News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by Covzire on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @05:42PM (#24781976)
Let's be honest, the only people screaming for censorship are firmly on the left. Controlling "disinformation" is a dog whistle for censorship, hoping that average citizens don't realize what they're really after. We all know who is going to be the moderators in flagging "disinformation" and we all know which ideology they overwhelmingly favor. I'd sooner trust a pyromaniac as fire chief of my local county than I would trust big tech companies to manage "disinformation" on my behalf.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:12PM (#24782814)
disinformation is a dog whistle for censorship, but fake news is...?

Censorship for thee but not for me.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by mod on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:56PM (#24783172)
"Fake news" is an attempt to discredit news stories. It's fundamentally different from disallowing them to be shared.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by easterncalculus on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:38PM (#24783036)
"Fake news" is a call to criticism. The amount of people bringing up "fake news" and calling for say, CNN, to not be able to report at all is minimal. Comparatively you can't have a conversation about "disinformation" without talking about social media companies' responsibility to delete or hide content.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:43PM (#24783062)
Ah ok, when Trump says a negative article about him is "fake news" it's criticism, but when "disinformation" comes out about Biden it's a call for censorship?

Am I insane for seeing the dissonance here?

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by refurb on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:02PM (#24783211)
One of them is saying “it’s not true” and one of them is saying “we should stop the public from seeing that”.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nobody9999 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:21AM (#24786918)
>One of them is saying “it’s not true” and one of them is saying “we should stop the public from seeing that”.

In this case, who is saying "we should stop the public from seeing that?" Not Biden. His campaign folks said "it's not true." I'm unaware of any calls from Biden to censor anything. Ever.

Please do correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by easterncalculus on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:05PM (#24783240)
I am agreeing with refurb's comment below you. Most people calling "fake news" are trying to convince you to not watch something. Most people calling "disinformation" are trying to convince you that you should not be able to watch something. I'm not taking the side of Trump or anyone at all by saying that criticism is different than censorship, that's just a fact. Your argument is not in good faith if bringing that up to you is considered an implicit support for Trump, or anyone really.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nobody9999 on Thursday October 15, 2020 @06:50AM (#24787068)
>I am agreeing with refurb's comment below you. Most people calling "fake news" are trying to convince you to not watch something. Most people calling "disinformation" are trying to convince you that you should not be able to watch something.

Huh?

You state that criticism is different than censorship. I agree.

However, I don't get the connection here. Calling something "fake news" or calling it "disinformation" are both criticisms. In fact, those terms are pretty much synonymous.

Which is irrelevant to the issue.

Twitter and Facebook are limiting distribution of this particular piece. Which is certainly akin to censorship. However, It's Twitter and Facebook taking these actions, not "most people."

Based on the details I've read (and thanks to this post, I've read quite a few), this story doesn't really pass the smell test, and may well be "disinformation."

Will you now accuse me of advocating censorship?

What if I'd said it was "fake news" instead? Am I advocating censorship now?

Calling for censorship would be something like "Don't let anyone see that!" Or "These monsters need to be silenced!"

There's a difference.

Unfortunately, we're all wrapped so tightly because, you guessed it, Twitter and Facebook (and others) use exactly those sorts of tricks to rile us up, to boost engagement and make more advertising dollars.

Which leaves us fighting each other over which synonym is worse.

In truth, most people are kind, decent human beings who just want to have a decent life. Sure, we disagree about a few of the details concerning how to have a decent life, but we agree about many more details.

The interactions of a bunch of really small groups who want to influence us for their benefit (whether that be for political power, profit or both) are laughing all the way to the bank as we tear each other apart.

Let's not let them do that any more, as we're only hurting ourselves.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:25PM (#24783394)
>Most people calling "disinformation" are trying to convince you that you should not be able to watch something.

