News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by jagged-chisel on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @10:59AM (#24777238)
You'd think if it had stopped any attacks, the program's proponents would be shouting it from the rooftops. But no- nothing. Not even attempts to lie ("oh, we stopped several attacks, but we can't tell you anything about them...")

PRISM is a phenomenal waste of trust and money.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by alehul on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:07AM (#24777356)
I have, maybe naively, always believed that the U.S. operates at a level of secrecy and complexity where dozens of terrorist attacks are thwarted every year, and that this surveillance plays a hand in it (but to admit that would hinder its effectiveness).

Is it really possible we only have <5 terror plots against our country in a given year, considering the population of our country, the amount of ideological extremism domestically and internationally, and the States' interventionism?

Maybe it is possible, in which case the U.S. has been very successful at convincing my generation it's a larger issue than it really is (I was a toddler when 9/11 happened, so it's all I know).

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by mattashii on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:20AM (#24777515)
> Is it really possible we only have <5 terror plots against our country in a given year

Last time I checked, the USA didn't need terror plots 'against the country'; they have enough problems with "deranged individuals" shooting at schools, events, protests, etc.

Why would you label those who could be your child, parent or neighbor, and disagree violently with those who have a different opinion than yours, as terrorists against the country? /s

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by fakedang on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:03PM (#24778164)
Unless they have a long beard and are of Middle Eastern or South Asian descent though. /s
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by throwaway0a5e on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:14AM (#24777440)
If you subscribe to a definition of "terrorist attack" that includes "someone with political beliefs I don't like possessing a handgun in violation of the law" then sure, dozens per year thwarted sounds about right.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:23PM (#24779816)
'Politically-motivated violence waged against civilians in violation of the law' (excluding situations of organized war) is the most likely the least controversial definition of terrorism.

I'm curious why you appear to imply this definition of terrorism is unsuitable.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by dragonwriter on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:17PM (#24780412)
> Politically-motivated violence waged in violation of the law' (excluding situations of organized war) is the most likely the least controversial definition of terrorism.

It is not, nor is it even compatible with the protoypical example from which the term terrorist derives, since the original Terror and the Terrorists who executed it operated entirely within and through the power of the State. Non-state terrorism is a more recent extension of the definition. Nor does it even capture the mechanism of intended effect which defines terrorism (the whole part that motivates the reference to "terror".)

Britannica and, somewhat surprisingly, WordNet have probably the best general definitions I can quickly locate, "calculated use of violence to create a general climate of fear in a population and thereby to bring about a particular political objective" and "the calculated use of violence (or the threat of violence) against civilians in order to attain goals that are political or religious or ideological in nature; this is done through intimidation or coercion or instilling fear".

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by pirocks on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:02PM (#24780265)
Not OP, but probably because the patriot act was passed in the aftermath of 9/11 when the understood meaning of terrorist attack was 9/11 scale not a dozen people max.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by usrusr on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:58AM (#24778114)
If you take that definition and follow its logical implications to the extreme, you'll find that you can prevent a lot of terrorism by just legalizing handgun possession. Well.. ever heard of a country called United States of America?
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by djsumdog on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:25AM (#24777595)
There is still a lot of unrest in Portland and Seattle, but Federal police (US Marshals, FBI, BORTAC, et. al.) have used regular old police work (cameras, under cover anarchists, wiretaps with warrants) to arrest a ton of these people when the city prosecutors simply wouldn't do a damn thing or catch and release them.

Now many of these people are facing federal crimes. You can get some serious years for swinging a sledge hammer at a US Marshal, as what happened at the Federal Courthouse in Portland. (Remember, three of those Feds are now blind in at least one eye from the green lasers?)

But the Anarchists/Antifa types that are burning down Portland are also being thrown together with the McCloskeys who were arrested for having guns out, while on their lawn, after people broke into their gated community. Or Jake Gardner, who the DA ruled as acting in self defense, with a full video clearly showing him acting in self defense after both he and his father were attached.

We're starting to see real terrorists conflated with what are clearly political prisoners from local officials.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by macintux on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:20PM (#24778358)
You’re not going to garner much sympathy for the McCloskeys. One vital rule of gun handling is to never point it at something until you’re ready to shoot, and she pointed it at people with her finger on the trigger.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by UncleEntity on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:06PM (#24779608)
> One vital rule of gun handling is to never point it at something until you’re ready to shoot...

Not so much, never point a gun at something unless you're willing to shoot -- a double barrel shotgun has a lot of power to make someone rethink their life choices when pointed at them without having to actually shoot.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by bigbubba on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:36PM (#24780619)
There are numerous formulations of this rule. The one used by the US Marines is 'Never point the weapon at anything you do not INTEND to shoot.'

In this formulation of the rule, pointing a gun with the intent to threaten isn't valid, since an intention to threaten is not an intention to shoot.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by UncleEntity on Thursday October 15, 2020 @03:31AM (#24785879)
What they tell you and what actually happens on the battlefield are two different things.

