Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by rendall on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @06:21AM
(#24696282)
To continue playing with our river analogy: consider a man fishing beside the river, who catches a large salmon. The man is ecstatic, for he is poor, and his family is hungry. Just as he draws his knife to gut it, the fish speaks! It says "Please do not kill me. Throw me back into the river, for I am the Fish King, and I will grant you 3 wishes. You can have whatever your heart desires." Astonished, the man agrees, and throws the talking fish back into the water. He speaks his 3 wishes into the air: to be rich, to be respected, and to be young again. Time passes. The man goes home to his hungry wife and child, hands empty. A day passes. A week. Then a year, and youth, wealth and respect remain elusive. A year after that, the man is fishing by the same riverbank - and remember, this is an analogous riverbank - an analogy for our ancestry - and the man catches the same fish! Or is it? It looks the same, but it does not speak. There is no recognition in its fishy eyes. It just lays on the shore, gasping, flopping. The man decides it's just a normal fish after all.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by throwanem on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @07:06AM
(#24696495)
The metaphor appears to have run away with you somewhat.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by rendall on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @07:15AM
(#24696552)
It is true. It has run away with us all
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by throwanem on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @07:22AM
(#24696591)
What are you actually talking about, though? Veiled and gnomic proclamations can be fun, but sooner or later you have to show your hand.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by rendall on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @11:55AM
(#24699085)
The fish represents the lost dreams of our ancestry, if not the fishy ancestors themselves. The man is us, all of us. The hungry family is our hungry family. Or perhaps our hunger for connection to our past. The story as a whole is meaningless, and in being so, represents the randomness and chaos in which we find ourselves. Is the universe beneficent, malevolent, indifferent? We cannot know for sure. We can only stare into the dying eyes that stare at us in turn, from the mirror, and guess.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by PTOB on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @03:19PM
(#24701351)
I do. This was quite entertaining.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by throwanem on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @12:21PM
(#24699434)
Nobody likes a smartass.
Re:Humans are more closely related than we commonly think
by rendall on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @01:57PM
(#24700567)
This is true and I approve this comment
And then what would an analogy look for prokaryotes - bacteria, archaea? If my understanding of biology is correct, it would be like an infinitely tall, densely tiered waterfall. There's some forward generational movement, but there's also plenty of lateral ones - exchanging gene packets "at runtime".