News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by throwaway13337 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:20PM (#24844458)
Back in '97, Microsoft invested 150m into Apple as well as published office on macs. This was very likely an effort to keep a competitor alive to pretend windows was not a monopoly.

Mozilla is in a much worse position than Apple was in '97. The only way they can continue to exist is to be on the take from Google's handout.

The corpse of Mozilla as a puppet to perform for regulators at Google's command is probably a net negative for the world.

Maybe Mozilla has run its course.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by foepys on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:24PM (#24844483)
The day Mozilla shuts its doors is the day when Google would become synonymous with the internet. Nobody would ever be able to make anything in it that Google doesn't want to exist.

Google would deprecate APIs for other APIs that seemingly have the same purpose but are missing a single crucial feature.

They would build websites on Chrome private builds that include features that make these apps possible and conveniently release them at nearly the same time so nobody can contest them at launch.

Add-ons would be deleted because of arbitrary "ToS violations" like Apple already does. Although they are already planning to cripple add-ons like ad blockers with manifest v3.

And much more.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by throwaway13337 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:33PM (#24844522)
The argument is that it's already happened. But because Mozilla exists, they can pretend that it hasn't.

In this way, Mozilla is actually helping Google dominate the internet by providing very useful regulatory cover.

Google has free reign to do all of what you listed. They tread lightly only due to fears of regulation.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by foepys on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:36PM (#24844535)
What's the next step after Mozilla shuts down and Google loses its cover?

Anti-trust cases take at least 10 years. This is plenty of time for Google to make the internet theirs and the then defunct Gecko engine to be too old to use. Blink and WebKit will be the only engines left.

Even if you then pry Blink and Chrome away from Google, there will never be another browser engine and it's naïve to think that just because Blink isn't legally part of Alphabet anymore that they will be instantly independent.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by d3nj4l on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:16AM (#24844689)
Exactly. Chromium is open source; Google can simply make open-source modifications to it the same way others can. Splitting Chrome from Google isn't going to do anything, and won't stop Google from making proposals to the IETF that work in their benefit.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dleslie on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:52PM (#24844605)
See also: Mozilla's mobile Firefox which has recently and needlessly broken a great many addons, including many that aided in preventing tracking.

I have two that seem particularly egregious in this context: one that removes utm tracking, and another that redirects amp to html.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dralley on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:23AM (#24844716)
What they did was rewrite half the browser, and release it before every single extension API was re-implemented (because the new version is vastly better in almost every other respect).

It's not really fair to pretend that they deliberately broke your addons out of malfeasance or something.

It seems that most of the APIs are now implemented but are buggy, so they added a flag to the nightly version that allows you to install any addon from AMO at risk of it maybe not working. Once it stabilizes you'll be able to use your addons again.

https://blog.mozilla.org/addons/2020/09/29/expanded-extensio...

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dleslie on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:27AM (#24844735)
As a user, the new version has a worse UI and no notable speed improvements for the sites that I visit.

When I go to open a tab, by default, the ability to close the bottom tab is obscured. And collections? Useless when I already had bookmarks in folders.

But hey, they managed to break important privacy-protecting addons in the process.

I'm not sure why I still use this browser.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by armada651 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @05:58AM (#24846259)
Want to chime in as well that Firefox Mobile before the rewrite was becoming close to unusable for me due to how slow it was.

The rewrite saved me from having to switch to Chrome on Android. It's not perfect, but it's definitely a big improvement.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by modo_mario on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:24AM (#24846389)
The speed improvements are extremely noticeable
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dralley on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:30AM (#24844746)
The speed improvements are very noticable for me.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by Jochim on Thursday October 22, 2020 @05:24AM (#24856227)
I didn't notice much/any speed improvement either. Losing the tab queue sucked and certain links now force open the youtube app rather than in Firefox. The url bar at the bottom is nice, but they released it without the ability to also reverse the order of results.

I think if the new version had just one killer feature it would have been received much more kindly but for many it's a straight downgrade in terms of experience. Personally I think it's crazy that they still don't have working chromecast support.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by marcosdumay on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:51AM (#24847863)
> I'm not sure why I still use this browser.

