News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:59AM (#24637081)
Sorry, but the only rational consumer response to a device that actively works against you is not to purchase it, not hack it. Once millions of people pay to be imprisoned on their own devices, the long game is lost no matter how good the hackers are, the firm has the upper hand and the resources to prevail in the long run.

And I am perfectly happy to assert this as a political preference, and vote in office people that vow to protect consumers from this kind of racketeering. I understand this might not be your cup of tea, and that some people prefer unfettered capitalism, its your political right. However I fell that allowing this in our society limits my freedom and choices, because the things you buy affect me too.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by cwhiz on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:56AM (#24637786)
Some of the people here can’t understand that some people have different opinions.

I don’t care that I can’t easily change the SSD. If that were important to me, I would buy a different laptop.

I don’t consider my MacBook Pro to be working against me, at all.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by kmeisthax on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:32AM (#24639811)
You don't care that you can't change out the SSD, but you will care when you take your dead laptop to the Genius Bar and they tell you it's going to be cheaper to buy a new one and that your data is already gone.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by Spivak on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:50AM (#24640031)
I don’t see how this changes the calculus. Presumably the parent knew this when they bought the laptop. People buy cars that are stupidly expensive to repair all the time. Just because the cost of ownership of a Honda Civic is lower than a Mercedes doesn’t mean everyone’s gonna go with the Honda.

If it works like iOS and just flashes a warning then I don’t see the issue. The self-check thing is invaluable when buying used devices.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by wltprgm on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:35PM (#24641299)
I could be wrong, but most mac users excluding developers don't know anything when they bought the laptop.

> that your data is already gone.

By the way, the parent comment was talking about this

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dlivingston on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:19PM (#24641127)
All I care about is having a high-quality *nix machine. Right now, a MacBook Pro with macOS fits that bill well: the calculus may very well change, on both the hardware and OS side, when x86 is replaced with ARM64, though.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by saagarjha on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @04:19PM (#24643332)
macOS on Apple silicon is just as UNIX as your Intel Mac was, at least at the moment.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by pvg on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:39AM (#24639901)
One reason Apple laptops are popular is that people, on average, like both the laptops and the service they get from Apple.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dkonofalski on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:29PM (#24644129)
No, I don't. I have backups of my data and, while it's not ideal that they can't swap out the SSD without swapping out the logic board, I don't care how they get it working again as long as they do get it working and Apple, at least in my experience, has been way more solid than any other computer manufacturer.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by cwhiz on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @03:04PM (#24642411)
Cheaper to buy a new laptop than to replace an SSD? Come on, man. I feel like you've never owned an Apple laptop and you're getting your opinions on the genius bar from Louis Rossman. What you're describing is probably 0.001% of genius bar encounters.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by fastball on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:26AM (#24637209)
Many people buy iPhones / Macs because of the (intended) security provided by things like the T2 chip.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:43AM (#24637296)
Such people would have no issue if they were to be provided with a 20 character secret code that allows rooting and fine grained security control. They would simply not enter it and rely on Apple's decisions for them.

This pretty much kills the whole "intended" security line, the intent is user control.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:04AM (#24637444)
Or perhaps Apple doesn’t want to have to build and support a complicated alternate signing mechanism that virtually none of their users want? I don’t see how a company should have an obligation to offer you exactly the product you want, particularly when there are tons of viable alternatives (which I’m guessing you’re using right now to type these messages).
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:13AM (#24637505)
Oh come on. It is a similar issue with network locked terminals - networks fought tooth and nail to keep the unlock codes away from the people who finished their contracts. In the end, it costs them nothing to provide the codes, but real money to lose customers.

