News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @08:59AM (#24209895)
Kinda strange.

Emacs is so inherently keyboard-focused that I fail to see the point of this... nor the need for it?!

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by thom on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:04AM (#24209937)
I'm not sure this is true. Emacs is fundamentally command driven - everything is a command, and can be invoked, edited or replaced the same way. What triggers those is obviously key bindings for a lot of people but it's not really what makes Emacs powerful or extensible. People have diverse needs when it comes to wanting to interact with a computer, and it's great that Emacs's flexibility allows them to.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kqr on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:59AM (#24210393)
I agree. Vim is inherently keyboard-focused. That Emacs is not, and instead focuses on the command as the fundamental unit driving everything, is its primary strength.

This is what makes Emacs more flexible than Vim to the point where there's a very faithful reimplementation of Vim for Emacs. Couldn't do the opposite, even if you wanted to.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:34AM (#24211496)
It is true that commands are at the heart of Emacs but as soon as you move beyond very basic use, invoking commands in ways other than through the keyboard becomes impractical. I'm not only talking about keyboard shortcuts but also about the fact that a lot of these commands actually take parameters that would be difficult to provide by mouse.

Emacs out of the box comes with a menu system. This is very good and useful for newcomers because it not only gives a familiar feel, it also helps discovering functionality. However, it is no coincidence that a lot of power-users turn off menu and toolbar, as evidenced e.g. by Steve Yegge's "effective emacs" tips (https://sites.google.com/site/steveyegge2/effective-emacs#it...). Now, not every user is a power-user, there is of course a spectrum, but to me it is fairly clear that the way Emacs is designed, mouse-based usage would be a limiting factor.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by thom on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @12:32PM (#24212322)
I too turn off the menu and toolbar in Emacs, and I'm not saying the setup in the article sounds good to me for that or any editor. But to give you an example of why I think it's an important point, I would absolutely love to be able to issue commands by speech, for example, for things I don't use very often, or just never remember what I've bound them to (or even for stuff I don't remember the name for). Some people _have_ this setup, I've just never invested the time. But it's possible because fundamentally Emacs is a platform first and an editor second. I doubt it would be a very popular platform without the ability to make keybindings, but you nevertheless you could still build useful apps on top of it, and I find that quite interesting.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @02:09PM (#24213796)
There's still a difference though between a setup that uses keyboard + speech vs. one that mixes keyboard and mouse. For instance, you don't have to take your hands off the keyboard to issue a speech command. Also, there's a fundamental usability difference between voice input and mouse input in that the strength of menus+mouse lies in the fact that a user does not have to remember the exact command, it can be looked up / navigated to. For speech, you have to remember the command just as you do when using M-x <command> in Emacs right now -- unless you're thinking of a fully fledged spoken dialog system type of interface that would allow interactive descriptions.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by thom on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:37PM (#24215189)
I rarely remember commands when I’m typing, I use completion and apropos to remind me, feels like something similar must be possible. Either way, obviously I spend most of my life with hands on the keyboard and I’m not going to make out Emacs isn’t optimised in many ways for that. I just think it’s sad if someone thinks the big ideas in Emacs are just how it handles keybindings, that’s all really.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Thursday August 20, 2020 @03:33AM (#24220802)
Yeah, that would be sad. Luckily, I'm not one of these people but at the same time, there's no denying that keyboard is the main modality most Emacs interactions are optimized for.

Your example of auto-completion is actually a good argument in favor of keyboard use since I cannot think of any other modality where a similar functionality could easily be implemented.

That said, I'm not arguing that keyboard-based interaction is per se superior to any other form of input. But to me, it's undeniable that Emacs is de facto a keyboard-centric editor. And let's not forget the history of the software: it was originally developed when terminal-based interaction was the norm, (wide-spread) use of mice came much later.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by morelisp on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @02:50PM (#24214499)
> a lot of these commands actually take parameters that would be difficult to provide by mouse.

Those that take interactive strings, maybe - but for those that take buffer positions or regions, which seems to me like a plurality if not majority, I would love to be able to invoke a command and then click+drag somewhere I want to apply, rather than having to set the point there and pop it back when done.

Or the other way around, select a region, right-click to get a choice of commands that work on regions - this could even be auto-generated by looking at the keymap stack for commands that work on regions.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by JadeNB on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:51AM (#24210955)
> This is what makes Emacs more flexible than Vim to the point where there's a very faithful reimplementation of Vim for Emacs. Couldn't do the opposite, even if you wanted to.

This claim seems at least suspect to me. Vim scripting isn't fun, and vim certainly isn't centred around it like emacs is, but it's possible. Usually making this claim would challenge people to solve it themselves, but I suspect that vim users care significantly less about welcoming emacs users into their environment than vice versa.

(Also, the various vim implementations in emacs are almost-but-not-quite there, to the point that I believe really experienced vim users fall into an uncanny valley.)

