News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by onion2k on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:36AM (#24222565)
The idea, that everythinw we know just came into existence at some point is as shocking as trying to think of something that has no beginning and no end.

It's only an issue if you think about space and time as separate things. I find it makes (a little) more sense when you understand that time is a function of spacetime. Therefore if you're happy with space not existing prior to the big bang (which people do seem to be OK with) then automatically time didn't exist either, and hence 'before the big bang' ceases to be a problem.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by istjohn on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:10AM (#24222822)
This is what gets me. I can imagine no space and no time. But in a reality without space and time, by definition, nothing happens. There is nothing to act or be acted on. There is no timeline by which to order cause and effect. But the Big Bang posits that, in fact, something did happen: space and time began. The most incredible event imaginable occurred in the most impossible circumstance. It just doesn't compute for me. It's much easier for me to imagine that time is just turtles all the way down.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by jeffhuys on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:17AM (#24224143)
I feel it was just logic: nothing existed, but what is nothing? To define nothing you have to define what "something" is. So there should be something to allow the existence of nothing.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by yetihehe on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:30AM (#24223001)
> The most incredible event imaginable occurred in the most impossible circumstance.

Think of time as "it prevents everything happening at once". Before there was time, nothing prevented everything happening at once, without space nothing prevented everything happening in the same place, so everything happened at once and in the same place. That everything happening made so much noise that it created space and time in a very big bang.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by appstateguy on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:02AM (#24223293)
What is that "something" that is happening all at once? In my naive understanding of cosmological theories is they seem to end in probabilities (e.g., eternal inflation) that emerge from a kind of (oxymoronic) "chaotic static", but what does that mean for this to "happen all at once"? That statement seems to imply there's no degree of freedom through which something can occur (at least casually).

I suppose the question comes to, what is time? I imagine "time" to be a degree of freedom through which something can change. I understand some see time to be related to entropy, and that it's an emergent property of this thermodynamic property but this seems too limiting. It would seem entropy is more-so an explanation for the arrow of time, but not time itself.

If time is defined as the dimension through which something can change then should time not be fundamental to any cosmological theories that extends beyond the Big Bang?

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by yetihehe on Friday August 21, 2020 @02:26AM (#24232557)
> What is that "something" that is happening all at once?

Not "something". Everything. Like "What is possible to happen? Everything is possible". If you can't divide that possibility by time period, everything possible will happen with probability of 1. How improbable is that universe will happen during 1 trillion years? Very improbable. But if you can't tell in how many years universe will happen, it just will exist.

> but what does that mean for this to "happen all at once"

If you don't have time to make difference between two things happening one after another, they will happen both at the same exact "time".

> If time is defined as the dimension through which something can change then should time not be fundamental to any cosmological theories that extends beyond the Big Bang?

The problem is, time depends on local state of space. More energy/matter in a chunk of space means time is slower relative to other chunks of space. So when you try to go into past with mass in chunk of space increasing into infinity, that time notion breaks.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by MacsHeadroom on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:43AM (#24224429)
A series of causal events requires network reccurance for time to be calculable. If it's not calculable it can't be said to exist in any mathematical sense. So, a series of non-reccurent causal events at the fundamental level processes causally without the existence of time.

The same is true of "space" for the same reason. A causal network without reccurence (a tree) has no way to compare objects since there are no horizontal relations and it cannot "look" at backwards relations.

A non-reccurent causal tree has multiple instances of "here" and "now." But without anything to compare a given here/now to the concepts are internally meaningless.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by istjohn on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:06PM (#24231227)
That's actually helpful.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by onion2k on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:20AM (#24223535)
I can imagine no space and no time.

There is no timeline by which to order cause and effect.

I would argue that the second sentence implies the first isn't true. You can't imagine that there is no time if you're saying things can't happen without time. What I said doesn't mean things can't happen, it just means they happen in a way that doesn't require time to exist (which could be everything happening in the same irreducible instant, or in any order, etc.)

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by simonh on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:47AM (#24222650)
That's just a semantic dodge to avoid answering phrasings of the question that use the term 'before'. However the comment you're replying to didn't use the 'before' phrasing. We can't dodge the broader question of how, or why the Universe came about in the particular form that it did so easily.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by asdfasgasdgasdg on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:04AM (#24222775)
You can dodge further by saying that causality only exists in space time, so asking what "caused" the start of space time is incoherent. But, "it just did" has never been a satisfactory answer outside the halls of churches and seminaries, so this dodge continues to be unsatisfying.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by mensetmanusman on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:09AM (#24222809)
The phrasing is worded wrong here:

“it just did” has never been a satisfactory answer inside of churches or seminaries. That is why almost all the metaphysical discussion in these areas of human thought are around why we exist (in human terms).

