Re:Compact nuclear fusion reactor is 'very likely to work,' ...
by ncmncm on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:36PM
(#24632652)
Exactly: there is no prospect or intent to actually, ever make a Tokamak that produces useful power. Besides the power density problem and the really absolutely enormous expense and already-sunk cost, the necessary neutrons would destroy the most expensive part of the reactor in short order, and make the rest radioactive.
The whole research program gets its funding as what amounts to a jobs program to keep high-neutron-flux physicists employed and available to draw upon for weapons work. That is one reason why any fusion process that does not emit neutrons is not given any of the research funds: weapons work doesn't need high-alpha-flux physicists. (Secondarily, they have papers that purport to show e.g. p-B fusion could never work.)
If we ever do get practical fusion, it won't be in a Tokamak, it probably won't be on the Earth's surface, and it certainly won't help resolve global climate disruption.
The money being spent on Tokamaks, on the other hand, absolutely could help a great deal with global climate disruption. But not while also maintaining the all-important high-neutron-flux population.
The whole research program gets its funding as what amounts to a jobs program to keep high-neutron-flux physicists employed and available to draw upon for weapons work. That is one reason why any fusion process that does not emit neutrons is not given any of the research funds: weapons work doesn't need high-alpha-flux physicists. (Secondarily, they have papers that purport to show e.g. p-B fusion could never work.)
If we ever do get practical fusion, it won't be in a Tokamak, it probably won't be on the Earth's surface, and it certainly won't help resolve global climate disruption.
The money being spent on Tokamaks, on the other hand, absolutely could help a great deal with global climate disruption. But not while also maintaining the all-important high-neutron-flux population.