Re:Elderly and Homeless: America’s Next Housing Crisis
by sologoub on Thursday October 08, 2020 @06:37PM
(#24724681)
Without going in to your level of economics nuance (close to unreadable for lay person), housing is absolutely elastic in that purchasing power plays a huge role. It is somewhat differentiated due to neighborhood amenities and other factors, but within those a house/condo are a commodity.
The bigger issue is that you have land use lock-in due to the tax advantage and zoning.
In simple terms, if you take 0.5 acre lot in Los Altos within close commute to Apple, Google, Facebook and Amazon. If taxes were market rate, then a lot more inventory would be available because these “assets” would be too expensive to just keep.
If zoning was not a factor, then the lot prices would be even higher due to being able to cram in more shared use spaces (condos) into it.
Of course, all these have extreme negative externalities (impacts) on those living around these lots and those living on them. That’s why we need some protections and middle ground between these as a society.
Of the various corrective measures, a land value tax (tax on the unimproved value of property) is likely the most widely known, understood, and accepted by economists. Other issues are more difficult to address (see e.g., Mancur Olsen's Logic of Collective Action), but also arise and create dysfunctions through economic logic giving rise to pathologies.
A reading of Adam Smith's sections on prices of various economic products and services suggests a set of differentiable behaviours by types:
1. Commodity goods.
2. Labour wages and services. Extended to include pleasantness, skill, training, constancy, success probability, and trust.
3. Natural resources (developed further by Ricardo, Grey, and Hotelling, though still fundamentally flawed).
4. Returns to stock.
5. Rents: monopoly and network services.
6. Assets and money (to Smith: gold and silver).
7. Interest.
8. Public goods.
9. Taxes.
Each has distinct behavious, much explained by later concepts of the marginalists and political theorists (class and power), though these are suggested by Smith.
There's some likely consolidation of these (rents, assets, and interest, say). Commodity goods follow laws of supply and demand as commonly understood, but only where goods are undifferentiated (no "luxury" branding, monopoly, or lock-in effects). Many of the others, for confounding reasons, deviate markedly some or much of the time. Smith was largely addressing these failures under merchantilism and politically-influential monopolists and classes.