News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by yadco on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:28AM (#24728528)
Donald Trump signed multiple peace deals this year
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by altacc on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:14AM (#24729104)
Out of curiosity, please list these recent peace deals.

If the UAE/Baharin normalization with Israel is on that list, them remove it. Getting two countries, who are not in conflict, to acknowledge each other and begin a formal relationship is definitely not a peace deal. A peace deal needs to involve the warring parties, which this did not.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by scottlocklin on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:37AM (#24729772)
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by rsynnott on Friday October 09, 2020 @10:00AM (#24729961)
At the time that was given, Egypt and Israel had been formally in a state of war for over 30 years, and just a few years previously there had been a war in which thousands had died. It's not really a comparable situation.

Also, it was, quite reasonably, given to Sadat and Begin, not Carter.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by scottlocklin on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:01PM (#24731929)
Sure it's a comparable situation. If UAE/Bahrain had been independent countries in 1948 they'd have in an official state of war with Israel up until now as well.

Man, people are really buttmad because Trump didn't turn out to be as much of a warmonger as, say, Obama. Count your blessings; he's done fine on foreign policy where it counts.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by 9HZZRfNlpR on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:28AM (#24729689)
Not listening and getting rid of Bolt? Anyone who was alive during Bush administration all around the world, and want world peace, cheered for the decision.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by sabana on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:16AM (#24729577)
So by your logic there would always have to be wars for there to be a Peace prize? What about keeping the peace? Preventing a war?
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by altacc on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:28AM (#24729688)
We’re talking about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict here. There is sustained and ongoing armed conflict between two or more groups. So yes, to win the peace prize for solving the Israeli-Palestine situation you have to have actually stop the conflict. There is no peace to maintain, and impossible to prevent a war that has already happened.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by bzbarsky on Friday October 09, 2020 @10:12AM (#24730065)
You're talking about the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. Other people are talking about the wider Israeli-Arab conflict, which has been closer to a cold war in the last couple of decades (modulo various training/funding for proxy operations), but just as real as the Cold War between the US and the Soviet Union. And worth defusing just like that one, though obviously it didn't have the "possible nuclear holocaust" issue going on.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by metalliqaz on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:21AM (#24729638)
No. Your leap of logic is unreasonable. He was talking about Trump's supposed list of peace deals.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by crusso on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:32AM (#24729221)
That's a ridiculous amount of hair splitting. The normalization of diplomatic relations between Israel and major powers in the Middle East is a huge win for anyone who cares about peace.

It's astounding to me that people hate Trump so much that they refuse to recognize the historicity of this moment. We're seeing a fundamental change in the dynamics of a conflict that has been ongoing for generations, and there's no denying that a huge impetus for that change has been a rethinking of how to solve the problem by the Trump administration.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by altacc on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:22AM (#24729647)
There have been many different attempts to solve the Israel/Palestine conflict and its many associated issues. Every US president has a go and having yet another attempt doesn’t win anyone awards until real results & a resolution between the parties involved in the conflict is achieved.

There was no big win here, Bahrain & UAE already had relationships with Israel, they were not in conflict. At best it can be described as possibly a small contributing factor to a future solution, if many other, much bigger and more relevant arrangements can be made. In reality not much has progressed. If anything, the few handshakes and promises made were a smokescreen for the unhappy status quo to go on as it was before.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by bzbarsky on Friday October 09, 2020 @10:09AM (#24730039)
I suspect the crux of the disagreement is whether the conflict is "Israel/Palestine", as you label it, or "Israel/Arab", as I suspect crusso labels it. The UAE/Bahrain peace deals are a big step for the latter, and not directly relevant to the former. So if you focus on the former, you are right that "not much has progressed", but that's a matter of what sort of progress you care about.

For a long time the two conflicts were sort of interlinked, in that the Palestinians were used as both a rallying point and a pawn in the more general Arab/Israel conflict. Part of the significance of the UAE/Bahrain deals is an ongoing de-linking of the two conflicts.

As a concrete example of a substantive changes that will actually affect the lives of a number of people that have happened recently in the larger Arab/Israel context, Saudi Arabia and Bahrain are now generally allowing flights from Israel through their airspace. This and the other recent liberalization steps are worth considering in the context of the situation described in https://ewerickson.substack.com/p/the-peace-deal-is-a-big-de..., where quite recently references to Israel were routinely censored in textbooks and encyclopedias in the UAE.

