News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by wombatmobile on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:15AM (#24676490)
> In recent history, the Panama Papers have comprised one of the largest and most influential leaks detailing information on offshore entities, company officers and financial (and legal) intermediaries, and has led to a global exposé of corruption and tax evasion. A systematic analysis of this information can provide valuable insights into the structure and properties of these entities and the relations between them.

OK, I get that. What are the insights?

In the Summary it says:

> We iterate that, while we certainly did not expect small-world phenomena to emerge in all networks, the fact that it did not emerge in even a single network, and also that the distribution of connected components (as a function of size measured in terms of number of nodes) seems to follow a clear and consistent trend throughout, suggest a similar fundamental difference compared to small-world networks.

Um, what does that tell us about corruption and tax evasion? Can somebody please explain in layman's terms?

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by idclip on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:54AM (#24676609)
It means corruption is a basic human behavior. Its a self generating phenomena, and is „natural“.

So there is no „illuminati“ to go after to solve this. Studies try and see how problems can be solved - if there was a single organizing entity like a mafia boss, it would be simpler to tackle the issue but there isn't, so its Marder than first expected.

As to tax evasion, id posit the question „so why are these people evading? Is it the law itself? Can they be otherwise somehow incentivized to invest in their Communities rather than evade? And how big is the contribution here? Is it worth pursuing?“

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by milchek on Sunday October 04, 2020 @03:23AM (#24677096)
> Can they be otherwise somehow incentivized to invest in their Communities rather than evade? And how big is the contribution here? Is it worth pursuing

I like this question. It makes me wonder what society would look like if we had micro community councils that operated this way, where residents “donated” parts of their wealth and those donations gave them some sort of stake, naming right, or voting power in community projects.

I wonder if we’d get the same sort of donations we get by wealthy families to get hospital wards named after them etc.

I suppose it requires a shift in what we value as humans, perhaps we could work toward a society where the amount you’ve given away gives you the most social credit or prestige, rather than how much you’ve amassed. Is it too naive and childish to think this sort of society is possible and could be an improvement over the current one?

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by Erwin on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:56AM (#24677374)
That society already exists in e.g. Nordic countries. If we look at Sweden, Finland etc, total tax revenues as percentage of GDP are 48-54%. In USA, they are 24.3%.

So here's a smaller community where the majority is fine with high taxation in exchange for freely available health care, higher education etc.

Family funds exist here (e.g. Novo Nordisk is 25% owned by a humanitarian fund, Mærsk) but are less important than US.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by DyslexicAtheist on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:11AM (#24678781)
> That society already exists in e.g. Nordic countries.

Why IKEA’s profits are mostly tax free https://www.afr.com/policy/tax-and-super/why-ikea-s-profits-...

Legal loopholes make Sweden a tax haven https://www.dn.se/nyheter/sverige/legal-loopholes-make-swede...

Siem Offshore Fined NOK 5 Mln in Tax Evasion Case https://www.offshore-energy.biz/siem-offshore-fined-nok-5-ml...

the issue is less how much tax _individuals_ pay. Tax avoidance on behalf of individuals is tiny and absolute "small-fry". The biggest cheaters that can afford it on a massive scale are companies.

one of the biggest problems is that if you want to compete in a global market space you're kind of forced to use legal (but dirty) tricks (tax optimization such as transfer pricing etc). The strategy is always to squeeze the consumer end (e.g. the retail) and supply side (production/manufacture etc) and this is where you're losses are while you scoop the profits from the middle (a tax haven). It's cool to talk about Cayman and Switzerland in silly Hollywood movies but some of the biggest tax havens are actually the US (Nevada, New Mexico, etc), Luxembourg, Netherlands, UK ... as long as we don't clean up this rigged global financial system we shouldn't even consider discussing about whether the average Joe has been taxed enough.