I use it because the alternative is Chrome. But I'm also very annoyed about the update (forced, like every one is on mobile) and I'm avoiding to use a browser at all on my phone because the experience is so bad.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by Miraste on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:58AM (#24848493)
Before the update, mobile Firefox was so slow for me that using Chrome with no adblocker was a better experience. Now their speeds are about the same. The update was a massive improvement.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by exged on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:26AM (#24844730)
Mozilla is already irrelevant. Firefox market share on desktop is already lower than Safari [1] and continues to decline.

[1] https://gs.statcounter.com/browser-market-share/desktop/worl...

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by walrus01 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:21AM (#24846371)
well that is certainly disheartening
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by finnthehuman on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:44AM (#24847796)
>The day Mozilla shuts its doors is the day when Google would become synonymous with the internet.

More and more I'm starting to agree with the people claiming Mozilla has already ceded on that front, and are just keeping the lights on as long as possible to keep getting paid.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by bhhaskin on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:35PM (#24849456)
Where is the proof for that argument? Firefox quantum is fantastic. Firefox's warp is coming along nicely. The last release (yesterday) adds a lot of performance improvements. The recent layoffs gained some bad will, but every large org does it from time to time. There are a lot of doom sayers out there, but not a lot of proof.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by oriesdan on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @04:38AM (#24845916)
Webkit does still exist :)

Also, Firefox being free software, we can expect forks to appear the very day Mozilla falls. I even wonder if having a swarm of small implementers wouldn't be better for the standards than having three big ones who discuss among themselves, then decide what the standards should be. Maybe browsers would stop getting more complicated than OSes and go back to essential, that way. I would really love seeing web engines getting simple again so that third party developers can contribute to them - and that's certainly a direction many small implementations would push toward.

Of course, this is only speculation. At least, it's not guaranteed doom.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by orra on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:06AM (#24846288)
> we can expect forks to appear the very day Mozilla falls

Eh, forks can legally appear, because it's free software. But maintaining them? Improving the product security, let alone adding new features? That's hella expensive. Hobbyists aren't going to write a competitive a web browser.

So, it's important to have a strong Mozilla with a good revenue stream.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by oriesdan on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:34AM (#24846749)
Yep, that's in line with what I was saying, except for the conclusion.

Yes, I don't see either small teams keeping up with the amount of features we currently have (and security is a direct factor of the amount of features), but I would rather see them scaling down browsers than making sure we can keep adding to them.

Also, beware to not discard "hobbyists" too easily. Hobbyists did create GNU (and still are maintaining it) and early linux. And Blink comes from Webkit, which comes from khtml, made by hobbyists.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dblohm7 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:27AM (#24848182)
That might be how those projects started, but it’s sure as hell not how they’re run now.

There’s no way they could revert to hobbyist projects and survive. Either they would die off or the money would fork them.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by hvis on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:14AM (#24847001)
Hobbyists can't as participate in the web standards organizations, and lobby for the changes most beneficial to the user (and not big corp).
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by d3sandoval on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:17AM (#24847531)
That's not true! You can get involved as an individual contributor and become a part of the web standards community. There's even a contribution guide: https://wpc.guide/
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by hvis on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:45AM (#24858539)
How are you, as an individual, going to protest the inclusion of "next DRM" in the HTML6?
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by walrus01 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:18AM (#24846355)
> The day Mozilla shuts its doors is the day when Google would become synonymous with the internet.

The English language Internet maybe. Due to the great firewall and locally-hosted data laws, China is building a whole parallel world of software, search engines and cloud based stuff that people who don't read and write Chinese rarely see. For instance, here's "Chinese youtube":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Youku

All centrally censored and monitored.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by oblio on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:48AM (#24846516)
China, as big as it is, is just 1 country.

Russia also does something similar but on a much smaller scale.

Google represents the internet for everyone else. And "everyone else" is almost 200 countries and probably thousands of languages and about 6 billion people.

It's not just the "English language internet".

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by berkes on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:20AM (#24846668)
China and India combined make over half the worlds population.

