The business of real estate is not to increase housing supply but to increase housing value as an asset class. And, given an inherently inelastic supply and rising demand, the best way to do this is by artificially constraining supply: keepin unnits off-market, limiting construction, density limmits, setbacks and separations, height limits, restrictions on multuple tenancies, and some aspects of building codes.
This isn't new:
When recently the mechanized industries, particularly in metal, entered the housing field with the production of “prefabricated houses”, they were met by the resistance of property holders, especially of the banks, who hold mortgages on about 58 percent of all 1933 value of all urban real estate, and who fear that an influx of cheap modern dwellings would subtract substantially from the market value of existing structures. These banks and loan companies have been unwilling to finance prefabricated houses except in rare exceptions and then on a limited basis.
-- Bernhard J. Stern, "Resistances to the Adoption of Technological Innovations", 1937
https://archive.org/details/technologicaltre1937unitrich/pag...
That’s a 2017 article. Now the fall is much greater because of COVID market shifts, but the rents really did slow or drop before in Downtown Los Angeles.
Real estate in California’s two large metro areas (SF Bay and Greater LA) is a mess, largely thanks to regulation and NIMBYism. That’s not a normal market. Add to it Prop 13 that prevents property tax adjusting tax base to market value of housing, even for corporations and rentals, and you have the recipe for really constraint supply. As the result, prices remain high.
Putting the burden on landlords will cause small-time landlords to exit and be either replaced by large corps that can afford the insurance-equivalent or the rentals will be sold to owner users and the people who have to rent will have even less supply to go around.
Of the various corrective measures, a land value tax (tax on the unimproved value of property) is likely the most widely known, understood, and accepted by economists. Other issues are more difficult to address (see e.g., Mancur Olsen's Logic of Collective Action), but also arise and create dysfunctions through economic logic giving rise to pathologies.
A reading of Adam Smith's sections on prices of various economic products and services suggests a set of differentiable behaviours by types:
1. Commodity goods.
2. Labour wages and services. Extended to include pleasantness, skill, training, constancy, success probability, and trust.
3. Natural resources (developed further by Ricardo, Grey, and Hotelling, though still fundamentally flawed).
4. Returns to stock.
5. Rents: monopoly and network services.
6. Assets and money (to Smith: gold and silver).
7. Interest.
8. Public goods.
9. Taxes.
Each has distinct behavious, much explained by later concepts of the marginalists and political theorists (class and power), though these are suggested by Smith.
There's some likely consolidation of these (rents, assets, and interest, say). Commodity goods follow laws of supply and demand as commonly understood, but only where goods are undifferentiated (no "luxury" branding, monopoly, or lock-in effects). Many of the others, for confounding reasons, deviate markedly some or much of the time. Smith was largely addressing these failures under merchantilism and politically-influential monopolists and classes.
The bigger issue is that you have land use lock-in due to the tax advantage and zoning.
In simple terms, if you take 0.5 acre lot in Los Altos within close commute to Apple, Google, Facebook and Amazon. If taxes were market rate, then a lot more inventory would be available because these “assets” would be too expensive to just keep.
If zoning was not a factor, then the lot prices would be even higher due to being able to cram in more shared use spaces (condos) into it.
Of course, all these have extreme negative externalities (impacts) on those living around these lots and those living on them. That’s why we need some protections and middle ground between these as a society.
You're also ignoring a pretty big option. Rather than choosing between landlords who rent and landlords who speculate, you could have local ownership of the building you live in.
More capital may be invested, but not necessarily in "providing" rental housing. Housing, being dependent on location/land, is not a commodity. In fact, you'll often see the opposite: Home owners (investors in their own right) and even developers trying to inflate housing prices by restricting supply by exploiting zoning laws: it pays to be a home owner in a neighborhood where the minimum lot size is 1 acre (Atherton), or, say, a developer interested in building only luxury apartments in desirable areas (Solana Beach, which is a city in California with 0 low-income housing, or really anywhere along a CA Coast).
The funny thing is, as home prices in major US cities become out of reach to the average American (as evidenced by the fact that many cities have higher renter rates than owner rates), a drop in property values could be a GOOD thing -- in that it could allow tenants to potentially own the dwelling they already live in which is currently out of reach.
If the law said landlords could not require those kinds of references when advertising a tenancy, that would be a legal framework hostile to landlords without the reference problem you described.
(Admittedly there would be unintended consequences. Maybe the reference problem would continue surreptitiously.)
Housing is also a basic human need. Both can be true, but when markets fail, we risk failing basic human needs and all the associated costs to society.
