News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by eddmc on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:23PM (#2424756)
There is some commentary on the terms that the Department of Justice have put on the deal here: http://www.tnooz.com/2011/04/08/news/google-ita-software-dea...

In brief:

- Google will be required to license QPX software to airfare websites on commercially reasonable terms.

- Google will be required to continue to fund research and develop the product “at least” at similar levels to what ITA had invested.

- Google will be required to develop and offer ITA’s InstaSearch product to other travel websites.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by martincmartin on Friday April 08, 2011 @07:32PM (#2425999)
By the way, Paul Graham was an early fan of ITA software, mentioning them in "Great Hackers"

http://paulgraham.com/gh.html

And even has an interview with ITA's original programming genius, Carl de Marken

http://paulgraham.com/carl.html

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by SkyMarshal on Saturday April 09, 2011 @01:18AM (#2426577)
I discovered those essays back in 2006 when I was working for an airline, and tried to get them to adapt ITA's technology for that reason. ITA was the best on the market at that time, and the e/web-marketing guys loved them too. But the bean counters deemed them too expensive and ruled them out. I left sometime after, was tired of trying to turn chicken shit into chicken salad (there were other issues involved, not just the data supply).
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by philfreo on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:17PM (#2425013)
Does anyone know what makes ITA so special? Why don't any of the big airlines have APIs that Hipmunk, Kayak, Orbitz, etc. can use directly? (Do any of them?) Seems odd that everyone should have to rely on this one company for the data, when it should be originating from the airlines.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by martincmartin on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:07PM (#2425607)
ITA's strength isn't data, it's algorithms. Finding the best flight is not just NP-complete, it's uncomputable. In practice, even a lot of sub problems are NP-complete.

http://www.demarcken.org/carl/papers/ITA-software-travel-com...

People think the problem is a graph search problem of finding the shortest path. But that's actually the easiest part of the problem. It turns out that prices aren't attached to individual flights, but rather are rules of the form "If the passenger goes from A to B on a Tuesday, the price is X, and it doesn't really matter what flights they take, as long as the total distance is less than 3 times the line of sight distance."

Then there are all sorts of rules about what fares can be combined with other fares, under which conditions, ...

I worked at ITA software on QPX, and their code is by far the most algorithmically complex code I've ever seen. As I mentioned, there are many, many sub problems, and each one is a tricky algorithm design problem.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by Homunculiheaded on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:27PM (#2425050)
Orbitz and Kayak both use them, check the wikipedia page on them for more info in that area[1]. ITA's real claim to fame, at least in communities like HN, is that they're one of the largest Common Lisp shops still around. Also my experience interacting with their employees has been that they're an exceedingly smart and talent bunch of people. Additionally, and especially if you lived in the Boston/Cambridge area, they're pretty well known for there rather challenging interview puzzles which used to be plastered all over the T [2]

[1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ITA_Software

[2] http://www.itasoftware.com/careers/puzzle_archive.html

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by MichaelSalib on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:45PM (#2425534)
I answered part of this question earlier at http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1473748

The thing to understand is that the airlines publish data that ITA uses. The problem is that it takes an incredible amount of engineering effort and algorithm smarts to go from 'published airline data' to 'this is the cheapest flight from BOS to LAX on 4/20'. ITA does have competitors; historically those competitors offered much lower quality products, although that might have changed.

One of the ITA co-founders wrote a presentation on some of these topics at http://www.demarcken.org/carl/papers/ITA-software-travel-com...

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by aerique on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:24PM (#2425043)
ITA is special not because of the data but because of what it does with the data. The others haven't been able to reproduce that. Think of it as the Google of airline data.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by nano81 on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:01PM (#2425164)
To give an example, check out http://matrix.itasoftware.com/

I've never found anything as useful or flexible for searching airline data.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by mkramlich on Friday April 08, 2011 @11:12PM (#2426395)
> Think of it as the Google of airline data.

And now they will be the Google of the Google of airline data.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:40PM (#2425087)
The data is available (not cheaply) from an company called ATPCO, which is owned by the airlines. The airlines publish fares and rules through ATPCO, and ITA, SABRE, and many others fetch the data and run the computations.

The computations are the hard part.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by philfreo on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:42PM (#2425094)
So if Hipmunk, Kayak, or whoever wanted to remove their dependency from ITA (by doing more computational stuff themselves), what's the best place for them to get their data?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:49PM (#2425553)
I'm pretty sure ATPCO is the only way to get the raw data; people who subscribe to it are not allowed to redistribute it.

