If the number really is 10%, that's significant. This letter is merely suggesting further research; I think it's far from fear-mongering.
Politics must decide whether to subject a large fraction of the population to the risk of this disease or whether to convince or coerce people to not go to football games, movie theaters and cocktail parties for a year or two.
Luckily, we as individuals still have the choice of not getting infected, although the risks of everyday activities increase dramatically when there are high levels of transmission in the community.
Do we restrict the community for the individual or the individual for the community?
Your feelings on this aren't universal and neither are mine.
Mask use is an individual issue in that it protects other individuals around you. Your right to throw punches stops at my nose. Suppose that we did nothing and let it spread. There would inevitably be a whole lot of people going around spreading it to people who don't want to be infected. This would be the case regardless of how individuals chose to self-isolate. People would go to the grocery store sick and breathe on everyone else there. This is the normal MO when in Flu season.
So it is an individual issue in the sense that as an individual I need to be able to buy food safely, and your choice to spread this unimpeded would infringe on that fundamental right.
And at the end of the day we're weighing the inconvenience of wearing a mask and staying home when sick for a few months versus the inconvenience of wheeling an oxygen bottle around with you for the rest of your life. If you have a cogent argument for why I should be stricken to save you the inconvenience then I'll listen.
Please do show us the people who are now seeking an oxygen bottle around for the rest of their lives because of covid that could have been stopped by a mask.
That said - I would expect some extremely rare outcomes in a sample of 35 million people. We live in a connected world: https://www.gwern.net/Littlewood
I really want to see good stats.
Even for, the simple you would think, case of CFR - what are the current reliable numbers here? In https://ourworldindata.org/mortality-risk-covid I only see cumulative nubers - that is not very informative when we can see how the mortality now is incomparable with the mortality in April and May, we need monthly or weekly cohorts data!
Until there is a good study that controls for biases as well as expected side effects of severe disease like pneumonia, we can conclude nothing about the population
Sure. But COVID-19 is currently in pandemic mode, having now infected at least 10% of the worlds population with zero signs of slowing down. This is not an endemic virus with a known cap on seasonal infections like the flu or colds. The area under the curve is going to be massive in comparison. That's the issue. Yes, it may have many similarities to the long term effects of other viruses. But now we will have hundreds of millions of people dealing with this, rather than hundreds of thousands. Quantity has a quality all of its' own.
Do other respiratory viruses attack the blood and kidneys?Genuinely curious. My mother has Leukemia leading to kidney damage. Definitely some fear of contracting it and passing it to her.
I have a friend in the “long hauler” group that is 38yo. Of the people I am one or two steps from, 45% are dead, 45% had mild issues, and 10% long hauler.
So, low number of N is definitely a problem, for both my experience and the paper.
> Coronavirus. These tend to do their dirty work in the winter and early spring. The coronavirus is the cause of about 20% of colds. There are more than 30 kinds, but only three or four affect people.
https://www.webmd.com/cold-and-flu/cold-guide/common_cold_ca...
> There are more than 30 kinds, but only three or four affect people.
There aren't enough cold viruses around to allow for a 0.2% fraction.
My mind was definitely in the mode of what number and kinds of viruses that a body is exposed to, not so much how contagious it is, but I see your point.
You criticise the article but then post this without any backup.
> The literature is saying that if you're under 48 the flu has a higher mortality rate
ditto. Show us the figures please.
> N=1 in this study
It's not a study.
https://www.nature.com/articles/s41590-020-00808-x SARS-CoV-2-derived peptides define heterologous and COVID-19-induced T cell recognition
>ditto. Show us the figures please.
When I have more time I'll pull out this figure. Let me know if you find it in the meantime.
"With regard to SARS-CoV-2, very recent studies described CD4+ and CD8+ T cell responses to viral peptide megapools in donors that had recovered from COVID-19 and individuals not exposed to SARS-CoV-2, the latter being indicative of potential T cell cross-reactivity21"
They seem to be saying there's value in peptide donors who had recovered from covid, a transfusion of which to those who've not had covid seem to be valuable. It does not say (AIUI) that there is "substantial cross immunity to it though T-Cells defence" in the sense of having a similar disease gives you cross immunity. If I'm wrong, which is likely, please point out the correct passage.
