News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:18PM (#24580204)
All the arguments about what company is most evil entirely miss the point.

You don't make a decision on a specific issue based on what company you like more, you base it on who is right on the specific issue.

From an ethical perspective that's what having a codified rule of laws is all about. Everyone get's the same rules no matter how much you like them. You don't arbitrarily punish people for doing things you don't like by denying them unrelated things that they are entitled to unless you go in front of a judge and get a judge to order that as a punishment for doing the thing you don't like.

From a entirely practical and short term perspective these decisions do not just impact the companies you don't like, they also impact everyone else because our legal system puts a very heavy weight on precedent.

I'm strongly reminded of the quote "Freedom of speech doesn't protect speech you like; it protects speech you don't like." (though obviously in this case it is applied to justice in general instead of speech in particular).

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by temp667 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:32PM (#24582579)
The question from a principle standpoint is - can a company create an area where trust / safety / security are prioritized. T

Developers no doubt disagree with this, they have created a web that is filled with crap. Let's be 100% clear about that.

Spam calls via voip, spam into email, ddos floods of every sort imaginable, impossible to unsubscribe, cramming and slamming on subscription renewals and the list goes on. They don't want root on your device to help you, but to screw you in enough cases that you shouldn't give them root. Trust / security / safety are low low low on the list of almost all startup and other developers "growth hacking" etc.

Apple wanted to create their own little world. Phones with updates that keep on getting updated, an app marketplace with much more transparent pricing (lot less fine print), and the list goes on.

You need to look at what apple is doing in context. The world on the net developers and hackers here on HN have created is terrible in many ways for many many people. At some point folks are just tied of the endless scams.

Now the same folks who trashed a lot of the rest of the web (do you answer your phone when an unkown number calls?) want into the walled apple garden.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:00PM (#24582920)
To keep the continuity of discussion, I assume that this comment was posted here because my top level comment was in part a reply to your (temp667's) comment here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24579860

I appreciate the attempt to connect this to the anti-trust suit, but I don't see this as a good justification for why your original critique is relevant for a few reasons:

- Many of the practices in your original critique are allowed on (or not prevented by) Apple's app store. The argument you are making here only makes sense as pertaining to anti-trust to the extent that you are critiquing practices that Apple is preventing.

- It doesn't particularly matter whether the people trying to overturn Apple's practice are the bad actors, or third parties are, since the lawsuit affects all parties (third party or not) equally. So while you could make a consumer benefit argument based on bad actors (indeed, Apple has tried to in the lawsuit), it makes little to no sense to focus on the parties suing (and simultaneously falls into the trap of just arguing that people you don't like don't deserve justice).

On a separate note - I also find the argument for Apple's bundling of services here unconvincing. I have seen no argument for why Apple's curation service needs to be bundled with the phone - which is the prerequisite of the anti trust suit. Consider that apple could perfectly well sell the hardware and OS, and separately sell (or even offer for free) a software package that locks out third party app stores and third party payment providers. Doing so would practically destroy any argument that they are using their monopoly on IPhone hardware and IOs to acquire a monopoly on app distribution and payment services. To the extent that people find the lock in useful, I expect they would install that software package.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by zaroth on Thursday September 24, 2020 @08:27PM (#24585240)
Apple does not have a “monopoly on iPhone hardware and iOS”. This is a fundamental misunderstand of the term. You cannot have a monopoly on your own product, because a monopoly is a state of a market and your own product is not a market.

Understanding this is fundamental to the actual legal issue at hand. First, the argument against Apple is not that they are bundling an App Store with their iPhone.

The argument against Apple is that they are restricting behavior that Apps may perform on their Store and also disallowing other stores. If their App Store was downloaded separately but then enforced the same restriction, you have exactly the same legal issue. Implementing the App Store to be a separate manual download, but keeping the same restrictions in place if it is installed, would be just as illegal as exactly what they are doing today.

They would have to at least allow installing multiple App Stores side by side, if not eliminate certain contractural provisions of being able to publish on the Apple App Store itself.

As for why Apple’s curation is bundled with the phone, it’s not a question of whether it “needs to be” that way, it’s a question of why Apple chose to do it that way. They chose that route for a myriad of very significant reasons relating to user experience, usability, privacy, security, safety, brand & reputation, performance, and accountability. From a financial standpoint they chose it because it ensure apps are profitable for both Apple and Developers, as well as consistent and predictable for end users. They also eliminate almost all software piracy on their platform with their model, which increases App Store revenue.

Their model enables HCI, Privacy, and Billing policies which they can enforce platform-wide, and which they can demand otherwise abusive apps to follow, simply because there is no other option if you want access to Apple’s customer base.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jariel on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:31AM (#24587463)
"They chose that route for a myriad of very significant reasons relating to user experience, usability, privacy, security, safety, brand & reputation, performance, and accountability."