“it just did” has been a satisfactory answer outside of churches or seminaries. This is why almost all discussion of why there is something rather than nothing in secular academia is ‘meh, impossible to know, don’t worry about it’

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by Udik on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:35AM (#24223703)
What I find shocking or, well, confusing, is the fact that things usually come into existence inside reality. Here we're talking about the coming into existence of something that it's easy to consider (I don't know how correctly) reality itself. How does that come out of nothing? And what even is nothing, outside reality?
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by hacknat on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:27AM (#24223617)
Time as implemented in our current universe (which has counter intuitive properties, such a universal speed limit, which math does not require). It is possible that there is a version of time “before” the emergence of our physical “implementation” of space-time. There is no reason to stop assuming that the mathematical property of contingency doesn’t extend beyond the BigBang. Math is the foundation of Physics, not the other way around.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by MacsHeadroom on Thursday August 20, 2020 @12:03PM (#24224652)
More concretely, a non-reccurent tree of causal events has both progression and various scales at consecutive slices of progression for an outside observer.

Intrinsically information about prior contingencies are unrecoverable "before" recurrence. But unrecoverable is not "non-existent."

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by simiones on Thursday August 20, 2020 @09:12AM (#24222845)
But for all we know, time IS separate from space. Time is not like the 3 spatial coordinates in many physical systems. For example, Entropy increases with time, which doesn't make sense for a space-like property. Also, causality can be used to define a notion of past vs future even in 4D space time.
Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by appstateguy on Thursday August 20, 2020 @10:35AM (#24223698)
This makes intuitive sense to me, but isn't the issue that relativity states that time is intrinsically coupled with space? Ones experience of time relative to another's is directly related to the topological features of the space they're in. If it's more curved, time also "curves" and slows down relative to another observer in flatter space.

How does this notion of time become decoupled from space?

One way I imagine it is that "time" as a concept encapsulates at least two properties:

1) The degree of freedom (i.e., dimension) through which things can change; and 2) The unidirectional flow of causal events

Relativity seems more concerned with defining time in terms of casual events (e.g., event horizons) than its dimensionality. If we define "fundamental time" as a dimension that allows for change can it then be decoupled from space?

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by gizmo686 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @11:46AM (#24224462)
The core equation of special relativity that couples space with time is (assuming the speed of light is 1):

    ds^2 = dx^2 + dy^2 + dz^2 - dt^2
Different observerse disagree on what each individual term of the right hand side of the equation are; but every observers agrees on what ds^2 is.

Thinking in terms of 3 dimensional euclidean space, this makes sense. If you fix your 3 dimensional coordinate system and pick 2 points in space, you can have:

    ds^2 = dx^2 + dy^2 + dz^2
Another observer could pick a different orientation for their coordinate system, and arrive at different values for dx, dy, and dz; but they would still have the same ds. This is just the pythagorean theorem. The distance between two points is the same regardless of how you define your axis. This also means that your 3 spatial dimensions are inherently coupled; because there was no particular reason to pick your axis the way you did.

Simmilarly, in the 4 dimensional spacetime defined by the metric:

  ds^2 = dx^2 + dy^2 + dz^2 - dt^2
There is no particular reason to pick the particular time axis that you happened to pick. It is coupled with the other 3 dimensions in exactly the same way that the 3 dimensions are coupled in euclidean space.

The only complication here is that rotating your axis under the Lorentzian metric require the Lorentz transform; whereas rotating them under the Euclidean metric requires the Galilean transform.

The coupling described here involves no notion of causality. Nothing in the metric prevents a path from traveling in both directions along the time axis.

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by tsimionescu on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:04PM (#24228168)
Well, even in this metric, there is an obvious separation between the 3 spacial dimensions and time. For example, a negative ds^2 indicates a fundamentally different kind of distance than a positive ds^2. In fact, events separated by positive distances would be considered entirely independent, while those separated by negative distances can have influenced each other; events for which ds^2 = 0 are simultaneous in any frame of reference.

Further, if two events have are separated by a negative ds^2, then all observers will agree on the order in which they happened, though they will not agree on the length of time that passed between them, or the relative positions.

Note that I'm using your version of the equation for the definition of ds^2 > or <0, though in general I've seen it expressed the other way around, ds^2 = dt^2 - (dx^2+dy^2+dz^2).

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by gizmo686 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @05:32PM (#24229266)
There is a clear assymetry between the temporal dimension and the spatial dimension; but it is not clear to me that this implies a seperation.

We can distances with ds^2 < 0 timelike, and ds^2 > 0 spacelike. We say that events with a spacelike cannot influence each other; but there is nothing in relativity that requires that (unless you introduce causality as an additional assumption, which we generally do).

This gets more messy in general relativity when you allow for large masses (read. Black holes).

In the case of a non spining black hole, we spacetime is described by the Schwarzschild metric. Expressing this metric in spherical cordinates, you find that when you pass the event horizon the sign of dt^2 and dr^2 flip, where r is distance from the singularity. This means a "timelike" seperation means that events are closer to each other in the time dimension; and events with a "spacelike" seperation are farther from each other in time. That is to say, "time" behaves in the way we think of as "space", and "space" behaves the way we think of as "time".

Re:Big Bounce Simulations Challenge the Big Bang by axilmar on Friday August 21, 2020 @04:40AM (#24233183)
Time measurement is coupled to space, not time itself.

Actually, time does not exist. It's simply the rate of change of matter.