There is a great book that links the emergence of this offshore industry with the dissolving of the empires (e.g. Gabon is laundering the money for the French elite in the same way as BVI, Caymans have been used by Brits) ...: "Treasure Islands: Tax Havens and the Men who Stole the World (2011) " https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Treasure_Islands:_Tax_Havens_a...

Even we clean up all our structures in the West there will be plenty of opportunity to move capital to Bahrain, Dubai or uhm ... Japan https://fsi.taxjustice.net/en/

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by ivanhoe on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:47AM (#24677633)
> So here's a smaller community where the majority is fine with high taxation

Yes, but it's not the majority that runs offshore companies in Panama, but those rich enough that it makes sense for them to go through the trouble of setting offshore companies up.

And IMHO the problem is in simple psychology of how humans compare between themselves. We don't compare in absolute means, but relative to people around us. If you're a middle class and you pay the same taxes as everyone else around you, you might grumble a bit, but in the end you'll except it as a part of life, because, well, everybody does it. If you make a lot more money than others and thus have to pay a lot more taxes, you'll perceive it as an injustice, being punished by mediocrity for your success. And you'll have a much less of morale dilemma should you try avoid paying it.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by stevenjohns on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:39AM (#24678566)
You're missing out on the significant unemployment in countries like Sweden. There is significantly better free healthcare in Australia - which has an average tax rate of 23.6%.

The correlation of high taxes = better quality of life doesn't hold much strength when you consider that there are plenty of countries doing well without it, and plenty of countries with high taxes that have a poor quality of life.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by neffy on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:23PM (#24680166)
There is extremely significant unemployment in the US as well. It's just not counted. The number of people in US prisons alone adds about 2% to the total unemployment rate. And abstracting a little from the endless and pointless arguments about whether work should be funded by taxation or by sales - and the correct answer there is it depends - imprisonment not alone removes productive people from society, but also remove other productive people to guard them. But of course, if you have private prisons, then the objective will always be to increase sales. For the same reason, paying surgeons by the operation is also a terrible idea.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by hestefisk on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:50AM (#24678640)
I’m Australian and my personal income tax rate is not 24%, but 40%. What tax rate are you referring to —- corporate, gross personal, effective personal?

In terms of model healthcare, Australia is not the system you want. Our health system grossly underfunded and ineffective with lots of waste from years of private sector health insurance.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by stevenjohns on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:42PM (#24682482)
I specifically said average, because it’s important to note that the Swedish personal income tax rate starts at 32% with a tax free threshold of about AUD$3k.

Re: healthcare, you won’t realise how good you have it until you try to go to a Swedish hospital with a torn ACL only for a nurse to diagnose you with a cramp, direct you to take paracetamol and refuse to let you see a doctor. Or when you try to have a blood test done and realise it’s not a 24 hour turn around, but a 24 day turn around if you’re lucky with 1-2 years minimum to see a specialist.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by adamsea on Monday October 05, 2020 @01:26PM (#24689847)
Yeah but we need more than a few instances to draw general conclusions. Is there like, a study?
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by T-A on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:34AM (#24677568)
That's just a higher level of taxation (i.e. mandatory), not the donations (i.e. voluntary) in exchange for naming rights or direct influence which parent is talking about.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by hdjdbtbgwjsn on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:37AM (#24677586)
In practice people that object to the taxes just move away.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by germinalphrase on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:26AM (#24678486)
They have the resources to do so, but How many low tax, high status countries are there to live in? How many people are free from all community, familial relationships that moving abroad had no social costs?
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by hdjdbtbgwjsn on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:58AM (#24678700)
For Scandinavians doing e.g. banking the UK has previously been a good option.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by T-A on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:45AM (#24677620)
Some do, but changing countries is not that easy.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by stareatgoats on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:55AM (#24677954)
> So here's a smaller community where the majority is fine with high taxation

The higher taxation not come about because "people were fine with it". It was the consequence of a political and social momentum caused by the cold-war era where workers were able to extract concessions from the haves under the threat of a socialist revolution if they did not agree, in turn the result of historical proximity to the revolutionary movements in Europe in the 19th century as well as the geographical proximity to a powerful socialist state for the most part of the 20th century. This momentum is now slowly being eroded by the whole political spectrum on the right, paradoxically including what is left of the Scandinavian social democracies.