This is incredibly naive.

They chose it to be this way for the purposes of profit.

Android is testament to the fact that high degree of quality and security and consistency can be maintained without any of the most iOS aggressive restrictions.

There is no material difference between security on either platform, they're both generally fine, apps are great on Android and people are not falling off the side of the earth because of 'scams or fallouts' regarding Android.

The existence and relative quality of the Android universe renders most of the arguments for iOS walled garden moot.

The term 'monopoly' may not apply perfect, but it's reasonable in the discussion, the anti-trust issues are obvious and have many historical parallels.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by temp667 on Monday September 28, 2020 @01:49PM (#24619334)
If andorid is great, then folks will pick android. That's fine and competition.

Things are a lot cheaper on android to, so they win on price.

The one android phone I ever purchased

1) Shipped with bloatware in the base install (!!!)

2) Shipped with an older android version.

3) The updates never came

4) The messaging story was CRAP (unsecured SMS / spam SMS)

Meanwhile I'm getting 4-5 years of updates on every iphone I have ever purchased. I've never gotten spam imessages I don't think. etc.

Apple choses these features because they think it will let them charge more for their stuff - which I think it does. Making a product people want by reducing scam behavior shouldn't be illegal, and people wanting your product and being willing to pay extra for it doesn't make you a monopoly. Def makes apple rich though!

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by zaroth on Friday September 25, 2020 @09:49AM (#24589646)
> This is incredibly naive.

Maybe you stopped reading. I also said they did it for financial reasons.

To say they did it purely for profit is overly reductionist.

But in the sense that they believe the policies they have put in place make their device superior in the market, and make the App Store generate more dollars per user (both for Apple and for Developers), then you could say that profit is always an underlying motive. As it is and as it should be in capitalism.

Whether you believe Android is great or not is irrelevant. I personally think you are glossing over some very high profile failings and failures of Android, but it’s totally besides the point. Similarly totally irrelevant whether they could have made different technical and policy choices over the last 12 years which may or may not have obtained the same or similar outcomes.

Apple does not owe anyone the right to distribute their Apps on Apple’s own store, no more than any product can demand placement on their own terms in any store. Only if Apple holds a monopoly on smartphones could Apple’s right to enforce their own policies on their own phone be limited. That’s why the term monopoly is important.

The existence and relative quality of the Android universe renders disagreements over Apple App Store policy beyond the reach of an anti-trust act.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:33PM (#24585707)
> Apple does not have a “monopoly on iPhone hardware and iOS”. This is a fundamental misunderstand of the term. You cannot have a monopoly on your own product, because a monopoly is a state of a market and your own product is not a market.

Precedent deeply disagrees with you on this. At the supreme court level see Eastman Kodak Co. v. Image Technical Services Inc. To quote the first paragraph of wikipedia out of laziness: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eastman_Kodak_Co._v._Image_Tec....

> Eastman Kodak Co. v. Image Technical Servs., Inc., 504 U.S. 451 (1992), is a 1992 Supreme Court decision in which the Court held that even though an equipment manufacturer lacked significant market power in the primary market for its equipment—copier-duplicators and other imaging equipment—nonetheless, it could have sufficient market power in the secondary aftermarket for repair parts to be liable under the antitrust laws for its exclusionary conduct in the aftermarket.[1] The reason was that it was possible that, once customers were committed to the particular brand by having purchased a unit, they were "locked in" and no longer had any realistic alternative to turn to for repair parts.

This has been held at the appeals court level to apply to products as well as repair services (because why wouldn't it). See newcal industries v. ikon office solution. Unfortunately since a large portion of the opinion focuses on this, it's hard to find a single quote that summarizes. Read the background and then search aftermarket in the opinion: https://www.leagle.com/decision/20081551513f3d103811540:

Here is my best attempt at picking out a relevant paragraph that explains the law:

> Taking these cases together, three relevant principles emerge. First, the law permits an antitrust claimant to restrict the relevant market to a single brand of the product at issue (as in Eastman Kodak). Second, the law prohibits an antitrust claimant from resting on market power that arises solely from contractual rights that consumers knowingly and voluntarily gave to the defendant (as in Queen City Pizza and Forsyth). Third, in determining whether the defendant's market power falls in the Queen City Pizza category of contractually-created market power or in the Eastman Kodak category of economic market power, the law permits an inquiry into whether a consumer's selection of a particular brand in the competitive market is the functional equivalent of a contractual commitment, giving that brand an agreed-upon right to monopolize its consumers in an aftermarket. The law. permits an inquiry into whether consumers entered into such "contracts" knowing that they were agreeing to such a commitment.

So I don't think it's a slamdunk whether or not Apple's secondary markets here are aftermarkets that anti trust can be applied to because of the third point in the above paragraph, but it's not a slamdunk the other way either, and your claim that you can't have a monopoly on IPhone apps because IPhone is apple's product is fundamentally flawed (rather, if it's true, it's because purchasing an IPhone is akin to signing a contract that you will only use IPhone apps distributed from Apple, and that you will only use Apple's payment system on those IPhone apps).

