News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by hourislate on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:06AM (#24679149)
In Toronto, Canada a simple renovation of a subway stations entrance (painting, tile, basic refresh) can take several years. All the while they will rope off large sections or shut down escalators for months while there is ZERO work being done.

There was a Subway station called Runnymede that took about 5-7 years and when completely you couldn't tell they did anything. I am sure it cost 10's of millions of dollars and could have been completely started and finished by a private contractor in a couple months.

The city has never been manage properly because there are no consequences to the ineptness of the Politicians and bureaucracy that run it. You could complain (a lawyer friend did) and they basically either ignore or make up some story how difficult it is to lay 200 sq/ft of tile and clean an escalator...These things take years of hard work and planning....

Surprised the city doesn't come crashing down under it's own weight of dysfunction but they seem to prop it up by the endless tax or fee increases.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by bleepblorp on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:22PM (#24681096)
Escalator and elevator refurbishment projects are extremely lengthy because most of the replacement parts needed to overhaul old escalators/elevators are no longer stock items and need to be custom made. In the worst case, parts may need to be reverse-engineered, re-designed to be compatible with current materials and manufacturing processes, prototyped, tested, and made through limited-run production.

If an escalator/elevator is shut down for a few months (or years) due to refurbishment, it's because worn, but vital, parts of it have been removed for use as reference materials so replacements can be made. It is also possible that vital parts could be too worn for the escalator/elevator to operate safely until new parts have been made and installed.

I'll also point out that published information on the Runnymede project indicates that the current round of construction started at the end of 2018, involved the addition of three underground elevator shafts, and is expected to be completed at the end of 2020[0]. Unless you are referring to earlier work, your '5-7 year' timeline to 'clean an escalator' is a vast exaggeration.

[0] http://ttc.ca/Service_Advisories/Construction/Runnymede_EA.j...

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by baud147258 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:28PM (#24683751)
When overhauling, how just replacing the escalator with a new model, which would have parts more easily available?
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by bleepblorp on Wednesday October 07, 2020 @04:33AM (#24706339)
This is frequently done when parts become too difficult/expensive to maintain, but replacement from scratch still takes many months.

Pretty much every part of the west is having problems with long elevator/escalator outages these days because so many escalators/elevators were installed in the infrastructure boom of the 1960s/1970s. They're now all reaching the end of their useful lives at the same time and they all need major overhaul and/or replacement.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by Waterluvian on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:53AM (#24679898)
I don’t know your qualifications, but I doubt you were involved in the project. When I hear people upset about infrastructure giving armchair estimates of how long it should take or how expensive it should be, I just hear the uninformed project manager being outraged at the software engineers’ estimates. “And when their work was done I toured the station/software and it looked exactly the same!”

I’m sure there’s bureaucratic inefficiency. But there’s always so much nonsense that gets appended to the criticism.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by hourislate on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:00PM (#24680475)
It doesn't take a genius to realize that there is something wrong about tearing up 10-20 tiles in front of an escalator and shutting down for 6 months only to appear one day and finish the job but still leaving the escalator off for another 1-2 months only to reappear to remove the barriers and turn on the escalator. Now do that all over again in and around the entrance to the station for another 5 years.

If you use the station everyday, you notice these things.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by Izkata on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:31PM (#24680695)
A comparison, to give people an idea of why this story sticks out:

In my 25-floor condo, the company that did our elevator renovation was able to replace 3 elevators over the course of 1 year. They were done in sequence, not parallel, so we had full use of 2 elevators the entire duration.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by sokoloff on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:20PM (#24680138)
What you say has some merit, of course. Does 5-7 years for a station renovation pass any kind of rough sniff test, though?
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by throw0101a on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:49PM (#24680386)
I live in Toronto: Runnymede station specifically is in a very built up area, and there's not a lot of elbow room to work. Do a Street View of 265 Runnymede:

* https://www.google.com/maps/place/265+Runnymede+Rd,+Toronto,...

* Opposite end: https://www.google.com/maps/place/260+Kennedy+Ave,+Toronto,+...

The subway in that area was built in the 1960s using (AFAIK) a cut-and-cover method, so it's not every deep below the surface:

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_2_Bloor–Danforth#Subway_c...

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel#Cut-and-cover

The original criticizing GP also assumes that it was a "simple renovation": is this a valid assumption? For example, how do you get a bunch of new elevators installed:

* https://ttc.ca/Service_Advisories/Construction/Runnymede_EA....

Drilling multiple elevator shafts seems more than a "simple renovation".

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by inglor_cz on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:38PM (#24681689)
Reconstructions of stations of the Prague metro tend to take between 6 and 12 months, rarely longer.