The welfare state will likely be a historical parenthesis between the laissez faire economy of the mid 18 hundreds and the new economy where the billionaires once again dictate the whole playing field. Unless a new situation arises where the haves once again willingly will agree to contribute towards funding a welfare state for some reason. I don't see it happening anytime soon however.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by mikorym on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:26AM (#24678870)
I think one answer is tax cuts for charity.

If I can give my tax money to someone of my choosing, I think it may incentivise people to feel better about where the money is going.

To be clear, not making your tax payments less, but rather choosing where it goes. Of course, if you have a network of nonprofits, this become a bit grey. In the USA I have gotten the impression that people do try to game the idea of nonprofits.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by Jenk on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:59AM (#24679102)
Taxes became a thing precisely because this model failed. The utopia of "common sense and decency" kicking in and ensuring public services are well funded is a false hope and does not work. Simply put, there is always a significant element in the populace that won't pay if they can get away with it, and making taxes optional just gives them an easy way to avoid contributing at all.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by nobody9999 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:42AM (#24678981)
>I think one answer is tax cuts for charity.

>To be clear, not making your tax payments less, but rather choosing where it goes.

Giving to charities reduces your tax burden, at least in the US.

In fact, you can generally deduct up to half your income[0] based on charitable contributions.

Does that meet your desire to better direct your tax dollars?

[0] https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-organiz...

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by mikorym on Tuesday October 06, 2020 @07:27AM (#24696610)
This I think is pretty much exactly how I think it should be. Half sounds decent.

But... I don't live in the US. We pay tax and received no services in return.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by frabbit on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:10PM (#24680993)
those donations gave them some sort of stake, naming right, or voting power in community projects.

You cannot forsee the possibility that the ability to purchase voting rights might result in another "natural" problem?

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by chii on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:18AM (#24677272)
> or voting power in community projects.

but then they get called lobbyists when this happens.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by trhway on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:32AM (#24677558)
the issue with lobbying is that too many and too large benefits is effectively sold for very cheap by the politicians selling stuff which aren't really theirs to start with. For example,a huge development should be permitted not in exchange for small political contribution. Instead the community should get something sizeable in return - new park, road, school, significant number of low income rentals, etc.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by adamsea on Monday October 05, 2020 @01:25PM (#24689828)
> what society would look like if we had micro community councils that operated this way, where residents “donated” parts of their wealth and those donations gave them some sort of stake, naming right, or voting power in community projects.

... I think the challenge is if concrete power such as votes, etc, is given based on financial contribution, then, it's not a democratic process.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by eternalban on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:47AM (#24678621)
Off shore safe havens exists because some sovereign authority has designated their domain as a "tax haven" and the usually very strict sovereigns of "big powers" are not sending their military to the said "off shore safe havens" to shut them down.

Opaque segments of the global financial networks enable Black Ops. No need to drag in Weishaupt and his worshipful brethren here, correct? So let's just discuss the "secret services" of the "big powers". Are they using the "tax havens"? I think the answer must be "Surely you jest, old boy!"

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by adamsea on Monday October 05, 2020 @01:28PM (#24689868)
I don't know who Weishaupt is but that's a good point; it's probably in the interest of most major powers to have opaque segments of the global economy.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by guerrilla on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:01AM (#24676637)
> It means corruption is a basic human behavior.

That is most certainly not what the study means. If you were going to extrapolate, you might be able to get away with corruption is basic rich people behavior, but even that is going way further than what the study is actually saying.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by nullsense on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:25AM (#24677286)
>That is most certainly not what the study means. If you were going to extrapolate, you might be able to get away with corruption is basic rich people behavior, but even that is going way further than what the study is actually saying.

