News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by modeless on Monday September 28, 2020 @08:16PM (#24622742)
No mention of the other part of this announcement [1]: "we will be making changes in Android 12 (next year’s Android release) to make it even easier for people to use other app stores on their devices"

[1] https://android-developers.googleblog.com/2020/09/listening-...

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by ineedasername on Monday September 28, 2020 @10:20PM (#24623602)
Yeah, I see both moves as being part of a careful dance around pending anti-trust issues. They're about to force holdouts to use their IAP system, which would be bad optics from an anti-trust point of view. However, if at the same time they make 3rd part app stores more viable they have a strong defense of "Look developers can sell their apps in other places on Android but if they want to sell through us, these are the terms."

If they really do follow through with reasonable support for other app stores, that will be a good thing.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:02AM (#24626623)
> If they really do follow through with reasonable support for other app stores, that will be a good thing.

It will better, but it’s hardly “good”. It would still mean that Google gets to decide exactly which rights and protections their competitors should have on Android.

It should be the other way around: government regulators (to protect the interests of consumers and the health of the free market) should decide how much power Google has over its competitors.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by ineedasername on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:42AM (#24627005)
That depends on how they implement 3rd party app stores. If anyone can make one, then Google doesn't have undue control over competitors.

I'm not sure government regulation needs to enter the picture unless courts decide there's an anti-trust issue, which open 3rd part app stores might make less likely. For Android, at least. Good still would face anti trust problems in other areas.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:48AM (#24627757)
> If anyone can make one, then Google doesn't have undue control over competitors.

That's not true. They still have the power to restrict a third party store whenever they want without any immediate repercussions.

Let's say they remove all of the scary popups that Android shows when you try to install apps outside of Google Play right now. That would be a big win for competitors. But then any time in the future, Google can decide to slowly bring back those popups under the guise of "protecting users" or some other FUD.

The problem is that we might not have a company like Epic in the future, which is very well funded, willing, and able to fight them in court. When Google starts slowly clawing back control, we'll see some people complain about it on the usual channels, but it's likely nothing will happen.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by thebean11 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:30AM (#24628256)
> Google can decide to slowly bring back those popups under the guise of "protecting users" or some other FUD.

But Google can do any thing right? They could push an update that plays Matchbox Twenty on full blast every night at 2am.

What are you suggesting they do, and doesn't you argument apply to every software publisher?

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:32AM (#24629041)
> But Google can do any thing right? They could push an update that plays Matchbox Twenty on full blast every night at 2am.

Sure, but they are not incentivized to do that. Forcing out competitors is something they're directly incentivized to do because it makes them more money. You can't trust a company not to do what a company exists to do.

The problem is that Google (and Apple) are way too big and powerful, and their pursuit for higher profits is stifling competition, innovation, and hurting the economy.

> doesn't you argument apply to every software publisher?

Not every publisher is immune to market forces the way Google and Apple are. If Spotify started blasting Matchbox Twenty on full blast every night at 2am, they'd go out of business overnight. If Google did it, people would just put their phones in another room when they go to bed.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by thebean11 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:42AM (#24629180)
> Sure, but they are not incentivized to do that. Forcing out competitors is something they're directly incentivized to do because it makes them more money.

Then why even go through the motions of making life easier for app stores right now? Because of antitrust? I guess I'm just not sure why that would change later. Google will still be an antitrust target 5 years from now.

In an ideal world, what would you like Google to do here?

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:06PM (#24629509)
> Then why even go through the motions of making life easier for app stores right now?

We can only speculate. Maybe it's a reaction to the legal issues they're facing right now, both from the DOJ investigation and the Epic lawsuit? Or maybe it's a more cynical plan to kill competitors by letting them think it's smart to invest in a competing store now, only to claw back control in the future and force them to lose customers and go out of business?

Maybe the upcoming changes don't actually make life significantly easier for third-party app stores (AFAIK they haven't shown what the changes actually are), and this is just a BS move to make them look better in the short term.

> In an ideal world, what would you like Google to do here?