As for getting processed data, that's called metasearch: scraping other sites' search engines. Kayak started out as pure metasearch, but moved to using ITA. Not sure whether they still do any scraping.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by satishmreddy on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:47PM (#2425116)
Herez my post on why google needed to buy ITA. http://bit.ly/h07ked
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by chollida1 on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:22PM (#2425452)
here's the actual link that the bit.ly link directs to:

http://www.thoughtsonconsumerweb.com/why-google-needs-to-bui...

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by dartland on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:05PM (#2425600)
While your thesis may be correct, some of your assumptions are a bit off:

1) Bing has stopped investing in travel tech, they now use Kayak for search. So do we still believe in the value prop?

2) Farecast (fare predictor) turns out to be not very valuable. So much so, that Bing couldn't even sustain development of their own search tool. Can Google do a better job of it? Maybe. Can they do a good enough job of if that it's ROI positive? I'm skeptical.

I agree that Google believes many of your assertions. I don't agree that this makes it true. Do people really need more sophisticated travel search functionality? Sure, you can imagine lots of cool stuff -- bells and whistles. But ask Kayak if their "Explore" feature (perhaps a lite version of what you can imagine Google doing with ITA) drives their business? I'd argue it's neat, good for branding and loyalty, but not at the end of the day, a major source of value.

That being said -- the key thesis of: Google trying to hold onto relevance in travel search -- is true. However, they are still pretty much a one-horse show (search revenue), and travel is one of (if not the) biggest vertical today.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by ig1 on Friday April 08, 2011 @07:20PM (#2425970)
Microsoft butchered Farecast, it never really had a chance there.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by philfreo on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:07PM (#2425612)
Citations?

I didn't know Bing was using Kayak now, and Farecast has been quite useful for me (fairly accurate) in the past.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by maayank on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:53PM (#2424900)
How cool would it be if you could type "flights to somewhere sunny for under $500 in May"

How cool would it be to receive suggestions for flights in May with clusters in my social graph as destinations?

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by hristov on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:52PM (#2425741)
Right because before I had to keep random acquaintances as friends and read their updates in order not to hurt their feelings, now I have to fly to random places in order not to hurt peoples feelings. Can't wait.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by thaumaturgy on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:37PM (#2426119)
I had a business acquaintance get her feelings hurt because I didn't follow her back when she followed me on Twitter. I looked at her feed and she literally had tweeted about her breakfast that morning.

I quit Twitter instead so that I wouldn't have to hurt anyone's feelings anymore.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by aerique on Saturday April 09, 2011 @08:32AM (#2427037)
What about just not caring whether you hurt someone's trivial feelings? That is becoming an important feeling in this ever-connected world.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by aerique on Saturday April 09, 2011 @07:39PM (#2428406)
Ugh, that should have said "important skill". Too late to edit now.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by thaumaturgy on Monday April 11, 2011 @12:35PM (#2433163)
I wasn't getting much value out of Twitter anyway (not a judgement on Twitter's value, just on what I was getting out of it), and my business depends a lot on maintaining healthy relationships with lots of people, since we grow primarily by referral. It just made sense to drop Twitter altogether and tell people instead that I don't use it.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by aerique on Monday April 11, 2011 @02:57PM (#2433833)
Sounds reasonable :-)
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by maayank on Saturday April 09, 2011 @05:26AM (#2426858)
I don't think that's a problem for everyone (I aim for linkedin/facebook separation for these reasons)... Nevertheless, you could filter by the "hide this post from" list, weights of friendship (amount of likes, views, etc.) and other statistics... Of course, this is only viable if you have friends/family all around the place, not just in your locality (definitely not for everyone). Still, seems like a nice advertising focus trick.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by eddmc on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:02PM (#2424945)
To your first question, you should take a look at http://adioso.com/ (YC W09) by http://news.ycombinator.com/user?id=tomhoward

Has been covered a few times on HN already e.g. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1651737

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by maayank on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:05PM (#2424963)
The first question is not mine, but a quote from the article. But I never knew of Adioso and it seems quite neat! So thanks :)
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by geeosh on Saturday April 09, 2011 @01:24PM (#2427555)
I'm working on something like that -- I'm starting with discovering where you can go on your airline miles, but it's all visual. I'm planning on integrating suggestions of low miles tickets where your friends are. I know this isn't quite what you're suggesting, but I'll be getting there :)

I just have a launch page up right now: http://flybymiles.com - but private beta coming next week.

