News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by FearNotDaniel on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:13PM (#24792578)
An interesting point of anecdata is that I didn't choose to upgrade my perfectly good three-year-old smartphone. I was forced to do so by the weight of compulsory upgrades to OS and apps that now make what was once a decent enough product completely unusable. I'm sure the hardware would last several more years if the vendors would allow me to run the same software that was originally installed on it.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by ta1234567890 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:04PM (#24793167)
I still use an iPhone 6 as my main phone, and works great. The trick is that I haven't upgraded iOS in at least a couple of years. I also kept an iPhone 5 as a music player at home, until a few months ago when, despite not upgrading the software, it became unusably slow (even for just playing music).
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by tachyonbeam on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:14PM (#24794062)
Apple does some funny CPU throttling when your battery gets old. Instead of just telling you "your battery needs to be replaced", they scale down your CPU's frequency to the point where the phone becomes completely unusable. It's not great. Most people don't realize that they could get their battery replaced in a matter of minutes, at a cost of about $50. I've done it with an old iPhone, and it worked like-new again.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by jws on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:28PM (#24794244)
The iPhone 5 does not do battery performance management.

If your phone has gone into performance management (to prevent crashing) you will see it in your Battery Health "Settings" panel. You can disable it there as well if you would rather crash than slow down.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by fhood on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:28PM (#24793457)
Hmm, my buddy has a 6s that is kept fairly up to date, and he says he had to do a battery replacement, but other than that it runs well.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by scrooched_moose on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:59PM (#24794619)
I begrudgingly upgraded from a 6S to the new SE back in August due to a shattered screen.

Other than a substantial camera upgrade, louder speakers, and no headphone jack I honestly couldn't notice a difference between the two. The 6S is still a rock solid phone.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by ahmedalsudani on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:55PM (#24793796)
A lot of people on this site still use the original iPhone SE. As you mention, replacing the battery is usually all an iPhone requires.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by jonnytran on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:22PM (#24795536)
Yes, I'm still using the original SE, and I love it. Even the new "mini" is still bigger than it. Luckily the latest iOS 14 still works on it, but I'm afraid that this will be the last one before they drop support.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by rajangdavis on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:25PM (#24793398)
What if there is a security issue with your OS?
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by escardin on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:14PM (#24794063)
They're screwed unless they update. Luckily the iPhone 6 was still getting security updates as of this year. It doesn't have ios 13+ but it does have security updates on 12.

As a 6 user for another month or so, my biggest complaint isn't slowness, it's the lack of ram that causes apps to be closed readily whenever you switch, compounded by the apps having to boot/reload again.

Most of the apps I use aren't IOS apps, they're things like chrome.

This is nothing like using a 3g or a 4 until they stopped getting updates, those were downright painful to use. This is merely frustrating.

I don't know what people expect from their phones, but 5-6 years of updates and the phone still running well is incredible. I hope my next iPhone gets me another 6 years. It seems likely.

I don't know what it's like in Android land, but I expect that the number people using a phone at all for 6 years is even less than those using old iPhones. At least they had way more ram for a same era phone.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by solveit on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:45PM (#24795164)
> I don't know what people expect from their phones, but 5-6 years of updates and the phone still running well is incredible.

My phone is a computer that happens to occasionally make calls. I expect a flagship computer to easily last a decade and phones should too.

In fairness, this attitude of mine is fairly recent and probably attributable to the fact that phones are now the price of computers. So it only applies a little to the iPhone 6, but will apply in full power to the next iPhone.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by ta1234567890 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:39PM (#24796125)
> I don't know what people expect from their phones, but 5-6 years of updates and the phone still running well is incredible.

I thought about that recently. And I would want for my phone to be something akin to my car, lasting for several years (10-20 of I take care of it), being able to repair it, and not needing constant updates just to keep working (although Tesla seems to be going in the smartphone direction).

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by cyberdrunk on Friday October 16, 2020 @04:07AM (#24798697)
Apple patches security vulns even in older versions of iOS (to support people whose device is too old to upgrade to the latest version) - I don't know for how long though.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by nabeards on Thursday October 15, 2020 @11:14PM (#24797069)
I also use an iPhone 6 as my main (and only) phone. I have the latest updates installed on it and just had a new battery installed in June. It works perfectly well! Of note, possibly, is that I have neither Facebook nor Twitter installed. I do use a slew of other apps though, without issue.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by codeisawesome on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:27PM (#24796036)
Wait so is it actually the case that iOS upgrades make iPhones run slower?
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by ta1234567890 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:43PM (#24796143)
Might not be on purpose, i.e. a newer os might just expect more resources to run, which are just not available on an older phone. The same happens with computers, try running the latest windows or macos on a 5 year old computer, it will probably run, but definitely not as smoothly as the os of the time when the computer was built.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by Klinky on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:15PM (#24796363)
Given that CPU perf on desktop has been rather stalled the last 5 - 7 years, it probably wouldn't be that bad.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by api on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:55PM (#24793043)
Software bloating to consume all available space is a long-observed trend that has been called Eroom's law, for Moore's law backwards. What Moore's law giveth, Eroom's law taketh away.

