The trick is in higher temperature plasma. The sun fuses protium (lone protons). We don’t have the confinement necessary on Earth to do this, so we fuse deuterium (1p+1n) and tritium (1p+2n). This reaction is more energetically favorable and is achievable on Earth. Coupled with giant microwave ovens and clever geometry and electromagnetic tricks, we can make plasmas much hotter (faster moving particles) than the sun can.
Once a plasma is fusing, it emits a lot of heat (alpha heating and fast neutrons). A plasma that requires no external heating (no microwave ovens) is said to be “ignited”. We don’t necessarily need or want ignition to have a successful reactor, but it’s a cool thought.
The major trouble with fusion reactors is keeping particles in the bottle long enough to fuse. Since they’re leaving anyway they have to go somewhere. You can tune vessel geometry and magnetic fields to have designated strike points where most of the plasma will exit confinement. These are called divertors. Run some coolant through your divertors and you have a heat source that can boil water and spin a turbine.
Here my knowledge gets shaky because I know that the fastest particles coming out of a D+T reaction are neutrons (they weigh much less than an alpha particle). Since neutrons are electrically neutral I think they are much less likely to become thermalized (they are not likely to bump into another particle on their way out). I’m not sure how neutron thermalization happens in reactor simulations, but I’m under the impression that it does.
Terrestrial reactors try for much higher reaction rates. But most designs still have power density issues that would make them uneconomical even if they could make net power. Net power is actually a very low bar, corresponding to an EROI of 1.
I appreciate that many people are commenting 'you couple the plasma to a working fluid', but I think the original comment was more along the line of how you couple a confined plasma to a working fluid. By definition the plasma is in a hard vacuum, magnetically bottled. What, then, is the coupling method? Thermal photons escaping confinement? I genuinely have no idea myself, but would really like to know.
I looked up the effects of neutron radiation on materials[]. Sounds like a hell of an engineering challenge to come up with a robust way of getting that energy out!
Radiation damage to materials occurs as a result of the interaction of a [neutron] with a lattice atom in the material. The collision causes a massive transfer of kinetic energy to the lattice atom, which is displaced from its lattice site, becoming what is known as the primary knock-on atom (PKA). [...] The magnitude of the damage is such that a single 1 MeV neutron creating a PKA in an iron lattice produces approximately 1,100 Frenkel pairs.
Yep. And anything touched by the neutron flux would become radioactive if it captures neutrons. For example steel, normal steel contains carbon, carbon captures neutrons, so the steel becomes radioactive, and also brittle. And then you need wiring and insulation and coolant and pumps and all that.
So, what is that blanket made of?
It needs to be a material which:
- can withstand high temperatures and radiation
- does not becomes radioactive itself
- facilitates production of Tritium by breeding
- operates in very high magnetic fields, which means high forces
No such material is known so far.
It is a bit like some engineer from 1700 said: "Well, you could just build a more efficient and compact and light steam engine, and connect it to a machine which has flapping wings, and then you have a transport vehicle which can carry people across the Atlantic ocean at supersonic speed, and at little cost."
It would have had to have been an unusually well informed and far-sighted engineer though, as Savery's engines first worked in 1698 and the first for-sale commercial engine, Newcomen's, wouldn't happen until 1712. And they were incredibly inefficient: 0.01% to 0.1%.
Do you know how far along are we in understanding how to build an effective blanket that can withstand the neutron flux while maintaining its physical integrity?
To collect energy, heat would be transferred to a working fluid (e.g., molten salt) by exposing that fluid to the hot plasma. Then the working fluid would be used to boil water and spin a turbine.
http://www.geeksworld.org/strip_981.html
http://www.geeksworld.org/strip_982.html
[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thermoelectric_generator#Effic...
[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Steam-electric_power_station#E...
Inducing a current by moving something in a magnetic field, or vice versa, may seem like simple designs, but perhaps that's why we haven't replaced them yet. Rotational motion seems easy to service and efficient.
Same with water being particularly easy to turn into a gas using heat, as well as being super plentiful on Earth. There are just a lot of things going for a steam turbine
We haven't found a better way to convert heat to electrical energy. We've done great things with solar, kinetic, gravity, etc.
I think the better analysis is to chart the efficiency of the conversion over time. I couldn't easily find a chart showing this, but I assume gigawatt scale turbines operating at 50%+ efficiency are modern engineering marvels compared to the earliest 7kW prototype made by Charles Parsons in 1884.
In theory, one could have "generate heat, and have the apparatus surrounded by a vacuum, surrounded by infrared photovoltaics" be the new universal backend for power generation. I have no idea about the associated efficiencies, of course.
We would have never entered the industrial era without boilers.
> Also, something else I never grokked, how do you get the power out? The plasma heats up, but how do you turn that into useful electrical energy?
Steam turbines; same as fission or coal. Or gas turbines, if you want to get fancy.
- fusion is developed
- b/c of fusion, the cheapest "rocket fuel" is basically water heated into steam by the fusion reactor
- people on Earth get upset about the "spacers" taking all of the "earthers" water
- the spacers then have to go to other sources of water in the solar system (I think it was either rings of Saturn or the asteroid belt)
The thing that struck me at the time was the "water as propellant" without the extra step of breaking H2O into hydrogen and oxygen.
Heat it sufficiently and it will be broken down.
It's just an average. Fusion occurs only in the core, which is pretty tiny, relatively speaking.
> The plasma heats up, but how do you turn that into useful electrical energy?
The same way you can turn any kind of heat into useful energy.
~250W/m3.
The whole research program gets its funding as what amounts to a jobs program to keep high-neutron-flux physicists employed and available to draw upon for weapons work. That is one reason why any fusion process that does not emit neutrons is not given any of the research funds: weapons work doesn't need high-alpha-flux physicists. (Secondarily, they have papers that purport to show e.g. p-B fusion could never work.)
If we ever do get practical fusion, it won't be in a Tokamak, it probably won't be on the Earth's surface, and it certainly won't help resolve global climate disruption.
The money being spent on Tokamaks, on the other hand, absolutely could help a great deal with global climate disruption. But not while also maintaining the all-important high-neutron-flux population.
In the sun, isn't energy production occurring at something like 100-1000 W/m3? So, if you want to build a multiple MW fusion plant, shouldn't these plants be ridiculously huge compared to, say, a wind turbine rated at a couple of MW?
Is the density of the plasma so much higher in a fusion reactor?
Also, something else I never grokked, how do you get the power out? The plasma heats up, but how do you turn that into useful electrical energy?
Nevertheless of course I hope it does work as advertised... someday.
Edit: thanks everyone for the thoughtful, insightful replies!