Corruption is incredibly widespread globally across all demographics. It tends to show up the least in WEIRD places, and be most obvious in poorer countries, but it's everywhere and every level of society.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by karlp on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:45AM (#24677336)
> It tends to show up the least in WEIRD places

What do you mean by that?

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by T-A on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:31AM (#24677549)
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by barumi on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:08AM (#24677427)
I'm not the OP, but to me the world "corruption" is a blanket term used to refer to the apparent or actual distortion of a system for personal gain.

Thus corruption can be found on any system, no matter the scale, and regardless of the shape and form of the gain that may be attained.

This definition implies that hypothetical cases such as a college professor using his right to park free of charge on campus to store his car collection, or a secretary using the company's printer to print out fliers, might surprise people who believe that corruption is the fruit of sinister morally and ethically empty sociopaths who are super wealthy and very powerful.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by frabbit on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:12PM (#24681009)
More like "illuminati" emerge "naturally" from the "Free Market".
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by fit2rule on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:50AM (#24677645)
They're evading because taxation is based on income.

If it were based on expenditure, there'd be no avoiding.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by froh on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:52AM (#24677652)
I don't understand. Mind to elaborate? Eli5?
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by nobody9999 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @06:23AM (#24677774)
>I don't understand. Mind to elaborate? Eli5?

Not OP, but I assume he/she means something like a consumption tax[0].

However, given that poorer people tend to spend more of their income than wealthier ones, unless such a tax is appropriately calibrated, it can be quite regressive.

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Consumption_tax

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by tupputuppu on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:20AM (#24679231)
A consumption tax can also be made progressive.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by fit2rule on Sunday October 04, 2020 @08:17AM (#24678437)
In a nutshell: Poor people stay poor because they can't save. That is why income tax is repressive - it guarantees economic stagnation, since nobody wants to work for the man.

Spending tax means that, no matter who you are, you will pay your taxes if you want to purchase something, whether its a commodity or product or service.

The rich will still be able to be rich - in fact, there will be more rich people - but they won't be encouraged to spend any of it without sharing it in the form of taxes.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by PedroBatista on Sunday October 04, 2020 @09:10AM (#24678772)
That’s cute but the economy is based on spending. Governments want people with some money but not enough where they’ll start to think they can stay at home playing the stock market. If the majority did that, society would collapse.

Also a version of that already exists in most countries, in Europe you pay around 18-25% of VAT in every purchase you make but income taxes tend to apply only if you make X amount of money which effectively means poor people don’t pay income tax.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by fit2rule on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:15AM (#24679195)
>Governments want people with some money but not enough where they’ll start to think they can stay at home playing the stock market. If the majority did that, society would collapse.

People still need to eat and live their lives. They'll have more revenue for doing that if they don't automatically have to give half of it to government.

Taxing spending removes a repressive socio-economic influence on people among different classes of economic status.

Poor people stay poor because that way they don't have to give away half their income. This has a much bigger socio-economic impact than most middle-class taxpayers are willing to admit.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by xavriley on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:25AM (#24676912)
In network science, it’s fairly common to take a graph of something and be able to apply techniques like neighbourhood analysis or clustering which then reveal something about the data. This comes up in all kinds of real world examples from social networks to music preferences etc. What the authors are saying (I think) is that they tried the same tricks on the Panama data and got nothing useful out of it. The standard graph techniques don’t explain anything useful about what’s going on. I would guess (from previous experience working on similar things at opencorporates.com a few years ago) that this is because these networks aren’t constructed according to the real world - instead they’re a response to specific tax rules. For example if you use a specific tax avoidance scheme like the Irish dog leg then the company structure will be defined by the laws of the countries involved. Another reason would be that intermediaries like company formation agents are likely to show connections where they don’t exist in reality. If I use the same company formation agent as say, Donald Trump, it doesn’t follow that we’re related financially. Finally the Panama papers were just about hiding assets in many cases, so you’ll have these chains of ownership going through as many countries as they could be bothered to work with. This is just to give law enforcement etc. a hard time. Again I wouldn’t expect graph analysis to make sense of that on its own. If anyone is interested, banks in the US are required to document their corporate structures so there’s good data available on their structures. It suffers from the same issues though - it’s hard to tell from looking at a graph of companies where the bad stuff is happening.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by nobody9999 on Sunday October 04, 2020 @04:36AM (#24677321)
>What the authors are saying (I think) is that they tried the same tricks on the Panama data and got nothing useful out of it. The standard graph techniques don’t explain anything useful about what’s going on.

