There might be legal issues with drastically reducing the functionality of devices after they've been sold, but I would imagine they could do this for new devices going forward. I think this points out a subtlety in the arguments of most people who take Epic's side in this struggle: it appears that Apple could avoid these allegations of anticompetitive behavior by either increasing or decreasing the restrictions placed on third-party software distribution. That's a little bizarre, but it surely must be the case, unless the argument is that all electronics manufacturers must provide an easy way to owners to run third-party software (think game console, GPS devices, stereo receivers, car infotainment systems, the microcontroller in every switching power supply, etc.). Presumably the response to this subtlety is that "iPhones are general-purpose computers, but game consoles, etc. aren't," but I disagree with that both in theory and in practice based on what buyers of these devices expect to be able to do with the devices.
Antitrust has always been about big companies abusing market power. These concepts are contestable, which means the law can only be enforced through expensive, time-consuming trials, but it doesn’t mean that the law is meaningless or not useful. The laws against assault and murder are also quite contestable in borderline cases of self-defence, but they are useful, and it’s easy to generate examples where the law is clearly not applicable just as with antitrust.
They would blame the person that ripped them off. If I take my car to a local garage and get defrauded it would be stupid to blame the car manufacturer.
> Third question: What's a customers recourse once they are the victims of fraud or simply want a refund for whatever reason? How easy will it be for them to reason about what to do?
You call the bank and say "hey, I have a fraudulent charge on my credit card" and they give you your money back. There's zero liability for the user. Plus, I'd way rather ask my bank to do a chargeback against a no name scammer than against Apple, Google, Amazon, or Microsoft.
What happens if your kid gets scammed via IAPs, spends $5k, and Apple sides with the developer? What's the result of a chargeback against Apple if you're massively invested in their platform?
Online payment processing is a solved problem. I think things like Apple Pay are fantastic as a system we can opt into, but I'd much rather have the current system of credit card processors with all the regulation and consumer protection that comes along with it.
Maybe something like "turns out games aren't a great fit for the app store." then they just boot the entire games category off the app store and only allow games on apple arcade.
The iPhone would no longer support third-party apps, and thus most iOS users will move to Android, and on Android, everyone will be familiar with installing apps from websites.
So in that world, all you need to do is develop only for Android and put up the .apk file on your website (using some sort of pre-made e-commerce software of your choice if you need to sell it), thereby getting rid of all censorship, friction, issues, rules, 30% fees, etc.
Every pre-installed Apple app has a better 3rd-party alternative, it would be no different for the store.
Undoubtedly if Apple allowed other companies to handle app discovery, the experience could be one or two order of magnitudes better, for both consumers and developers.
And then, how many bad experiences for these types of purchases (or articles about bad experiences) will customers tolerate before they stop trusting in-app or third party purchases? One? A hundred?
Or a real life analogy: every year someone drinks bleach and dies. I'd rather we didn't make bleach completely illegal.
Maybe Apple can do what the Mac does and have some prompts like "hey danger ahead".
Just to be clear, I'm just trying to understand if folks think the app store is a public commons or is it private property?
Lots of the comments on this issue imply that the store is a public commons. And I'm wondering if that's a common view.
Are they offering to allow a replacement to enter in or effectively bricking devices (well soft brick, as they can still call and text)?
In my mind, I'm toying over how committed Apple is to the customer experience. Apple always talks about the user experience first and if they honestly believe that a free and open store is a bad experience (just for the sake of discussion accept this point), would they consider ending the app store (say for all new devices) because they'd rather give a "great" experience rather than being forced to give one they believe is substandard. Essentially protect their brand.
I don't see Google ever doing something like that. But Apple... I dunno.
Its not a headache, it's basically a money grab at this point, 30% of sales of a digital-only product. They're laughing all the way to the bank.
>And my second question: Who do you think customers will blame when someone uses an alternative payment approach to steal from customers? Google/Apple? The app provider? Themselves?
>Third question: What's a customers recourse once they are the victims of fraud or simply want a refund for whatever reason? How easy will it be for them to reason about what to do?
There are many ways to build payment platforms without letting Apple rob 30% of your sales. For e.g. Paypal has consumer protection polices. Buyers can dispute transactions/services, etc.
Depends on what you mean by that. If you are saying that they have a right to not run any of their apps stores anymore, then sure.
