That’s a 2017 article. Now the fall is much greater because of COVID market shifts, but the rents really did slow or drop before in Downtown Los Angeles.
Real estate in California’s two large metro areas (SF Bay and Greater LA) is a mess, largely thanks to regulation and NIMBYism. That’s not a normal market. Add to it Prop 13 that prevents property tax adjusting tax base to market value of housing, even for corporations and rentals, and you have the recipe for really constraint supply. As the result, prices remain high.
Putting the burden on landlords will cause small-time landlords to exit and be either replaced by large corps that can afford the insurance-equivalent or the rentals will be sold to owner users and the people who have to rent will have even less supply to go around.
Of the various corrective measures, a land value tax (tax on the unimproved value of property) is likely the most widely known, understood, and accepted by economists. Other issues are more difficult to address (see e.g., Mancur Olsen's Logic of Collective Action), but also arise and create dysfunctions through economic logic giving rise to pathologies.
A reading of Adam Smith's sections on prices of various economic products and services suggests a set of differentiable behaviours by types:
1. Commodity goods.
2. Labour wages and services. Extended to include pleasantness, skill, training, constancy, success probability, and trust.
3. Natural resources (developed further by Ricardo, Grey, and Hotelling, though still fundamentally flawed).
4. Returns to stock.
5. Rents: monopoly and network services.
6. Assets and money (to Smith: gold and silver).
7. Interest.
8. Public goods.
9. Taxes.
Each has distinct behavious, much explained by later concepts of the marginalists and political theorists (class and power), though these are suggested by Smith.
There's some likely consolidation of these (rents, assets, and interest, say). Commodity goods follow laws of supply and demand as commonly understood, but only where goods are undifferentiated (no "luxury" branding, monopoly, or lock-in effects). Many of the others, for confounding reasons, deviate markedly some or much of the time. Smith was largely addressing these failures under merchantilism and politically-influential monopolists and classes.
The bigger issue is that you have land use lock-in due to the tax advantage and zoning.
In simple terms, if you take 0.5 acre lot in Los Altos within close commute to Apple, Google, Facebook and Amazon. If taxes were market rate, then a lot more inventory would be available because these “assets” would be too expensive to just keep.
If zoning was not a factor, then the lot prices would be even higher due to being able to cram in more shared use spaces (condos) into it.
Of course, all these have extreme negative externalities (impacts) on those living around these lots and those living on them. That’s why we need some protections and middle ground between these as a society.
You're also ignoring a pretty big option. Rather than choosing between landlords who rent and landlords who speculate, you could have local ownership of the building you live in.
The business of real estate is not to increase housing supply but to increase housing value as an asset class. And, given an inherently inelastic supply and rising demand, the best way to do this is by artificially constraining supply: keepin unnits off-market, limiting construction, density limmits, setbacks and separations, height limits, restrictions on multuple tenancies, and some aspects of building codes.
This isn't new:
When recently the mechanized industries, particularly in metal, entered the housing field with the production of “prefabricated houses”, they were met by the resistance of property holders, especially of the banks, who hold mortgages on about 58 percent of all 1933 value of all urban real estate, and who fear that an influx of cheap modern dwellings would subtract substantially from the market value of existing structures. These banks and loan companies have been unwilling to finance prefabricated houses except in rare exceptions and then on a limited basis.
-- Bernhard J. Stern, "Resistances to the Adoption of Technological Innovations", 1937
https://archive.org/details/technologicaltre1937unitrich/pag...