The impression I got was not that they found nothing useful, but that they didn't find broadly interconnected networks within the data.

If that's the case, it's likely that the transactions in the data aren't tightly linked.

Which is useful, in that it tells us that those involved in such activities are not a cabal of evil elites, rather they're disparate groups with little in common except their desire to avoid taxes/hide assets.

That conclusion certainly implies that addressing these activities will be more difficult as they are decentralized and widespread, but it's certainly not useless IMHO.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by newen on Sunday October 04, 2020 @01:43PM (#24680785)
It just means that they didn’t find useful network structures with the specific network analysis methods they used and the specific networks that they constructed using the data.

It leaves room for tons of other network analysis and data analysis.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by ColanR on Sunday October 04, 2020 @10:11AM (#24679178)
> that they didn't find broadly interconnected networks within the data.

That seems to agree with what the parent said. It sounds to me like if a broadly interconnected network was found, that would be a failure on the part of the people trying to facilitate the tax avoidance schemes - the closer to homogenous noise the graph looks, the harder it is to trace. Based on that, I'd say that there's no utility in trying to prove the negative, i.e., that larger networks do not exist.

If the people hiding their assets actually did their job well, they would expect and hope that you (as an outside analyst) would come to exactly the conclusion that you have come to.

Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by davisr on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:30AM (#24676540)
It means the corruption is spread far and wide, without a central group of 'authority'.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by hashtagmarkup on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:41AM (#24676572)
It means the author has to worry about car bombs from more than a single entity.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by idclip on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:50AM (#24676595)
Hah.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by hashtagmarkup on Monday October 05, 2020 @01:29AM (#24684791)
Murder. Lol.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by plutonorm on Sunday October 04, 2020 @05:54AM (#24677661)
There are no lizard people. No New world order and no Illuminati. Disappointing because that makes it all much harder to solve and makes it that much harder to view humanity in a favourable light.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by WealthVsSurvive on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:37PM (#24680272)
Humans are easy to view in a favorable light. Humanity, less so. Humans take individual actions that help themselves. Humanity forms networks of perverse incentives that harm others. If we build a network of perverse incentives, and catastrophe befalls us, an interesting thing happens: no one wants to lose in the time of loss. This is when you get revolutions, invasions, fascism threatening where the imaginary border lines are drawn. It's all merely loss aversion. Change is necessitated by material reality, in which the average person, fearing for their loss of wealth or for their loss of potential future life, are driven to extreme or violent actions. There needs to be one world currency, and it needs to be subject to entropy without human intervention (and something similar with material buildup and 'property'); we will kill ourselves otherwise as that which nourished us in the past is today's poison. Nothing is forever, why is wealth? Loss over time due to entropy as law needs to be more accounted for in our world economy as a whole. There is a level of individual wealth and capital advantage one may gain that literally destabilizes international peace (I'm looking at you global oil): why do we allow it? It's like nations have become lame date-show suitors to international oligarchs, offering missiles as flowers, and it's pathetic, and it's weak.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by canjobear on Sunday October 04, 2020 @02:41AM (#24676955)
It means they ran a bunch of off the shelf graph theory algorithms and the results were confusing.
Re:Structural studies of the global networks exposed in the ... by civilized on Sunday October 04, 2020 @12:43AM (#24676578)
It means the authors were trained to plot degree distributions of any network they come across, and hey, here's another network, let's plot some degree distributions