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by nodamage on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:59PM (#24585842)
Note that Eastman Kodak is viewed in legal circles as the exception to the general rule of disallowing single-brand relevant markets, due to the particular circumstances of the case.

In Kodak, customers originally purchased Kodak copiers without any restrictions, and then several years later Kodak changed their policy and stopped selling repair parts to third-party servicers, which left customers locked into buying repair services from Kodak instead.

In Newcal, IKON amended their lease agreements with their customers without disclosing to the customers that the length of their service contracts would be extended as well, similarly leaving customers locked into buying services from IKON.

In both of those cases, there was an element of deception, and customers did not know that they would be restricted in the aftermarket when they made their original purchase. It's tough to argue that those circumstances apply here, since Apple's policies have been clear since the launch of the App Store and have never changed. In fact, some courts have interpreted Kodak to mean that absent a change in policy, Kodak does not apply.

Note that the paragraph you quoted specifically says: "the law permits an inquiry into whether a consumer's selection of a particular brand in the competitive market is the functional equivalent of a contractual commitment, giving that brand an agreed-upon right to monopolize its consumers in an aftermarket." I expect Apple will be able to successfully convince the court that this is indeed the case.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:06PM (#24585874)
If I was epic I think I would be focusing on the fact that consumers generally don't have any idea about the restriction on payment providers, and that the terms of that restriction have changed over time.

But that gives up on half the case, so we'll see what they do.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by nodamage on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:58PM (#24586138)
That's true, but for Epic's tying claim they've argued that the tying product is iOS app distribution and the tied product is payment processing, which again relies on establishing that iOS app distribution is in fact a valid antitrust market.

If that fails, they might be able to amend their claim to argue that iPhones are the tying product, but then that opens up a different set of questions about how much market power Apple has in the overall smartphone market.

(They also need to establish that payment processing is actually a distinct product or service from app distribution, which is not necessarily obviously true and depends on a separate set of factors.)

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by zaroth on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:51PM (#24585794)
> "Your claim that you can't have a monopoly on IPhone apps because IPhone is apple's product is fundamentally flawed".

I never claimed that at all.

It's a question for the courts to decide if it wants to allow Apple's current App Store contract to stand, and if not, what remedy they propose. But it wouldn't be because Apple has a "monopoly" on the iPhone or iOS, it would ride partly on the question of, from your own source, "whether consumers entered into such "contracts" knowing that they were agreeing to such a commitment", and I suppose partly on whether the contract is illegally anti-competitive even if it was entered into knowingly.

Further quoting from your own source, Newcal v Icon;

"First and foremost, the relevant market must be a product market. The consumers do not define the boundaries of the market; the products or producers do. Second, the market must encompass the product at issue as well as all economic substitutes for the product. As the Supreme Court has instructed, "The outer boundaries of a product market are determined by the reasonable interchangeability of use or the cross-elasticity of demand between the product itself and substitutes for it." As such, the relevant market must include "the group or groups of sellers or producers who have actual or potential ability to deprive each other of significant levels of business."

Further reading of that case (a great example by the way) involves discussion of an interesting case against Domino's pizza. Franchisees attempted to sue because they were contractually required to purchase ingredients from Domino's, and Domino's therefore held a monopoly on their ingredients. It's not that substitute ingredients didn't exist, they just weren't allowed by Domino's to buy them.

Similarly with the App Store, it's not that other apps don't exist, it's just that contracturally, iOS doesn't allow you to download them. There is a competitive market for apps (very clearly!) but yet the market for apps on an iPhone is contractually limited in a way which you might be tempted to call a monopoly. The Third Circuit ruled otherwise. As long as customers knowingly entered into this contract, the existence of the contract provision does not create a illegal monopoly.

> "The Third Circuit held that the contractually created difference among otherwise-substitutable products was insufficient to create an economically distinct antitrust submarket."

The counter argument is given as Kodak v. Image Technical Services. In this case, Kodak is monopolizing the market for repair parts and services. The Supreme Court rules that buyers of Kodak machines could not reasonably predict that such a purchase would lock them into buying overpriced Kodak parts and services down the line.

> The Court rejected that analogy on the ground that the consumers could not, at the time of purchase, reasonably discover that Kodak monopolized the service market and charged supracompetitive prices for its service. Id. Kodak's market power in parts and services, therefore, did not arise from a knowing contractual (or quasi-contractual), arrangement.

By comparison, no one who is buying an iPhone could reasonably be unaware that the App Store is the only way to install apps on it.

More importantly, Apple isn't being sued by consumers. It's being sued by App Developers, who did certainly quite knowingly enter into a contract with Apple to write apps for their platform.