I've pointed weapons at people without the intention of shooting them while covering other solders and on occasions where they "just didn't look right" -- can't just randomly start shooting people but you also don't want to be caught off guard if they decide to start shooting at you. The last time this happened some car rolled up on our guard post and all of us were pointing our weapons at said vehicle while we sent someone out to figure out what they wanted (which turned out to be the main gate so they could find out what happened to one of their relatives who was arrested or something). Nobody intended on shooting them but if they didn't stop short or acted suspiciously we would've lit them up with the .50cal.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by jessaustin on Thursday October 15, 2020 @02:13PM (#24791772)
I'm sorry for what was done to you in the military. Please try to find a different way of existing in our society. People you'd never suspect have firearms, and will use them to kill you in response to the behavior you describe here.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by InitialLastName on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @04:04PM (#24780906)
My preferred formulation is "Never point a gun towards anything you don't mean to destroy". Including things within a reasonable solid angle of your target.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by snypher on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:04PM (#24780292)
This is a hero fantasy, and allows you to be legally killed by pretty much anyone. Don't do this.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by djsumdog on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:28PM (#24780518)
Well in her case, she knew the gun wouldn't fire. It turned out the firing pin was assembled backwards for it to be used in a play. (The police took apart the gun and put to back together to charge her; it's in the evidence documents)

But I agree, she should have treated the gun like it was armed and ready. She flagged the back of her husband's head several times.

BUT, that isn't in and of itself criminal. In fact, nothing they did was criminal. They were in a gated neighborhood, people ripped the iron gate down, and I think it's clear they were reasonably defending their homes.

The law they're charged with says they were in violation of "brandishing a firearm in a threatening manner," but nowhere in the law do they define "threatening" .. it's ambiguous, it's a badly written law and it conflicts with federal laws and the 2nd amendment.

Viva Frei and Robert Barnes are two lawyers who have done some incredible breakdowns on this case:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CRN-Xrcf8Co

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by blaser-waffle on Thursday October 15, 2020 @10:31AM (#24789007)
> Well in her case, she knew the gun wouldn't fire. It turned out the firing pin was assembled backwards for it to be used in a play. (The police took apart the gun and put to back together to charge her; it's in the evidence documents)

Along with never pointing your gun at something you don't want to destroy, you always assume a gun is loaded. That's not just a gun you pickup, that's any gun anywhere. If someone else is holding it then it's loaded too.

> In fact, nothing they did was criminal. They were in a gated neighborhood, people ripped the iron gate down, and I think it's clear they were reasonably defending their homes.

Bullshit. Brandishing is a crime in pretty much every US state and Canadian province. There are affirmative defenses to Brandishing, like real physical threats to life or property, but that gate was community property and not theirs alone.

I could see them getting out of the charges and having enough reasonable doubt to do so. Right now it's being leveraged as a kulturekamf headline to make 2nd Amendment nuts get angry.

But make no mistake, if you point a real gun at people, with a finger on the trigger, you're implying you're going to kill someone. You'd better have a damned good reason for it, and be ready to stand to any consequences; "judged by a jury instead of by St. Peter", etc.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by ShamelessC on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:28PM (#24778464)
I don't have a response for you because you're probably dug in, but anyone reading this please consider that it's riddled with misinformation.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by djsumdog on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:29PM (#24780537)
Could you consider maybe you're believing the misinformation?

I never finished my video on Portland, but I do have one up on CHAZ, and I use to live and have friends in that area. I suggest you watch it:

https://battlepenguin.video/videos/watch/9f81cd38-3ee9-4f26-...

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by ShamelessC on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:09PM (#24782258)
Sorry but I don't think engaging with you will result in the interesting conversation that HN strives to achieve. I'm not trying to dismiss you outright, and I'm sure there are a few incidents that match your theories but that you are extrapolating to a trend that doesn't exist but has been reinforced by Fox News etc.

Anyway, best of luck. Thanks for being civil.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by tomjakubowski on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:42PM (#24778641)
Portland: Feds suffer 277 injuries but no lasting blindness.

https://pamplinmedia.com/pt/9-news/475908-384635-portland-fe...

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by djsumdog on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:30PM (#24780557)
Well that's good. I'm glad they're not permanently blind. Those green lasers are still very powerful and shouldn't have been used they way they were.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by Proziam on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:23AM (#24777548)
> Is it really possible we only have <5 terror plots against our country in a given year

That depends on your definition. If you're talking about organized 9/11 style attacks, absolutely. It's hard to bring plans like that together no matter how strong your convictions. If you're talking "random mentally ill person unleashes devastation on a group of US citizens" then no, there's certainly far more. That said, situations like that are best handled by local authorities. The Stoneman Douglas High School shooting is a prime example of that because as the story unraveled it became clear that the shooter had a history that was well known to the local police (and FBI if I recall?).

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by thelean12 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:00PM (#24779543)
I'm not sure I believe the whole "oh the CIA and FBI stop a ton of stuff and they just don't tell us" thing.

The FBI made a huge deal about them stopping the plot to kidnap the Michigan governor and take over their capital building. Why would they hide other stuff?

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by greyhair on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:44PM (#24780072)
If you count domestic terror, for example, the recent conspiracy to kidnap a Governor (or possibly two).