It's a big change from that to where we are now, and importantly it's a lot harder to sustain hostility against people you interact with on a daily basis than against a mysterious and vilified "other" that you never experience in person. So to the extent that easier travel leads to the travel actually happening, a practical effect of the sort of normalization of relations we are seeing could be a reduction in hostility "on the ground". Though that's likely to take a generation or three; these things are slow to change.

Now how much credit _Trump_ should get for any of this, I dunno; I wasn't in those conversations. But I also don't think people should claim that the changes here are not important just because they (for excellent reasons!) dislike Trump.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by jacobush on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:21AM (#24737430)
I have a fear the de-linking of the Israel/Palestine and the Israel/Arab conflicts will lead to Israel completely crush Palestine.

Which will be very unpalatable for the wider Arab community, and suddenly we will be back to square one.

I see no realistic solutions, unfortunately.

As for Trump, I know many who can acknowledge that thankfully he has not started any wars, yet see him as incredibly dangerous to the US, and by extension, the world. When the US shrugs, the world trembles.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by metalliqaz on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:27AM (#24729678)
no it is not. the deal was specifically a hedge for Israel's leadership against an unknown future for the trump administration in the US. they may as well have got Texas to sign a deal with Massachusetts.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by contravariant on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:16AM (#24728789)
No matter what he did it's a bad idea to give the Nobel Peace Prize to someone so divisive.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by netcan on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:44AM (#24729825)
Well....

Politicians like to be recognized as "great" and a the Nobel Peace Prize does appeal to many. Trump's desire is a good example. If you avoid controversial figures, you avoid using the prize as a motivator exactly where you need it.

For example, Begin/Sadaat and Arafat/Rabin. The first peace worked out. The second one didn't. But, all four of these people led a pretty violent life as militaristic and nationalistic leaders. They're all extremely controversial in the middle east, and in their own countries.

I definitely don't think avoiding divisive political figures is a good. thing. That said, I don't think he's earned one.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by kabouseng on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:28AM (#24728840)
For example someone like Obama...?
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by contravariant on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:58AM (#24728997)
Just because your politics only has 2 sides doesn't mean any criticism of one side is automatically in favour of the other.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by mola on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:48AM (#24728942)
When did obama say anything devisive? When did he actively intended to enflame tense situation? When did he say anything outright disrespectful to his opposition ? Obama may not have been perfect but he was always respectful, always kept his cool.

Comparing Trump's hateful rhetoric of his opposition to How obama conducted himself is a bad joke.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by ThomPete on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:55AM (#24728980)
You din't find it divisive becauee you agree with a lot of what he says. A lot of people found it divisive and the result was Trump.
[dead]
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by ThomPete on Friday October 09, 2020 @04:14PM (#24733946)
Why do you think Twitter is the right platform to measure that by?
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by metalliqaz on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:14PM (#24735954)
Because it's easiest to search.

Please, explain to me how "LIBERATE MICHIGAN" is not divisive.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by ThomPete on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:10AM (#24738401)
It easy to search but it doesn't have many of Trumps voters which makes it a useless platform to decide or measure whether Obama was divisive.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:33AM (#24737483)
> Inclusive language does not stop being inclusive just because it angers racists.

Now when Pandemic struck, Trump could have used it as an excuse to defund HBCUs right? That is what a racist would do. On the contrary, he delivered an additional $1.4 Billion through the CARES Act:

"This Administration is committed to the success of HBCUs, Minority Serving Institutions, and the students they serve. Each institution is unique and is an important part of this country's educational fabric," said Secretary DeVos. "By providing additional support to these important institutions, we can help ensure they emerge from this crisis stronger than before. I encourage these institutions, like all others, to use these funds to provide emergency grants to students during this challenging time, and to expand remote learning programs and build IT capacity. These are challenging times, but if we take this opportunity to transform higher education to meet the demands of the 21st century, our nation's students and higher education as a whole will be better for it."

[1]: https://www.ed.gov/news/press-releases/secretary-devos-deliv...

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:31AM (#24737476)
> Do you really want to start comparing the public record?

Public record is what they did when they were both in office for the people of the United States. I would definitely compare the two because Trump will win hands down. You are wanting to compare the two Twitter accounts. Tweets don't feed people. Tweets don't solve issues. Tweets don't make policies.