But I do not agree that they should have to right to force me, by law to not install other app stores on my phone. If I bought the phone, then I should be allowed to do whatever I want with my own property, including installing other app stores that 3rd parties voluntarily offer me.
> think these app stores are some kind of public commons.
It is not about public commons. Instead, it is about physical property that I purchased, the device, that I own.
> Who do you think customers will blame when someone uses an alternative payment approach to steal from customers
I don't care. That is not my problem. That is not an excuse for apple or google to tell me what I can and cannot do with my own property.
> What's a customers recourse
If customers don't like a ceratain app store, or solution, then they don't have to use it. I am not trying to force other people to do anything with their own phones. I just want Apple to stop doing this to my devices, when they, for example, sue people who offer repair services.
This is an interesting answer. It sounds like you're not an app developer, so why do you care if Apple takes 30% cut of the developers app? Or is it that you're concerned about apps you like not being available due to contract disputes? Could you elaborate?
Because those costs inevitably either get passed down to the consumer, or mean that there are less resources to make the game, which results in a worse experience for me, the customer.
I don't want Apple to force everyone to give them a cut, because that is real money that would either stay in my pocket otherwise, or would provide more resources to game companies.
More money that stays in developers pockets means that they are incentivized to make more games or spend more resources on them. Or it can result in more developers entering the space, because there is more money overall to get.
Apple isn't providing any value to me here, that I could not get elsewhere, if there were competing app stores. I don't want them to force everyone to give them that money.
(And no, I dont' accept the argument that Apple's app store would always be significantly better than everyone else's, so much so that they deserve a full 30%, automatically. If they end up being better, thats fine, but I still want competition, and for other app stores to be able to compete fairly)
The stunt by Epic, aside, has that ever happened to you? Has your Netflix bill ever gone down because they secured a better discounting with their cloud service providers due to their growing volume?
That's never happened to me (but maybe my experience is unusual)
But for the sake of discussion, let's explore how this might play out.
If a developer switches to a different payment services or store, they'll have to make a decision - pocket all the cost savings (and hopefully pass it on) or take some percentage of that saving and channel into their new acquired support costs. They'll have to support refunds, false charges, etc, right?
The big developers will hopefully act responsibly and balance the savings with their new support costs.
But what about the small(er) ones? Will these 2-10 people developer shops be prepared for the support costs? What if the support costs are greater than the savings?
What's your take?
Think about the opposite situation.
Imagine that Apple charged 90% of the costs of having a game on the app store. How many game companies do you think would make games for that? My guess: probably not many.
> If a developer switches to a different payment services or store, they'll have to make a decision - pocket all the cost savings
Also, even in this situation, with the game developer pocketing all the savings, I would much rather prefer them doing this, than Apple taking the money.
To re-iterate, even if we agree that the money would not go to the consumer, and not trickle down at all, I still want this to happen.
This is because now there is more money in the gaming industry, which means that there is now more reason for game developers to make games. So I still want that to happen. Because it means that there is more reasons for developers to make games.
That is still much better than if Apple gets the money.
> They'll have to support refunds, false charges, etc, right?
Yes, and those costs are much much cheaper than 30%. It is not even close. Paypal charges 3% costs. So that is where the prices would probably go to.
> What if the support costs are greater than the savings?
They won't be. 30% is a very large number. But even if we agree that they are, in some small percentage of cases, then those companies can feel free to continue to put their service on the Apple app store. So you can't use that argument.
If other app stores are bad, then people will just list it on the app store instead, and you can't use this argument.
I don't want to force companies to put their app on other app stores. I just want it to be an option. That way the best app store wins. Problem solved.
So, to say again, even if the game developers pocket all of the money, I still rather that happen than Apple getting a dime, by forcing people to use their app store.
I will go even further, actually, and say that even if there is zero proven benefit to consumers, by either trickle down prices, or because of more games being produced (due to game devs having more resources, by pocketing everything, and using those resources to make better/more games), I would still rather my money go to game devs, because philosophically I consider it to be their game, and they deserve the money more than Apple.
Does anyone disagree that Apple and Google have the right to just go "this app store business is just not worth the headaches, we're gonna shut it all down."
When I read hackernews a lot, I get the impression folks think these app stores are some kind of public commons.
And my second question: Who do you think customers will blame when someone uses an alternative payment approach to steal from customers? Google/Apple? The app provider? Themselves?
Third question: What's a customers recourse once they are the victims of fraud or simply want a refund for whatever reason? How easy will it be for them to reason about what to do?