News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by arkitaip on Sunday November 08, 2020 @10:42AM (#25026425)
Title is misleading. We are talking about an use case where a mobile phone bought from a bank/creditor on an installment plan can have it's features locked until payments are resumed.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by buzzerbetrayed on Sunday November 08, 2020 @10:44AM (#25026434)
Oh wow. That’s even worse than what the title implies.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by ByteJockey on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:11AM (#25026648)
Can you elaborate a little on what you originally thought the title meant?

Because I thought it meant that banks would be able to monitor/lock your phone, which they would presumably use as a prerequisite for installing their banking app. Basically millions of people who have no other way to remotely access banking services being forced to have their most personal details monitored by large financial institutions and allow those institutions to cut them off from their phones.

Then it seems that it means that if you buy something on an installment plan and stop paying, you lose the ability to use it to the full extent.

We can make an argument about a phone being necessary in the modern world, but the second scenario seems much less Orwellian than the first.

This implies to me, that you may have had a very different interpretation of the title, and I'm curious what it was.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by jiofih on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:27AM (#25026776)
I also interpreted as banking apps having the ability to lock your phone (for security reasons).

I don’t know how you think that this is fine - it is not how financing works. You borrow the money to purchase the device, and go into debt with the lender. They don’t own the phone and shouldn’t have any kind of access to it - it is purely a financial dispute the moment you stop paying.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by ByteJockey on Sunday November 08, 2020 @03:17PM (#25028598)
Forgive me for not knowing this, I've never financed a phone (I used those $40-80 walmart smartphones until fairly recently).

Do phone loans of this sort not function as collateralized loans? In such a loan, ownership reverts to the lender when payments aren't made, or perhaps several payments (depending on the contract).

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by jiofih on Monday November 09, 2020 @08:33AM (#25034598)
Even in that case. Think of a car lease, ownership can be reverted but the lessor has no access to the vehicle on their own.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by efreak on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @03:41AM (#25043903)
Unless they installed a gps tracker and remote kill switch. Which they might well have done. With self driving cars, eventually the car may be able to return itself.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by ByteJockey on Tuesday November 10, 2020 @10:06PM (#25055095)
They send a repo-person after you instead.

Is that really the model you want here?

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by blfr on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:16AM (#25026692)
No, it isn't because it limits the damage to devices purchased from a source you can avoid. That you would want to avoid anyway.

This device has complete access to your Google account, probably your photos, emails, maybe even credit cards. Smartphone has become such an important piece of personal computing that you want to buy one straight from the manufacturer or their authorized dealer and, since you're on HN, preferably with unlockable bootloader.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:46AM (#25026928)
Honestly, how long until all kinds of shady actors come up with excuses to gain access to the api? My device, my choices. If it is not paid, sue me in a legal court. Everything else is private enforcement.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by crankyoldcrank on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:49AM (#25026950)
If it's financed it.. isn't really your device until it's paid off. By your logic repo men should be illegal.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:54AM (#25026988)
No, the phone is mine, it is a collateral for the loan. If I'm not paying, the court must acknowledge the fact before the lender has the right to private enforcement.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by kshacker on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:11PM (#25027119)
Well they are changing the perspective. The phone is theirs until the payment is complete.

Very likely that's how they write the contract too. They may still sell it like "auto pilot" but the paperwork defines the actual contract.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by p49k on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:18PM (#25027169)
They are "changing the perspective" to a behavior which is predatory and stacked against one party. A company cannot just write anything they want into a contract and expect it to be enforceable; there are rules surrounding what is and isn't acceptable in contracts.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by Aeronwen on Sunday November 08, 2020 @02:44PM (#25028333)
Rent-to-own has been a thing for ages.

While predatory, it's apparently acceptable in contracts.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:18PM (#25027170)
Everything is legal in a sufficiently corrupt system. It doesn't make it moral.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by robocat on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:17PM (#25027163)
Even if the phone were destroyed, you would still have to pay the debt.

When purchasing a phone on credit, you sign a contract which gives the lender certain rights they wouldn’t otherwise have. No “rights” are broken.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:23PM (#25027201)
Yes, I must pay the sum because I've borrowed the money and what happens to the phone is my responsibility. It has nothing to do with the rights of the lender. Their rights are to repossess the phone if it is not paid because the phone is collateral, not because they own it.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by p49k on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:29PM (#25027243)
Using repo men (self-repossession) is in fact illegal in much of the civilized world.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by Shivetya on Sunday November 08, 2020 @11:51AM (#25026962)
if its not paid how is it your device? If the agreement does not surrender complete control and with regard to the subject mentioned they are not, it is not yet your device.

now if you complete the agreement then if becomes your device. however contracts which usually allow for remote control specify it very clearly.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:00PM (#25027046)
Because I'm borrowing from the lender to buy from the seller. The fact that they are the same entity is not significant.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by cortesoft on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:13PM (#25027143)
So do you think it is wrong for a bank to send a repo man to take back a car that someone hasn't paid the note on?

What if they set it up as a "rent to own", where you can get to rent a phone for $x a month, and after N months you own it? Would it be ok to restrict functionality then?

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by gostsamo on Sunday November 08, 2020 @12:27PM (#25027231)
The bank can repossess a collateral if the contract is broken. That's why it is collateral. However, this is a legal procedure and is not subject to their whims. If they set it as a rent, I'll just go to the guys who give me the same money, but I'll own the device. Renting it means that I have no legal recourse against unreasonable search for example. This is not a house and I don't have any rights written anywhere.
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by dang on Sunday November 08, 2020 @03:01PM (#25028461)
We've changed the title (it used to be "Google Launches App That Lets Banks Remotely Lock Your Android Device") since we changed the URL (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25027134).
Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by rkagerer on Sunday November 08, 2020 @01:39PM (#25027794)
Who the flip would want to buy a phone from their bank?

I already avoid buying my phone hardware from my telco service provider, even if it means I have to pay more (for an unlocked product).

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by teh_klev on Sunday November 08, 2020 @01:54PM (#25027936)
Any time you're "buying" a phone on a plan then it'll involve a credit agreement and there'll be a bank involved somewhere. So when you walk into your local phone shop pick out a nice shiny handset and decide on a monthly plan (because you can't afford 800 quid plus to buy it outright) you'll be signing a credit agreement. It's the underlying finance company that this app is aimed at, not the retailer or the telco. Until that 24-48 month plan is paid up you don't own the phone, the finance company does.

This is why I buy my handsets outright, not locked to a carrier (and also because of recent financial bad luck my credit rating is a total dumpster fire).

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by goatinaboat on Sunday November 08, 2020 @01:26PM (#25027662)
on an installment plan can have it's features locked until payments are resumed

Plot twist: when you finish paying it off you still don’t really own it. You are just permitted to use it be the real owner all along, Google. Until they want paying in cash again, and they cut off your OS updates. “Nice phone you got, shame if it got a virus”.

Re:App lets banks lock your financed phone if you default on... by URfejk on Sunday November 08, 2020 @10:45AM (#25026444)
Yes, but I couldn't post a title that long ...