> Inclusive language does not stop being inclusive just because it angers racists.

Since you wanted to compare the two let us start with funding of Historically Black Colleges. Because a "racist" President would never increase funds for HBCUs. Instead, he would ensure that the funding is reduced. Obama in the first two years: $1.43B. Trump in first two years of his office: $1.58B [1].

"And even though we may not be able to fully trust numbers compiled by officials working under partisan directives, there are few budget outlines of any kind which suggest other than what too many of us fear; the guy we love to hate is showing historic love to historically black colleges."

[1]: https://hbcudigest.com/obama-vs-trump-who-did-more-for-hbcus...

“Oh, man … yesterday was great and historic. I’ve been around a long time and I’ve never seen so many black folks gathered in the Oval Office,” said Haynes, who was part of that photo opportunity. He also helped bring together the Trump administration and congressional leaders to discuss areas of collaboration between HBCUs and the federal government.

“With this executive order, we will make HBCUs a priority in the White House — an absolute priority,” Trump said. “A lot of people are going to be angry that they’re not a priority, but that’s OK.”

[2]: https://theundefeated.com/features/trump-signs-executive-ord...

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by metalliqaz on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:53AM (#24738633)
you're living in a fantasy world, an absolute fantasy world, if you think Obama was more divisive than Trump.

And I didn't say Trump was racist, I said that inclusive (rather than divisive) language angers racists. I think it's very telling that you interpreted that as "trump = racist" and jumped into action with unrelated talking points you just happened to have laying around. That's very shill-like behavior.

Even though I think he probably is racist, I don't know for sure. What I do know for sure is that he intentionally uses rage-bait and wedge issues to divide the public for his own benefit. This is clear and obvious.

That "evidence" up there is from a class of argumentation designed not to change anyone's mind, but to give supporters an excuse to put concerns of racism out of their head and stay with him. That's why you find it so convincing. you want to like him. Most of politics is like this.

How can I tell? Well it's flimsy to anyone who cares to look. For example, the only numbers cited compare two values that are very similar (within 10%) but compare two period separated by 8 years, with the former during an bad economy that Obama inherited from Bush (and fixed) and the later during a good economy that Trump inherited from Obama (and destroyed). Also, as I'm sure you know, executive orders don't increase funding for anything. Congress does that. What Trump did is what he always does. Some purely-performative stunt that does no actual good and is just designed to grab headlines. Moving an advisory board into the White House is a death sentence, not a benefit.

But of course none of this matters. Your tribe is your tribe, until death do you part. What you might want to consider is that your tribe will only survive if you cut out the cancer.

I won't be responding further. Have a nice day, and try not to catch the 'rona.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @12:11PM (#24739892)
> you're living in a fantasy world, an absolute fantasy world, if you think Obama was more divisive than Trump.

You want to know how divisive Obama is? He literally put immigrant kids in cages and split them from their parents. And he even admitted to that [1]. But hey guess what, your fake news media showed it as Trump doing it and even attributed an image of kids being put in cages during Obama's tenure as that of being done in Trump's tenure. Obama literally effing said: "That is our direct message to the families in Central America. Do not send your children to the borders. If they do make it they'll get sent back. More importantly they may not make it". This is Obama for you. Ah but no one will make a fuss about it because he is the Nobel Peace Prize winner! How can he ever say anything that is wrong? He just can't. Only Trump can. Cos "Orange man bad".

> That "evidence" up there is from a class of argumentation designed not to change anyone's mind, but to give supporters an excuse to put concerns of racism out of their head and stay with him. That's why you find it so convincing. you want to like him. Most of politics is like this.

That is far fetched and ridiculous assertion. He had friends from all races before he ran for Presidency. People loved him. The press loved him. Everyone wanted to share a limelight with him. No one had any problems until he ran for Presidency. So either he was a racist or he isn't. You can't have it both ways. You are trying really hard to paint him as a racist. And then trying to diplomatically say that you did not mean that he is a racist. Nice try!