I don't know of any statue that requires Apple to provide access to their own device to third party software developers. Third parties can write an app for iOS or not, but when they do so, developers enter into a contract with Apple that decidedly comes with some conditions.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:00PM (#24585843)
If that first sentence isn't what you meant then I'm afraid I've totally missed your point, and continue to miss it.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by zaroth on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:19PM (#24585948)
Perhaps I don't know what you mean "monopoly on iPhone Apps". I said they don't have a monopoly on iPhone or iOS, because such a statement is nonsensical.

It seems to me that you moved the goalposts to talking about iPhone apps.

I mean, they obviously don't have a monopoly on iPhone apps either (probably 99.99% of all apps are not written by Apple). What they have is significant and costly contractual terms which they require developers to agree to before they let you publish an app on their device. Some argue that those terms may be illegally anti-competitive, but it wouldn't be because of a "monopoly".

The court case you referenced emphatically states that explicit contractual provisions cannot form the boundaries of an antitrust submarket.

Fundamentally consumers have a choice when they buy a smartphone. They can choose from several different manufacturers, and the market is highly competitive. The whole beauty of a capitalist market is that companies get to choose the features and experience their product provides to differentiate themselves, and as long as consumers have a choice between products, those products should live or die based on those features and experience.

Apple is clearly doing quite well in a highly competitive market making the product design choices they are making, because consumers are choosing that experience over the alternative.

To bring it back to the Kodak case, if we were to consider whether Apple has a monopoly on iPhone repair & service, I would say, "Hey gpm, that's entirely possible. I don't know if they do or don't, but it's important that they aren't anti-competitively dominating that market!" Repair and service of a brand is logically quite different from the brand itself.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by freedomben on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:32PM (#24583266)
> To the extent that people find the lock in useful, I expect they would install that software package.

Deep down I would guess that most people will still object on consequentialist grounds, because they know that not enough people will opt in unless forced, and so vendors will be able to ignore the walled garden. Apple sure as hell wouldn't be able to take 30% if there were other ways onto the iPhone, as big vendors would avoid it, thus requiring most users to give up the safe walled garden.

I still come out strongly against Apple on this one however as I am not a consequentialist.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by valuearb on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:40PM (#24584511)
Selling separately destroys the iPhone brand and business model. Far fewer would pay for a separate OS, iPhones would have to be more expensive if they didn’t bundle a services component, customers wouldn’t trust iPhone as much.

There is a simple solution, and it’s not misguided delusional antitrust talk. It’s buying the other type of smartphone that is 85% of unit sales world wide.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by reificator on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:53PM (#24585044)
Two choices for something as complex as a smartphone does not make a free market.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by valuearb on Thursday September 24, 2020 @11:57PM (#24586430)
It’s far more than two choices since their are hundreds of Android manufacturers, many whom add their own software to the stack. It’s more like dozens of differentiated competitors, of which Apple is rate largest but still only a small minority of the market.

There aren’t many freer markets. The automobile business was still a free market when Henry Ford refused to paint cars in your choice of color.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by reificator on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:52AM (#24586684)
And how many of those phones don't run Google Play Services?

Right now your choices are "Google doesn't spy on me" or "I can sideload apps or use alternative stores".

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by temp667 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:46PM (#24583403)
You don't have to agree with apple, but they clearly think the halo effect of having just one reasonably fair app store on their platform increases their platform brand power and profits both. I think they are right.

Can I ask a question. When your elderly parents or kids ask for a phone (assuming they are not developers), does it give you no comfort that if its an apple from end to end including app store things will be a bit more reasonable?

And you do realize if things are unbundled, then EVERY phone company will dump their crap onto every users phone except for the folks who know enough to go uninstall / use the lockout thing you are talking about. And you don't think that will damage the overall apple brand?

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:24PM (#24583851)
> You don't have to agree with apple, but they clearly think the halo effect of having just one reasonably fair app store on their platform increases their platform brand power and profits both. I think they are right.

I agree, but "it makes us more money and gives us more power" has never been a defense against anti-trust law. Indeed if this was not true I imagine that anti-trust law would never have been necessary in the first place.

> Can I ask a question. When your elderly parents or kids ask for a phone (assuming they are not developers), does it give you no comfort that if its an apple from end to end including app store things will be a bit more reasonable?

First I have to point out that the unbundling solution solves this problem entirely. I just install the "lock this to the apple ecosystem" software before I give them the phone and I get all the current benefits as it pertains to children and elderly tech-dependents with none of the anti-trust issues.

I have to admit that I can only answer this question in theory. I have no kids (and don't plan on future kids) and my parents are more technically competent than average. The extent that I manage their technology is "this is good value for the price" and installing ublock origin everywhere.

The honest theoretical answer though is I don't think it would. There are a number of reasons for this.