But I agree that serving "all the rest" is important: Even if Lesotho, Iceland and Trinidad, combined hardly make "a healthy online business model", they are there, and this diversity should be paramount to the internet. Silicon-valley giants are not helping here either, though.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by TheNorthman on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:32AM (#24846736)
China and India combined only make about 36% of the worlds population [0], a share that is poised to fall in the coming years.

[0]: https://www.wolframalpha.com/input/?i=%28china+population+%2...

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by oblio on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:35AM (#24847719)
As the side comment, no they don't. China and India aren't half the world's population. And their share is falling.

Even if they were:

1. India is (partly) English speaking, so it doesn't fit the split.

2. If you exclude the English speaking world (let's say 1 billion people) and China + India (3 billion people), you're still left with almost 4 billion people. Out of which about 1 billion live in developed countries or are middle/upper class in developing countries. So that's a big market. Japan, the EU, Latin America, etc.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by berkes on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @11:09AM (#24848570)
> English speaking, so it doesn't fit the split.

English speaking =/= American values.

But a tiny part of your search-engine, social-network, app, or whatever is about the translations of the UI. The largest part is about how social constructs, ideals, workflows, and so forth fit. An Indian user might be able to read the screens on your app just fine, but might still be left out due to cultural issues.

In the EU this often becomes very clear when your startup "expands to Belgium" for example. It is not just about translating the app in Dutch and French; the way people interact, do business, communicate; the problems people have, the problems they dont have, and so forth are very different.

This is a pet-peeve of mine: we are all pushed in an American Template due to the prevalence of Silicon Valley "dictated" norms. When I was young, nudity on television in my country was normal. A local movie would have to have at least two naked tits. Today our media has become prude; no more tits on TV on prime-time; something that creeps onto us as "collatoral damage" of using primarily US media platforms.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:33AM (#24844758)
> The day Mozilla shuts its doors is the day when Google would become synonymous with the internet.

There's more to the internet than what is accessed via browsers, but as far as browsers are concerned, well, Apple is not spelled M-O-Z-I-L-L-A.

The vast majority of all browser use that isn't Google's Blink is WebKit; Mozilla was significant, but not so much today.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by foepys on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @01:27AM (#24844991)
Try setting up a mail server and sending more than 5 mails a day to Gmail, the biggest mail provider. Be prepared for your mails to be declared spam.

Google has their own DNS they default to on Android. Who knows when google will "block harmful domains".

Google is pushing alternatives to HTTP that are vastly more complicated and improve speed, thus increasing search/page rank.

Yes, you will be able to run things yourself. Just don't expect them to be discoverable.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:36AM (#24846448)
I think you misunderstood. I wasn't saying Google doesn't have influence over the non-browser parts of the Internet, I'm saying Mozilla isn't a counterbalance to them on the non-browser parts, nor is Mozilla anywhere close to the most important counterbalance, any more, in the browser space.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by jmnicolas on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @09:26AM (#24847638)
If Google started behaving like you envision, the community could always fork the last known good version of Chromium.

When not using Firefox I'm using an ungoogled version of Chromium (from the Woolys site) I didn't see much difference with the original Chrome.

Anyway as the recent news showed, Mozilla's management is extremely wasteful of their resources. If the project was just paying devs to work on Firefox, much less money would be needed and if needed the whole thing could probably be funded by donations.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by Yizahi on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:46AM (#24848379)
Of course there isn't much difference because Chromium is basically Chrome. There is no single independent Chrome/Chromium fork today meaning that they are the same. Everything Google adds to Chrome get down to Chromium. Sure you can (maybe) cut some telemetry but functional changes stay. If Google decides to switch some protocol handling, or deprecate stuff, or add stuff it all propagates to all mods of Chrome.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by whatsmyusername on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:48PM (#24849580)
Edge. Which you will see increase in market share.
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by Yizahi on Friday October 23, 2020 @11:26AM (#24870465)
Edge is dead and closed. Chrome-Edge will indeed gain market share and it is better than nothing, but I dispute that it is an independent browser making independent decisions about browser engine and other important stuff (not about GUI and telemetry).
Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by whatsmyusername on Sunday October 25, 2020 @08:08PM (#24891393)
That's what I meant. Though I guess they've decided to take the google route in deploying manifest v3.

