The real important question, as you aluded to, is "What about Fukushima" - a disaster occuring in a rich, western nation, Japan; Japan is a nation generally seen as being on the leading edge of technology. If a disaster can occur in Japan, it can feasibly happen anywhere in the west.
The big giveaway here is that we now consider the great Greek writers as part of the “Western Canon”, while the Greeks and the Romans of the time considered the Greeks to be eastern. Oh and the byzantines are considered mostly considered to be Greek speaking easterners, even though they considered themselves to be Romans and the name “Byzantine Empire” was created long after it fell.
It’s a very confusing thing.
The point is that it does happen despite planning. It won't happen in the same way in Germany but something else can happen.
The chief architect of the Fukushima plant tried hard to convince his bosses that the wall which protects the plant is not tall enough to protect against rare but possible huge tsunami waves, but hasn't been heard. He turned out to be right.
The plant also had emergency cooling pumps, but the pumps were connected incorrectly. This was unforeseen, I can give you that.
In any case, the Fukushima disaster caused one direct human death, or something like that.
In general, modern nuclear stations are no less reliable than fossil fuel plants, and only freak accidents, like a major earthquake and a tsunami, or personnel knowingly switching off all safety systems (the Chernobyl case) lead to catastrophic failures. This still can and should be improved upon, by using reactors with inherently self-contained designs, lack of high-pressure components within the reactor, etc.
It goes to show that even in developed countries corruption happens and this is a major liability to nuclear plants. If it can happen there it can happen anywhere.
And deaths aren't the only measure of accidents. It also caused major pollution.
I would argue that they were aware and still got hit by the risk. I don’t see “well, that specific failure won’t be what gets us in Germany” as especially compelling.
Given the costs involved however, I find it hard to imagine tepco will make the same mistake again in the next 50 years or so.
(Side note: I am pro-nuclear for baseline load in general. I'm also a realist about how likely problems are to repeat/ryhme.)
They could have protected against this, but siting it near the coast is desirable for cooling purposes too (and has been helpful in some ways for cleanup as they've been able to dispose of waste in the ocean), so there are conflicting concerns here.
Things fail from time to time, if that thing failing is catastrophic, it gets very expensive to ensure 100% reliability.
This is a hurdle people are only throwing in front of nuclear plants. Nuclear plants can run indefinitely if maintained - just like all major infrastructure.
https://www.iaea.org/sites/default/files/29402043133.pdf
> It is evident that the average age of power reactors in the IAEA's Member States is increasing. (See accompanying graphs.) By 2000, more than 50 nuclear plants will have been providing electricity for 25 years or longer. Most nuclear power plants have operating life-times of between 20 and 40 years.
> Ageing is defined as a continuing time-dependent degradation of material due to service conditions,including normal operation and transient conditions. It is common experience that over long periods of time, there is a gradual change in the properties of materials. These changes can affect the capability of engineered components, systems, or structures to perform their required function. Not all changes are deleterious, but it is commonly observed that ageing processes normally involve a gradual reduction in performance capability.
> All materials in a nuclear power plant can suffer from ageing and can partially or totally lose their designed function. Ageing is not only of concern for active components (for which the probability of malfunction increases with time) but also for passive ones, since the safety margin is being reduced towards the lowest allow-able level
This article from 2009 addresses the lower age estimates from the 1980’s era, saying reactors could last for 80 years or even more.
https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/nuclear-power-pla...
"We think we can replace almost every component in a nuclear power plant," said Jan van der Lee, director of the Materials Ageing Institute (MAI), a nuclear research facility inaugurated this week in France and run by the state-owned nuclear giant EDF.
EDF is state owned just as much as nuclear reactor construction company => I wouldn't trust that guy
Some components certainly do degrade due to use, but it's entirely feasible to reuse large portions of the old plant by replacing the components that have degraded.
This is simply untrue. Just look at French fleet. 40 years is minimum of their planned lifetime, and they probably will be operated for 50 or maybe even 60 years.
Nuclear ages faster then thermoelectric, which ages faster than hydroelectric. It's a tradeoff.
I don’t think this has ever been a question. Put them in a shed for 100 years then recycle the metal.
Stellarators don’t have the chance of disruptions, but would still need to rely on tritium.
What about decommissioning costs?
Fukushima is a good example of costs from a normal accident we can expect from time to time. Costs are at 200b USD and rising, and they still don't have the reactor site under control.
Even normal decommissioning is incredibly expensive and usually covered by governments and ignored in the costs of electricity.
https://nuclear-news.net/2020/09/24/9-1-2-years-after-meltdo...
https://cleantechnica.com/2019/04/16/fukushimas-final-costs-...
Nuclear fusion (if we ever get to commercial production), will make nuclear much more attractive again though and cut decommissioning costs a bit (though there is still the question of how to deal with reactor parts).