Google? Nothing. In an ideal world, tech giants wouldn't be allowed to self-regulate anymore. Google could do whatever they want, but sane and reasonable regulations would keep them in check.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by thebean11 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @01:38PM (#24630679)
> Google could do whatever they want, but sane and reasonable regulations would keep them in check.

I may be naive, but Google's move seems like evidence that the regulations are keeping them in check to some extent.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:21PM (#24631199)
But there are no regulations. This move is (most likely) a reaction to the recent lawsuits and the potential risk of future regulations. For the past 10 years they've done nothing remotely like this, and likely wouldn't have done anything if it weren't for Epic.

note that we still don't really know what exactly it is they're doing, since the blog post was vague on specifics. It could literally be nothing.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by blinkingled on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @09:57AM (#24627860)
> That's not true. They still have the power to restrict a third party store whenever they want without any immediate repercussions.

That's true even today - you can install whatever the hell you want on an Android device by merely toggling a button. You can even root it and go further - much easier for Pixels - sure some apps will refuse to work on rooted devices but that's hardly Google's fault.

What are you trying to demand here - complete anarchy like PCs? I am not sure that's a good thing.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:28AM (#24628975)
> you can install whatever the hell you want on an Android device by merely toggling a button

I can because I'm a computer geek. The majority of the population wouldn't know how to or care to learn how to go through the trouble of enabling "unknown sources" and ignoring all the scary malware warnings. Without that population, the prospect of running a commercial third-party store is hopeless.

> complete anarchy like PCs?

What anarchy? Software distribution on PC is great because users can, and regularly do, go straight to the vendor's website to buy their software. There is no middle-man.

From the security side, since Android and iOS have had sandboxing built in from day one, the risk of downloading software from a random website is much lower than it is on Windows. It's not zero, but it is lower, and it's not that much riskier than downloading a random app on Google Play (which has always been filled with malware).

But lets say it's still too risky for some reason. Fine. That's what anti-virus software is for.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by blinkingled on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:49PM (#24631478)
So you want Google to basically advertise/encourage how to install stuff from unknown sources or to enable it by default?

I am not sure that's a good thing for majority of the population. Sandboxing does nothing if you download untrusted apps and give them permission to send SMS or setup a VPN or do whole lot of damage. If you aren't a geek you are saying ok to anything any app asks.

Android actually optionally, with rightful warnings allows PC like anarchy for geeks - if you are arguing that should be the default I am not sure many people will agree with that.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @04:05PM (#24632310)
> I am not sure that's a good thing for majority of the population. Sandboxing does nothing if you download untrusted apps and give them permission to send SMS or setup a VPN or do whole lot of damage. If you aren't a geek you are saying ok to anything any app asks.

People already say ok to anything any app asks on Google Play. That isn't a problem unique to competing app stores, it's a problem with Android's permissions UI/UX. Just look at any non-tech-savvy Android user's phone to see that "anarchy" is already the status quo.

> if you are arguing that should be the default I am not sure many people will agree with that.

The only arguments I've heard against it have been FUD (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fear,_uncertainty,_and_doubt)

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by ineedasername on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @11:29PM (#24635428)
As I said, it depends on Google's implementation of 3rd party app stores. Any platform has power over what appears on the platform. Pointing out that Google does as well is practically axiomatic.

You aren't just making an argument against google, your line if thinking would vilainize all platforms. At the same time that you're implying that no platform should be allowed to dictate what gets on the platform. I fundamentally disagree. As-is, I think Android has exposure to anti-trust accusations. But an open system of allowing 3rd party app stores nullifies that. Of course they'll still have control, but the measure of abusing power isn't that you have it, it's how you use it. And Google might be smart enough to realize that their use of power until now has brought too much anti-trust scrutiny, and that needs to change. Or maybe they'll screw it up, but you seem to automatically believe whatever they do will be bad. That is a narrow view that assumes Google doesn't understand the dangerous position it's in right now.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by bogwog on Wednesday September 30, 2020 @01:47PM (#24641431)
> Any platform has power over what appears on the platform. Pointing out that Google does as well is practically axiomatic.

That's not what I'm pointing out or focusing on.

> you're implying that no platform should be allowed to dictate what gets on the platform

I never said or implied that.

> but you seem to automatically believe whatever they do will be bad

I don't believe that, and have not said anything to suggest that I do.