- I really don't trust the app store to stop abusive behaviors in the first place.

- I could lock probably lock down an Android to the extent that I'm as happy as I would be with an apple (not very).

- I would (and do) worry a hell of a lot more about the internet than I would (do) about apps.

- I worry about the internet a hell of a lot more on IPhones than I do on androids, because I can't install a proper adblocker, because of Apples anti-competitive policies regarding browsers (the ad blocking api's in safari are gimped compared to firefox).

- At the point where I don't trust someone with a phone, I also wouldn't trust them with a credit card in general... at which point none of the payment stuff is problematic (But I acknowledge that the social reality w.r.t. the elderly and credit cards makes this a hard problem).

> And you do realize if things are unbundled, then EVERY phone company will dump their crap onto every users phone except for the folks who know enough to go uninstall / use the lockout thing you are talking about. And you don't think that will damage the overall apple brand?

This can be solved with apple only providing phones to sellers who agree not to do that easily enough. While I know epic has some issues with this strategy (as it pertains to Google and pre-installing fortnite) I do not.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jrnichols on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @12:06AM (#24624071)
> I worry about the internet a hell of a lot more on IPhones than I do on androids, because I can't install a proper adblocker, because of Apples anti-competitive policies regarding browsers (the ad blocking api's in safari are gimped compared to firefox).

This is silly. Who determines what a "proper adblocker" is? There are plenty of adblockers available for iOS. In fact, you can even use Firefox AS an adblocker.

This is a non-issue.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jrnichols on Tuesday September 29, 2020 @07:20PM (#24634200)
I am not surprised to see a downvote. It's sad to see that the Apple hatred from reddit has spilled over here as well. Was anything I said inaccurate?

No, it wasn't. OP there made a ridiculous complaint and demonstrated a lack of technical knowledge. Yet I get voted down for being correct?

I see.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by bad_user on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:57PM (#24584153)
On the ad-blocking side, Android fans are blowing this out of proportion.

First of all, Safari’s content blockers, while far less capable than uBO, are pretty adequate for the time being. In my experience, iOS Safari + Wipr is fine.

Also, and this point is underrated, content blockers work in most app web views. For example Twitter’s or Gmail’s. Not all web views of course. Facebook for example chooses to use a web view, for opening links, that doesn’t have support for ad blockers.

Moreover, alternative browsers, such as Firefox, or Edge, or Brave, or Vivaldi, could still implement ad blocking. Not via an extension, but built in. And they in fact do. Microsoft’s Edge included.

Firefox on iOS is a little weak of course. They are only blocking domains meant for tracking, and they use the Disconnect list. Which is rather short. But they do take care of common ad exchanges, when in strict mode.

Also, Safari itself blocks third party tracking by default. It doesn’t block the requests themselves, but it does block the cookies they set. So it doesn’t block a request to Google Analytics, but it does block its cookie. New in iOS 14 is that this capability became available to all web views. So including Firefox on iOS. Users have to opt-out if they don’t want it.

Also iOS 14 has disabled the advertising ID, by default. Users have to opt-in explicitly, screwing the plans of Facebook, whose SDK is used by a lot of apps to gather metrics.

I would love to have full Firefox on iOS, but truth is, this is a false narrative. Given Firefox’s popularity on Android, I can tell you that iOS users are in fact more protected from trackers and ads, out of the box.

And it’s not just about Firefox’s popularity btw, I’m a huge Firefox supporter, but on Android it sucked in terms of performance, behavior, and compatibility with the web. From simple things, like pinching to zoom, with the fonts getting all blurry. As a technical user, you might live with that, but you wouldn’t subject your parents to it.

You make it seem like on Android you have choices. Well, not really. Most people use Chrome, or Samsung’s browser. On iOS, did you know that the only browser without ad blocking capabilities is Chrome?

Not to mention that you can also do DNS-level blocking, via NextDNS, or Pi-hole.

And there’s another aspect. My son has an Android and a majority of games are ads-driven. Imagine a drawing app that forces kids to click for more ads in order to receive clues/rewards, without which they can’t advance in the game. Quite brilliant if you ask me. It also forces them to disable any ad blocking that their parents installed ;-)

Well, on iOS people actually spend money on apps. And Apple has a new subscription even, called Apple Arcade, which gives people access to a collection of games without any ads, or in-app purchases. Just pay a subscription, and the games can’t play tricks on you. This is what curation does.

Unfortunately my son wanted an Android for now. So I’ll have to wait about 2 years, until his Android tables becomes unsupported and obsolete. And in the meantime my iPad Pro from 2015 will still be upgradable to the latest iOS.

If you’re saying that you can’t trust iOS’s ecosystem more than Android, for you children, then you’re seriously unfamiliar with it, sorry.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jamienicol on Friday September 25, 2020 @04:46AM (#24587888)
> From simple things, like pinching to zoom, with the fonts getting all blurry.