> For example, the only numbers cited compare two values that are very similar (within 10%) but compare two period separated by 8 years, with the former during an bad economy that Obama inherited from Bush (and fixed) and the later during a good economy that Trump inherited from Obama (and destroyed)

Are you kidding me? Trump had the best economy ever until Corona came knocking on the doors sent as a gift by China. And don't you dare try to paint it on Trump. The epicenter was in New York, run by a Democrat Governor who pushed this stupid policy of getting infected covid patients admitted to nursing homes and intermingle them with non-covid patients instead of making them go through a home quarantine. The majority of the Covid cases are from Democrat controlled states/districts with California contributing the most. How do I say that majority of the Covid cases are from Democrat controlled districts? Here is the research to back it up [2]

> Also, as I'm sure you know, executive orders don't increase funding for anything. Congress does that. What Trump did is what he always does. Some purely-performative stunt that does no actual good and is just designed to grab headlines. Moving an advisory board into the White House is a death sentence, not a benefit.

I stopped reading after this. The CARES Act was approved by Congress you absolute doofus. [3]

"The Coronavirus Aid, Relief, and Economic Security (CARES) Act was passed by Congress with overwhelming, bipartisan support and signed into law by President Trump on March 27th, 2020. This over $2 trillion economic relief package delivers on the Trump Administration’s commitment to protecting the American people from the public health and economic impacts of COVID-19."

> But of course none of this matters. Your tribe is your tribe, until death do you part. What you might want to consider is that your tribe will only survive if you cut out the cancer.

No. My tribe bothers about fact checking the media lies and find out the truth for ourselves. We don't just believe whatever the media says as gospel truth. Maybe you should start doing that. You can start that by learning about the CARES Act. It was passed by Congress. And yes, Trump's increase of 1.4 Billion $ in funding for HBCU is in the Act itself. It is called the HEER Fund. You can read about it here: [4]

> I won't be responding further. Have a nice day, and try not to catch the 'rona.

I see what you did there. Just so you know I am an Indian who takes active interest in US politics. But yeah you just confirmed my feelings of Democrats being the worst of the lot. You have to be some special kind of evil to say "try not to catch the 'rona". You think I am actively going to go looking for and catch Coronavirus? Are you kidding me? I would never say that even to my worst enemy. But hey when Democrats can found the KKK, they can stoop to any level. You just cemented that feeling I have for Democrat supporters. Thanks for that!

[1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sjxay-XeSks

[2]: https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2020/05/26/coronavirus...

[3]: https://home.treasury.gov/policy-issues/cares#:~:text=The%20....

[4]: https://www2.ed.gov/about/offices/list/ope/caresact.html

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by LeCow on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:54AM (#24728969)
One thing a lot of people don't realise is that Trump is the first president in a long time that hasn't invaded a country. Sure he's authorised bombings, which president hasn't?

But I can't remember the last time a president didn't put troops somewhere. Ironically he's getting a lot of hate for pulling out of Syria/Germany.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by not_a_moth on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:49AM (#24728945)
Try listening to his addresses and speeches over the last couple years, and look at the policies he's implemented. Look at all the dishonest coverage, and yes his blunt way of talking doesn't help, but it's still hard not to conclude that the media is the primary source of him being considered divisive.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by tinco on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:11AM (#24729079)
I've seen a bunch of his speeches and many if not most of his speeches made my blood boil and I don't even live in the US, I don't read/watch much US media and my local news though allegedly left leaning only reports factual news on him and US politics in general.

Can you give an example of him being respectful or understanding of democrat policy or politicians?

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by tsimionescu on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:28AM (#24729191)
The only way the media is making Trump look divisive is by reporting his words.

He has called fascists good people. He has called Mexican immigrants rapists. He has called other countries shitholes. He has recognized the illegal move by Israel to have Jerusalem as their capital (one of the only countries in the world to do so!). He refuses to endorse BLM, one of the largest popular movements in decades, and has sent armed forces to crash peaceful protests. He has escalated deportations even more. He has continued and increased Obama's assassination programs in the middle east, even assassinating a high foreign dignitary on another country's soil. He has repeatedly downplayed and refused to manage the greatest medical and economic emergency in almost 100 years, with consequences that will be visible for the next 20 years.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by crusso on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:36AM (#24729240)
He has called fascists good people. He has called Mexican immigrants rapists

I'm not a fan of Trump's personality, but on HN, can't we be intellectually honest about politics?

The statements above are not in fact what he said if you allow him any honest amount of context.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by tsimionescu on Friday October 09, 2020 @12:33PM (#24731614)
Maybe the fascists one is a little ambiguous. I believe that he meant exactly what I said, but I admit that other rational people can believe otherwise.