Here is what an 8-bit CPU with 64KiB of RAM could do in 1986:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H9k5Xa2PpEg

Obviously this is far behind current UIs in areas like resolution and graphics, but it's not so strikingly far behind that it's unusable or unrecognizable.

Does it really take gigabytes of RAM and multiple 2+ghz cores to deliver the same basic paradigm as this 8-bit CPU in 1986, but in 32-bit color, 4K resolution, and with better language and character set support? Really?

What would a quad-core 2ghz machine with 16GiB of RAM be able to do if software were written in equivalently efficient ways, dispensing with so much unnecessary bloat and layers of indirection?

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by matthewmacleod on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:59PM (#24793097)
* Does it really take gigabytes of RAM and multiple 2+ghz cores to deliver the same basic paradigm as this 8-bit CPU in 1986, but in 32-bit color, 4K resolution, and with better language and character set support? Really?*

You haven’t described what modern software does though. You’ve just listed a random subset of features.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by api on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:25PM (#24795561)
Modern software that does more or less the same thing as old software uses 10X to sometimes as much as 100X the resources to do the same thing. I am arguing that more colors, higher resolutions, and prettier text is not sufficient to account for this bloat.

Examples: simple paint programs, text editors, terminals, mail clients, basic word processing, and so on. In all cases resource requirements have exploded to an extent that can't easily be explained by gains in features or capability.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by User23 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:44PM (#24793673)
Your smartphone isn't the problem, the problem is irresponsible businesses. We used to have the same kind of crap in the USA. Companies insisted they couldn't be economically viable without dumping toxic waste into our rivers and lakes.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by jlarocco on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:10PM (#24794008)
> We used to have the same kind of crap in the USA.

Oh we still do: https://houston.culturemap.com/news/city-life/01-26-12-there...

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by abawany on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:37PM (#24792847)
I wonder if things would change if the os updates were handled by a different vendor, i.e. a model where the phone makers sold hardware and os vendors sold installs/updates? Maybe if the motivations of phone makers were decoupled from the os vendors, then phones could be supported a while longer due to the os vendors desire to improve their profit?
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by Arubis on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:50PM (#24792994)
There’d need to be some fairly heavy regulation in place to keep the separate vendors from collaborating/colluding. Intel and Microsoft were perfectly happy to keep their shared customer base on a rapid, predictable upgrade path for about two decades. Granted, of course, the upgrades were _attractive_ so long as Moore’s Law held out.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by SilasX on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:40PM (#24794389)
So like Windows in the 90s? That was it’s own nightmare for gaming with random crashes and games not working.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by phatfish on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:44PM (#24795730)
I think the OP means like Windows now.

My laptop doesn't get Windows updates held back because Dell wants to sell me the latest model.

Drivers are also much better with the original vendors version most likely working fine even if it's not on the laptop manufactures list of tested drivers.

Desktops are effected even less.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:58PM (#24795842)
The "smartphone" world needs the equivalent of NetBSD for larger form factor computers and development boards. An open-source, modifiable, freely available, experimental OS that can run on both old and new "smartphone" computers. With larger form factor computers the tradeoff has generally been less hardware support on the very newest ones. Over time however the support for newer hardware generally increases as contributors have the chance to tinker with it. Instead of losing performance from the same hardware, users generally gain performance over time. Whatever one may think of this dynamic, it does allow for the longest possible use of hardware.

Tech companies should be shamed for the "disposable" computer culture they have put so much effort into creating. It is possible to improve software without requiring new hardware. With the prices Apple charges for hardware, there should not be any forced obsolescence.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by swiley on Friday October 16, 2020 @07:08AM (#24799590)
You're probably looking for postmarketos. I run it on my pinephone although I think it supports some androids.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Monday October 19, 2020 @03:21AM (#24824002)
Would rather wait for NetBSD support of Pinephone.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by hombre_fatal on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:36PM (#24792844)
If there is any individual guilt here, I don't think that would free you from it.

Though I'm not very convinced of the individual guilt angle. It's a systemic problem of incentives (lack of good ones).

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by forinti on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:45PM (#24792938)
Look at the countries that were labeled Sustainable Economies in recent years (Cuba and Ecuador). Is there a way to convince people in rich countries to live with the same level of consumption as these countries do? Can you even convince these countries to stay as they are?
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by 542354234235 on Friday October 16, 2020 @12:25PM (#24802343)
> Cuba

An island nation that the most powerful country in the world has been trying to cripple economically for half a century.

> Ecuador

A country with a smaller GDP than that majority of US states.