The assumptions you are making about me or my argument to arrive at these conclusions seem to be inaccurate. I would be happy to continue this discussion, as long as you ask me to clarify something rather than attempt to arrive at your own conclusions, potentially derailing the whole conversation.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by dalbasal on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:06AM (#24626667)
Anti-trust, ultimately, is not really about optics.

Proving a "trust" is a pretty arcane affair... and fairly tangential to actual monopoly issues.

In any case, available and viable are two different things. I doubt that they'd intentionally make them viable.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by michaelmrose on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:13AM (#24624623)
A salient point is that whereas the requirement to use the billing system will be phased in at once any benefits rolled out to users as part of android 12 will take 4 years reach 80% of users.

ndroid 9 released more than 2 years ago and is now and 52% of users are now on 9 or later whereas more like 80% are at least on 7 which was released 4 years ago.

https://www.appbrain.com/stats/top-android-sdk-versions

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by riquito on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @02:34AM (#24624725)
Android version 10 has better update tracks than previous versions (project Treble benefits, landed in Android 9), and it keeps getting better, Android 12 should take less to reach the same user base
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by michaelmrose on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:03AM (#24624881)
10 took a year to reach 25%. It's too early to say anything about the uptake of 11 let alone 12 which doesn't exist. 80% uptake for a new version in 2 years would represent a stunning success. In that happy scenario your billing change still hits 2 years before most app customers have any chance to benefit from alternative stores ensuring that everyone pretty much has to switch over or die.

Pragmatically if I was google I would SAY I am making it easier for users to do business with someone else while making it as daunting as possible to actually do so in order to pressure vendors to at best offer both their wares for sale on both stores if they want to actually have customers.

Your play store policy can then forbid say offering your goods for sale at a lower price elsewhere or advertising the existence of an alternative version in app on the play store version.

As long as you keep it available on the play store most users will check their first and you can keep the revenue in house without strictly forbidding competition.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by kuschku on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @06:11AM (#24625851)
And yet the OG Pixel hasn’t gotten any updates in a year now.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by fallennode on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:26AM (#24626346)
The OG Pixel was released in early 2013. ~6 years of software updates is really good compared with any other smartphone.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by phh on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:17AM (#24626764)
Uh... No... it has been released at end of 2016. It received 3 years of software upgrade, which most high-end Android OEMs deliver, (Though it got 3 major upgrades, while most OEMs stop at 2), and pales in comparaison to iPhones.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by ac29 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:44PM (#24632063)
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by kuschku on Friday October 02, 2020 @07:18AM (#24661410)
That’s weird, my OG Pixel says it has received its last security update on October 6, 2019, and has no updates available
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by eloisant on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:43AM (#24627021)
The percentage of users using the latest version isn't necessarily the percentage that matters for a given developer.

For example, if we're talking about Fortnite, usage of the latest version is certainly higher than the general population. Older versions of Android are mostly used on cheaper devices, or users who seldomly upgrade their phone, and don't care that much about installing applications.

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by michaelmrose on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @05:11PM (#24633042)
This is a good point but games may be a special case as they require a more powerful phone. Still there is probably a link between willingness to part with money and having a newer phone.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by thebean11 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @10:32AM (#24628284)
Whereas Netflix, probably closer to the average Android version distribution..
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by Abishek_Muthian on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @03:18AM (#24624971)
I think even android 10 has made improvements w.r.t third party stores, I'm able to seamlessly update from Fdroid just like Playstore which wasn't possible in the earlier iterations.
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by jimktrains2 on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @08:04AM (#24626644)
I still need to click update and then install. Is there a setting to let it update automatically? Or can you describe what's changed for you from before?
Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by Abishek_Muthian on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:33PM (#24629901)
Sorry, I seem to be having Privileged Extension on my ROM[1]. But if you have unlocked boot-loader with custom recovery, you can flash the OTA to enable it as well.

[1]https://gitlab.com/fdroid/privileged-extension/#how-do-i-ins...

Re:Google requiring Android apps on Play store to use its bi... by jimktrains2 on Thursday October 01, 2020 @07:24AM (#24649652)
Thanks!