In the meantime check out http://wanderfly.com - they could use a much better recommendation engine, but the content is there (ie: beach for $500)

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by neutronicus on Friday April 08, 2011 @12:57PM (#2424624)
I wonder if the Common Lisp codebase will survive the acquisition?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by cpr on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:04PM (#2424659)
Google higher-ups strike me as not so dumb that they'd misunderstand the crucial nature of that code...
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by peterb on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:45PM (#2425110)
I'm pretty sure Mr. Norvig will have a thing or two to say about this :-)
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by neutronicus on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:15PM (#2424712)
The DOJ's conditions also seem to tie their hands a bit as far as what changes they can make with ITA's software, I realize.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by diegob on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:55PM (#2424907)
Do you have a link? This seems interesting.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by neutronicus on Friday April 08, 2011 @09:50PM (#2426260)
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by swah on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:56PM (#2424918)
Nah, I think they'll rewrite it in C++. No, really.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by rbanffy on Friday April 08, 2011 @10:54PM (#2426364)
I, for one, hope Google App Engine starts supporting it ;-)
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by runevault on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:12PM (#2424700)
I'm sort of surprised this went through since their advantage in search mixed with the power ITA has within their field leads to very powerful mix that could put competitors at a serious disadvantage. Maybe the DoJ saw something I did not to make it less of a problem, but even as a google fan it's... ungh. I don't like this going through.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by skymt on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:37PM (#2424827)
The key was Google's agreement to continue licensing QPX on “fair, reasonable and non-discriminatory terms”. According to the linked Justice Department press release, they're also required to continue development of the publicly-available version of QPX.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by runevault on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:20PM (#2425025)
Very interesting. Be very curious to see if it is enforced (although I think google is more prone to not risk it since they are under so much scrutiny if nothing else).
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by pdaviesa on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:56PM (#2425573)
A bit conspiracy theory-ish but perhaps the DoJ let this go through now to provide more anti-competitive ammo 3-5 years down the road.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by throwa_way on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:14PM (#2425216)
So, I have an interesting perspective to share. I'm graduating and might end up working for Kayak. I know at least part of their infrastructure depends on ITA, and while the existing contract goes until 2013 (I think), Google is obviously looking to compete. Kayak also recently filed for IPO.

It's not like Google has never failed at any of its ventures, but to me it seems like it might be a tough competitor to everyone in this field, since a decent amount of traffic does come through search results. On the other hand, I think a majority of users come in directly, either through WOM or advertising or previous use.

So, what is HN's thoughts on the situation for Kayak? Would it be a wrong move to accept a job there? The engineers seem smart, the work is interesting, the culture is sane and easygoing. What's the worst that could happen?

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by dartland on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:08PM (#2425614)
Kayak is a great company and this is a fascinating time to be in travel search. Go for it! A first job under Paul English (even a few layers beneath him) is a big win and Kayak's engineering reputation so great that you'll have plenty of opportunities down the road.

So in summary: Worst scenario is pretty darn good for you!

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by eklitzke on Saturday April 09, 2011 @12:57AM (#2426546)
I wouldn't discount a company because they're competing with Google. There are a lot of companies that have competed with Google and have successfully out-competed them (likewise, there are a lot of companies that Google has acquired after failing to out-compete). You should look at Kayak on its own merits -- if the folks there are giving you a good offer, and you think the company has a good chance, then go for it.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Saturday April 09, 2011 @06:33AM (#2426924)
>while the existing contract goes until 2013

I believe the consent decree was reported to say that ITA has to renew existing contracts until at least 2016. So that's 5 years before Kayak might, theoretically, lose access to QPX. Don't worry about it; 5 years of a good job is a good run.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by brown9-2 on Saturday April 09, 2011 @10:34AM (#2427203)
2-5 years is a long time for Kayak to make alternate plans.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by hristov on Friday April 08, 2011 @05:57PM (#2425760)
This is a good opportunity for someone to start a competitor of ITA. Google are only required to serve the ITA clients for five years. They will probably stop afterwards, they will want people to use their search engine to find flights.

