News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @05:59AM (#24835601)
The UK has adopted the US model of "hollowing out"; services that get used by the small elite fraction of the country that lives in the right bits of London are good, everything else is quietly ignored.

It also has a pseudo-market for broadband services through LLU. The network service and billing are done through various providers which compete on price. The ADSL line is monopolized by BT Openreach, who combine the efficiency of a state monopoly with the pricing of a private monopoly.

The government periodically gives BT money to improve speeds. BT pay this money to shareholders and then fail to improve speeds. Both parties are apparently happy with this arrangement.

One of the candidates at the last election promised free high-speed broadband to the country. Media commentators agreed that this was ludicrous pie-in-the-sky.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by PaulKeeble on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:56AM (#24835941)
London is actually one of the bad areas for broadband. Due to the density its not been deemed worthwhile to roll out fibre to home at all and fibre to the curb is often held up by a bunch of factors including there being no room in the local telecoms office for the hardware and difficulties placing the boxes on the street to contain the replacement dslams alongside the other road works. Many rollouts have been held up for many years due to very hard logistics problems.

It has proven much easier to roll out fibre into villages and smaller towns where DSL is no where near as obvious as the solution and there is room to place the equipment easily.

What irks me more than anything is the fact that builders are making big blocks of flats and running normal copper cabling into them. Ones that opened just 5 years ago genuinely had ADSL back to the local telecoms office and only recently got upgraded to DSLAMS in their basements to fibre. It really doesn't save a lot of money to put copper in instead of fibre at this point and to not have planned at the very least VDSL is just quite ridiculous. These types of builds have just made local issues with broadband that much worse.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:24AM (#24835756)
This is a summary entirely tilted by a very questionable political perspective.

You'll find the same problems elsewhere in Europe dealing with population density and rolling out the infrastructure for this stuff. I know plenty of people in Sweden, France, Germany who struggle with exactly the same issues, despite better headline average speeds etc.

> "hollowing out"; services that get used by the small elite fraction of the country that lives in the right bits of London are good, everything else is quietly ignored.

Fundamentally wrong given that central London is in a large proportion (often > 50% by ward) social housing. Or are the millions of people who live there the "small elite" too? Or perhaps it is the case the high population density urban centres are naturally the easiest place to build infrastructure to benefit the most people.

> BT pay this money to shareholders and then fail to improve speeds. Both parties are apparently happy with this arrangement.

Clearly this isn't true. BT OR has for many years been separated and highly and transparently regulated. Perhaps you would like to explain more your implications of corruption that isn't visible to anyone else?

https://www.ofcom.org.uk/__data/assets/pdf_file/0019/114814/...

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by pjc50 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:50AM (#24836266)
https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/britain-being...

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-23194287

https://br0kent3l3ph0n3.wordpress.com/2013/09/26/dcms-misman...

(admittedly those aren't all recent, but that's how we got in this situation over the past decade). It's not just me but the Commons Public Accounts Committee.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by easytiger on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @08:04AM (#24836351)
Can you explain what you think those links prove related to the above discussion?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by LargoLasskhyfv on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:58AM (#24836311)
Huh? Sweden? I thought that was paradise, and where there is no fibre, some 4G, or WLL(Wireless Local Loop) thing is used instead?
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by gazoakley on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:57AM (#24835947)
Whilst competition has been pretty slow to improve speeds, there are an increasing number of altnets around the UK with small providers running their own FTTP networks. This is even happening in rural locations through organizations like B4RN. I wish it would move faster, but I'm glad that we have some competition - Corbynband would likely have nuked other providers, and I can only imagine the kind of filtering that would get applied to it. Hopefully good ISPs like Andrews & Arnold can stick around.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by cactus2093 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:39AM (#24835837)
As an American that is a familiar story, with telcos over the years taking money and not delivering the upgrades promised. We were supposed to have a lot more widespread fiber to the home for instance, and I think we still pay a little more than many other countries.

However by now in 2020, I believe the majority of the US has access to internet over cable tv lines/docsis instead of dsl with speeds more like 100mbps, with up to 1 or 2 gbps available in big metros for $70 a month. I know many rural areas are still underserved, and of course not every household is subscribed to internet service, but it seems to be available in most places.

I’m really surprised internet in the UK seems to be an order of magnitude or more slower for such a large percentage of the population.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by hirako2000 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:52AM (#24835914)
That's right, my UK broadband in central Edinburgh gives me 6Mbps if im lucky. 1mbps upload.

I roam around in South east Asia, not the developed states such as Singapore.. In Vietnam I get 60mbps, 16Mbps upload at home for 15 USD per month. I go to coffee shops they are all equipped with 40 to 100Mbps. Malaysia offered 300Mbps for $50 per month. 5 years ago.

And all plans are truely unlimited. Whats more? 4G/edge is commonly covered across the country, 8Gbytes pay as you go for.. 5$

The telecom companies in the UK, US and most developed countries are simply treating customers like cows and protect their oligopoly via corruption/lobbying of officials.

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:59AM (#24835958)
We used to get ~60Mbps in central Edinburgh. However, we moved out to a rural area and we get 22Mbps down and 1 up and that is really good for a house outside of a city or town.

Edit: We had a problem with our BT connection recently and I almost got a 4G connection from these folks: https://www.4g-internet.co.uk/

Edit: Actual fibre connectivity was going to be a few thousand just to get a quote... :-(

Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by hirako2000 on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:08AM (#24836019)
Yes some Edinburgh blocks have fibre. And those who don't only get copper adsl. My neighbours (same block) have had fibers for several years, go figure.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @07:54AM (#24836292)
We live ~12km from the centre of Edinburgh and only recently got mobile phone coverage at our house - so I shouldn't complain too much out Internet speeds.
Re:YouTube broke for 40% of the UK population after rolling ... by arethuza on Tuesday October 20, 2020 @06:20AM (#24835732)
Can't have tax-payers money used to improve conditions for normal people - that would be socialism!.