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by vvillena on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:01AM (#24210424)
Why not? Some things make a lot of sense, like the context menu. The current right-click behavior just sets the text selection mark. This doesn't make much sense anymore: every other editor uses click and drag to select text using the mouse. This frees the right mouse button, and a context menu makes lots of sense. Emacs is a highly complex software, which is then customized with lots of modes. Making functions accessible via a context menu would be awesome for both usability and productivity. The menus could be easily customized to further improve user workflows.

As for the rest: maybe some of the features are nice to have. I don't really care for tabs, and standard shortcuts are usually a non-issue, since everyone ends up using whatever they prefer ("standard", Emacs, or Vim). In any case, most advanced functions are usually accessed by name, whatever the editor.

The important takeaway is that every Emacs user should acknowledge the fact that the mouse is underutilized. We may not need it, but it's a huge barrier to overcome for new users.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:41AM (#24211575)
Emacs of course has long supported menus but I think every serious user would agree that it's not necessarily a love child. I agree with you that it is the strength of menus in general that they allow for easy discoverability of functionality. However, at the same time, Emacs provides other ways to the same end.

Simple interfaces are especially useful for newcomers, I agree to that point as well. At the same time, most power-users of Emacs do not use the mouse at all. While not everyone aspires (or even should aspire) to become an Emacs power user, the question might be asked at what point it would be wise to switch from mouse-based use to keyboard-based use as you progress? Does it even make sense to first learn an interface you're better off ditching at some point as your expertise raises?

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by vvillena on Thursday August 20, 2020 @03:55AM (#24220925)
It makes complete sense to start using the mouse, and to keep improving our own workflows over time. Take the Mac interface: it's built in a way that allows users to just use the mouse, but everything is accessible via keyboard shortcuts. One of the key features of the Mac is the constant feedback the user gets, and the fact that this feedback is always the same, whether the user uses the keyboard or the mouse. Animations, selections, menu highlight when invoking actions... It's a very well-thought experience that makes things better for all kinds of users.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by mrspeaker on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:04AM (#24209939)
I use Emacs as my primary... everything. But I totally see the point and need for mouse-driven functionality. Emacs only works if you have two functioning arms with hands on them. Put a coffee, a sandwich, a cat, a kid, a beer... in one of your hands, and Emacs is unusable. If my cat wants some attention, I can't keep typin' stuff.

Though, not sure why the mouse-driven features are also wrapped up making shortcuts match VS-Code etc. That makes it a lot less useful.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:43AM (#24211601)
If you can't type, I'm not sure the mouse is going to get you much ahead either ;-)

But it's true that there might be a certain class of users with impediments for which a different input modality setup could be very beneficial. However, note that standard Emacs already provides menus and mouse support, it's just not what is commonly the focus of the editor.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by macintux on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:13AM (#24210538)
I was looking at a recent HN post about chording, and it struck me I'd have a hard time using a chording keyboard with Emacs. This might address that problem for me.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by JetSetWilly on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:26AM (#24210106)
Emacs has thousands of shortcuts for every conceivable piece of functionality. Personally, I will remember shortcuts for commonly used things - and all the other functionality may as well not exist if it is not easily discoverable.

A gui is a nice way to make a lot of functionality discoverable.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by fluffything on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:35AM (#24210185)
> may as well not exist if it is not easily discoverable.

But it is easily discoverable ?

I literally just do M-x and can I get a buffer open with _all_ emacs commands and their explanation, and can do a fuzzy search on that, e.g., so if I type "M-x align re" I get only one command highlighted that can just execute "align-regexp".

That's the main thing I like about emacs. I don't have to remember a million shortcuts, just what things are possible, and then I just type a description of what I want to do and hit enter and that's it.

A GUI / having to use the mouse would push me completely out of "the zone".

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by JetSetWilly on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @05:00PM (#24216381)
That's cool if you can remember roughly what the command is called. For example, I wanted to format some XMl in a buffer. In a GUI, I'm fairly sure I could find this easily, in emacs it is "go to google" and find out that you want sgml-petty-print or whatever. So a bunch of M-x searching for "format" is hopeless.

Emacs tends to have its own names for many concepts, making things even more obtuse.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by BeetleB on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:40PM (#24218174)
In about 70-80% of the cases, using ido or helm, with some guesses on what the command name may contain, is enough to find me what I need.

But yes, to be frank, my productivity in Emacs really took off once I started memorizing things with flashcards. I currently have 603 cards for Emacs (including elisp).

(And telling a newbie that would cause a lot of despair!)[2]

The other thing that really helped is I started using/making hydras.[1] So now when I encounter a new, interesting mode, instead of memorizing lots of command names or keybindings, I just build my own custom menus.

