I think the problem you're running into is that you just aren't used to these words. I imagine people having the exact same complaints about a computer "mouse" actually reminding them of the animal or "paste" reminding them of glue, but once you get used to them they just become the terms for things.
There was one memorable time when this happened, and as I was walking the user through their Dial-Up Network Settings configuration, I asked him to right-click on his dial up connection icon, and he had trouble understanding me. I said something to the effect of, "does your mouse have two buttons?", and he replied, "yes, and I'm mashing this critter right here".
So the parallels of the peripheral and the rodent are not lost on everyone.
And you can do even worse: translate "by default" with "in caso di successo" (trans.: "in case of success")
Or also very bad: translate "by default" with "alla scrittura su disco" (trans.: "when writing on disk")
At least the new term must not mean anything else than what it should.
La moda in statistica è il corretto termine classico.
As a native speaker I would never read - in context - "ometti" as little men. IE: "Se ometti un parametro...". Every language is context sensitive.
Same for "moda", when I read: "moda, mediana e media..." I would never - ever - think that "moda" is, in the context, "fashion".
"resto" - as used in: "Here is your change" - "Ecco il tuo resto" - would never be read as such in context. IE: the nursery song [1] "Quarantaquattro gatti, in fila per sei col *resto* di due" is an example of unambiguous use in the context of maths.
So: in context all these words make sense, as it's the case with many words in many languages.
[1] https://youtu.be/2jDOj0Xhcc8Maybe it’s fake etymology, but it works
https://hsm.stackexchange.com/questions/7675/what-is-the-ety...
Now look at programming in English and it has the same "issues". "bug" means defect when it could also mean a little critter. "super" means the parent class? How do people know you don't mean the superlative? How does "short", "float", "long" describe numbers? You "catch" things? "map" and "dictionary" certainly aren't the things I have on my coffee table by the same name. I've heard of race being a "protected class", but not a "BeanFactory" being one.
It was always arbitrary from the start.
You're making the same mistake that beginners make when they think "ugh, English is so much more precise than this language I'm unfamiliar with!" when they are completely blind to the ambiguities of English that we take for granted.
Similarly, a "file" is a bundle of papers, not an individual document. A "program" lists things that will happen in a performance, but it's not an instruction sheet. An "application" is a form that you fill in for a bureaucrat. Etc.
You can just about support the computer sense by thinking that a default choice is used when a user has failed in their duty to make an explicit choice, etc. But it is a bit of a stretch.
Of course, by now, the computer sense has fed back into broader usage, so it just seems like a perfectly ordinary use of the word.
No way: the correct translation of "by default" is "valore predefinito", anyone who translates it "per difetto" has serious issues with Italian language.
" "by default". In Italian it is translated (correctly) "per difetto" "
Correctly? Not at all!
Please don't take as given Google Translate's translations.
https://dizionari.repubblica.it/Inglese-Italiano/D/default.h...
Nowadays it is not used much, but it has been for years in texts related to IT, a reference:
http://vietatoridere.blogspot.com/2012/06/default-significat...
BTW "per difetto" is also used in legal matters to mean "in mancanza"
Take a look at this http://www.treccani.it/vocabolario/difetto/
The only use of "per difetto" that existed before a translation of "by default" was ever needed is in the expression "approssimazione per difetto", and the new meaning forcefully attached to "per difetto" makes sense only in the worst nightmares after a "peperonata co' e cozze".
Picchi probably is only witness of a niche neologism, that was probably bred from a bad technical translation. But it was a bad neologism in the first place, it was incorrect right from the start.
EDIT Nevertheless I take your point: you did your research before you wrote "correctly".
No, as said it is used in legal matters, example:
https://www.brocardi.it/massimario/59534.html
And you go tell this Italian professor:
http://www.diit.unict.it/users/alongheu/linguaggi/aa0910/lez...
The point is that it is actually correct in Italian, if you think about it also in "arrotondamento per difetto" (as opposed to arrotondamento per eccesso")[1] the meaning is that of "arrotondamento per mancanza", i.e. meaning #1 in the Treccani dictionary while it is much more commonly perceived as meaning #2.
[1] respectively "round down" and "round up"
At first sight this (default = difetto) looked like so many careless anglicisms, where a faint similarity in sound and meaning induces someone into believing it is a translation.
And this happens really more than needed in technical texts. My point was that you cannot trust technical people to make good translations, an it is outrageous that a translation is considered correct just because it was written in a book. But this does not apply here.
I am making up my mind that this was instead a delicate and careful intellectual construction that dutifully just failed to convey the meaning.
So be it.
Actually, I believe the etymological root of "default" is exactly the same as "difetto."
"from Old French defaute (12c.) "fault, defect, failure, culpability, lack, privation," from Vulgar Latin *defallita "a deficiency or failure,"" [1]
The issue is that in English this was then used to mean "failure to pay a loan" (in 1850s) and then someone in the 1960s started using it in computing to mean the option chosen if the user fails chose."
So English just stretched the meaning way beyond the original, so it's no surprise that this new meaning doesn't really match in other languages' cognates for the word.
It's not something ridiculous out of left field.
It's probably just a matter of being used to it, because nobody would complain that mean(array) is about the moral qualities of the array (seeing mean as an adj.)
A pet peeve of mine is "by default".
In Italian it is translated (correctly) "per difetto", and it is "fine" when other people already know the term, but otherways "difetto" is also the translation of "defect", and you will have a tough time explaining to a layman that it is not a "defect" in that other sense.
Another "queer" word (I found it in the Italian version of some database tools) is "ometti" (which is the correct translation of "omit") but that actually I normally read as "little men".
In Excel there is "MODE" (statistical function) that is translated into "MODA" which I read as "fashion" and "MOD" (modulo operation) which is translated into "RESTO" (which has a more common meaning of "change" in the sense of what a cashier gives you back when you pay besides that of "remainder").