This is an aside to your conversation, but just wanted say we're currently rolling out webrender to more devices in the new version of Firefox for android, and it fixes the blurriness when zooming.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by bad_user on Friday September 25, 2020 @07:00AM (#24588566)
That's awesome to hear, thanks!

Also I like the new version on Android, hopefully it will reach feature with the older version.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by greycol on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:16PM (#24583768)
Sure Apple can create their area of trust/safety/security in their apple store allowing those who want that to stay there. They can't however do that on a device they've sold to customers.

The question from a principle standpoint is - can companies stop a customer from modifying a device they own when it only effects the customer.

Or more realistically there is more than one question and you have to make trade offs between the right answer to all of them (and what people believe the right answer to be).

My view is: Make it hard to install out of App store, warn people about all the security/trust/safety there losing each time they enable a fine grained permissions. It's a simple security rule; don't install anything not in the app store, yes pay the 30% premium for that security. Yes it's not perfect but the current situation definitely isn't either.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by spideymans on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:55PM (#24582856)
>Trust / security / safety are low low low on the list of almost all startup and other developers "growth hacking" etc.

Yeah I find this general argument that developers should be "trusted" with the "freedom" of an "open" ecosystem, with all those happy buzzwords, so off-putting. I mean, sure, I might perhaps trust the small indie developer working out of his basement to not screw me over, but by and large the software that end users are interacting with are coming out of faceless billion dollar behemoths looking to squeeze every dollar out of their users (and associated data) as possible. I have zero reason to trust them, particularly given the conduct of the Internet giants (ahem... Facebook).

Perhaps if these businesses had a more user-friendly business model, end users would've been comfortable using a less restrictive mobile software platforms, similar to what we used to have on desktop computers. Facebook et all have reaped what they sowed, and they get zero sympathy from me regarding their App Store situation. They're the reason that users (even on HN) generally celebrate when Apple imposes an ever growing list of privacy restrictions on their activities.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jariel on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:25AM (#24587420)
Apple can have their garden, nobody is complaining.

The issue is one of choice and consumers ability to go beyond the walled garden.

The issue of 'scams' is a canard: there are browsers on iPhones that allow users to be involved in any number of hustles.

"Now the same folks who trashed a lot of the rest of the web (do you answer your phone when an unkown number calls?) want into the walled apple garden."

This just doesn't make any sense, moreover, it has nothing to do with 30% margins.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by cma on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:43PM (#24584539)
> Apple wanted to create their own little world. Phones with updates that keep on getting updated, an app marketplace with much more transparent pricing (lot less fine print), and the list goes on.

Other than anti-trust and similar laws, there is nothing stopping Apple from eventually creeping it onto the web. It's "their" device after all.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by bonaldi on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:43PM (#24582045)
The wider context around the specific issues can still be useful in deciding what's "best" (distinct from "right"). EG: look at the antitrust case Apple lost over eBook pricing. The rules said they should lose in order to ensure a fair market for eBooks, a minute's consideration of the wider context said that if they lost Amazon would suck up the entire market. Which it did. The net result, even if narrowly within the rules, was a loss for consumers and for competition
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by stefan_ on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:57PM (#24582893)
No, the rules say organizing a price fixing ring is illegal. The result of which was literally to simultaneously raise prices for consumers across all platforms.

It's particularly ironic in this case because the whole point of the exercise for Apple was to increase prices so they could still charge their extortionate 30%. Amazon wasn't remotely that greedy.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by valuearb on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:35PM (#24584478)
That’s the silliest perspective on this case you could have. Apple gave publishers the right to set their own prices, but in return required they don’t undercut those prices on other platforms.

Apple had only a a small market share at the time. Publishers could have said, nah, we are happy with Amazon, and refused to agree to Apple’s terms. This is about as clear a free market as one gets, that it became an antitrust issue shows how crazytown antitrust law has become.

This was attractive to Publishers because they were terrified of an Amazon monopoly. Amazon selling ebooks at cost did nothing for Publishers long term because it was killing other ebook competitors. This offered a viable competitor to be an ebook outlet.

Instead the misguided Justice department and a judge made Apple back down and what do we have now? Exactly what publishers feared, an Amazon monopoly.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by rebelos on Thursday September 24, 2020 @10:56PM (#24586130)
"It's awful that a $2 trillion tech company's price fixing conspiracy flatlined and consumers in 2020 pay really low ebook prices. What is American justice coming to?"
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by kelnos on Friday September 25, 2020 @12:02AM (#24586458)
Do we, though? I feel like most ebooks on Amazon are priced similarly to their paperback counterparts, or at least not significantly lower to the point that it reflects the fact that they don't have to manufacture a physical good or get someone to drive a truck to bring it to me.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by moate on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:13AM (#24586772)
I mean you’re tying value to cost which is weird for art (which is the majority of e-books, novels)

This is like complaining a painting is too expensive because the canvas and paint only cost 100 dollars.