The only thing special about ITA is their excellent software. Apparently they get their raw data from another company that is willing to license the data to anyone. I am sure that there are still some old LISPers around that can write a similar software for a new company.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by MichaelSalib on Friday April 08, 2011 @06:06PM (#2425789)
Apparently they get their raw data from another company that is willing to license the data to anyone.

This is not true. In order to do what ITA does, you need schedules, fares, and availability data. You can buy the first two from clearinghouses if you have enough money. But the only way to get availability data is to either contract with airlines directly OR contract with your competitors.

I am sure that there are still some old LISPers around that can write a similar software for a new company.

That is just breathtakingly wrong.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by hristov on Friday April 08, 2011 @06:45PM (#2425880)
Breathtakingly wrong? Are you saying there aren't any old lispers left? Or that old lipers cannot write similar software?

Before you say something is breathtakingly wrong you should read it carefully and try to understand it. This way you might also get some of the jokes that are currently flying over your head.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by MichaelSalib on Friday April 08, 2011 @06:59PM (#2425920)
There are plenty of lispers left. I'm one of them. I also used to work at ITA.

The bit that is breathtakingly wrong is the notion that you can just take some smart lisper, lock them in a room, and have them replicate what ITA did and have that be a viable business. See martincmartin's and my comments later in this thread to learn why that would be incredibly hard. With a smart enough team and enough time and money, you could certainly do it, but this is a project that would take many years and its unlikely anyone would be able to keep funding for that long. ITA had a much easier job: it was competing with very poorly designed systems that ran on mainframes and had very little CPU power available.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by gruseom on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:21PM (#2426087)
Given what you and martincmartin are saying, I am left wondering why Google was able to buy ITA for so little. How can such a thing be worth less than a billion dollars?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by MichaelSalib on Friday April 08, 2011 @08:44PM (#2426139)
Because there's a rather finite amount of money spent on air travel which means that the valuation of any one company in that sector will be well within Google's means?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by gruseom on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:59AM (#2427376)
Perhaps. But in that case it's a much smaller market than I imagined. Also relevant is that ITA raised $100M in 2006, so their $700M exit is hardly a home run by VC standards. It doesn't seem to match the astonishingly strong technical and market position you (convincingly) describe.

http://www.itasoftware.com/news-events/press-release.html?id.... Note that the round included Sequoia who are known for caring only about big markets.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by jsnell on Saturday April 09, 2011 @01:40PM (#2427603)
ITA raised all that money to build a reservation system to replace the old mainframe systems that are fabulously expensive to run. That would have been a market of the kind that required outside investement from a company that was already profitable (I think ITA had more people working on the reservation system than the search), and that a big VC would love to bet on.

From what I hear it worked technically, but failed commercially due to the badly timed recession. It seems like a fair bet that Google's offer wasn't putting a lot of value on the reservation system. Even if it could be made to work, it's not the kind of a business that Google is usually in.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by peterb on Saturday April 09, 2011 @03:09PM (#2427844)
The margins in air travel are also slim. Google did a very smart thing here. There business model can support the ITA purchase, not many other businesses could do this. The kicker is they also just hired a lot of talent.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by calbear81 on Friday April 08, 2011 @06:59PM (#2425918)
It would be good to read up on ATPCO. Basically, ITA sucks up the ATPCO feed as well as any direct connects with airlines worldwide and then processes that data into usable feeds for clients. In many cases, the trouble/expense of handling the ATPCO data is not worth it to sites so they pay ITA to provide them with a feed that meets their responsiveness/API/uptime/accuracy requirements.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by calpaterson on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:07PM (#2424674)
Hipmunk might be in trouble.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by eddmc on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:15PM (#2424709)
Hipmunk are a customer of ITA. See http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=1912477

In the Google announcement, they say that ITA’s existing contracts will be honored & have extended contracts through to 2016

This deal was announced a long time ago. Hipmunk will have already planned for this situation

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by travisglines on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:10PM (#2424689)
Today feels like Google (attempt of) squashing YCombinator startups day.

First they're doing Youtube Live -> Justin.tv etc.

Then better flight search -> Hipmunk

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by cryptoz on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:15PM (#2424713)
It could also be viewed as epic validation that the ideas are gold. I most certainly believe Hipmunk can compete against Google; the team is completely awesome and they're far more nimble and agile. Although Google does have an unbeatable vision of Maps I'd imagine...there's no real reason you shouldn't be able to get bus times and airplane times in the same place. And perhaps if you could then pay for the bus and the plane using your Android NFC...

