News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by vinniejames on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:50PM (#24623014)
This was removed because the machine generated captions have reached near parity with crowdsourced captions. Machine captions can be scaled to caption the entirety of YouTube, something crowdsourcing could never accomplish.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by kelnos on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:50PM (#24623418)
That's not even close to true. Maybe it is for bog-standard American English, but whenever I watch a British show where you have people with a variety of accents (UK English, Irish, Scottish, Welsh), the auto-generated captions are pretty bad.

And in any language, the machine-generated captions don't have punctuation. You also miss out on non-speech cues that a manual captioner will often add, like a note that there's music playing in the background, or that a loud crash happened off-screen, or simply that a person laughed.

> Machine captions can be scaled to caption the entirety of YouTube, something crowdsourcing could never accomplish.

They certainly don't scale the same way, but one of the entire purposes of crowdsourcing is that it scales better than trying to employ what will inevitably be a smaller number of people. I still think there's value there, at least until machine-generated captions are actually on par with a human. We're not there yet.

Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by wruza on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:11PM (#24623177)
As a non-english speaker (writer actually, since I cannot fluently speak) who routinely watches popsci/math/etc videos on youtube, I assure you that machine-generated subtitles are completely useless. It may "parse" the usual speech, but not specific terms, and when it fails often (it does), a text becomes a mess. By disabling user-generated content they basically pin everyone with hearing issues to funny cat videos and amazing pop star interviews. I don't think they can scale beyond that right now.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by frosted-flakes on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:33PM (#24623313)
also the machine generated captions are

completely devoid of punctuation

and proper capitalization so that all the words

run together in an endless nonsense sentence also they're

useless because each word pops up on the

screen one a time very slowly in time with the audio

with arbitrary line breaks sounds useful but

it makes it impossible to read the captions and actually

watch the video because you're forced to keep

your eyes on the weirdly scrolling captions you

can't just read one line at a time like proper

captions and it never gets the hard to

hear words right you know the ones that

would benefit most from proper captions

---

Also, the machine-generated captions are completely devoid of punctuation and proper capitalization, so that all the words run together in an endless, nonsense sentence.

Also, they're useless because each word pops up on the screen one a time, very slowly (in time with the audio), with arbitrary line breaks. Sounds useful, but it makes it impossible to read the captions and actually watch the video because you're forced to keep your eyes on the weirdly scrolling captions--you can't just read one line at a time like proper captions.

And it never gets the hard-to-hear words right. You know, the ones that would benefit most from proper captions.

Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by henrikschroder on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:40PM (#24623712)
Fantastic example!

Creating real subtitles is as much a combination of art and skill and judgement and balance as editing the video itself.

A good subtitle allows you to quickly read ahead, and then move your eyes back to the video, back to the people speaking, so that you can watch them act out the line.

A good subtitle doesn't transcribe everything said word for word, but reduces spoken language to written language, and focuses on the gist of what's said.

A good subtitle for hearing-impaired viewers describe important sounds that happen off-screen, such as doors opening or closing, but skips non-important sounds, and sounds of things happening on-screen.

Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by maven29 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:45AM (#24624486)
I feel like you're conflating captions and subtitles here, they're not the same thing.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by jacoblambda on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:15AM (#24624956)
While they are technically different, they are very similar and much of the "art" is the same between them.

Good subtitles and CCs both have to be structured carefully so that they do not negatively impact the delivery of lines in the content. The biggest offender of this is comedy series as an improperly structured and timed CC or subtitle will ruin many jokes.

Another aspect of this is how they handle making it easy to digest multiple lines of dialogue. Good CCs and subtitles will either structure the dialogue such that a certain voice is always on top or bottom or alternatively will match colours to voices.

Similarly, in content that is visually busy or rapidly changing, good subtitles and CCs will stay out of the "busy" section of the screen and avoid using a colour or outline that would interfere with the readability based on the background of the scene.

They are different but with regards to what makes them good, they are basically the same.

And to add on to this, on just about everything but live feeds, they are produced and added to video more or less the same way.

Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by frosted-flakes on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:14AM (#24626290)
One difference is that captions shouldn't differ too much from the original audio. If they do, it's confusing if you're reading and listening at the same time. Translated subtitles don't have this problem.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by henrikschroder on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @07:36PM (#24645406)
> They are different but with regards to what makes them good, they are basically the same.

Yes. The rules for how long to show a subtitle, and when to pop them in and out are the same, regardless of the actual text shown. Everyone can decide what characters-per-second limit works for them, but whatever you choose, it fundamentally alters everything else and restricts what text can actually go in the subtitle. Translated or not translated, sound cues or no sound cues.

Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by Polylactic_acid on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:12PM (#24623555)
God your example is such a good demonstration. Captions are an art and not simply "correct is correct". They also have to be timed correctly to match what is being shown on the screen as well as pausing for the correct amount of time to match the effects that the speaker is giving.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by jk700 on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:16PM (#24623209)
I'm pretty sure crowdsourcing subtitles in different languages is the primary use of the feature precisely because machine generated translation of machine generated captions produces gibberish.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by heavyset_go on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:00PM (#24623788)
The machine generated captions would be hilariously poor if people didn't depend on them, and as such, they're tragically poor.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by maple3142 on Monday September 28, 2020 @11:49PM (#24624003)
I think it only applied to English. For example, autogenerated caption for Japanese videos usually fails miserably, even a Japanese learner can easily spot where the wrong is, and it is not uncommon.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by watwut on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:10AM (#24624917)
It does not apply to English. Maybe they are less horrible then Japanies ones, but they are not good either.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by memsom on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:48AM (#24625702)
And some languages just don't get autogenerated captions at all. "No captions available" is pretty common on videos even from fairly large European countries. I think Russian, English, French, German and possibly Spanish and Italian frequently get autogenerated captions, but Polish, Swedish, Norwegian, Czech... (languages I deal with frequently) sorry, no captions.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by memsom on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:41AM (#24625649)
Machine captions in English. Not in non-English. Swedish and Norwegian, both fairly close to English, when compared to say, Chinese of Japanese, have no autogenerated captions - the system simply never offers that as an option. If you think the system is perfect, you are very wrong.
Re:YouTube is shutting down crowdsourced captions by tmpz22 on Monday September 28, 2020 @09:13PM (#24623190)
Do they have parity across all languages or just English?