5-7 years remind me of the Sofia metro (Bulgaria) during the Soviet Bloc era. It was officially under construction for like 20 years but in practice, the budget just wasn't there so the works went forward veeeeeery slowly, in some years literally nothing was done.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by Waterluvian on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:32PM (#24680239)
My intuition tells me 5-7 years doesn’t pass the sniff test. But if I’m wrong, maybe the government can endeavour to be more transparent. Doesn’t take a lot to show us a general timeline breaking down the major tasks.

My criticism is purely: we don’t know better so let’s avoid throwing numbers out there.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by throw0101a on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:05PM (#24680508)
> There was a Subway station called Runnymede that took about 5-7 years and when completely you couldn't tell they did anything.

Drilling shafts and installing new elevator is a bit more than a "simple renovation" IMHO.

https://ttc.ca/Service_Advisories/Construction/Runnymede_EA....

And that assumes that they're not doing structural fixes for a station that was built >50 years ago (Line 2, B-D, opened in 1966).

* https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Line_2_Bloor–Danforth

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by CydeWeys on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:17AM (#24679641)
Private contractors aren't a solution to the problem; that's orthogonal. Lots of work goes to private contractors here, with the same results.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:03PM (#24679973)
The interesting comparison being to private contractors working for private entities. I somehow doubt that Walmart is spending years and tens of millions of dollars to re-tile one of their storefronts. Which proves that it can be done, when there isn't an incentive for corruption and waste.

The question is how to remove the corruption and waste.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:40PM (#24680295)
You're right, Walmart isn't doing that. Part of the reason is that Walmart has essentially zero interest in building civic infrastructure. They have to just pass health & safety regulations and then they plan to do absolutely nothing more.

Public buildings and infrastructure, on the other hand, have other considerations in play. Durability, civic pride, long term safety ...

I travel around the US a lot and always marvel at the stuff that was built by/during the WPA. It is incredible - absurdly overbuilt by any current standards, but that very fact is at the heart of why they are still standing, still enjoyed, still viable.

Nobody will be saying that about any Walmart building in 90 years.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:07PM (#24680521)
The WPA overbuilt everything because its underlying purpose was to reduce unemployment, even if it meant inefficient allocation of labor, because the alternative (massive unemployment) was considered even worse.

That entire system has since been discredited, because there is no actual need to allocate the labor inefficiently on purpose to reduce unemployment instead of still being as efficient as possible and just e.g. increasing the number or projects. Or even better, stimulating demand for labor by giving money directly to the general population.

But the problem in this case isn't high unemployment, it's high inefficiency. A program designed to reduce unemployment by increasing inefficiency is obviously not a solution for that.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:11PM (#24680564)
I wasn't discussing the employment side of WPA in any way.

I was talking about what they built and comparing it to contemporary big box store architecture.

You're making an implicit claim that the labor was used inefficiently, which may be true. But unless that takes longevity and less easily measured attributes into account, I'm not sure you can prove that.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:52PM (#24680853)
It's straightforward to compare the net present value of overbuilt boondoggles to modern commercial architecture which trades dramatically lower initial construction costs for modestly higher ongoing maintenance. The reason private entities overwhelmingly choose the latter is not that they prefer to waste their own money.

Moreover, longevity is often a cost. How many overbuilt old post offices and municipal buildings are we now effectively stuck with in places where they're no longer an appropriate size for the locality? The city's needs are going to be different in twenty or thirty years than they are now, so there is no point in designing ordinary structures to last longer than that when it so often makes more sense to build a new one after that period of time consistent with the needs of today rather than a generation ago.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:03PM (#24681444)
There's an assumption there that its not possible to design and build things that can be adapative and function across a much longer timespan than a modern big box store's typical lifetime.

There's also an assumption that the cost of have an imperfectly adapated building is higher than the cost of multiple building efforts over time. Since both costs are rather variable, it's hard to assess if that is true.

Claiming that private entities are immune (or at least, less susceptible) to the same problems of temporal discounting that clearly affects both individuals and many north American governments seems without foundation to me. There are many incentives in play for private entities to favor short term gain over long term gain, and significant evidence that this affects their behavior just as much as it affects individuals and governments.

I don't agree that it's straightforward to compare "net present value". Go and visit the WPA constructions at many national parks. Nobody would agree to them being built today, so even if you could establish the cost to rebuild them, the fact that there's no way we would ever end up replacing them makes it extremely hard to establish their value to us as a society.

But I don't want to defend those old energy inefficient, hard-to-maintain structures to much. I'm thinking more about what their construction actually represented in terms of a society's willingess to invest (inefficiently!) in the future, and in a more-than-barebones aesthetic.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by AnthonyMouse on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:53PM (#24682900)
> There's an assumption there that its not possible to design and build things that can be adapative and function across a much longer timespan than a modern big box store's typical lifetime.

