A statement by them a few days ago: "The most compassionate approach that balances the risks and benefits of reaching herd immunity is to allow those who are at minimal risk of death to live their lives normally to build up immunity to the virus through natural infection, while better protecting those who are at highest risk"
There's a very obvious problem here. Those at high risk have to intermingle with everyone else, and most at high risk don't know that they are.
You don't just 'gain herd immunity'. You get the virus, be contagious, give it to anyone else you come in contact with, and they go out and do the same. People can't afford to quarantine and refuse it. People will not wear a mask, they don't care. Americans whom won't die from the virus will not take it seriously.
In reality barrington is advocating that people die. Which if they're doctors they've violated their do no harm promise - not that it ever meant anything.
As far as I can tell barrington has no leg to stand on. It doesn't matter if they're supposed 'experts', if they're right then they can prove it.
This is not factually accurate. The majority of deaths are those 65+, most people in this group are aware of their age
This is the problem with the declaration. We can see from recent events in the UK that most of the transmission was amongst younger people but a couple of weeks later and it has spread to vulnerable parts of the population and the death rate is increasing.
Just like there are good faith arguments for the proposal, there are also good faith arguments against it.
This has been frustrating this week. I appreciate the author's nuanced approach. It seems that fear has made many too irrational to actually listen to this group of scientists, or to even attempt understanding of the principles on which they base their recommendation.