I know it's been an insane 4 years, but, for Trump, this isn't true. He said, in his first year, he wanted to stated to take NBC off the air[1]. It's a message that he's been saying since before he took office. Understandably, taking a billion dollar corporation off the air is a lot more difficult than wiping an anonymous poster online, but to imply that "Fake News" is entirely just criticism is just complete ignorance of what the man has been saying for years.

>I'm not taking the side of Trump or anyone at all by saying that criticism is different than censorship, that's just a fact. Your argument is not in good faith if bringing that up to you is considered an implicit support for Trump, or anyone really.

If someone says the only people screaming for censorship are firmly on the left, how am I supposed to argue that point without focusing on Trump?

I'm not bringing this up because I want you to vote Biden or not vote for Trump, but to dispel this notion that "censorship" is exclusively some far left/right tool of oppression. My personal view is that these platform should do whatever they want, just like how HN mods run Hn the way they feel, and no private platform is "obliged" to give you a platform no matter how large they are. Regardless the _government_ should be limited in power to tell private companies in what they should and should not publish. To this day, there has been no _US government_ pressure to "censor" legal political posts - it's been entirely private actors who have taken censorship action. However to suggest that one side is 100% free speech and the other side are coming to take your "free speech" is misrepresenting what both sides.

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/world/americas/us-politic...

[dead]
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by logarhythmic on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:42PM (#24783884)
Are you really concluding those commenters are "alt right" based off of what they said?

I find that bizarre

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by ColanR on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:24PM (#24782928)
IIRC, fake news was originally used by the left, but co-opted by Trump.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:45PM (#24783077)
It doesn't matter, the claim "Let's be honest, the only people screaming for censorship are firmly on the left." is demonstrably false.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by mellosouls on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:10PM (#24783277)
A strange thing to say in a thread commenting on a news item where the left are censoring the right. Again.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:30PM (#24783426)
Today, I flipped a coin and it landed heads, the same as yesterday. Very strange of you to say it would ever land tails.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by mellosouls on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:36PM (#24783845)
I'm sure that sounds clever to you, but I've no idea what it means or what relevance it has.

You said something is "demonstrably false" that is actually happening and is documented in the subject of this whole thread.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by nemothekid on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:25PM (#24784185)
Do you not know what "demonstrably false" means? Here is a simple proof by contradiction:

Claim: Let's be honest, the only people screaming for censorship are firmly on the left

Contradiction: Trump, as I've shown in other comments, has also been calling for censorship for several news organizations.

The only way you believe this claim is not demonstrably false, is if you believe Trump is firmly left, which is ridiculous, but if he is, then I guess you got me.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by mellosouls on Thursday October 15, 2020 @05:06AM (#24786464)
The vast majority of censorship cases are from the left. Cancel culture - the left.

This whole thing is a problem of the left (and I speak as a man of the left, thoroughly disgusted with the affair), and that is what I read from the "screaming" statement, and your counter as a denial of a very clear and shameful phenomenon.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by thinkingemote on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:29PM (#24782973)
Correct but it was basically limited to the obviously fake "russian" troll farms.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by cgrealy on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:27PM (#24783409)
It was actually a fairly bipartisan term used to identify trivially disprovable stories.

The right wing tended to be more political ("Obama is a muslim communist who wants your guns") while left wing fake news tended to lean more towards new age, non-evidence-based "wellness" ("this juice cleanse will prevent cancer").

Trump, in what was quite frankly the smartest political move he's ever made, turned it on it's head and basically started using it to discredit actual stories that painted him in a bad light (inauguration numbers, etc).

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by MeinBlutIstBlau on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:50PM (#24783117)
Alex Jones touts a lot of nonsense but that doesn't mean the merits of what he's ranting about don't have value.

Also as a comedic medium, it's an art form nobody else is doing. He isnt even indecent compared to just full of themselves types. He's just rants on hypothetical nonsense.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by reducesuffering on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:44PM (#24783506)
Strongly object to characterizing Jones as "comedic." His rallies sound like 1930's fascist speeches.[0]

[0]https://youtu.be/vL8Dz4mGv1g?t=61

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by MeinBlutIstBlau on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @09:57PM (#24783975)
There are more leftists that take what he says seriously than his own fans. People like him because he's willing to tout nonsense but seem serious.