> Which means instead of an orderly market, rental units are transferred based on non-monetary consideration. I don't see how this world is better for anybody.
I think you should consider economics courses from different schools. Absolute market normativity cannot solve every problem on earth, nor always form orderly markets by themselves. Governments are needed to intervene on these market failures and undertake other duties that cannot be properly market-ified. By your perspective non-monetary transfers or government intervention on basic medicine, food, water or law enforcement also wouldn’t make the world better for anybody.
The answer to a socialist utopia is not a liberalist utopia, as neither can transcend the complexity of the problem at hand alone.
This doesn't mean that free unregulated markets are a solution to everything. But they're a great first step on a road of progressive [in a technical sense, not the commonly associated political sense of the word] refinement.
Perfect information symmetry is a precondition for the theoretical free market construct, but by no means a magical, inherent property to markets. In fact, there are many instances in which information flow has to be legislated in order to help the market operate; from nutrition labels on our food to real estate transactions in which information flow is necessitated, and for example making insider trading illegal in which information flow is prevented.
> Non-market systems hide incentives under opaque covers and increase the potential for catastrophic failure.
Market based systems can and have done this too. Most recent example is the 2008 crisis in which in the name of financial instrument innovation, toxic assets were blended under opaque covers and people bought them, leading to catastrophic failure.
Information flow and markets are mostly unrelated. Think of the stock market; only information it can tell us is the current and historical price points, everything else has to come from side channels, which will never add up to telling if a stock will go up or not for sure.
I don't agree. This is view not indicative of how things operate in reality.
As a market participant, one can always determine incentives by "following the money", as long as the actors are somewhat rational. Talented traders, middle-men, etc develop an instinct for these flows which can never be perfectly legibilized into economic models. This intuition then leads them to deduce information that is hidden. The corollary to this is one shouldn't participate in markets without this ability, which is why almost every retail investor should not be directly involved in stock markets and just invest in index funds instead. The second corollary is because these flows are impossible to realistically quantitatively model, no faithful model of the market is possible unless the model replicates the market structure itself. All thats left are impermanent imperfect models, some may be based on historical data, some on various heuristics specific to a given market, some even partially successful in predicting what will happen for some time, but all ultimately doomed to failure as other market participants game them.
Your examples, food labeling, real estate txns, insider trading are great arguments for progressive refinement of market dynamics, which is the position I'm arguing. They are not arguments for an alternative to markets and no known alternative to markets can solve these problems while maintaining the same level of functional efficiency that markets do.
> Market based systems can and have done this too.
Yet society recovered. Under non-market systems, an irreversible catastrophe is more likely than under market systems. Because market systems are unstable, they transmit critical information faster than non-market alternatives, allowing for preventive measures. Even if this information is imminent collapse. Market collapse and dysfunction prefigure collapse and are valuable information in-and-of themselves. This remains the case despite anthropogenic climate change, etc.
Markets are ultimately not about money, but information. What sort of system can transmit information more efficiently than a market can? No centralized system has been proven to be as successful. And, for foundational math reasons, I don't believe any sort of planning algorithm can beat a network of decentralized profit maximizing agents. So our two options are 1) to improve market function via progressive refinement or 2) find an alternative analog that preserves the information fluidity that markets provide. I have very little optimism on 2) but am open to being surprised.
We would all do fine if long term rentals were replaced with purchase, and those that can't afford to purchase put in free government housing until they can.
Rent dates back to kings that owned all the land and made commoners pay to live on it. I don't think it's right to profit off something so essential as the place you reside, it gives landlords near infinite leverage if tenants are too poor to move.
I agree with above, somebody has to eat the losses, and it should be the entities speculating on investment properties, not the (usually poor) people renting single units in them
Rental housing is a business. If the marginal return to capital of providing rental housing goes up relative to other investments, then more capital will be invested in providing rental house, until equilibrium. Likewise, if the marginal return to capital of providing rental housing goes down, capital will be moved out of rental housing.
If the risk of being a landlord is increased, then a small landlord has a bit of problem in that it will be hard to diversify their portfolio. They will need to enter into some kind of risk-transfer transaction. The simplest would be to purchase some kind of insurance that pays out in case of government-mandated rent moratorium. Insurance company actuaries would work out a reasonable premium, and that premium would be added to the rent required of tenants.
All-in-all, that would be a reasonably orderly solution -- with the net effect of raising rents to cover the insurance premium.
Of course, we can all imagine a world in which we have both rent control and government-mandated rent moratoriums. In which case, the return to capital in rental house goes down and the supply dries up. Which means instead of an orderly market, rental units are transferred based on non-monetary consideration. I don't see how this world is better for anybody.