News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by kelnos on Thursday October 08, 2020 @05:12PM (#24724006)
I'm sympathetic to this argument because on the face of it, it seems correct and should be the way we ideally do things.

But many things in the world that should not be politicized are, in fact, politicized. Perhaps Coinbase wants to hire a more diverse bunch of people, and starts an internal initiative to do so. Perhaps they do this not out of any political motivation, but because they genuinely believe (as they should!) that having a more diverse workforce will help them make better decisions about their product.

But of course there will be some (many?) who will decry this as Coinbase "being political". You just can't win, really.

Re:A follow up to Coinbase being a mission focused company by throwaway894345 on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:53PM (#24724803)
I'm not coinbase, so I can only speculate as to their meaning. While it's possible to define "political" so abstractly that it becomes all-encompassing, it's pretty clear to me that they probably mean to prohibit political debates that are unrelated (or only very tenuously related) to their core mission.

"We should hire a more diverse workforce because diversity improves our collective judgment, thereby furthering our mission" is on its face a fine subject for discussion provided you're evaluating the claim on its merits and not sneaking in overtly political implications like "we have a moral responsibility to hire diverse candidates". One could envision a fruitful, dispassionate discussion about how much return on investment the company could expect from a diversity initiative, how that ROI stacks up against other opportunities, how to measure the ROI and make sure the initiative is meeting expectations, whether or not it runs afoul of anti-discrimination law, what kind of diversity (race, gender, viewpoint, etc) is most likely to yield the highest ROI, etc.

Of course, it's prudent to stay away from these kinds of charged topics altogether because it's very likely that you have employees that will take this as an opportunity to pollute a potentially productive conversation with their overtly political opinions.

That some things are easily abused by bad-faith employees doesn't mean that we should let bad faith employees have free reign.