Oh jeez. I love the future.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by kovar on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:13PM (#2424701)
Evolution in action.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by benologist on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:28PM (#2425271)
Luckily google sucks at squashing startups and ends up buying them for ridiculous amounts of money.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by SwellJoe on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:26PM (#2424774)
I'm pretty sure this drastically increases the odds of a Google acquisition of Hipmunk.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by StavrosK on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:42PM (#2425099)
How? They already have the data and plumbing, all they need is a GUI. I don't think Google would go for a Hipmunk-style GUI, they'd just build something search-based you could see in your results.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by SwellJoe on Friday April 08, 2011 @03:59PM (#2425377)
It shows Google wants to be in this space and is willing to buy into it. I don't know that Google will specifically go for Hipmunk, but when any major corporation starts buying into a market, they tend to make more than one acquisition, and it's often the partners of the big companies they acquire first. I'm pretty certain they'll make a couple more strategic acquisitions in the airline/travel space, and Hipmunk is one of the more interesting partners of ITA, since they're new enough to probably be cheap (single or double digit millions, if Steve were looking to be acquired), and all the original team is still in place, no one has cashed out. Hipmunk is also one of the most interesting teams in the space.

Further, if I were doing a talent acquisition, I can't think of many people I'd want more than the reddit team, and Hipmunk is currently pretty much made up of the early reddit team. Of course, Steve is already rich (by some definition of rich), so probably isn't desperate to sell for merely "talent acquisition" money, but Google can afford to stretch the meaning of talent acquisition, and have done so in the past to get really interesting people.

Also, saying "all they need is a GUI" is vastly underrating the importance of the GUI. I can imagine an Android app with a Hipmunk style UI being really powerful. Sometimes you want to find the perfect balance of price and schedule, and sometimes you want to do that while in the middle of a meeting or in the cab on your way to your hotel so you know when you're flying again, or whatever.

And, to get specific about YC-related acquisitions, Google docs had a spreadsheet when they acquired Zenter. All they needed was a GUI, but they acquired a two-man company that had a few tens of thousands of lines of code. Probably a talent acquisition (and a smart one, since Robby and Wayne are awesome), but nonetheless, an acquisition.

Anyway, I agree that Google will definitely be building this into the search user interface. But, when Google moves into an area they don't just do the search interface. Maps has loads of entry-points into it, including non-search oriented use cases, and Google made several acquisitions and developed a bunch of stuff internally to make Maps happen.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by nhebb on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:46PM (#2425112)
They could probably spin new features faster than Google. For example, every service I've seen requires a departure date and return date. In my head, I thinking, "I don't know - sometime this summer." I'd like to be able to pick a destination, the number of days, and have it tell me when I should go on vacation to get the cheapest fares.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:54PM (#2425569)
http://matrix.itasoftware.com/ does that. You can ask for exact dates, but the default is that you give it a date and the number of nights to stay.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:37AM (#2427324)
...just realized I left out the important part: it searches for something within a month after the date you gave it.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by encoderer on Friday April 08, 2011 @04:14PM (#2425423)
What makes Hipmunk great is their UI.

Google is not known for revolutionary UI.

Re:Google acquires ITA Software by pdmccormick on Saturday April 09, 2011 @11:05AM (#2427261)
I have a warm fuzzy memory about the first time I saw Google Maps and Suggest, and had that feeling that, "surely this is the future."
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by encoderer on Sunday April 10, 2011 @04:25PM (#2430322)
Maps was an acquisition. Most every innovative product Google has in the marketplace was an acquisition.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by pdmccormick on Monday April 11, 2011 @10:30AM (#2432667)
Not disagreeing, but I thought the Maps web UI came about post acquisition, and that the technology had previously been developed for desktop apps?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by dave1619 on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:17PM (#2424722)
Who does Jeff Huber, SVP of Commerce and Local, report to?
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by metageek on Friday April 08, 2011 @02:42PM (#2425097)
Larry Page, I think.
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by WhatMatt3rs on Saturday April 09, 2011 @05:26AM (#2426857)
How much?? That's all that matters, that's all I care
Re:Google acquires ITA Software by bauchidgw on Friday April 08, 2011 @01:40PM (#2424842)
rough times ahead for flight and travel sites (which generated good money via leeds to flight search sites) ... googles killing one internet ecosystem after the other.