News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by laurieg on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:13PM (#24767559)
A different word order, any different word order, changes language learning from "learn a bunch of substitutions for my native language" to "learn a completely new system". There's a huge mental overhead for the latter.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by adrianN on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:20PM (#24767624)
The effort of learning a different grammar is dwarfed by the effort of memorizing a sufficiently large dictionary to understand everyday speech. To read at an elementary school level you need 5-20k words.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by imtringued on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @03:39AM (#24774161)
That's not true. People usually learn around a thousand words per year. Someone in their 20s is expected to have a 20k vocabulary but much of that is academic or professional vocabulary. i.e. the overlap between a mechanical and a software engineer might only be 15k words.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by majewsky on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @06:42AM (#24775145)
Is that number for active or passive vocabulary? For active, it seems reasonable, but GP is talking about reading comprehension, i.e. passive vocabulary.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by munchbunny on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @08:43PM (#24772000)
I thought that too, but as a bilingual person who studied Latin for several years... either I'm linguistically handicapped, or the grammar was legitimately tough to wrap your head around. Or both. Some of it was that I really did struggle with the grammar. Some of it was that sometimes we really were reading syntactically complex writing.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by rangibaby on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @09:58PM (#24772403)
If you're a master of the grammar, I think it's possible to start figuring things out from context once you've learned a critical mass of words
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by adrianN on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @12:49AM (#24773176)
Yes, but "critical mass" is much larger than you'd commonly think. It's the low frequency words that contain most information in a sentence.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by airstrike on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:03AM (#24773270)
> It's the low frequency words that contain most information in a sentence.

This is an incredibly insightful point.

Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by solarmist on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:08PM (#24778973)
Thank you. That's a very succinct way of putting it. I wonder if there's a term or concept for this in linguistics.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by bernulli on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:27PM (#24767689)
There's a lot more to learning a different language than learning substitutions.

For starters, there is hardly any bijective mapping between words. Translating 'run' to German could mean any of 'rennen, renne, rennst, rennt, renn, laufen, laeuft' and I am sure I am missing quite a bit.

And that only scratches the surface, let's not get started about Grammar or idioms, etc.

The word order really only adds negligible overhead.

Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by solarmist on Wednesday October 14, 2020 @01:13PM (#24779038)
You get closer to something bijective when you only consider lemmas, but then you'll probably have around 1/3 that are bijective, 1/3 that 1->2 or 3 and 1/3 that are 2 or 3->1.
Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by numpad0 on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @03:47PM (#24769531)
More like building a completely different persona for each family of languages. “Learn a bunch of substitutions” approach only goes so far, your language specific part of identity must be separated at where thought processes for languages diverge and necessary new parts must be built.

Philosophers deny linguistic determinism(a notion that language sets the ceiling for thoughts) but that’s just talking Turing Completeness.

Re:What Chinese looks, feels and sounds like when you're fro... by thrwyoilarticle on Tuesday October 13, 2020 @01:28PM (#24767702)
So learn it. You'll get to practice it with every sentence you ever use.

Conversely, you'll only use 'ballon' when you take about un ballon. I hope that's frequently enough for you to remember the word & its gender. At least it looks like the word 'ball', something you don't get with Vietnamese's 'bóng' or Chinese's '球[1]'

And you'll still get funny looks if you say you're getting ready to go to the New Year's ballon, because substitutions fail with homonyms in both directions. And you'll have to learn and relearn about ten thousand of these substitutions.

[1]maybe?