News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by lawrenceyan on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:51AM (#24835530)
Wow, are internet speeds in the UK actually that slow? Why are they so far behind the EU?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:59AM (#24835601)
The UK has adopted the US model of "hollowing out"; services that get used by the small elite fraction of the country that lives in the right bits of London are good, everything else is quietly ignored.

It also has a pseudo-market for broadband services through LLU. The network service and billing are done through various providers which compete on price. The ADSL line is monopolized by BT Openreach, who combine the efficiency of a state monopoly with the pricing of a private monopoly.

The government periodically gives BT money to improve speeds. BT pay this money to shareholders and then fail to improve speeds. Both parties are apparently happy with this arrangement.

One of the candidates at the last election promised free high-speed broadband to the country. Media commentators agreed that this was ludicrous pie-in-the-sky.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by PaulKeeble on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:56AM (#24835941)
London is actually one of the bad areas for broadband. Due to the density its not been deemed worthwhile to roll out fibre to home at all and fibre to the curb is often held up by a bunch of factors including there being no room in the local telecoms office for the hardware and difficulties placing the boxes on the street to contain the replacement dslams alongside the other road works. Many rollouts have been held up for many years due to very hard logistics problems.

It has proven much easier to roll out fibre into villages and smaller towns where DSL is no where near as obvious as the solution and there is room to place the equipment easily.

What irks me more than anything is the fact that builders are making big blocks of flats and running normal copper cabling into them. Ones that opened just 5 years ago genuinely had ADSL back to the local telecoms office and only recently got upgraded to DSLAMS in their basements to fibre. It really doesn't save a lot of money to put copper in instead of fibre at this point and to not have planned at the very least VDSL is just quite ridiculous. These types of builds have just made local issues with broadband that much worse.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:24AM (#24835756)
This is a summary entirely tilted by a very questionable political perspective.

You'll find the same problems elsewhere in Europe dealing with population density and rolling out the infrastructure for this stuff. I know plenty of people in Sweden, France, Germany who struggle with exactly the same issues, despite better headline average speeds etc.

> "hollowing out"; services that get used by the small elite fraction of the country that lives in the right bits of London are good, everything else is quietly ignored.

Fundamentally wrong given that central London is in a large proportion (often > 50% by ward) social housing. Or are the millions of people who live there the "small elite" too? Or perhaps it is the case the high population density urban centres are naturally the easiest place to build infrastructure to benefit the most people.

> BT pay this money to shareholders and then fail to improve speeds. Both parties are apparently happy with this arrangement.

Clearly this isn't true. BT OR has for many years been separated and highly and transparently regulated. Perhaps you would like to explain more your implications of corruption that isn't visible to anyone else?

https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/114814/...

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:50AM (#24836266)
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/britain-being...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23194287

https://br0kent3l3ph0n3.wordpress.com/2013/09/26/dcms-misman...

(admittedly those aren't all recent, but that's how we got in this situation over the past decade). It's not just me but the Commons Public Accounts Committee.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:04AM (#24836351)
Can you explain what you think those links prove related to the above discussion?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by LargoLasskhyfv on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:58AM (#24836311)
Huh? Sweden? I thought that was paradise, and where there is no fibre, some 4G, or WLL(Wireless Local Loop) thing is used instead?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by gazoakley on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:57AM (#24835947)
Whilst competition has been pretty slow to improve speeds, there are an increasing number of altnets around the UK with small providers running their own FTTP networks. This is even happening in rural locations through organizations like B4RN. I wish it would move faster, but I'm glad that we have some competition - Corbynband would likely have nuked other providers, and I can only imagine the kind of filtering that would get applied to it. Hopefully good ISPs like Andrews & Arnold can stick around.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:39AM (#24835837)
As an American that is a familiar story, with telcos over the years taking money and not delivering the upgrades promised. We were supposed to have a lot more widespread fiber to the home for instance, and I think we still pay a little more than many other countries.

However by now in 2020, I believe the majority of the US has access to internet over cable tv lines/docsis instead of dsl with speeds more like 100mbps, with up to 1 or 2 gbps available in big metros for $70 a month. I know many rural areas are still underserved, and of course not every household is subscribed to internet service, but it seems to be available in most places.

I’m really surprised internet in the UK seems to be an order of magnitude or more slower for such a large percentage of the population.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by hirako2000 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:52AM (#24835914)
That's right, my UK broadband in central Edinburgh gives me 6Mbps if im lucky. 1mbps upload.

I roam around in South east Asia, not the developed states such as Singapore.. In Vietnam I get 60mbps, 16Mbps upload at home for 15 USD per month. I go to coffee shops they are all equipped with 40 to 100Mbps. Malaysia offered 300Mbps for $50 per month. 5 years ago.