But that assumption is, by and large, true. If you look at hundred year old buildings, by modern standards they're extremely flawed. The insulation is typically poor or non-existent. They often had higher ceilings due to the limitations of contemporary lighting and HVAC systems, which are now a liability with respect to heating and cooling.

There is little reason to suspect that progress in building design has been discontinued, so a building from today would be expected to be similarly deficient by the standards of a hundred years from now, which means there is little reason to design it to last that long.

But the biggest flaw is often that the building is the wrong size. Decades ago you needed five stories and now you need ten. Or you needed five stories and now you need one. The obvious solution to that is to move to a bigger or smaller building as the need arises.

> There's also an assumption that the cost of have an imperfectly adapated building is higher than the cost of multiple building efforts over time.

Not at all, because the replacement building doesn't have to be on the same lot. You don't have to knock it down to build a new one consistent with your current needs. You can build a new one and then sell the existing one to someone who may be able to make productive use of it as it is. But then it's not the state reaping the benefits of any unusual longevity.

And that assumption may still be true in many cases regardless. If you have a five story building which over time comes to be surrounded by skyscrapers, it could easily be cost effective to remove it and make the lot available for another skyscraper, or for the new owner to do so and in so doing yield two dividends to the local government -- one from the sale of a lot with a high property value, and then another from the increased property tax revenue from the taller building.

> Claiming that private entities are immune (or at least, less susceptible) to the same problems of temporal discounting that clearly affects both individuals and many north American governments seems without foundation to me.

Temporal discounting isn't a problem, it's what you're supposed to do. An expense today is much more costly than the same dollar value expense in 50 years, because if you don't spend the money today, you get 50 years worth of interest on it (or don't have to pay 50 years in interest on having borrowed it).

> I'm thinking more about what their construction actually represented in terms of a society's willingess to invest (inefficiently!) in the future, and in a more-than-barebones aesthetic.

In which case you're essentially asking for the state to fund architecture as art with tax money. But if that's what the taxpayers want, why don't the buy it directly?

More saliently, spending tens of millions of dollars to re-tile a subway station isn't doing that anyway.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by PaulDavisThe1st on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:07PM (#24683295)
> If you look at hundred year old buildings, by modern standards they're extremely flawed. The insulation is typically poor or non-existent

You're assuming a certain type of climate. Hundred year old buildings with huge levels of thermal mass in year-round warm climates are exactly what you want, not insulation. The high ceilings are also extremely practical in such environments.

>There is little reason to suspect that progress in building design has been discontinued

Building design: no question that we've got new stuff that in the right conditions is better than what we had 100 years ago. We have some new stuff (e.g. insulated glazing) that is just better always. But there are many aspects of actual building construction that could be argued to have gone backwards in the last 100 years, mostly because of the rise of developer-led construction and the economics that this implies.

> the replacement building doesn't have to be on the same lot.

Fair point.

> An expense today is much more costly than the same dollar value expense in 50 years, because if you don't spend the money today, you get 50 years worth of interest on it

That assumes that you don't gain anything of value from the expense today. If what you are saying was so simplistically true, there would no point in investing in anything at all. If I put money into blue chip stocks with the expectation of earning profits, I do so with the idea in mind that these profits will exceed any interest I might have earned by saving it. If we collectively put money into a beautiful city hall or park lodge, we do with the idea in mind that what we will gain over the life of the building is worth more to us that the interest we might have earned by saving the cost instead.

> In which case you're essentially asking for the state to fund architecture as art with tax money

If you can't differentiate or acknowledge the concept or utility of public investment in public places, then I'm certainly not going to persuade you that this is not what I'm asking for.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by throwaway0a5e on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:21PM (#24683712)
>Public buildings and infrastructure, on the other hand, have other considerations in play. Durability, civic pride, long term safety ...

Who's paying? I can't express within the confines of the rules here how livid this sort of "we should spend taxpayer money on looking good to fluff our own egos" thinking is. The public is best served a vinyl tiled "Walmart subway" where the lightbulbs work and the trains run. Not a billion dollar marble monstrosity. Any bureaucrat opting to condone the latter is shirking their duty to use the resources at their disposal to deliver maximum results to the taxpayers.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by PaulDavisThe1st on Monday October 05, 2020 @10:27AM (#24688043)
It has nothing to do with "fluff our own egos".

I'm not advocating for "a billion dollar marble monstrosity". I'm advocating for the difference between a well built city hall and a Walmart store.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by mdifrgechd on Sunday October 04, 2020 @11:54AM (#24679910)
Procurement is one of the root causes, specifically running the procurement out of a government bureaucracy where the actual tactical outcomes (refurbishing the train station in the example above) are way down the list from other priorities such as the appearance of fairness in procurement, and other government aims like job creation etc.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by pnw_hazor on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:52PM (#24680855)
In the US, it common for local or federal RFP's (requests for proposals) to include a hard requirement that qualified vendors have done the same kind of project before. This usually excludes any new players from the game.

