News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by ketzo on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:41PM (#24722998)
> ...your work, which occupies a large portion of your life, should not be divisive.

I get that desire, I really do, but I think it's so important to recognize that your work is not apolitical. It doesn't matter what you're building. What you build does not exist in a vacuum, and the decisions you make around politics at work are themselves political decisions.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by dingaling on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:10PM (#24723338)
> work are themselves political decisions

But those political decisions are ones relevant to the mission of the company.

Coinbase probably shouldn't be involved in politics around police reform, fracking, climate change or the Second Amendment because they are orthogonal to its mission. Insert other topics as you see fit.

And hence its employees should leave their opinions of such matters at the door.

Coinbase should be focused on politics around global financial regulation. And its employees should focus their workplace political energy on those matters.

Also, it's generally just polite and respectful to your coworkers to provide a non-political, non-partisan workplace.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by kelnos on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:12PM (#24724006)
I'm sympathetic to this argument because on the face of it, it seems correct and should be the way we ideally do things.

But many things in the world that should not be politicized are, in fact, politicized. Perhaps Coinbase wants to hire a more diverse bunch of people, and starts an internal initiative to do so. Perhaps they do this not out of any political motivation, but because they genuinely believe (as they should!) that having a more diverse workforce will help them make better decisions about their product.

But of course there will be some (many?) who will decry this as Coinbase "being political". You just can't win, really.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:53PM (#24724803)
I'm not coinbase, so I can only speculate as to their meaning. While it's possible to define "political" so abstractly that it becomes all-encompassing, it's pretty clear to me that they probably mean to prohibit political debates that are unrelated (or only very tenuously related) to their core mission.

"We should hire a more diverse workforce because diversity improves our collective judgment, thereby furthering our mission" is on its face a fine subject for discussion provided you're evaluating the claim on its merits and not sneaking in overtly political implications like "we have a moral responsibility to hire diverse candidates". One could envision a fruitful, dispassionate discussion about how much return on investment the company could expect from a diversity initiative, how that ROI stacks up against other opportunities, how to measure the ROI and make sure the initiative is meeting expectations, whether or not it runs afoul of anti-discrimination law, what kind of diversity (race, gender, viewpoint, etc) is most likely to yield the highest ROI, etc.

Of course, it's prudent to stay away from these kinds of charged topics altogether because it's very likely that you have employees that will take this as an opportunity to pollute a potentially productive conversation with their overtly political opinions.

That some things are easily abused by bad-faith employees doesn't mean that we should let bad faith employees have free reign.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by mrguyorama on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:35PM (#24723656)
Taking "no stance" on a political issue is itself a political stance for the status quo. It is impossible to not be political
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by manigandham on Thursday October 08, 2020 @11:12PM (#24726383)
No stance means just that. Redefining terms and imposing a will is the overtly irrelevant and aggressive political posturing that these policies are trying to avoid.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by username90 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:07PM (#24723960)
If the outcome of society would be the same if you exist or not then you are not political. For example if you don't vote and don't support any political causes, then the people who take the time to get involved decides everything and you had no influence.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by xmprt on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:12PM (#24724487)
There are 4 levels of competence. For all the people who know they are incompetence and therefore abstain from voting there are a lot of people (possibly more) that don't know their incompetence and decide to vote regardless. If you're not voting because you're uninformed, you're probably much more informed than many of the people who are voting.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by chii on Friday October 09, 2020 @02:57AM (#24727509)
> don't know their incompetence and decide to vote regardless

That's a very wrong way to understand what democracy means. If you're incompetent, you are still afforded a vote. And you sleep on the bed you make.

and in any case, the incompetence voter implies that they could be voting "wrong". This is a deep and insidious implication because implying something can be wrong also implies the other "competent" voters are "right". The very notion that one side is "right" is very anti-democratic.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by chrisdirkis on Friday October 09, 2020 @12:12AM (#24726754)
If one million people don't care about changing the status quo and 50 do, the status quo will won't change. If one person doesn't care and 50 do, it's much more likely. The status quo exists in everyone who does nothing to change it, even if they don't move to actively affect things.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by nickff on Friday October 09, 2020 @12:19AM (#24726788)
Isn't 'no stance' just the 'null stance'? Similar to how one must reject the null hypothesis to accept another, one must reject the null stance to take another.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by sershe on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:06AM (#24727565)
That is a mis-characterization. My no-stance stance is not that I support that status quo, it's that I'll try to care about myself and my friends and family no matter what you political idiots do. Communism? Sure. Fascism? Whatever. I'd rather that you didn't, but it's more productive to mitigate it for myself than to get involved either way.