He's literally the Jim Cramer of conservative voices. Everybody who listens to him listens with the foresight that there can both be positive and negative repercussions depending on how much of what they say you'll believe.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by tootie on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @05:59PM (#24782151)
I don't think that's a fair judgement at all. Not when the right is actively attacking honest journalism at its source while also screaming about anti-conservative bias on social media every time they filter disinformation. I would also not at all categorize deplatforming disinformation as censorship either. Nor incitement to violence. I only agree in that it's not a job that any of these companies are setup to handle.

EDIT: https://www.npr.org/2020/05/27/863011399/trump-threatens-to-...

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by dang on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:45PM (#24784703)
We detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24781792.
[dead]
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by Covzire on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:44PM (#24782591)
Thanks for the reply I guess, and the clear reminder why so many had to die both in NA and Europe for the first amendment to become a reality.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:55PM (#24783566)
It's ironic to be championing the virtues of free speech in reply to a completely innocuous post that was flagged to death.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by p1necone on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:43PM (#24783504)
How is the first amendment relevant here?
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:03PM (#24783224)
> What is with all these people talking as if the American right and left are just two regular sides of the same political coin without addressing the massive elephant in the room.

The (GOP) elephant in the room uses 'both sides bad, vote for the Republican' as a strategy with the more educated segment of the electorate. Except for people who criticize both parties from the hard left (well left of Bernie Sanders) and the very hard right (the few people who think Trump isn't extreme enough), 'both sides bad' talking points generally come from Republicans who aren't open about their party affiliation. It's not an honest argument--indeed it's a form of subjective disinformation in and of itself--but it's effective with a certain demographic that is over-represented in the STEM sector.

That demographic is people who behave like this

https://thenib.com/mister-gotcha/

in response to mild suggestions that, just maybe, some of the benefits of the past 75 years of economic and technological progress should be shared a little more evenly.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by drewrv on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:58PM (#24784419)
> Let's be honest, the only people screaming for censorship are firmly on the left.

This year the president has sued to stop publication of two books because they embarrassed him, one from John Bolton and another from Mary Trump.

This year police in cities across the country have opened fire on journalists.

These are legal and physical attacks, on journalists and publishers, coming from government officials. Social media moderation policies are interesting and important. But if you see censorship and attacks on free speech only coming from one side, you should probably diversify your media diet.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by artificialLimbs on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:39PM (#24784666)
I suspect the original statement is referring to sheer volume, where your examples are more few and far between, particularly where it concerns violence. "Only" could have been left out of the sentence for greater accuracy.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by zetazzed on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:18PM (#24782877)
Right wing district attorneys are currently suing Netflix over Cuties, in a throwback to early-90s moral outrage arguments by people who have not actually watched a film and understood anything about it: https://www.cinemablend.com/news/2556282/netflixs-cuties-bac...

People have just gotten so used to conservative calls for censorship that they escape all notice.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:35PM (#24782514)
The only reason measures to curb disinformation would have a partisan impact is because conservative parties (throughout the industrialized world, not just in the US) use disinformation strategies far, far more than do other parties.

Center-left/left parties use reality to galvanize their base voters into action. Their voters are people who aren't pleased with what's happening in their countries and want to change it for the better. There's no need for center-left parties to lie that their electoral opponents eat babies when their electoral opponents actually put children in cages.

In contrast, right wing parties overcome the inherent unpopularity of their revealed policy platforms (running on platforms of cutting taxes on the very rich while making life harder for the average person is not popular) by using disinformation to make a stated platform based on fabricated wedge issues. Hence, the imaginary convoys of South American migrants that were about to storm the US-Mexico border in 2018.

