News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by awinter-py on Sunday November 22, 2020 @07:50PM (#25182499)
Have never understood EFF's objection to 'pay for privacy' (covered in the middle of this article). Being able to pay for privacy is better than not being able to. It creates the beginning of accountability for cos and optionality for users.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by backtoyoujim on Sunday November 22, 2020 @08:22PM (#25182676)
How can that kind of inequality look like justice to anyone other than someone very economically privileged ?
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by google234123 on Sunday November 22, 2020 @09:12PM (#25182941)
The alternative is that they dont have access to these services.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by bradbot on Sunday November 22, 2020 @09:12PM (#25182936)
Why the downvotes? The point is legitimate. Not everyone would be able to afford to pay for something like this.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by google234123 on Sunday November 22, 2020 @09:13PM (#25182951)
Not everyone can afford a BMW. Is that fair?
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by brianush1 on Sunday November 22, 2020 @10:23PM (#25183299)
Privacy is (or at least should be) a right. BMWs aren't.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by kuyan on Monday November 23, 2020 @01:18AM (#25184064)
You are correct. The California Constitution, Article 1, section 1 gives each citizen an inalienable right to pursue and obtain privacy.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by renewiltord on Monday November 23, 2020 @02:41AM (#25184401)
And what, pray tell, do you expect a service provider to do when this happens? Privacy advocates screamed themselves shrill like this and what happened is that the NYT went paywall. Then they screamed themselves shrill that the poor don't have access to good news.

Well...what did you think would happen?

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by awinter-py on Monday November 23, 2020 @02:39PM (#25190767)
look your objection is valid but:

privacy as a legal right is complex and ill-defined -- if you look just at CCPA or GDPR, these are big laws with large compliance costs with the risk of benefiting incumbents like FB/G

if your goal is to develop a robust case law for privacy in the united states, pay for privacy accomplishes that because if I pay a dollar for 'private mode', and the vendor breaks our contract, I can absolutely sue.

we also don't know which privacy features users want. hard to write laws without market research, and you can't do market research if there's no market for a good.

another issue is that if privacy laws 'demonetize free tiers', you're effectively paying for privacy anyway. 'pay for privacy' vs 'privacy as right' may be a false choice.

I'm not saying market privacy is fair on the face of it, but it may be more effective than the alternatives.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by ragebol on Monday November 23, 2020 @05:40AM (#25185401)
Because privacy is a right. And being bribed into giving it up is not a solution.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by AntiImperialist on Monday November 23, 2020 @07:00AM (#25185807)
Does the right to bear arms mean that someone should give you a gun for free?

Whether it's a right has nothing to do with whether you have to pay for it.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by ragebol on Monday November 23, 2020 @07:50AM (#25186198)
A right in itself costs nothing, to exercise a right is something else. If you've always had (some level of) privacy and that is (suddenly) taken away. With gun, you don't have one by default and getting one costs something. With privacy you (should) have it by default and now it would cost something to keep it.

I wonder if people would accept to have to give up a gun they already had and then get paid to not have one anymore, while they have a right to have a gun.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by AntiImperialist on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @01:43AM (#25195952)
You're talking as if Google is getting into your home and taking away your privacy.

A milkman knew where you lived, a plumber knows what your interiors looked like. You sacrifice your privacy for service.

Google is no different. You used their services in exchange for your information. It costs you nothing to not use these services.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by Gibbon1 on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @02:08AM (#25196076)
The milkman and plumber aren't in the business of spying on me and selling that information to people that will use it to harm me.

The deal with google is their spying goes beyond any business relationship.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by AntiImperialist on Tuesday November 24, 2020 @03:34AM (#25196481)
No, Google is neither spying on your nor selling your information to third parties.

When you use their service, they know about you. When they filter our spam for you in Gmail, their software reads your emails. When you look up in Maps where you are, their service tracks where you are. By the way, you can delete your data and stop tracking anytime while continuing to use the service (something you could not do with your milkman or your plumber). They could always continue doing it behind your backs, but the milkman could also poison you. You have to trust them and take legal action if you catch them doing something that they are they aren't.

When advertisers want to use Google, they tell Google where they want their ads. For example, a dental clinic can tell Google something along the lines of "Show my ads in search engines to people in my area who are searching for 'affordable dentist'" and pay Google when people click the ads. The dental clinic never gets any user data from Google.

Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by cblconfederate on Monday November 23, 2020 @06:11AM (#25185570)
happiness and safety are rights too. Some people get paid extra to give up some of their safety or happiness and we consider it the right thing to do. It's not all black and white
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by ivanche on Monday November 23, 2020 @06:50AM (#25185751)
Hm, show me one constitution which declares "happiness" as right?
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by cblconfederate on Monday November 23, 2020 @07:05AM (#25185836)
the american i think
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by rtkaratekid on Monday November 23, 2020 @08:07AM (#25186355)
That’s actually in our Declaration of Independence from the British Empire. I don’t recall the constitution including it as well (although most Americans consider it a given because it was in the DOI). Originally Jefferson wrote, “the pursuit of land,” but that was changed at one of the conventions before it was ratified by representatives of the colonies at the time.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by tolbish on Sunday November 22, 2020 @11:59PM (#25183730)
Should something like privacy be up for sale to begin with? We as consumers never really got the choice to decide. The internet age quickly arrived and our privacy became a commodity to be glossed over in private policies.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by AshWolfy on Sunday November 22, 2020 @09:29PM (#25183049)
It doesnt solve the issue and wouldnt actually be much money anyways