How many companies build large bridges, airports, subways, railroads, tunnels, etc? Not many.

It is part of the racket that discourages innovation.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by mdifrgechd on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:37PM (#24681217)
Yeah, that is one facet of the overall institutional approach to procurement that treats everything like a commodity that can be perfectly substituted and comes down just to cost (and maybe a few other checkbox categories). A flexible approach that procures for outcomes but doesn't prescribe how to get there is much better at admitting creative delivery solutions, including those from new entrants.

Of course past experience is still a logical thing to consider when judging the overall risks of a project. But if you look for creative solutions you can get away from "look, this entrenched legacy business is the only one meeting out experience requirements".

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by pnw_hazor on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:46PM (#24680811)
Prevailing wage laws that are used in many areas. (added: private contractors must pay them if working in the government constructions projects)

https://secure.lni.wa.gov/wagelookup/ApprenticeWageLookup.as...

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by snowwrestler on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:54PM (#24680441)
> In Toronto, Canada a simple renovation of a subway stations entrance (painting, tile, basic refresh) can take several years. All the while they will rope off large sections or shut down escalators for months while there is ZERO work being done.

This most likely happens because of insufficient government funding for maintenance.

Government budgets reset every year; governments can't take unspent program money at the end on one fiscal year and bank it for next year. There is no way to "save up" for big expenses aside from directly allocating sufficient funds in the funding legislation.

That sort of lump allocation is a lot easier to get for new work. The main reason is, new work has better optics--you go from nothing to something. Maintenance, unless it changes the cosmetics, looks about the same at the end as it did in the beginning. Boring! "What did we get for all that money??" citizens ask.

And maintenance is harder to budget for in a lump sum because you don't know how bad things are until you actually start the work. This is generally true of maintenance--anyone who has renovated an old home knows this. Until you open the wall, you don't know how much work needs to be done.

So what you do in government is start the maintenance projects you have at highest priority, find out how bad things are, and then do as much as you can with the budget you have. It it's not enough to complete an atomic unit of work, you just sit on partially-done work until more money becomes available.

And ironically, the irritation caused by unfinished work can help get you the money to finish the work.

If maintenance was properly budgeted, then the subway system could afford to do a full refresh all in one continuous go. Usually it's not, so usually they can't.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by jungletime on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:19PM (#24680134)
Canada is seriously declining. Have you seen grocery store prices lately?

Most of the housing in smaller cities is getting very old, built to very poor standards. Requiring constant maintenance. The owners often still stuck in 25 year mortgages, fixing houses that will fall apart in less time than that.

Many of Schools haven't been updated in decades, despite having asbestos insulation.

I visited a former Eastern Block country this past summer. New roads, infrastructure and buildings everywhere. Built to a much higher standard too. Much better food in Restaurants too. Thinking of moving back to Europe.

Considering the 300 billion deficit this year alone, declining credit ratting, higher taxes. The money for infrastructure will be hard to come by in the next decade.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by namdnay on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:48PM (#24682157)
> I visited a former Eastern Block country this past summer. New roads, infrastructure and buildings everywhere. Built to a much higher standard too.

To be slightly simplistic, that’s probably more of a reflection on the generosity of Western European taxpayers than an inherent standard of the country you visited

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by bleepblorp on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:03PM (#24681443)
Point of order: grocery price rises are due to the pandemic, in part due to the cost of protecting agricultural temporary workers from COVID-19. World harvests of many crops have also not been good this year[0], which has also increased prices.

[0] http://www.fao.org/3/ca9803en/ca9803en.pdf

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by legulere on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:18PM (#24680124)
Failures and inefficiency is just as common in private companies. It's just not as visible usually.
Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by lordnacho on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:27PM (#24680195)
Assuming we're not talking about private companies doing government projects, a private company will eventually run out of money if their projects fail. That's ostensibly why it's good to run certain things privately: a bunch of entities get a go at making the most popular widget and society gets the benefit of having various widgets available. The losers have their assets/staff recycled into the economy.

Not saying it always works.

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by legulere on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:50PM (#24680398)
Companies can have more money and power than countries. There's not much keeping them from running into the same inefficiencies. Money is often secured through oligopolies that naturally occur, allowing enough money to be spent on inefficiency.

I wonder if you have never seen waste at work?

Re:Why American cities can’t keep up with infrastructure mai... by lordnacho on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:39PM (#24682465)
Well that's what I mean by ostensibly and "not saying it always works".

There's a long list of ways it can go wrong.