As such, restricting disinformation will have a partisan impact. Within the US, there is no Democratic equivalent to Qanon, so anti-disinformation measures that impact the likes of Qanon will have no impact on the Democratic party whatsoever. This, however, isn't a bad thing.

Functioning societies can have zero tolerance for 'alternative facts.' Disagree over goals and interpretations, but facts must be accepted by all. Democracy requires an informed electorate and there can be no functioning democracy when one side is free to invent its own version of reality.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by julienb_sea on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:27PM (#24783407)
Here's the problem. A fact can be stated in a variety of different ways with different implications. A fact is also a fairly confined data point, and excludes any extrapolation, modeling, hypothesis, root cause analysis or policy prescription. Pretty much nothing worthy of discussion is a fact.

Debating facts is pointless. People debate opinions, interpretations, implications. You cannot declare an implication from a fact as itself a fact. Nor can you claim people disagreeing with an implication are lying about facts.

As an aside - right wing platforms as you put it generally include a variety of popular proposals with the lower and middle class. These include immigration protectionism, lowering consumption taxes like gas taxes, taking a conservative stance on societally expensive government policies, and lowering unemployment rate through encouraging business growth. You may not agree with these policies, but to claim they are disinformation and thus not worthy of consideration is blatant biased censorship.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @08:46PM (#24783520)
The only reason measures to curb disinformation would have a partisan impact is because conservative parties (throughout the industrialized world, not just in the US) use disinformation strategies far, far more than do other parties.

Center-left/left parties use reality to galvanize their base voters into action. Their voters are people who aren't pleased with what's happening in their countries and want to change it for the better. There's no need for center-left parties to lie that their electoral opponents eat babies when their electoral opponents actually put children in cages.

In contrast, right wing parties overcome the inherent unpopularity of their revealed policy platforms (running on platforms of cutting taxes on the very rich while making life harder for the average person is not popular) by using disinformation to make a stated platform based on fabricated wedge issues. Hence, the imaginary convoys of South American migrants that were about to storm the US-Mexico border in 2018.

As such, restricting disinformation will have a partisan impact. Within the US, there is no Democratic equivalent to Qanon, so anti-disinformation measures that impact the likes of Qanon will have no impact on the Democratic party whatsoever.

Functioning societies must have zero tolerance for 'alternative facts.' Disagree over goals and interpretations, but facts must be accepted by all. Democracy requires an informed electorate and there can be no functioning democracy when one side is free to invent its own version of reality.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:15PM (#24782317)
Well yea, the left wants misinformation to be labeled/censored because they're no willing to lie like the right does. Once the left catches on to the need o create their own fake news you'll see this from both sides.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by dx87 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:27PM (#24782443)
At the VP debate Kamala Harris repeated the lie that Trump called covid a hoax. Niether party has a monopoly on lying to their base.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by youthbrigade on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:44PM (#24782587)
He said it at a rally on February 28th.

Source: Video on c-span https://www.c-span.org/video/?c4865556/user-clip-trump-this-...

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by Covzire on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:16PM (#24782858)
I remember this, he clearly refers to how he acted quickly to stop the flow of people from overseas and how few cases of COVID there were at that time. The "Hoax" was how Democrats were claiming Trump was xenophobic and/or accusing him of overreacting, if you remember Nancy Pelosi out walking around in Chinatown without a mask etc around this time. But how quickly the winds can shift.