The "none of the users want it" is circular reasoning. If unlock was possible on a mass scale, developers would build for the unfettered iDevices and a market would emerge separate from the one Apple controls. Then users would want it, since it provides value for them - cheaper apps, legal apps that are banned in the Store etc. Of course Apple will fight to the death to prevent such a thing.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:33AM (#24637634)
The difference was when that was common, virtually all the carriers in certain countries did it because as you said it netted them more money and for a while they mostly refused the compete on it. There are plenty of competitors selling rootable phones and laptops, there’s even ones completely without stuff like Intel’s Management Engine. These are more niche, because the desire for them is more niche, but they’re by no means extinct or on the way out. The users have the option to opt for different products with the properties you want.

There is less money overall put into these products, and correspondingly less software, but that’s not because of anti-competitive practices. It’s because the reality is less people care about this stuff. I don’t think “people are obligated to put effort into the products I want” is a particularly noble political position, since you seem to be insistent on framing it that way. The position you’re talking about in the carrier case is different, it’s “people are obligated not to conspire together to do things that none of their users want and give them no options to vote with their feet”.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by toyg on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:59AM (#24637814)
In the "carrier era" you could still buy unlocked phones directly from the manufacturer. Your analogy doesn't hold.

The truth is that there is a threshold, a level of user complaints that turns a legitimate practice into an anti-competitive one. People disagree on where this threshold lies - is it at 0, is it at 1000, is it at millions? Until recently, most of Apple's shenanigans have kept the complaints under thresholds small enough to be socially acceptable, that's all. If more people complain, that threshold could be reached.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @08:21AM (#24637992)
That wasn’t the case for CDMA phones in the US (and back then not every manufacturer made models for multiple bands). There was no SIM card to swap in. If you could buy unlocked phones from the manufacturer without the carrier subsidy, what was anti-competitive about it?

That’s an interesting metric for anti-competitive practice. Isn’t a large number of user complaints basically the core mechanism that drives market competition? Once you have enough users complaining about an aspect of a product (or otherwise being underserved), why would they not go to a competitor if one is allowed to exist (as they are in this situation)?

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by toyg on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:39PM (#24641350)
A manufacturer had to have a relationship with carriers to move enough product to make its prices affordable even off-carrier. Manufacturers who couldn’t sell through carriers were effectively made uncompetitive by the carrier cartel, that also resulted in a number of other restrictions (how one can pay for stuff etc). In this sense, as I wrote elsewhere, Apple strong-arming ATT was a big step forward; but it also took legislation on this side of the pond to force carriers to play nice with unlockings, there was no chance the market would self-correct.

Which takes me to the second point: the market alone often does not self-correct. This is why we have antitrust laws and authorities to enforce them. People lack the education to be able to reason about “voting with their wallet” in an effective way; and even when they do, they often don’t have the resources to follow through. This is why contract bundles are so popular, despite the fact that they make handset more expensive overall: people can’t do math, and when they do they still often lack the cash reserves to buy a handset in one go rather than paying small instalments for a long time. If a market fails, it’s legitimate for the law to step in; and one indication of failure is the level of discontent from consumers.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by coldtea on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:53AM (#24637358)
>This pretty much kills the whole "intended" security line

Only if the "20 character secret code" had the same security characteristics, which it doesn't.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:59AM (#24637406)
It has the same security as the scenario of buying vs non buying a product for its alleged security: you either use it or you don't. If you do, you are greeted with copious warnings and voiding of warranty, so it would definitely be a conscious act.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dkonofalski on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:38PM (#24644244)
You're completely ignoring the fact that a large part of the user base of these products explicitly buys these products because they don't have these options. Windows attempted to add UAC control to the OS so that people wouldn't install random files from websites without being notified of the changes being made and browsers tried to add systems where users had to go into the options and turn off protections in Windows Defender to be able to install. What was the end result? These websites just started offering tutorials that showed users how to turn off those protections and bypass them completely. If you give people a way to bypass security, they'll do it in order to get to what they think they want. The problem is that most people don't understand the unintended consequences of those actions. That's the entire reason why people trust Apple to make those decisions on their behalf.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:18PM (#24644670)
Ah, the ole "idiot user" rhetoric, imprisoned for their own sake. Say I call the Apple support center, ask for the code, and they warn me in no uncertain terms that I'm voiding my warranty and would not be eligibile for continued support.