And all plans are truely unlimited. Whats more? 4G/edge is commonly covered across the country, 8Gbytes pay as you go for.. 5$

The telecom companies in the UK, US and most developed countries are simply treating customers like cows and protect their oligopoly via corruption/lobbying of officials.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:59AM (#24835958)
We used to get ~60Mbps in central Edinburgh. However, we moved out to a rural area and we get 22Mbps down and 1 up and that is really good for a house outside of a city or town.

Edit: We had a problem with our BT connection recently and I almost got a 4G connection from these folks: https://www.4g-internet.co.uk/

Edit: Actual fibre connectivity was going to be a few thousand just to get a quote... :-(

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by hirako2000 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:08AM (#24836019)
Yes some Edinburgh blocks have fibre. And those who don't only get copper adsl. My neighbours (same block) have had fibers for several years, go figure.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:54AM (#24836292)
We live ~12km from the centre of Edinburgh and only recently got mobile phone coverage at our house - so I shouldn't complain too much out Internet speeds.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:20AM (#24835732)
Can't have tax-payers money used to improve conditions for normal people - that would be socialism!.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by danpalmer on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:11AM (#24835672)
I think this article misrepresents the state of UK internet.

Most of the population are wired for fibre and have been for a few years now. This typically starts at ~35Mbps, ~70Mbps is very common, and a few providers will do 200-300Mbps but in more limited areas. Some suppliers do 1Gbps, but these are often limited to apartment blocks in cities or towns that invested heavily in infrastructure.

This quote is misleading:

> Found some data about internet speed in the UK, wasn’t easy to come across, that puts 45% of UK housesolds have < 8 Mbps connection.

The graph below shows that this is a survey of ADSL2+ users where the technical cap is 20Mbps. They obviously can't get any better. Anecdotally this matches my expectations.

I think the reality of the current state is that most of the population can get fibre, but many haven't bothered upgrading from their ADSL/ADSL2+ packages. When I've done price comparisons there's typically not a lot of difference in price mid-market, but there are some very low end providers who will do ADSL/2+ for ~£10, where typically home broadband/fibre is £20-40.

Lastly, with things like home internet it's not useful to talk about area coverage.

> I moved to a newer home earlier this year and like most places in the UK (even in London) it only had broadband internet aka slow ADSL over copper.

Yes, most of the UK does not have fibre, but a significant part of that is fields. In reality most of the _population_ have access to fibre, but of course they are not evenly distributed. Area coverage makes a bit more sense when talking about wireless/cellular services because people move about.

There are a few areas of London that were wired up in the late 90s/early 00s in such a way that they are very hard to re-wire for fibre. The Surrey Quays area comes to mind as one. Those areas have essentially skipped fibre and are moving straight to 5G.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by jfindley on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:44AM (#24835870)
You appear to be using the term access to fibre a bit loosely. The vast majority[0] of the UK only has access to a product called "fibre to the cabinet" (FTTC), which is a poor substitute for what would pass for a fibre connection in most countries.

For those not from the UK, FTTC is a product where they run fibre connections to the local cabinet - however from there it runs over the end users phone line using VDSL2. For historical reasons this line may be aluminium instead of copper, and is often long with lots of splits and joins. As you can expect, this can degrade performance a great deal, and there's basically nothing an end user can do to get this upgraded. For PR reasons, these connections are named "Superfast broadband" and the regulator notes that 95% of the population can get one. However in practice due to old and badly maintained phone lines, real speeds are often much lower than the "minimum 30Mbps" they claim.

0: As per https://www.increasebroadbandspeed.co.uk/broadband-statistic... only 8% of the population has access to "real" fibre to their actual premises.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by danpalmer on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:27AM (#24836487)
You're right, I'm using "fibre" loosely here. What I really mean is a connection that is an order of magnitude faster than ADSL/2+ and that solves the problem being complained about in the article.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by Silhouette on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:23AM (#24835748)
I don't know why the parent was downvoted. It's a reasonably accurate summary of the state of Internet access in much of the UK, and it correctly identifies the misleading emphasis on ADSL-based technologies in the article.

In practice, most UK premises now have at least FTTC available, which can give realistic download speeds of up to 80Mbps depending on how close to the cabinet you are. FTTP is the technology currently being worked on in a lot of areas but will obviously take a long time to become the norm if only because existing housing stock will need new cables to be physically installed. If you're willing to have that disruption and to pay the premium, there are also cable companies that will install dedicated lines for you with much higher speeds even if FTTP isn't yet available in your area using BT's network.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by jfindley on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:11AM (#24836038)
Likely because the parent said "Most of the population are wired for fibre" which is wildly misleading. FTTC would not fit most people's definition of being "wired for fibre".

