Around 1999 SGI Octanes were about 50K, at the time NT machines (think Intergraph) appeared that were, for many, many purposes, just as capable. They were 10K.
In addition the MIPS chip was considerably worse than a dual proc x86 machine of the same vintage. I was working at a company where there was a C++ API. Compilation time on the SGI was 2 hours. It was 10 minutes on the Intergraph.
When cards like the Nvidia Quadro and FireGL cards came they were better than SGI machines and cost a few thousand dollars.
This guy worked for NEXT, who were eaten early because they produced massively overpriced workstations that there was a small market for. They didn't even survive the workstation market, let alone the coming wave of better hardware from very large development budgets for mass market parts.
Exactly. As much as I liked the environment the premium you paid for what was sub-par performance really killed the market. And when SGI ended up selling intel Windows boxes the writing was on the wall for them as well.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Visual_Workstation
I disagree that next got 'eaten early' though, effectively every Mac you've used since those days was a Next workstation marketed under a different brand. Next morphed into Apple much more than that Apple acquired Next.
Be’s TCP stack was never very good. It never had big money applications like Frame or Illustrator, and lacked the robust dev platform (and paying customers) that Next had.
And I'm using "business" in a generic sense. This was an important quality for schools, as well, where Macs were incredibly popular (for a number of reasons, including favorable pricing from Apple and historical support for schools since the 80s). Single user OSes just don't fit within any organization trying to at least pretend to have decent IT.
How has OS X's "multi-userness" helped organizations?
Do you literally mean two or more people using the same Mac?
Has it been useful for organizations that users can ssh into Macs? Or is Apple Remote Desktop involved? (Does Apple Remote Desktop even allow 2 people two use two instance of OS X's GUI at the same time?)
Or by "multi-user" do you refer to the services that can be enabled using the "Sharing" pane of System Preferences (e.g., file sharing, printer sharing, remote management, internet sharing)?
It’s not about simultaneous use, but standard user management, access control, and permissions.
Though yes, technically this also allows multiple to access it simultaneously via ssh and other things that’s not the important part for IT in this instance.
- BeOS was not a great choice, though certain aspects were much better than NeXT, primarily the filesystem. There were a lot of things missing, but BeOS's lack of printer support was the headline issue; seems ridiculous today, but "desktop publishing" still mattered to Apple at the time, and it spoke to immaturity of the BeOS graphics stack.
- Aside from WebObjects, the vaunted NeXT software stack was bitrotting. It was buggy and unstable on commodity PC hardware, and it was never polished enough for non-Unix-savvy end users. Apple spent something like six years bringing it up to a consumer-ready spec before they felt comfortable dropping classic Mac OS.
- The original iPod used no NeXT-derived software.
- But without the NeXT purchase, Apple wouldn't have gotten Steve back.
- Without Steve back at Apple, the iPod wouldn't have existed.
- Without the iPod, you don't get the iPhone.
This is not: “NeXT was just a way to be rid of a legacy business”
Apple needed an OS, they bought NeXT which was a superb investment given how critical the OS has been.
They also needed cashflow, and more importantly to appeal to consumers and differentiate themselves from Windows PC. The iPod was a successful part of that strategy.
The iPod served its purpose and now is gone. NeXT became the most commercially successfully operating system of all time.
Also, according to Avie Tevanian, Steve Jobs lost interest in NeXT when it shed its hardware business and shifted to a software company primarily selling to the enterprise business community instead of education, its intended market. Jobs focused his attention on Pixar, leaving management to the VPs of sales, engineering, and finance.
With Windows NT and Linux being viable operating systems for the sorts of applications people used workstations for, it was only a matter of time before workstations died out. The main thing holding back Intel machines by 1996 or so was software support for workstation type applications such as EDA and CAD tools, but this was sorted out within a few years.
The last holdout was SGI, which was used in the visual effects industry, but NVIDIA caught up to them in about 1999 and SGI gave up on its performance leadership, and the applications followed.
Today they're mainly used for low-end cheap routers, because high-end market is occupied from ARMs.
What Linux + x86 did kill was the entry- and mid-range Unix server market. Redhat grew very rich largely by offering a cheaper platform (x86 + RHEL) to run Oracle RDBMS. And when the web started taking off, Linux + x86 was the default platform (still is). Similarly, the technical computing market (clusters, supercomputers, etc.) more or less completely migrated to x86 + Linux.
IBM sort of survived this carnage by retreating into the high end, and by having a lot of other business (consulting, mainframes, software, etc.) that they could leverage.
Sometimes I wonder if Sun could have survived if they had gone for the x86 commodity hardware route. They already had built the first generation (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun386i ) but instead decided to go all-in on SPARC and bespoke hardware.
When x86 & NT became good enough for whatever engineering application they were working with, there was a large incentive to switch that one to NT and consolidate everything on one machine.