How can this prevent any mentally sane person from trusting Apple made the correct decisions and not root their device?

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dkonofalski on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:50PM (#24644961)
No, not "idiot user". No one is imprisoned. In the same way that people choose to be part of organizations and groups with rules and limits to what can be done, people choose to use devices that are slightly limited in exchange for reliability and security. I don't want Apple waste time and resources to need to support the people that call the call center to ask for this supposed code and most people using their devices don't either. If they did, wouldn't the market make that movement?
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:54PM (#24645573)
No, it wouldn't, see the terminal unlock code for contract phones discussed below. If your opinion is that the free market is all correcting and magical and that laws and regulations should never intervene in private consumer choices, I have a failed state I can introduce you to, not to mention a salmonela infested burrito.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dkonofalski on Thursday October 01, 2020 @02:49PM (#24654702)
Unlocking phones isn't in the same scope at all. Locking a phone in the first place was done because carriers were subsidizing phones so they needed to ensure they stayed on their networks. An "unlock code" for root access to a phone is a giant security flaw and a potential vector even for anyone that doesn't want the functionality or care to root their phone. The fact that the option could exist for someone to bypass security is, in and of itself, a security risk. The specific reasons I buy iPhones for family and staff is because I know they can't do those things, even if they wanted to. I want them to have smartphones so they can run specific apps or connect to our servers but I don't want even the possibility of those devices being compromised.

You call it a prison. I call it a fortress.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by fastball on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:49AM (#24637327)
That's definitely a fair point! Though I think this could probably open you up to some MITM style attacks where someone intercepts a Macbook in transit and steals the root key that comes with it or something. Maybe not though, I guess it really depends on how you accomplish this.

But on the surface it does seem like that could work.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:02AM (#24637421)
How does me (or anyone else) buying a MacBook affect your freedom and choices? Was there some extinction of e.g. Linux-capable devices I didn’t hear about? And if I actually want the security features, who are you to say that’s not an option for me?
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by amelius on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:05AM (#24637448)
The more people use X, the more developers will focus on X and not on Y. From there, even fewer people will use Y and the downward cycle continues.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:08AM (#24637472)
Okay, so why do your preferences for the device take priority over the majority of users who don’t care about what the T2 does and the ones who do and actually want it? Why should it be illegal for a company to make a product for us instead of you?
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:17AM (#24637529)
Clearly the majority has won thus far and Apple is not restrained in any way. But I have the right to a differing political opinion, and when the majority shifts, your freedoms are not encroached, just like when the majority of people decide smoking should not be allowed in airplanes.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:24AM (#24637570)
That’s a bizarre analogy to me, and you’re implying a symmetry to the situation that doesn’t exist. I want to be able to buy a product that has the properties that I want, and I want you to be able to buy a product with properties that you want (in part because I also want and own products with the properties you want). You want the only option to be products made with the properties you want, so that other businesses are forced to make more software for the products you want. Which of these is restricting freedom more?

I think you’re going to have to try harder to convince anyone that this situation is analogous to second hand smoke. You probably want to come up with better arguments for your “political” movement.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:41AM (#24637690)
The condescendence is really unwarranted, it is a simple idea that purchasing options are affected by political choices of others. To give a symmetrical example, you are not allowed to purchase completely safe recreational drugs, because of the opinions the majority holds on their use.