But for the second one he has stated 'When Mexico sends its people, they’re not sending their best. They’re not sending you. They’re not sending you. They’re sending people that have lots of problems, and they’re bringing those problems with us. They’re bringing drugs. They’re bringing crime. They’re rapists. And some, I assume, are good people.' I don't know how you can read this other than as a statement that most Mexican immigrants are drug delaers/users, criminals or rapists.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by tim333 on Saturday October 10, 2020 @02:52AM (#24737113)
Not a Trump fan but by "...rapists. And some, I assume, are good people" he no doubt meant some were rapist not all, which is factually correct. Trump says so much bad stuff that twisting his words only really weakens the opposition case.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by tsimionescu on Saturday October 10, 2020 @08:21AM (#24738451)
That expression clearly implies that MOST immigrants are drug dealers, criminals, or rapists - and that he can only assume that a few of them must also be good people (he can't know for sure that any are, though, he can only assume it - implying he has only seen the drug dealers, criminals, and rapists).
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by person_of_color on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:13AM (#24729097)
Didn’t he call other countries shitholes?
[dead]
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by mola on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:32AM (#24728864)
Obama getting the prize wrongfully doesn't make trump more or less suitable.

As an Israeli, I tell you, this peace deal is a joke. We've had relations with the UAE for decades, they were never hostile to Israel. It was nothing more than a photo op for Netanyahu. The UAE and Bahrein didn't even send same level representatives. The sent foreign ministers for meeting our prime minister. Seems silly, but it tells how serious this accord is.

So a peace deal that changed nothing. And will only let some arms dealers pocket extra bucks. The Palestinians will still be under Israeli military rule. Israel citizens are still targeted by missiles and rockets. Violence is still prospering here. Peace is no closer.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:20AM (#24737428)
> As an Israeli, I tell you, this peace deal is a joke

Not a joke but a start. You have to start somewhere and this is the first step towards it.

> Seems silly, but it tells how serious this accord is.

Not silly at all. Peace Accords bind Nations. It has nothing to do with who was present at the signing ceremony. As long as it is accepted by the Nations involved it is as legitimate as they come.

> We've had relations with the UAE for decades, they were never hostile to Israel

Hostility is not just in terms of War. Hostility can even be in terms of who the country votes for in the UN on key issues that concerns Israel. If you look at it that way, India has never been hostile towards Israel. Never waged a War. But we always supported the Palestinian cause. That has started to change because of the development of Israel-India ties with India moving closer to Israel than ever before since 2014. It was because of Modi's visit to Israel and Netanyahu's visit to India. These things might seem silly but this is how diplomacy is carried out. How else would you think a solution can be achieved without waging a big War? Through diplomatic means. For Israel, truly making friends is a big criteria. It helps in putting diplomatic pressure on Israel's adversaries instead of resorting to military options! Right now Israel is using military options because it lacks unanimous support across the World. Nearly half of the countries in the World oppose Israel's moves. Through these Peace Accords, the countries that were on the fence when it came to Israel will now be more enthusiastically involved in achieving final Peace in the region. Because they are now stakeholders too. Once these countries (and many others) join in, pressure will build on Israel's adversaries to come to the table and negotiate a Peace deal. This is how it is done. One small step at a time.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by nindalf on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:11AM (#24729086)
Complaining about downvotes on HN after being flagged already. It's a bold strategy, let's see if it works out for you.
[dead]
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by panpanna on Friday October 09, 2020 @06:50AM (#24728637)
Not trying to get political, but I feel the middle east talks wasnt even between the right countries.

Get Syria, Iran, Palestine and Israel to sign a peace agreement, now that would be an accomplishment.

Peace between Israel and Bahrain? Were they even fighting?

Edit: should have known this was a touchy subject...

[dead]
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by panpanna on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:09AM (#24728733)
Sure, but Turkey and Egypt recognized Isreal in 1950 and 1979. Saudi Arabia/Iraq/Syria still do not recognize Israel.

In comparison, Bahrain and UAE are tiny countries that already had pretty normal relationship with Israel, just not very official.

So an achievement by POTUS, yes. But let's not oversell it.

(Not gonna comment more on this, politics make me nervous)

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:03AM (#24737341)
> So an achievement by POTUS, yes. But let's not oversell it.

