News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by yalogin on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @09:56AM (#24408384)
That was the reason why it fell? In that case looks liem they made the right decision not to include it. Any stock that moves 20% on this kind of decision is fundamentally flawed.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sokoloff on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:00AM (#24408418)
TSLA shares fell back to levels not seen since August 17th, 3 entire weeks ago. In the meantime, the company confirmed that it sold $5Billion of additional shares into the market last week. It's not just the S&P news, IMO.

Disclaimer: I am short $TSLA since about 2 weeks ago, because I can't wrap my head around the valuation and near parabolic move short-term. I do think that they are more valuable than some other large automakers, but probably not more than all of them put together. :)

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by wp381640 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:14AM (#24408570)
I almost pulled a short a few weeks ago but couldn't bite the bullet because the market is so damn irrational I wouldn't be surprised if TSLA was meme'd up to a trillion

Tend to stay away from anything that is "my cousins friend at work asked how to buy stocks because he wants to buy x"

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by vsareto on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:21AM (#24408641)
>Tend to stay away from anything that is "my cousins friend at work asked how to buy stocks because he wants to buy x"

Oh, so basically the entire stock market during the pandemic?

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by wp381640 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:24AM (#24408679)
Had tons of upside on mid-cap techs which tend to go under the radar and the usual apple, amzon, google which for some reason aren't sexy

But, ye - things are crazy at the moment with retail investors

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by bryanlarsen on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:14AM (#24408563)
> I do think that they are more valuable than some other large automakers, but probably not more than all of them put together. :)

The Enterprise Value of Tesla ($398B) is only slightly more than the Enterprise Value of Toyota ($337B). VW's is $224B. They have a valuation larger than any other automaker, but not even close to that of all put together.

EV = market cap + debt - free cash

Not including debt in a company's valuation is like saying that the valuation of my house is only $100K if I still have a $400K mortgage on my $500K house.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by the-dude on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:02AM (#24408429)
And Softbank.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by omgwtfbyobbq on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:07AM (#24408478)
That's what I was thinking too. With all the short interest, they're an attractive target to push upwards.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:12AM (#24408533)
> Disclaimer: I am short $TSLA since about 2 weeks ago

How/where did you get shares to short? At what margin interest rate are you having to pay?

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sokoloff on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:18AM (#24408604)
Etrade. It isn't even listed as a "hard to borrow" security (just confirmed that by entering a proto-order and confirming another security that is hard-to-borrow does give a warning at that point in the flow).

Per that, I'd imagine any brokerage would allow you to short them.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by arthurcolle on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:18AM (#24408608)
he's probably using puts
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sokoloff on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:23AM (#24408668)
No. I'm outright shorting the shares. Implied volatility is so high now as to make buying options fairly unattractive for medium and long-term bets.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by arthurcolle on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @04:47PM (#24425745)
You could be using spreads to hedge out the vega risk, not a huge deal.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by MuffinFlavored on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:11AM (#24409184)
Say you want to short $10,000 worth of TSLA shares, what kind of margin interest rate are you paying? Is it 8%/yr?
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sokoloff on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:22AM (#24409297)
I've held the shares short for short enough time that I haven't gotten tagged with any charges yet to give you actuals. The interest is super-low in any case, so when you're shorting shares that have moved parabolically, you're probably not worried about whether the borrow is 1% or 4% per year (or at least I'm not).
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by WhompingWindows on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:14AM (#24408572)
I think they're a scientifically-based "story"/"brand" stock based on climate science and reticence to change from other car makers...but, tangentially, if we have a recent influx of wealthy liberal people who believe climate is a huge threat, doesn't it make sense that the objectively best BEV maker is going to get a ton of interest from these investors who haven't lost income and wealth due to COVID and are looking for future-proof assets?

Maybe $TSLA and the market at large wouldn't be doing so well if rich investors could still spend money on vacations, luxury events, concerts, travel, etc?

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by extremeMath on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:29AM (#24408725)
I feel so conflicted when I read posts that consider Tesla "the best". I did benchmarking on all automotive interiors, exteriors, and infotainment systems, and Tesla was Kia level.

The interiors and exteriors were actually bad. The infotainment system was buggy and cheap, but it was feature rich and fast. If it wasn't Tesla, people would hate it for not having buttons.

The reliability is notoriously bad too.