From the US standpoint, the shutdown should have happened in January. After the first US case, there was no purpose in locking down the boarder. Politician fail.
Physicians stressed harsh lockdowns and played into the fear. This wasn't science or statistics, this was fear. Physician fail.
After hundreds of coronavirus cases in the US, governors created their own lockdowns, but had no control over traveling between state lines. This created no benefit but created poor economic conditions. Politician fail.
You know who has been correct but seemingly unheard during all of this? Scientists/epidemiologists.
They predicted the spread perfectly but Politicians, citizens, and Physicians did not listen.
The bigger takeaways were our options for how to handle the pandemic and expected outcomes.
We're trying for a different sort of community here, in which people have thoughtful and curious conversation. If you don't think that's worth trying for, that's fine, but we'd be grateful if you'd at least not damage the experiment like this. I'm sure you wouldn't litter in a city park or dump motor oil in a lake...it's kind of like that.
- reduced tax income, vastly more debt
- frustration within the population
- revelation of systemic flaws
All of these make a government look bad. No matter how true or untrue, the current government will be held directly responsible.
I don't see any instance of emergency laws being abused in a way that was impossible or inconvenient beforehand. Terrorism has already done its part here.
So where are your examples?
A quick search will bring up many examples. Perhaps you're only considering the US?
"Authoritarian governments are using coronavirus as an excuse to crush freedom of expression" [1]
"Would-be autocrats are using covid-19 as an excuse to grab more power" [2]
"How Authoritarians Are Exploiting the COVID-19 Crisis to Grab Power" [3]
"Cambodia is using coronavirus as an excuse for human rights abuse" [4]
[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/voices/coronavirus-free-speech...
[2] https://www.economist.com/international/2020/04/23/would-be-...
[3] https://www.hrw.org/news/2020/04/03/how-authoritarians-are-e...
[4] https://www.smh.com.au/world/asia/cambodia-is-using-coronavi...
Governments just love reducing tax dollars by shutting stuff down!
Look at Hungary, Hong Kong, Cambodia, Venezuela etc. A quick search will bring up many examples.
So is classic SARS, which is known to cause a post-viral syndrome similar to the one the letter proposes. Indeed, the letter opens with a discussion of exactly that syndrome. So it seems a bit odd to be talking about mysticism and religion in this context.
It's odd to me that anyone would mistake it for a study, actually, seeing as it says "Letter to the Editor" right at the top and has no gross morphological features in common with a research paper. No one seems to be trying to represent it as something it makes no pretense of being, except for people who seem to want to discount it without any significant consideration. That's an odd correlation to observe, but there is a lot that's odd about how people have reacted to this pandemic, I suppose.
You're kidding, right? Anecdotes like this one are dominating the media coverage, especially with regards to 'extended' symptoms of covid.
>Covid has been turned into a religion completely lacking any scientific rigour and I feel this paper will be used as a tool to add to the fear.
I don't think that's correct. Covid is well above influenza mortality in every cohort except children, I believe.
https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/hcp/planning-scena...
All viral respiratory infections have the potential to have some side effects to varying degrees but I can't help but feel that this letter will be used to support the concept of "long covid" on an unsuspecting public.
Yes, covid is terrible but it's a different strain of a coronavirus (of which 20% of common colds are too), it's not something mystical. There's a strong chance we have substantial cross immunity to it though T-Cells defence. The literature is saying that if you're under 48 the flu has a higher mortality rate. We've mostly passed through the gompertz curve of the virus mortality as described by initial research by Hope Simpson regarding the seasonality of influenza viruses.
We can't base national health policy on individual health outcomes. Covid has been turned into a religion completely lacking any scientific rigour and I feel this paper will be used as a tool to add to the fear.