The major value of a book, to a consumer, is the words it contains not the paper it’s printed on.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by austhrow743 on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:20AM (#24586799)
Forget art, they're a software developer working for a software company that produces software for other software developers. Zero physical items created. Sit around all day getting paid great money to produce nothing tangible and then thinks something dodgy must be happening for ebooks to be close to physical books in price. Very odd.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by kelnos on Friday October 02, 2020 @12:52AM (#24659002)
> The major value of a book, to a consumer, is the words it contains not the paper it’s printed on.

Yes, and that's exactly my point.

If a paperback book is priced at $10, and it costs $2 to manufacture, $1 to ship, and $3 to market (made-up numbers, but the values don't matter), with the rest going to the author/publisher, then we're saying that piece of art is worth $4. If the e-book edition costs $8, perhaps that $3 marketing cost is still there, but the marginal cost of storage and distribution is probably a few cents... so somehow now that piece of art is worth $7? That doesn't add up.

I mean, I get it: the price you pay for something is generally just the highest price that the market will bear, a price that maximizes profit... and the "intrinsic value" of something doesn't matter or maybe doesn't even exist. Even the cost to produce it may not matter, if the seller wants to use a particular item as a loss-leader.

What I object to is, back when e-books started being a thing, the big promise was that they'd be so much cheaper than physical books, because the marginal cost to "produce" and "ship" one is near-zero. But of course that promise never materialized; it was just marketing to get people to buy Kindles.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by valuearb on Friday September 25, 2020 @05:58PM (#24594542)
From the Department of Justices perspective value is tied to price. They wanted to stop Apple from asking for price parity with other outlets because it would drive prices up.

And what happened after their victory is that prices didn’t go down, they look like they went up.

Of course this has little to do with the artists, they typically don’t get to price their novels, and only get a royalty that’s not likely impacted much either way. Higher prices are higher royalties per unit, sure, but if they lead to lower unit sales it’s not likely better.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by Nullabillity on Friday September 25, 2020 @01:00PM (#24591809)
Price = value of art + distribution cost

The art itself hasn't changed, so it makes sense to demand that the price follows when the distribution cost approaches zero.

As for whether that would actually happen...

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jariel on Friday September 25, 2020 @03:22AM (#24587403)
"This is about as clear a free market as one gets, that it became an antitrust issue shows how crazytown antitrust law has become."

It has nothing to do with platform prix fixing, it has to do with de-facto monopoly over a portion of US mobile devices, or rather, an oligarchy between Google and Apple.

The same issues existed with oil, electricity and telephone networks - there were claims of 'choice' but really there was not.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by TYPE_FASTER on Thursday September 24, 2020 @07:00PM (#24584672)
Royalties for self publishing an ebook on Amazon top out at 70%.

https://kdp.amazon.com/en_US/help/topic/G200644210

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by eecc on Friday September 25, 2020 @02:49AM (#24587204)
Are you suggesting someone other than Apple is making extortionate margins?

/s

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by traib on Thursday September 24, 2020 @09:41PM (#24585741)
"Best" for whom? Any action has the potential to be either good or bad, depending on who you ask. But if it has a positive impact on society as a whole - that's probably good enough. And striving to do the right thing, upholding important beliefs like fair access to justice and freedom of speech, these certainly fall in that category.

If a smaller company, or even one of us on HN had sued Apple would that suddenly make it okay? Apple's actions haven't changed, why should the identity of the plaintiff matter?

Regarding your specific example - if Amazon is doing something wrong, then an antitrust case should be brought against them too. But that doesn't (and shouldn't) give anyone the right to continue doing something unethical and illegal.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by munk-a on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:08PM (#24583676)
The ethics of speech protection and laws are a complicated subject - I strongly agree that being moral judgements into punishments is a dark road that has led to a lot of racism and other discrimination in the past... but justice isn't blind and unmoving, justice should evolve to reinforce changes in ethical thinking in society at large. There have been several prominent incidents recently that have shown that the portion of legal enforcement relying on societal norms in the US has been broken, I think due to our general acceptance that greed and money are good and having those things means you've succeeded in life.

Legal judgments that leave a bad taste in your mouth shouldn't be ignored but examined to see if the laws that we have actually fit the society we're trying to maintain - people shouldn't be arbitrarily persecuted for actions and ex post facto protections are very well intentioned and wisely put in place to protect against some really heinous abuses - but questioning whether the law should be changed to prevent future incidents isn't bad - it's how our legal system evolves.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by rtikulit on Saturday September 26, 2020 @11:50AM (#24599665)
I think the discussion and analysis of each company's prior behaviour is exactly on point--the question before humanity in the general case is "what are these companies really up to?"

