News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by gerikson on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:49AM (#24787567)
"I'm looking at my sympathy-o-meter and the needle's barely moving".
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by hashkb on Thursday October 15, 2020 @07:53AM (#24787597)
This does highlight a real problem- advertisers feel like they deserve a better tool than the users they're targeting.
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by otabdeveloper4 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @08:52AM (#24788056)
Why is it a problem if they're the ones paying for it?
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by freehunter on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:30AM (#24788999)
Because the rest of us aren’t given the option to pay for it. “But it’s free” is a ridiculous argument when there’s no paid alternative.
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by RestlessMind on Thursday October 15, 2020 @12:22PM (#24790343)
This is simply not true in my experience. Most prominent example is Youtube, where there is an option for an ad-free experience which is decently priced. And yet, the adoption is very low and you still see people complaining about ads on Youtube all the time.

I guess a vast majority of people simply don't want to pay if there is a somewhat acceptable free alternative.

Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by beagle3 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:11PM (#24793246)
I'm paying for many "freely available" services, like RSS readers, email service, and more. I pay to not be the product.

The reason I do not pay for YouTube is that despite paying, I'm still the product - Google is still collecting every bit of data about me, to spam me on their other channels. Instead, I use YouTube (and every other Google product) logged-out, deleting cookies often[0]. I can't do that if I pay for YouTube.

[0] I used to reject cookies, but Google has become unusable that way -- everything goes back to defaults which are exceptionally bad for me.

Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by thewebcount on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:33PM (#24795017)
> Most prominent example is Youtube, where there is an option for an ad-free experience which is decently priced. And yet, the adoption is very low and you still see people complaining about ads on Youtube all the time.

For me, this is similar to why I won't pay for the New York Times subscription, either. I mainly only do stuff on both sites when I find a link to their site. I don't go to their site to do stuff on my own. Why would I subscribe to a site that I don't go to on my own? I do subscribe to ArsTechnica, for example, because I go there frequently.

Furthermore, I might not mind ads, but the ads on YouTube are very obnoxious. There's no intelligence, so you get weird situations like watching a 2 minute ad before being able to watch a 30 second video. Or ads cutting off the speaker mid word. Who thinks that's a good experience? If they can't get that stuff right, why would I pay them?

And on top of that, I find YouTube's "Hey did you know you can pay us money now?!?!?!" pop-ups all over the page to be obnoxious enough that I have decided I will never pay them any money.

Were I a regular visitor who wasn't so off-put by their ham-fisted advertising, I might have considered it, but now they've made going to their site so unpleasant I just avoid it if I can, or hold my nose for a few minutes when watching something with ads. Then I get away from their site as quickly as possible.

Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by dime on Friday October 16, 2020 @04:21AM (#24798769)
I'd love to pay for Youtube if they eliminated tracking/profiling. Not having ads is not enough of an incentive here.
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by MichaelMcG on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:45AM (#24788584)
Exactly, a segment of social media users don't mind or are largely apathetic to the advertising/data collection because it keeps the platforms free--that's all that matters to them.

The advertisers are effectively the customer, with the social media platform acting as a vehicle to reach the willing end-user.

With this model, a polished & efficient dashboard/UI for advertiser engagement is as important (if not more important) than the front-end experience that provides end-user engagement.

Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by nerdponx on Saturday October 17, 2020 @01:51AM (#24807714)
I am sympathetic to the free-but-ad-supported model. This is how we get Reddit, Stackoverflow, and Google Maps which is a fucking global map and GPS with much better navigation quality than any of its predecessors and it costs exactly $0 to the end user.

It might be the case that there is simply not enough subscription revenue in the world to fund such an operation without advertising. People forget just how much objectively good and useful stuff we have access to because of ad-supported $0 products. Hell, you could argue that Tensorflow and PyTorch themselves are ad-supported products.

The sticking point is that your old ad-supported classifieds paper and network news channels weren't surveilling you across the Web.

And as much as I think we need strict data privacy laws, it's hard to ignore the fact that Facebook ads used to be for penis pills and karate scams, but now for the most part are things that I (or at least my demographic) might want to buy.

Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by hashkb on Thursday October 15, 2020 @04:40PM (#24793615)
Many users felt locked in to FB / like it was a vital part of their life for quite a while before it became an advertising platform. It's only attractive to advertisers if it's a good product for users. They pioneered the business model of selling users out, and in general users think that's gross.
Re:Media buyer: Facebook updates have ‘wrecked the ad platfo... by thetanil on Thursday October 15, 2020 @09:35AM (#24788491)
This makes it sound like FB has done something to improve the tool for the users.