They did try again in the late '00s: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sun_Ultra_series#x86 I always wondered why that didn't work out for them; seemed like a natural pivot.
By the late 00's, Linux was much more solid and Sun didn't stand a chance.
They did a Hail Mary effort with ZFS & dtrace, but in the end few people cared enough to switch.
- Matlab
- Pro/E
- Solidworks
- Ansys
- Autocad
- Altium
- STK
I don't buy this entirely. I'd agree it ate into the market share, yes of course it did. And the blurring of commodity server and desktop hardware ate further.
What Linux didn't replace was accountability: there were plenty of shops which needed hardware vendor supplied and supported OS. It wasn't a technical decision, but a checkbox their customers demanded as some sort of due diligence checkbox. Then Redhat arrived on cheap hardware and ate into that share further, because they checked some of the boxes.
Sparc and Solaris was still technically superior for some things and still had all the throats to choke.
What changed for Sun was Oracle buying them: jacking prices; buying all the competitors to control them like Sleepycat, TimesTen, and MySQL; suing customers; suing security researchers; suing benchmarkers; and charging triple (not an exaggeration) to reinstate lapsed support contracts etc etc.
"We're a Sun Shop" was not longer the appeal it once was on the server, and of course nobody would need a desktop Sun with those downsides.
SUN were basically forced to sell or face bankruptcy in a year or so. Their market was already gone by then. They were completely uncompetitive against Redhat and commodity x86, and they knew it - hence the big opensource push, which was too little too late, and the overall feel of confusion they were projecting. There was just no reason left to buy SUN for anyone but the most hardcore Solaris geek.
In hindsight, they should have tried to pivot to services, instead of focusing on releasing free software in the hope it would drive hardware sales.
https://www.computerweekly.com/news/2240061933/Sun-enables-o...
There are many reasons for the demise of workstations, mentioned in other posts, but I don't think that Linux was one of them.
Depends on where you look. In academia and scientific computing, the landscape is completely different.
Most of the software is written Linux-first. Because it's both easier to move on to clusters and open source philosophy (GPL & MIT licenses) is more prominent than ever.
A lot of the cutting edge tools are open source and there's a strange model in some: Software is free, code is open, but for research you need a license. You need to give your license number in your publication otherwise it might get rejected and/or retracted and you'd be fined by the company developing the software.
Forking is not feasible since both the software is well known and developing that kind of scientific software is very hard (to put it mildly).
Yes, MATLAB works everywhere but, MATLAB is not the peak scientific software. It's generally the base camp where you start. If you want MPI even for local runs, you're in *NIX land, squarely.
There are also other interesting software, like Singularity which can run containers as non-privileged users and some software (like OpenFOAM) is also available as a prebuilt container.
Java is (was? still is?) free for non-commercial use only. Even if OpenJDK is present.
There were some other software which I was using but, forgot their names (since I don't use them anymore).
IIRC OpenJDK had to change/reimplement some image processing algorithms from Kodak et. al but, I'm not sure whether Oracle is using older closed source libraries or OpenJDK's re-implementation in its version.
https://blogs.oracle.com/java-platform-group/oracle-jdk-rele...
I have been designing semiconductors since 1997. All of the EDA (Electronic Design Automation) tools from Cadence, Synopsys, Mentor, and others are written for Unix/X11. Back then everyone had a Sun SPARC or HP PA-RISC on their desk. A few had an IBM RS/6000 or maybe a DEC Alpha. In the server room we had some Sun Enterprise E4000 class machines with 12 CPUs and 16GB RAM.
We started using Linux on the desktop as X terminals to the Suns in the closet and got rid of most of our Sun desktops.
From around 2002-2012 all of the EDA vendors ported their tools to Linux and we ran them straight on our Linux desktops. For multiple simulation runs we would send those jobs to the server cluster machines through LSF.
Since around 2013 the 3 companies I have worked for have used virtual desktop sessions using NX or X2Go running on the remote servers. All of the remote servers run Linux with a GNOME/KDE/XFCE desktop. Then we run the client on whatever machine and OS you want. Disconnect your session at work, go home, reconnect, and you have the exact desktop with everything open just as you left it.
I used to work for a company that did this called MSI. It developed an application for designing mobile telephone radio networks. You would load up a terrain map, specify the location, height and antenna type of your transmitters, and it would calculate signal strength, interference, traffic capture, etc. we'd sell the software, workstations, backup systems, storage arrays, etc as a turn key system.
The second pillar was as development systems for server or mainframe applications. You wanted to be developing on a system with the same architecture and software as the target system. To an extent you can lump in sysadmin workstations into this category. When I was a sysadmin I'd develop scripts on my workstation, and often compile and test open source software on it before deploying it to our environment, such as GhostScript, Apache and early versions of Python. Yep, back then these didn't come along with the OS.