I don't see any genuine argument for "Best", they might have the hardest, lowest paid workers, or the only car you can natively play a 30 year old video game, but when comparing Tesla to Nissan or GM EVs, I don't see why you'd get a Tesla.

It's more expensive and you get less.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sokoloff on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:33AM (#24408769)
I daily drive (well, pre-COVID anyway) a Nissan LEAF. The interior on the LEAF (a $22K car to me) seemed at least as nice as the 3-5x as expensive Model S that colleagues own.

However, if they were the same price, I'd much, much rather have the Tesla. Nissan's battery tech [and capacity] is way worse than Tesla's.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by dingaling on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:44AM (#24409514)
>Tesla was Kia level

Kia offer a seven-year warranty, even on the battery. And are joint first in the 2020 JD Powers survey.

Tesla are nowhere near that level. Your benchmarking is flawed.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by andreilys on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:45AM (#24408904)
Signaling effect of owning a Tesla is much higher than a Nissan or GM EV.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by gumby on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:13AM (#24408556)
> Any stock that moves 20% on this kind of decision is fundamentally flawed.

When a stock join an index, all the index funds (which simply passively follow the index) have to purchase a proportionate amount of that Stock (and got rid of whatever stock was ejected). Sonic you think stock X will go into an index you know that there will soon be a brief surge in demand for shares of X. Why now own some so that when that surge happens you’ll make a quick profit? Oops, didn’t join, so now you probably want to get rid of thats tick you just held to flip.

I don’t think Tesla is a good investment but this particular and unusual case is not why.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by LatteLazy on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:17AM (#24408601)
Wouldn't any stock that was removed from the index fall 20% as indexers sold it? This is the power of Indexes, not the weakness of Tesla isn't it? (I am actually glad it didn't make it in as I think it's too volatile and also I want to buy some :) )
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by qaq on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:02AM (#24408432)
And what would be a reasonable drop?
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by xirbeosbwo1234 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:08AM (#24408485)
Probably about 95% based on fundamentals.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sroussey on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:55AM (#24409026)
I remember Cisco, Qualcomm, and Amazon falling 80-90% last tech crash.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by bumby on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:50AM (#24408967)
I know you may have meant that tongue-in-cheek, but do you think they should fundamentally be valued as a traditional manufacturer or as a tech stock?
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by kingnothing on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:08AM (#24409161)
Tech companies can build something one time and sell it a million times. Tesla builds one car, one powerwall, one roof, and sells it one time. It is more akin to a manufacturer than a tech stock.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by bumby on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:34AM (#24409413)
That’s a good distinction. Would that also imply APPL is not a traditional tech stock but more of a tech/consumer hardware stock? I haven’t looked yet but I’d be Cypriots how their valuation compares in that light
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by kingnothing on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @03:11PM (#24411844)
Apple is an interesting one. They definitely have a consumer hardware division, but there's also the app store where they take a big cut of everything sold through it. Other than reviewing apps, they built it once and get to reap profits off of it indefinitely. Same for music, tv, iCloud backups, etc.
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by rsynnott on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:16AM (#24409237)
Traditional manufacturer. Saying "we're a tech company over and over" isn't going to make the global ASP for cars double, and they would ultimately need both that, and grabbing an unrealistically large part of the market, to justify their current price.

(The solar business is even worse; that's basically a generic product and should be expected to have extremely low margins in the long term)

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sroussey on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:57AM (#24409052)
Why tongue-in-cheek?
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by bumby on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @11:07AM (#24409146)
Maybe it wasn’t meant that way, but it can certainly be read if one considers the “95%” as an exaggeration. That’s why I was trying to clarify if it was meant to be out of line with “cyclical manufacturing” or with “tech”
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by sroussey on Wednesday September 09, 2020 @01:47PM (#24423665)
The idea that Tesla should have a “tech” multiple, which generally means 80% margins and high growth rates, is kinda scary, since they don’t have either. 80-95% drop would be reasonable if and when it loses its “story”.

But it can use its valuation to bring in capital to try and make the business into something else.

Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by doopy-loopy2 on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:11AM (#24408521)
haha
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by justjonathan on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:04AM (#24408453)
The reason it fell?https://xkcd.com/904/
Re:Tesla Shares Fall as It Fails to Make It into S&P 500 Index by vsareto on Tuesday September 08, 2020 @10:10AM (#24408517)
Idk how anyone can look at Tesla and see that it's "fundamentally" flawed.