Each (including Apple) has a hidden agenda. They can be both beneficial and harmful. They are not our friends! They deserve our scrutiny, suspicion and supervision.

A company is a system that was created to pursue an agenda. That agenda is nothing like the agenda of a typical human individual (except at absurd levels of abstraction) and is not necessarily net-beneficial to actual humans in the short or the long run.

It's an axiom of systems analysis that behaviour trumps speech when you are trying to figure out what a system is really up to. To say it another way, we would like to identify the actual operant utility functions of these companies, so we can predict what they are really working towards, and what their behaviour and impact might be in the future. Their prior behaviour is the best signal we have!

To force the discussion to revolve around "laws" and "right" is to pretend that current ethical positions and laws are optimal and can't be gamed. A superficial inspection will show these premises are false.

The ongoing work of governance is to try to figure out economic, social and legal rules that "work" for some consensus definition of "work". That requires a clear understanding of what is actually happening, and good scenario analysis for the range of possible outcomes (including unintended consequences). Maybe that's unrestricted free markets, maybe sometimes it isn't. Maybe it's the law as it currently stands, maybe it isn't.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jariel on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:16PM (#24581672)
The issue is 'anti competitiveness' not 'evil' and most arguments are pointed at that.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @02:21PM (#24581754)
Things have improved since I posted this.

At the time I posted this the top comment and many other highly voted comments were just criticizing epic, spotify, and tinder. E.g. complaining that epic sells to kids, spotify doesn't pay artists enough, and that tinder sells sex and commits age discrimination.

Regardless of whether or not they are valid complaints, they aren't at all related to anti trust (or if they are, no one was bothering to make the connection).

This use to be the top comment, for reference: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24579860

This was the comment that was the tipping point for me making the post, and was at the time ranked fairly highly (hence all the replies to it): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24579479

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by anm89 on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:37PM (#24583980)
Well said.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by jlelse on Thursday September 24, 2020 @12:34PM (#24580430)
> All the arguments about what company is most evil entirely miss the point.

This!

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by geodel on Thursday September 24, 2020 @01:54PM (#24581383)
> I'm strongly reminded of the quote "Freedom of speech doesn't protect speech you like; it protects speech you don't like...

Modern addendum is "You can have Freedom Of Speech but no guarantee for Freedom After speech."

Edit: Just to clarify, It is not my opinion. It is Social media warriors warning people "Free speech is not free of consequences"

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by mercurysmessage on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:19PM (#24582448)
"Free speech is not free of consequences"

This is absolutely true though? I fail to see your point.

You are free to say what you want, and other people are free to criticize you for it. If you don't support the right to criticize, you don't support free speech.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by RonanTheGrey on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:46PM (#24582735)
Depends on the consequences. Usually this is invoked to mean "it's fine for me burn down your business or destroy your life because I don't like you because consequences <grin>"

In general, the statement CANNOT be true, because the chilling effect explicitly suppresses free speech -- being a result of consequences. Ergo, consequence (of a particular type) is in fact suppression of free speech.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by lucisferre on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:47PM (#24584070)
> Usually this is invoked to mean "it's fine for me burn down your business or destroy your life because I don't like you because consequences <grin>"

What a ridiculous hyperbole of what it "usually" means.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by geodel on Thursday September 24, 2020 @04:04PM (#24582969)
It is more of "free to criticize' vs 'free to destroy livelihood' thing. Some would say both are same or second is just an implementation detail of first.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by alkonaut on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:06PM (#24583655)
Free speech is the right to not be arrested for speaking. It's not the right to not be punched in the face for saying stupid things (there is a separate law for face punching).
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by seneca on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:13PM (#24583726)
> Free speech is the right to not be arrested for speaking. It's not the right to not be punched in the face for saying stupid things (there is a separate law for face punching).

No, the 1st Amendment is the right to not be arrested for speaking (in the United States). Free Speech is a philosophy that would absolutely cover not committing physical violence against someone for what they say. Violence in response to speech is probably a good starting point for the definition of unfree speech.

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by gpm on Thursday September 24, 2020 @05:36PM (#24583975)
This is spot on. In addition the first amendment is theoretically protection against punching you in the face not being prohibited because of something you said. The government could make face punching legal in general, but not legal only if the victim first makes an idiot out of themselves.
Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by alkonaut on Thursday September 24, 2020 @06:51PM (#24584606)
Yes, the reason we have laws against face punching people who say dumb things is partly to protect free speech in the philosophical sense (there are obviously other reasons too, such as that it hurts).

This still doesn’t mean that speech without consequences is possible. The grandparent comment mentioned the loss of a livelihood as an example (unsure exactly what it refers to but could be e.g boycotts).

Re:Epic, Spotify, and Tinder form advocacy group to push for... by DevKoala on Thursday September 24, 2020 @03:13PM (#24582390)
I struggled to read your comment, but it shouldn’t be ignored. What you are saying is correct.