Describing 80Mbps for FTTC as realistic is also a bit of a stretch. If you live in an area with modern phone lines and happen to be close to the local cabinet, this may be your experience but isn't that representative of the population as a whole. Per https://labs.thinkbroadband.com/local/ the mean download speed for FTTC is only 34Mbps, which given that some users are getting speeds of 80Mbps should tell you a lot about how poorly it performs for others.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by Silhouette on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:59AM (#24836321)
I live in a very old village, some miles outside the nearest big city, and we routinely see those actual speeds on OpenReach FTTC. I suspect that the lower average figures have more to do with ISPs offering lower prices for a 40Mbps capped service (which does seem to have been quite common as FTTC has spread) and with some ISPs using much higher contention levels than others.

In any case, even if 34Mbps is the real world average download speed for the type of fibre connection most homes would be using today, that's still much higher than the figures in the article would have suggested for a typical UK home Internet connection speed.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by jfindley on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:30AM (#24836501)
34Mbps mean, across a population of ~67 million, suggests that there are substantial amounts of people getting much less than that. The data is broken down in more detail here[0], and while this isn't limited to just FTTC connections it still has some useful data.

Some takeaway points: Firstly, median speed is always lower than mean, often significantly so, as the mean speed is inflated by users with very fast connections. Secondly, the bottom 20% get very poor speeds, often in the ranges mentioned by the article. Perhaps the article should have said 20% rather than 40%, but I'm not sure that really changes the sting of the title much? Thirdly, and I think this is in some ways the most important takeaway, some users getting excellent connections appears to have no correlation whatsoever with users overall in that area. For example in the City of London, a very wealthy area generally, the top 20% get 94Mbps and the mean user gets 56Mbps. Howwever the median user only gets 39Mbps, and the bottom 20% get only 6.5Mbps - which is definitely little enough to experience the problems in the article.

And for the record, I too live in a very old village, some miles outside the nearest big city, and I pay for the best connection possible to get, which gets me actual speeds far below the "minimum advertised speed" it's supposed to reach. The problem is down to aging aluminium phone lines, which Openreach refuses to replace.

0: https://labs.thinkbroadband.com/local/councils

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by user5994461 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:20AM (#24836097)
The article is correct and you say it yourself, the majority of the population does not have access to fiber.

Eventually you have to realize that as a person you either have good internet or you don't. The poor experience for the 40% who have no access to fiber and don't live right next to the DSL cabinet is very real. We could debate whether the proportion is closer to 30% or 40% or 50% but that doesn't help with the issue.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by d_theorist on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:19AM (#24835719)
I don’t know why this comment is getting downvoted. I agree that the numbers in the article are not representative of the reality in the UK. Entry-level broadband for most people is around 30Mbps minimum.

To say that 4.5Mbps is typical is completely incorrect.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by DanBC on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:35AM (#24836549)
> but there are some very low end providers who will do ADSL/2+ for ~£10,

Where are you finding those please? I'm currently paying £18 for TalkTalk and I'm looking to switch to something cheaper.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by reedf1 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:03AM (#24835630)
Having lived in the UK and the US, I think a strong reason is that the copper wire is literally entrenched. There seems to be a strong (legislative? legal? political?) aversion to easily replaceable overhead wires. Underground cable is the strong preference here. At the moment I live in the city centre of Manchester (the second or third biggest city depending on who you ask) and am stuck with VDSL.

There are other problems as well - arguably there is no functional market for internet here. The UK is quite a small and centralised but for whatever reason cannot deliver infrastructure to "rural" areas that are only 50 or so miles from the largest cities in the UK, e.g. Wales.

I have co-workers who have moved into new builds with only copper to the building.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by ath92 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:13AM (#24835685)
Underground wires are the preferred choice for most of the EU as far as I know (at least in western Europe). There are also much smaller countries in the EU that provide far better internet than what's available in the UK, apparently. There must be some other reason.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by MagnumOpus on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:40AM (#24835841)
> There seems to be a strong (legislative? legal? political?) aversion to easily replaceable overhead wires

I live in the UK with only overhead wires on my street (probably 60-80 years old copper wiring). Those wires are eyesores, and also break regularly since tree branches cut them in storms. Given Openreach's incentives, forget about these wires ever being replaced by fibre.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by robjan on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:30AM (#24835789)
Those entrenched cables are mostly DOCSIS 3 cables over which broadband speeds can be achieved. BT has traditionally provided telephony through overhead wires and those are where the problems usually lie.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by raequal on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:31AM (#24835792)
Oooh yes. Recently moved to London from Switzerland and it was a shock as if i moved to a third world country. From a widely availably gigabit to at best a 10-20 Mbit so called "broadband".

I have to bond all available connections to me (broadband, 4g, bt wifi hotspot; thinking even of adding a high gain directional wifi antenna to a nearby mall) to get some borderline decent speeds here

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by poooogles on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:02AM (#24835627)
>Wow, are internet speeds in the UK actually that slow?