So I'll probably be dumping them for firefox (or rather, reversing how I use them. Use firefox for my 'logged in' browser and edge as my 'noscript, no cookies, no history, default browser')

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by trabant00 on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:02AM (#24846933)
Maybe that is not a bad thing? Maybe the current state is encouraging people to hang on to impossible hopes for things to get better. And if Google would become synonymous with the internet the people would drop that hope and start building something that would really benefit users and not big co?

Something like a paradise after apocalypse scenario. Or maybe it's just wishful thinking.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by microtherion on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @06:16AM (#24846344)
> Back in '97, Microsoft invested 150m into Apple as well as published office on macs. This was very likely an effort to keep a competitor alive to pretend windows was not a monopoly.

Yes, but ultimately, it DID keep Apple alive at a critical juncture, and Apple ended up returning to relevance, at least in newer markets.

So maybe even such artificial life preservers sometimes have a competitive benefit.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by leejoramo on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @11:39PM (#24844546)
To clarify, in 1997 Microsoft promised to continue publishing Office for Mac. Arguably many of the core MS Office applications (Word, Excel, PowerPoint) started on the Mac.

Yes, Word for DOS existed before — I used it — but Word for Windows was much more like the Mac version.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by kqvamxurcagg on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:41AM (#24846807)
Mozilla has become dependent on Google. It's natural they will lobby for their payments to continue. It's a great strategy by Google - keep the #2 competitor dependent on you and they will even lobby on your behalf. All for a few hundred million dollars!

Another HN post several weeks ago showed the bloated salaries of Mozilla executives. Mozilla as an organisation should be much smaller, sustainable and led by technicians not business executives.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by tzs on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @12:17PM (#24849258)
> Back in '97, Microsoft invested 150m into Apple as well as published office on macs. This was very likely an effort to keep a competitor alive to pretend windows was not a monopoly.

> Mozilla is in a much worse position than Apple was in '97.

Indeed. In fact, Apple was in no short or medium term danger when they got the $150 million from Microsoft. They had at the time around $1.2 billion in cash reserves.

Getting Office on Mac was probably far more important to Apple than the cash. The deal guaranteed Microsoft would support Office on Mac for at least five years.

Microsoft got more out of it than just looking a little better to antitrust regulators. Part of the deal was that Apple would drop its lawsuit alleging that Microsoft had copied large parts of the look and feel of the Mac GUI. That had been going on for many years.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by perryizgr8 on Thursday October 22, 2020 @10:40AM (#24858488)
> Maybe Mozilla has run its course.

Unless they let their Steve Jobs back at the reins. Guess who.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by artiszt on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:14AM (#24846630)
>Maybe Mozilla has run its course<

most certainly not technically given for instance : https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24817304

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by gilrain on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:30AM (#24846724)
Well, they laid off the entire Servo team, which was effectively their R&D and was responsible for many of the recent performance wins in Firefox.

So, certainly yes technically.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by jhoechtl on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @07:56AM (#24846913)
Didn't the servo team mostly dabble with Rust? What a bad idea from the very beginning to invent a new language and base core components on it when all you have to to is speed up an exisitng product and you are already using the fastest known language fot that task (--> C).

A slow Firefox was an architectural problem not because of choosing the wrong tooling.

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by nemothekid on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:49AM (#24848411)
I can’t tell if this is a sarcastic remark or if you truly believe speeding up something as complex as a browser is a cake walk.

Two big reasons Rust was invented was to (1) easily parallelize the renderer without introducing many bugs (2) speed up the browser without introducing many exploits.

It’s common knowledge now in applications like Chrome (and even Windows) that memory errors are the largest source of CVEs and that type of exploit is almost impossibly difficult to cause in Rust

Re:Mozilla Reaction to U.S. vs. Google by ylyn on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:29AM (#24848218)
Languages are not just about speed.

And Rust is plenty fast.