That should count.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by TheRealDunkirk on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:03PM (#24778911)
Yeah, at least the CIA claimed that "enhanced interrogation techniques" was yielding actionable intelligence.

I remember a story from years ago that some lab was working on a lens for a satellite for the NSA with a resolution that would be able to discern different coins on the ground from space. They were complaining that, after all their work, the job was cancelled, and they weren't going to get paid. What it meant, of course, was that they had found a better alternative.

The fact that the NSA isn't even bothering to lie about this is telling. The linked article says they won't even be trying to get Congress to let them continue the process, and this is even more telling. But what it's telling me ISN'T that it does not work, and it's certainly not because they suddenly grew a conscience about the Constitution. It's just that they don't need this particular vector to get the sigint they're looking for now.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:29PM (#24779898)
Identifying a coin from orbit is almost certainly physically impossible due to the diffraction limit[0] and the maximum payload diameter of existing space launch vehicles.

As for the PRISM replacement, it's fair to assume that the NSA simply buys whatever social contact graphs it wants from Facebook and commercial data brokers.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diffraction-limited_system

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by Pick-A-Hill2019 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:26PM (#24779185)
Regarding the story that you recalled some years back - There is conjecture that the HST (Hubble Space Telescope) repurposed some NSA technology. Not exactly a definitive source but Wikipedia has some details.

https://space.stackexchange.com/questions/3448/was-hubble-re...

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/KH-11_Kennen

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by beagle3 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:06AM (#24777339)
> PRISM is a phenomenal waste of trust and money.

Only if you believe its stated purpose is its real purpose.

I suspect it's actually a huge success if you measure it against its real purpose.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by nobleach on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:11AM (#24777394)
I'm not asking in an accusatory manor, I'm generally curious. What do you think it's real purpose is?
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by alasdair_ on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:49AM (#24777980)
Increased power for the people that control it.

(With a bonus side effect of lots of government dollars funneled to certain Contractors.)

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by fsflover on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:15PM (#24780391)
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by bastardoperator on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:13AM (#24777408)
They're not going to tell you about wins or loses, it would be silly to think otherwise. I'm not saying I agree with the program in any capacity, but those of us that have worked with government have a simple saying "loose lips sink ships".
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by phobosanomaly on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:08PM (#24778207)
We read about the loses in the news, because people are killed and injured.

We hear about the wins too.

The whole Bin Laden raid was a massive publicity coup for the Obama administration. It was shouted from the rooftops.

If a president can point to something in an election year and go "see, see there, I made you people safer," they will.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by craftinator on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:07PM (#24778970)
I subscribe to this belief as well. Presidents have the power to declassify information at will, and I haven't been alive to see a president that isn't spending lots of time singing their own praises; popularity contests tend to select people of that ilk.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by Zigurd on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:43AM (#24777888)
The reality is that actual terrorism makes the papers, and real terrorists get tried and convicted. This is just mystery-mongering by people with nothing to do but defend a budget.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by throwaway91914 on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:19PM (#24779098)
> PRISM is a phenomenal waste of trust and money.

Surveillance is about gaining power through information asymmetry. Spying on military, political or FINANCIAL targets is worth trillions.

It has nothing to do with terrorism, and everything to do with political hegemony.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by anarazel on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:14PM (#24779703)
There's been a lot of statements about the efficacy of parts of PRISM, just not about the metadata collection. Obviously not the end-all-be-all but the PCLOB reports about 215 and 702 are worth skimming.

215: https://documents.pclob.gov/prod/Documents/OversightReport/e...

702: https://documents.pclob.gov/prod/Documents/OversightReport/8...

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by failuser on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:34PM (#24779271)
One reason not to do that is to hide your methods. The usual tactic to show good anti-terrorist results is to inject provocateurs into fringe groups and paint them as thwarted terrorists. I hope that US is not going that route.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @02:35PM (#24779973)
The US already has gone down that route.

Most of the Islamist terrorist plots federal authorities have 'broken up' over the past twenty years have involved undercover agents leading on people who are too dysfunctional to be dangerous to do things for which they can be convicted.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by hashtagmarkup on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:24PM (#24782406)
> Not even attempts to lie ("oh, we stopped several attacks, but we can't tell you anything about them...")

What if that wasn't a lie? If they truly couldn't tell you "anything" about them, they couldn't even acknowledge they existed. Whether or not a government should be allowed to keep such secrets is another matter.

Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by dhimes on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:49AM (#24777987)
I would think the opposite: If the program was greatly effective, I would want a blog post just like this to capture the bad guys' attention. That way they might tend to be less careful and make it easier on me.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by leetcrew on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:03PM (#24778916)
why? even if you are extremely confident in your ability to thwart terrorists, wouldn't it be better to discourage them to the point where they don't even try?
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by dhimes on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:26PM (#24779181)
Oh definitely discourage them, but don't give away how you know. In the defense world the secrets are usually classified lower (sometimes much more so) than the sources.
Re:PRISM – NSA surveillance program did not prevent a single... by FerretFred on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @11:10AM (#24777378)
"oh, we stopped several attacks, but we can't tell you anything about them..."

This!