The third pillar was academia and scientific institutions, where they were used for analytical work, or to develop custom software needed for particular research projects, or tools needed by the institutions.
Most of the vertically integrated ISV stuff moved to Windows, but some such as CAD and VFX is still rooted in Linux. The other two niches, dev workstations and scientific applications, also either went to windows or to Linux. So yes it didn't all go to Linux, but the slices of the pies that didn't got to Windows mostly went to Linux.
It did in certain industries like VFX/CG: it used to be SGI workstations running IRIX, now almost all large high-end VFX companies are running Linux on x86, and have been since ~2003 (there were one or two stragglers for a bit, but some companies like DD moved to Linux (and NT for a bit) in the late 90s on x86).
Main reasons were the Linux and GNU development environment slowly overtook the Solaris one in convenience - in the end even the SUNs ran mostly gcc and the whole open source stack. Also getting drivers and (patch) installation was fairly easy for Linux and a major headache with Solaris.
Another one does the same in Sun's former offices.
Whereas the current inhabitants are both pure advertising companies, who just happen to use tech as part of their operations.
That is not to say "real" innovation is not taking place, but I get the sense it's just optimization and refinement of internal processes. Maybe VR or high(er) speed networking, but with all the recent IP lawsuits (a copyright on APIs?!) it seems to me that the collaborative spirit of truly new discovery is gone. To use the cliche, I can't shake the feeling that we've discovered everything already.
But what do I know; it all happened before I was even born. I'm just amazed every time I read about all the discovery and experimentation that named it Silicon Valley in the first place.
Once you saw the applications ported to NT (CAD, GIS, 3D graphics), people realized they could run them on much cheaper PC's. You would be able to buy 4 Pentium II's running NT for what a single Sun/SGI would cost. Hell you could buy two PC workstations for what a graphics upgrade cost on the SGI machine.
Given how baffling Solaris x86 was as a product (is it supported? is anyone at Sun taking it seriously? is hardware coming? are they all breathing swamp gas over there?) over the years to those of us who really wanted to like Solaris x86, this seems like a pretty generous comment.
I think you're right about IBM. I don't know if they were the least poorly managed of the Unix vendors, but they had some real customers because of their mainframe business. They definitely deserve some credit for stretching Linux to that hardware.
IBM had some Unix workstations, but that was never their core. Their core was mainframes. IBM could lose the Unix workstation business without blinking. Whereas Sun, SGI, etc., if they lost the Unix workstations, they were dead, because that was who they were.
https://www.zdnet.com/article/server-sales-sun-wins-the-batt...
That was never really true of SGI.
I remember that some guy at SGI wrote an article titled "Pecked to death by ducks", that argued that SGI would never be done in by commodity hardware - that commodity hardware wasn't powerful enough, so it would be as absurd as being pecked to death by ducks. Then dual CPU machines came out, and so he wrote a sequel: "Pecked to death by ducks with two bills".
In the end, though, SGI got pecked to death by 700-pound, 15-foot-tall ducks - the commodity hardware got better faster than SGI's did.
But in the mid-to-late 90s, I loved SGI machines. Not by 2005, maybe, but in their day, they were great.
However the market for workstations that start at 50k is really tiny and saturated quickly. When the PC workstations with comparable I/O performance appeared and sold for half to a quarter of what SGI wanted, SGI was doomed.
It's funny, there was a brief and very painful period where you could point to things SGI's hardware could still do better than everyone else, but it was a rapidly shrinking category of things and everyone could see they were doomed. It was made more painful by the totally ineffectual ways they attempted to save themselves. Proprietary NT hardware! Itanium! Totally random Linux stuff!
A lot of replacement equipment was ordered from large manufacturers of commodity computing products. Are those highly capable devices workstations? PCs? I think they're both.
Linux also gave IBM for the first time an OS that ran on all its hardware, from low-end x86 to POWER workstations to xSeries/iSeries minis to mainframes to supercomputer clusters, a goal it achieved with System/360 in the 1960s then soon had to abandon when the minicomputer and PC markets emerged.
Typing this from a workstation with 64 GB RAM. Maybe not a lot these days, but this comp is ancient by now and still chugs along nicely.
I went to a seminar by an Open Source hacker at a Unix user group conference in the late 90s, where he talked about the Sun funded work he'd done on getting the Linux kernel to run well on Sun workstations. He was absolutely clear that he thought Linux would kill Sun because it completely undermined their software license business, but that this was their problem. They just had no good options.
I suspect the reason IBM was able to reconcile with Linux and even go all-in on it was that it complemented their lucrative very high end server and mainframe businesses. Their workstation businesses benefited from a halo effect from the super high-end mega-systems that protected it from becoming total road kill, but Sun and the other vendors never really managed to establish themselves at the super high-end, so when Intel ditched Itanium and PCs caught up with RISC they were left without a market.