The metric you use of avoiding "restricting freedom" is a strongly ideological stance in itself and is not a natural goal political systems strive for. You might value some flavors of individual autonomy and imply they have an universal vocation by calling them "freedom". I might favor other sets, such as the restriction of corporate power and consumer empowerment, and call those, in turn "freedom", see for example the GPL ethos. Both sets of political views are legitimate and can be pursued in a democracy.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:52AM (#24637761)
Okay, but again, if your metric is consumer empowerment, how does you dictating the properties of products consumers can buy based on your personal preferences result in more consumer empowerment? Can most consumers take their System76 laptop, and then set it up so it has the properties of a laptop with something like the T2 chip if they so desire? Any more than you can reasonably be expected to delid the T2 chip in a MacBook to get it to do what you want?

I’m not trying to judge your statements by my goalposts as you seem to be implying, I’m trying to understand the internal logic of what you’ve been saying which AFAICT isn’t lining up.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:59AM (#24637812)
This might be a confusion started from the answer of "amelius", the logic of which I don't fully support. I believe consumer freedom is hampered first and foremost by monopolies (or, in the mobile OS case, oligopolies) and my political choice is to maximize market forces and restrict anti-competitive behavior. This is the grounds on which I oppose Apple practices, not some idea that if people buy Apple products it somehow prevents development for other platforms.
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by johncolanduoni on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @08:10AM (#24637911)
Again, where is the monopoly that forces you to buy devices with a T2 chip (or something) analogous? That’s simply not the world we live in, and it doesn’t seem to me like we’re moving toward it. And if your political choice is to maximize market forces, why are you trying to fight the market forces that result in there being a large market for Apple’s devices and a small (but extant and healthy) market for the devices you want? Do you think that most consumers “really want” the devices you want? If so, why do they choose not to buy them even though they are available?

Right now, as a consumer (which, like you, is my only realistic lever on this situation), I’m pretty happy that I own some Apple devices and some very not-Apple devices. I’d be pretty pissed if I was forced to choose only one of these (in either direction). I think you’d find the same reaction if you became president of the world and threw everyone’s Apple devices in the trash and handed them a Librem 5 or something similar. Do you contest that this would be their reaction? If so, what is your definition of market forces and anti-competitive behavior?

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by yholio on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @11:32AM (#24639815)
Monopoly power is not a market force, it's an abuse of the market to the detriment of the consumers. If "the market forces that result in there being a large market for Apple’s devices" is Apple using its platform to, say, restrict competition and maximize app revenue, thus having more money to invest in their platform, thus forcing competitors to apply the same dubious tactics or fail, then this is not a pro-consumer model because it leads to an oligopoly at best or impenetrable monopoly at worst.

The consumers can buy any system with any chip they want. If it is employed by Apple to enhance security that's great, for example the Mac. If it's used to lockdown the device so that no competing software can be run, a la iPhone, for them to maintain the stranglehold on the app market, then I am against it on political grounds and my position is not falsifiable.

You are inworking an oligopoly situation and accuse me of wanting to turn it into a monopoly, but I want the exact opposite: all existing platforms to still exist, and additionally, all those prevented by anti-competitive behavior, which by my non-falsifiable definition includes any lockdown on the hardware that is sold in the marketplace, that can only be, and is only used to limit the options of the owner.

It is not like Apple devices would cease to be produced or be confiscated if we pass laws mandating software freedom on purchased hardware, from iPhones to tractors.

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by dkonofalski on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @05:40PM (#24644268)
Doesn't that, by your own admission, mean that people care about X and not Y? If people don't care about Y, why should manufacturers be forced to appeal to the fraction of people that do?
Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by coldtea on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @06:52AM (#24637346)
>Sorry, but the only rational consumer response to a device that actively works against you is not to purchase it, not hack it.

"Actively works against you" is your reading. I very much appreciate what the T2 does, and hope the next update will be even more difficult to hack (aside from its other functionality).

Re:Apple’s T2 security chip jailbreak by amelius on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:04AM (#24637438)
The main problem is that:

- on the one hand (I believe) developers would prefer owning more open devices (like Librem/Purism, Pine64 etc.)

- on the other hand they want to develop for the masses, which means they will need access to Apple hardware.