News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Getting Paid for Your Data Is a Bad Deal by awinter-py on Monday November 23, 2020 @02:39PM (#25190767)
look your objection is valid but:

privacy as a legal right is complex and ill-defined -- if you look just at CCPA or GDPR, these are big laws with large compliance costs with the risk of benefiting incumbents like FB/G

if your goal is to develop a robust case law for privacy in the united states, pay for privacy accomplishes that because if I pay a dollar for 'private mode', and the vendor breaks our contract, I can absolutely sue.

we also don't know which privacy features users want. hard to write laws without market research, and you can't do market research if there's no market for a good.

another issue is that if privacy laws 'demonetize free tiers', you're effectively paying for privacy anyway. 'pay for privacy' vs 'privacy as right' may be a false choice.

I'm not saying market privacy is fair on the face of it, but it may be more effective than the alternatives.

There are no comments on this comment yet.