @04:43AM (#2520388)
I've been on flights between London and Mombasa in Kenya where the aircraft stopped to refuel in Luxor in Egypt and we didn't get off.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by guelo on Thursday May 05, 2011 @09:13PM (#2519623)
I'm trying to comprehend how it is unethical to game a system that is constantly gaming its customers.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by roel_v on Friday May 06, 2011 @05:02AM (#2520417)
The unethical part is in willfully entering into a contract that you know in advance you are not going to uphold. Feel free to not enter the contract - but don't lie to get part of the benefit, and then sneak out of the rest.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by wmeredith on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:55PM (#2519233)
I think hypocritical is the word you were looking for, rather than "ironic".
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by jeza on Thursday May 05, 2011 @11:43PM (#2519923)
Isn't it unethical to create this scenario in the first place? Charging people more to travel a shorter distance than a longer distance on the same route. It just doesn't seem logical in any sense. Perhaps the coverage in NYT will force the airlines to clean up their act.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by michaelochurch on Thursday May 05, 2011 @06:56PM (#2519239)
What's unethical is the pricing behavior of the airlines, not taking advantage of the hidden-city phenomenon, which exists because certain routes, though longer, are immune to airline price-gouging on account of a fair market.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by gojomo on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:23PM (#2519312)
Perhaps all carriers' in-flight magazines will retaliate next month with front-page "How To Beat The NYT Paywall" articles.
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by euroclydon on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:23PM (#2519316)
I don't think the unattended bag part is a big deal. Who would check a bag to some city they're never going to?
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by mbrubeck on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:46PM (#2519387)
Not allowing unintented bags is one step to prevent bombings. The answer to your question ("Who would check a bag to some city they're never going to?") is "someone who is trying to blow up the plane."
Re:How to Beat High Airfares by hugh3 on Thursday May 05, 2011 @07:55PM (#2519409)
Who would check a bag to some city they're never going to?

A person who wants to blow up an airliner. That's the point.

Re:How to Beat High Airfares by euroclydon on Thursday May 05, 2011 @09:35PM (#2519671)
No, that a point, but not the point here. In this case it's irrelevant, because anyone pulling this maneuver would not check their bag.