Is it selfish? Probably, and I'm open and proud about that.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by lexs on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:12AM (#24727600)
So Individualism? That's pretty clearly a political philosophy / ideology.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by sershe on Friday October 09, 2020 @03:31AM (#24727689)
Yeah, the same way atheism is a religion and "off" is a TV channel.

Individualism as a political philosophy would be smth like advocating for libertarianism/adjacent stuff, etc. The apolitical stance is the apolitical stance. I do not engage in politics unless it's a minimum-effort activity like the default mail-in voting (WA). Sure, I may know approximately what the best way to organize society is, and if aliens landed and put me in charge I'd become political; but as it is, I do not care, mostly because it's not productive, but in no small part because actively caring about how to organize society is heavily correlated with being very wrong (IMHO).

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by bluntfang on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:40PM (#24723705)
>Coinbase probably shouldn't be involved in politics around police reform, fracking, climate change or the Second Amendment because they are orthogonal to its mission.

It's impossible to not involve yourself in politics that effect your employee's everyday lives.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by f69281c on Thursday October 08, 2020 @04:02PM (#24723248)
To me this take rolls into the general "silence is violence" or "either you're with us or against us" refrain that has become background noise to me. It reads the same as someone telling me I'm enabling fascism by not posting a black square on instagram or whatever.

I'm nearing the point of being aggressively dismissive towards this kind of attitude, because a lot of it doesn't even seem to be laid out in good faith. People are just addicted to being mad, addicted to being right, addicted to the idea that they can channel their anger through pop politics and get validation for it as a bonus.

I have an extremely low opinion of the people and groups who follow along with whatever pop social issue is trending today because they don't want to get in trouble, and IMHO those people aren't really worth interacting with because again, it's more about landing a spicy dunk on the bad guys (tm) and collecting heart icons than whatever issue they're using as a weapon today.

>your work is not apolitical. It doesn't matter what you're building

spare me.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by freeone3000 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:03PM (#24724403)
We control the information flow for billions. How the hell could that NOT be political?
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by war1025 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @09:25PM (#24725780)
> We control the information flow for billions

Who is "we"?

The majority of people here don't work for FANG

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by username90 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @10:53PM (#24726264)
And the large majority of people at FANG have about as much control over the flow of information as a plumber has over the flow of shit from a city. They just keep the system running, they don't influence it.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by war1025 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @11:04PM (#24726334)
Even more so then. "We" don't control anything any more than anyone else.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by ErikBjare on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:53PM (#24723138)
I see people replying this a lot, and those who do must have missed what Brian said about it this exact thing in his original post.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by baggy_trough on Thursday October 08, 2020 @03:51PM (#24723117)
This is really a noxious idea. It's like saying that because we all breathe the same air, everything I do affects you. No, not in the vast majority of cases.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by Avamander on Friday October 09, 2020 @07:00AM (#24728689)
Okay this is like the worst example.

Everything you do does affect the environment around you. For example if you take a Bahamas trip, you are paying to generate tons of CO2. If you buy a diesel car, or just driving one, you're affecting the shared air as well.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by baggy_trough on Friday October 09, 2020 @05:57PM (#24734830)
Yes that is true in a pedantic sense. It is also true that my gravitational force affects everyone in the world as I move about. But not enough to matter.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by tupputuppu on Friday October 09, 2020 @01:52PM (#24732497)
If you want to have such a broad definition of political, then why restrict the whole fight to tech companies? Why aren't on the barricades about the fashion industry or traditional media?

Are you sure this isn't just an excuse to make things political in these west coast companies that are full of young, hot-headed, extremely left wing people?