These are probably not good or representative examples of how this would work writ large.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by foolmeonce on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:48PM (#24792974)
I think Linux is on the cusp of being up to the task, so not buying a device now with more open than average hardware is a decision worthy of remorse. But a few years ago it made little difference unless you considered yourself a psychic for forecasting future vendor behavior.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by reificator on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:52PM (#24793012)
> I think Linux is on the cusp of being up to the task, so not buying a device now with more open than average hardware is a decision worthy of remorse.

You're right, I think 2021 will be the year of the Linux desktop.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by chaosharmonic on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:34PM (#24794304)
Tbf Android is also starting to converge back toward mainline. AOSP is one patch away from booting off of it, assuming you have drivers. To that end, Google is beginning to move the ecosystem toward a generic device kernel, with a set of hardware interfaces for handling those drivers in a standard way across devices.

This would enable custom kernels to target a range of compatible devices at once, which (among other things) would then simplify porting over alternative Linux-based OSes. Including the convergent ones we're starting to see pop up on way less impressive hardware.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by foolmeonce on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:54PM (#24793036)
Linux is now the best desktop, despite no advances since 1998..
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by wyre on Friday October 16, 2020 @01:15AM (#24797709)
i3 came out in 2009..
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by forinti on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:41PM (#24792892)
I only upgraded my phone recently because I couldn't get a new battery.

Sure, the new one is better, but the old one did everything I wanted it to do.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by beenBoutIT on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:38PM (#24794371)
The funny thing is that cellphones have gotten slim to the point that adding replaceable batteries and upgradable RAM wouldn't make them ridiculously thick or heavy.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by dTal on Friday October 16, 2020 @03:43PM (#24804295)
I don't believe a replaceable battery needs to make a phone any thicker or heavier. Just take anything that's glued now and secure it with machine screws instead. "Replaceable battery" isn't the same as "swappable in the field with no tools", and while that's nice to have, it's not necessary in order to forestall device obsolescence.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by narrator on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:46PM (#24793692)
Surprised nobody has mentioned Android on here. The Galaxy Note 4 is now 6 years old. It was the last flagship smartphone with a removable battery. It still works great.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by beenBoutIT on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:24PM (#24794203)
RIP the removable battery. Apparently the massive consumer demand for phones with low Z-heights has made replaceable batteries an impossibility and that's that. Same story for laptops. It's a only a matter of time before Tesla and other electric car OEMs realize they can force customers to buy new cars by making their batteries irreplaceable. All they need to do is build the batteries into the frame in such a way as to slim the cars profile and consumers will be fine with it. Something like a disposable low-profile Tesla Fiero with a 3-4 year maximum lifespan will quickly become the unavoidable reality car makers have always wanted to impose on the consumer.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by bergstromm466 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:49PM (#24794520)
> made replaceable batteries an impossibility

I was pretty excited to see that the new Fairphone actually has a user replaceable battery

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by Vinnl on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:14PM (#24795458)
All previous ones had that too. Additionally, it has a user-replacable screen, camera, and audio module, off the top of my head.

Of course, that's also the point of the product.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by bergstromm466 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:14PM (#24795462)
Yes, thanks for adding that important fact!
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by beenBoutIT on Friday October 16, 2020 @02:22AM (#24798067)
What will it take to get replaceable batteries on mainstream phones designed for US cell networks?
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by bergstromm466 on Friday October 16, 2020 @06:36AM (#24799433)
What i know is that today's Corporate/Firm production sends many young kids in Ghana to a cancer-driven death [1], or has them digging in death-trap cobalt mines in Congo [2] - and that it can at times make me feel hopeless, angry and frustrated.

Some of the most hopeful strategies i've come across is Sensorica's Open Value Network style Commons-based peer production (as well as projects like Precious Plastic, Open Source Ecology and WikiHouse, etc.), coupled with using a Holochain-pattern Resource Event Agent accounting method, currently being developed by http://valueflo.ws / Holo-REA (from the people at http://mikorizal.org/)

[1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mleQVO1Vd1I

[2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tv-hE4Yx0LU

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by soperj on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:02PM (#24794663)
Galaxy s3 has a removable battery, and it's thinner than most phones you get now.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by sliken on Friday October 16, 2020 @12:06AM (#24797353)
Maybe a law stating that anytime someone stops updating the OS for a consumer device they have to release source so the community can support it themselves.
Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by geodel on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:32PM (#24792801)
> weight of compulsory upgrades to OS and apps that now make what was once a decent enough product completely unusable.

Software developers and companies alike are very proud of it. I can understand companies defending it due to commercial concerns. But developers defending addition of enormous number of dependencies, bloating the software and calling it best practice to reuse existing components saddens me.

Re:A toxic, nightmarish lake created by our thirst for tech by e40 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:33PM (#24795620)
This is one of the main reasons I switched from Android to iOS. Got really tired of getting new phones when they would run out of updates. I hope to keep my 11 for 6 years, maybe more.