Redirecting you to my comment here:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24737337

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by shripadk on Saturday October 10, 2020 @04:02AM (#24737337)
> Get Syria, Iran, Palestine and Israel to sign a peace agreement, now that would be an accomplishment.

Did Obama do that? Then why was he given the Nobel Peace Prize? See that is why I said it is a joke! You guys have different standards for Obama and Trump. With Obama, he literally did not do anything and was given the Nobel Peace Prize. Even he was shocked when he heard it. But Trump did much more good than Obama and yet he hasn't been awarded. It is a joke!

Obama literally launched 12 new proxy wars during his entire tenure. Trump hasn't launched even one. Most US Presidents have been involved in some War or the other. Trump pulled troops out of Syria and Afghanistan. That is an accomplishment in itself.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by Synaesthesia on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:19AM (#24729129)
Frankly if Obama won it, so should Trump.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by altacc on Friday October 09, 2020 @09:31AM (#24729716)
One-upping Obama seems to be a primary motivation for Trump, but it’s not how awards work. Just because Obama got the peace prize when he shouldn’t have doesn’t mean Trump should also get it when he shouldn’t have. Two wrongs not making a right and all that.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by collyw on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:29AM (#24729200)
Trump is far more deserving. He has been far more anti-war than Obama.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by m0zg on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:04AM (#24728704)
With more peace deals to come, by the way. Also he did not start any new wars, and started withdrawing US forces from the idiotic endless wars started by previous administrations. Donald Trump has done more for world peace than any US president since Reagan. It'd go further back than that, but Reagan defeated communism, which is pretty huge in itself.
Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by addicted on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:19AM (#24728804)
Somehow more forces in all the places he said he would withdraw forces from than the beginning of his term = withdrawal of forces?

The only genuine force withdrawal he did was in Syria, which will damage the US dramatically going forward because they completely abandoned their allies because Erdogan was able to sweet talk Donald Teump.

And the “peace deals” are a joke because they were signed between Israel and countries that were never hostile towards each other in the first place. UAE and Bahrain? It was simply Trump paying UAE/Bahrain your tax dollars for them to formally announce something that has always been the case, and Bibi doing the same so that Trump could continue to allow him to annex Palestinian land in peace to satisfy the most orthodox people in his country who are keeping him in power and saving him from prosecution.

And yeah, supplying arms to the Saudis so they can continue slaughtering the Yemenis and unilaterally breaking a peace deal so Iranians can die in massive numbers are not starting a war, but is causing civilian death tolls that are extremely high.

And sure, creating massive instability and allowing China to run free in most of Asia and Africa is also not starting a war, but is completely weakening the US and emboldening China in ways we couldn’t have imagined 5 years ago (for all his anti China talk, Trump has been remarkably weak against them, which isn’t surprising considering that until January the highlight of his tenure was gonna be a joke of a trade deal with China, and that he spent years without touching trade with China but slapping tariffs on all the US’s allies).

And of course, dismantling treaties with Russia, such as the open skies treaty for example, which was a completely one sided treaty in favor of the US and its allies only served to increase the risk of war.

And how about jumping into peace talks between S Korea and N Korea (S Korea’s new President was elected on the explicit platform of trying to restart peace discussions with N Korea) and derailing the entire process, by giving Kim exactly what he wanted...a photo op with the US president which he could promote within his own country, without getting anything in return (I guess the love letters from Kim to Donald Trump was something).

And we haven’t even gotten to the part where he and his have explicitly and implicitly supported and emboldened white supremacists in the US and Europe.

Donald Trump is best looked at as someone who never boiled the water, but definitely turned up the temperature so it’s hitting close to 190. He has taken decades of goodwill and trust, and burned it so he could claim minor victories which hurt the US massively but can be something for him to crow about.

It requires an extremely narrow way of looking at the world (at basically the PR level) to think Donald Teump is even close to being net positive for world peace.

Re:The Nobel Peace Prize 2020 by crumbshot on Friday October 09, 2020 @08:22AM (#24729150)
> It requires an extremely narrow way of looking at the world (at basically the PR level) to think Donald Teump is even close to being net positive for world peace.

This checks out - pretty much everything being posted by Trump fans in this thread is a rewording of the PR spin we see Twitter bots spamming everywhere.