This and the Charlottesville "fine people hoax" that Biden himself keeps repeating is fake news that just won't die, nor does Twitter seem too keen on helping kill it off either.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by colinmhayes on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:22PM (#24782911)
He literally didn't stop any flow. He's still talking about how he closed the border to China. False, he closed the border to Chinese nationals. Anyone else coming from China was fine. Trump lies constantly. Incessantly. It's legitimately ruined public discourse which is why people keep pushing social media to label/censor misinformation. Trump literally said "fine people" too, referring to literal white supremacists. I don't give a fuck if he walked it back or said something else first. Trump starting with a prepared statement before telling us how he really feels has happened over and over. Remember when Trump totally didn't leak classified info to Russia. Until he admitted himself that he had.
Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by squidlogic on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @07:36PM (#24783023)
Text from the transcript (it's all caps on the site):

PRES. TRUMP: THEY HAVE SPENT THE LAST THREE YEARS, AND I CAN EVEN GO FURTHER THAN THAT THREE YEARS SINCE THE ELECTION BUT WE GO BEFORE THE ELECTION, WORKING TO ERASE YOUR BALLOTS AND OVERTHROW OUR DEMOCRACY. BUT WITH YOUR HELP WE HAVE EXPOSE THE FAR-LEFT'S CORRUPTION AND DEFEATED THEIR SINISTER SCHEMES. LET'S SEE WHAT HAPPENS IN THE COMING MONTHS. LET'S WATCH. LET'S JSUT -- JUST WATCH. VERY DISHONEST PEOPLE. NOW THE DEMOCRATS ARE POLITICIZING THE CORONAVIRUS. CORONAVIRUS. THEY ARE POLITICIZING IT. WE DID ONE OF THE GREAT JOBS -- HOW'S PRESIDENT TRUMP DOING? THEY GO, NOT GOOD. THEY DO NOT HAVE ANY CLUE. THEY CANNOT EVEN COUNT THE VOTES IN IOWA. NO, THEY CAN'T. THEY CAN'T COUNT THEIR VOTES. ONE OF MY PEOPLE CAME UP TO ME AND SAID, MR. PRESIDENT, THEY TRIED TO BEAT YOU ON RUSSIA, RUSSIA, RUSSIAN. THAT DID NOT WORK OUT TOO WELL. THEY COULD NOT DO IT. THEY TRIED THE IMPEACHMENT HOAX. THAT WAS ON A PERFECT CONVERSATION. THEY TRIED ANYTHING. THEY TRIED IT OVER AND OVER AGAIN. THEY LOST. IT IS ALL TURNING. THINK OF IT. AND THIS IS THEIR NEW HOAX. WE DID SOMETHING THAT HAS BEEN PRETTY AMAZING. WE HAVE 15 PEOPLE IN THIS MASSIVE COUNTRY AND BECAUSE OF THE FACT THAT WE WENT EARLY, WE COULD'VE HAD A LOT MORE THAN THAT. WE'RE DOING GREAT. OUR COUNTRY IS DOING SO GREAT. WE ARE SO UNIFIED. WE ARE SO UNIFIED. THE REPUBLICAN PARTY HAS NEVER EVER BEEN UNIFIED LIKE IT IS NOW. THERE HAS NEVER BEEN A MOVEMENT IN THE HISTORY OF OUR COUNTRY LIKE WE HAVE NOW. NEVER BEEN

I'm struck by how this is almost a perfect example of the rorschach test that is Trump.

You could easily read this as saying that [COVID] is a hoax.

You could just as easily read this as saying that [the democrats saying he is doing a bad job with COVID] is a hoax.

Re:Facebook, Twitter block the NY Post from posting by Covzire on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:24PM (#24782401)
Are you absolutely sure you would notice when the left 'catches on' and starts creating their own fake news?

You might be able to spot it when there is a constant parade of anonymous sources that never seem to provide any actual proof for bombshell claims meant to hurt Trump etc.

Or maybe various newspapers and cable outlets will run hundreds of stories and thousands upon thousands of hours of ill-sourced coverage into the opposite allegations against Trump, that he would be colluding with some foreign actor, say, i don't know, Russia?

Maybe prominent Democrat house members might make claims again and again to the media that they had seen first hand evidence of collusion with Russia. Maybe the jig would be up when, under oath they would be asked the same questions and they were suddenly not so sure, nor could they produce any evidence.

It would be tricky, for sure.