Yes, https://www.speedtest.net/result/10279588044. I share this connection with 5 other people in the evenings, thankfully only 2 of us use it during the day so video conferencing is passable most of the time.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by nicoburns on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:55AM (#24835562)
Not in cities where there is cheap fibre available. But in rural areas it can definitely be like this. It's at least partly because the government ordered our national telecom provider to halt their fibre rollout in the 80s/90s because it deemed it anti-competitive. It's still catching up for lost time.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by amriksohata on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:54AM (#24835554)
The annual 2019 world speeds report from research firm M-Lab and Cable.co.uk has revealed that for 2019 the United Kingdom delivered an average (mean) broadband ISP download speed of just 22.37Mbps (up from 18.57Mbps in 2018 and 16.51Mbps in 2017), ranking us 34th fastest in the world (up from 35th last year).
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by adamfaliq on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:57AM (#24835579)
Anecdotal evidence:

Lived in the UK for five years and yes, it was bad. Virgin Media is the worst culprit. It marketed its broadband as 5G but has unreliable bandwidth. Not to mention this predatory behaviour. [0]

[0] https://virginmedia-is-evil.com/

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by doublerabbit on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:56AM (#24835572)
Because we have a government who doesn't give a shite arse about infrastructure. And that of BT Open Reach corruption.

I live in the city centre and I don't even have fibre. Meanwhile all the new corrupt housing developments all get "fibre" as a perk for buying a house on land that floods.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by Nexxxeh on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:04AM (#24835633)
Around here at least, the fibre I've seen in new builds isn't OpenReach, it's OFNL.

But fellow city dweller here. I'm stuck on Virgin Media coax where I live, despite being about two streets and direct line of site from the BT exchange.

16mb ADSL2 is the best OpenReach can give me as a consumer.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @12:18PM (#24839156)
> I live in the city centre and I don't even have fibre. Meanwhile all the new corrupt housing developments all get "fibre" as a perk for buying a house on land that floods.

In what fashion do you call this corruption?

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by doublerabbit on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @08:16AM (#24847019)
Corrupt housing developments in the UK. Look it up.

Buying off councils, planning permission. You name it.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @10:51AM (#24848439)
You want me to look up your vague unspecific conspiracy theory?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by doublerabbit on Wednesday October 21, 2020 @02:01PM (#24850382)
> You want me to look up your vague unspecific conspiracy theory?

Yes I do, doesn't take a genius. Do you even live in the UK? I've been nice and even included the search for you.

https://www.google.com/search?q=housing+scandels+2019+uk+flo...

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt9764140/

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2019/oct/13/profits-from-p...

https://www.councilhousescandal.co.uk/

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-46279048

And for real experience, I lived next to a field that was repurposed for housing development and because the "deed" was lost, ie owner paid off by housing development company, it is now all houses.

Not forgetting the case of the local council selling off the library of my town to another housing development.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Sunday October 25, 2020 @02:08PM (#24888449)
So what above proves your point regarding systematic corruption?

Pasting a load of hastily googled things doesn't advance your prejudice induced argument one iota.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by formerly_proven on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:00AM (#24835611)
UK isn't an outlier for Central Europe, because speeds are universally pretty bad there (Germany, France, Spain, Poland, Italy etc. all have similarly bad or even worse results). Sure, it's not Russia-bad or Australia-bad, but it really ain't good.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by puszczyk on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @10:24AM (#24837633)
I don’t know much about Spain or Italy, and I agree that Germany uses a lot of copper cables. But France and Poland? Esp. in Poland it most towns you have fiber, all new buildings have had fiber for ages. I currently pay 15–20€ / month for 1Gbps in a like 5th biggest city in Poland (not center, but not far either). In a couple of places in France I’ve stayed longer the internet was good as well (though I don’t recall the prices or exact speed details) — cities including Paris and towns. Granted this is all anecdotal and my bubble, etc.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by formerly_proven on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @10:40AM (#24837849)
While I think fiber is technically better (if the last mile is passive), results are more important and by that metric Poland doesn't seem to be doing any better than its neighbors:

https://www.fastmetrics.com/internet-connection-speed-by-cou... https://www.speedtest.net/global-index

In both of these Poland ranks similarly badly (31st/43rd) despite entirely different data sources. France ranks slightly better but still pretty bad. Note that the first site lists median speeds, while speedtest.net shows averages.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by burntoutfire on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @03:06PM (#24841191)
Poland is still not that urbanized, so relatively large numbers of people living in remote places are for sure bringing the stats down. But, from what I've seen, in the cities getting 150 Mb/s, 300 Mb/s or even 1 Gb/s is common.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by jlouis on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:55AM (#24835564)
Probably a complex explanation with many reasons.

I dont think there is a single reason.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by doublerabbit on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:56AM (#24835575)
Oh there is. The government.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by aloisdg on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:01AM (#24835618)
Capitalism.