[1] https://github.com/abo-abo/hydra

[2] But it really shouldn't. Emacs, with all its packages, and modes, is like a language with all its libraries, and not just the standard ones. Remembering all the commands/keybindings is akin to expecting someone to know all the APIs in all the libraries. It's OK if you don't. Most people don't.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by fluffything on Friday August 21, 2020 @07:49AM (#24234056)
> That's cool if you can remember roughly what the command is called. > > [ ... ] > > In a GUI, I'm fairly sure I could find this easily, in emacs it is "go to google" and find out that you want sgml-petty-print or whatever.

I just yank into a new buffer, set it to xml mode, "M-x indent" reveals the command to format xml (indent-region or indent-buffer or something like that), enter, yank it back. Done.

In an editor with a gui, I would just go to "Help -> Search" and do pretty much the same, which would reveal the menu item to click to achieve something. I find emacs ido/helm workflow for this much better. Never need to memorize anything.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by jcynix on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:07PM (#24219160)
Microsoft's office products are mostly GUI centered. But I rarely can easily find ways to accomplish things there and instead get lost in their GUI, which sometimes looks like a twisty maze of little passages all different. So "GUI" isn't a panacea for ease of use IMO.

In emacs I can use "apropos" (i.e. "c-h a") or "c-h v" for example to search for ways to accomplish what I'd like to do.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by jolmg on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:32AM (#24211453)
If you hit `C-h b` you get a list of all the current keybindings. `C-h m` lists the keybindings focused on the active modes. You can search either for the functionality or binding you're looking for. Also, `C-h k` followed by any keybinding will describe the keybinding. If you get the documentation of a function or command with `C-h f`, it'll also mention the keybindings it's bound to, if any. All these `C-h` help keybindings are described if you hit `C-h C-h`, and they're also mentioned in the tutorial that's linked to when you start up emacs for the first time on default configuration.

These helps are also available in the GUI menu bar, for example Help > Describe > List Key Bindings, which also mentions the keybinding `C-h b` to the right of that.

How is discoverability of keybindings lacking?

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by morelisp on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:26PM (#24215029)
Discovery of functionality is lacking, not the keybindings. Most of the time I want an answer to "how do I do...?" not "what happens if I press this key?", and even isearching the help buffer I have to guess did they suffix `at-point` or not? did they call it `swap` or `transpose`? `forward` or `next`? did they make a `sexp` do something useful in this mode, or will it just pick something between parens, or some awful mix of the two?
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by philsnow on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @07:23PM (#24218014)
Emacs suffers somewhat here for its ancient-ish heritage, because it was conceived and developed in the depths of university computer lab precursors, when people had different names for everything.

Try explaining "yank-pop" to somebody who's only ever used sublime/vscode.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by wtetzner on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:43PM (#24215272)
Does a GUI actually solve any of these problems?
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by morelisp on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @03:54PM (#24215441)
Yes, a GUI allows you to give richer contextual feedback without introducing modality to the core functionality. For example, if I can click and drag, I do not need `transient-mark-mode`, a tricky modality in our "non-modal" editor. If I can summon a menu of relevant commands for a region, I do not need a menu of all commands filling up multiple pages of a separate window.

A GUI also introduces other problems, but the ability to just point at what you want to know more about or do something with has been a cornerstone of discoverability since the introduction of the mouse.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by throwaway_pdp09 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:18AM (#24221070)
> For example, if I can click and drag, I do not need `transient-mark-mode`, a tricky modality in our "non-modal" editor

transient-mark-mode just allows you to see what you're selecting. If you don't have it you don't see what's being selected until you release the mouse. You need that more with a mouse than a keyboard.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by morelisp on Thursday August 20, 2020 @06:29AM (#24221801)
> transient-mark-mode just allows you to see what you're selecting.

Yeah, no. It's a modal state, and since Emacs doesn't support modal interfaces directly, it touches tons of separate commands (anything using `region-active-p`) and means it's tremendously difficult to find out all it does!

    Many commands change their behavior when Transient Mark mode is
    in effect and the mark is active, by acting on the region instead
    of their usual default part of the buffer’s text.  Examples of
    such commands include M-;, M-x flush-lines, M-x keep-lines,
    M-%, M-%, M-x ispell, and C-x u.
    To see the documentation of commands which are sensitive to the
    Transient Mark mode, invoke C-h d and type "transient"
    or "mark.*active" at the prompt.
The reason selection with a mouse also triggers it is because all these commands would not DTRT unless it did, given Emacs's approach of forcing mice to fit into the system designed for keyboards.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by throwaway_pdp09 on Thursday August 20, 2020 @08:48AM (#24222657)
Hmm, thanks for pointing this out. But I'm slightly baffled, for the commands you gave (flush-lines, M-%, M-S-%) that's fine - transient mode with keyboard (between point and mark) and with a mouse, they are the same thing. Transmode is just highlighting AFAICS (between point and mark) and that mode quits the moment you release the mouse (leaving mark where you started the drag, point where you ended it). The convention of "operate only on stuff between point and mark" is necessary, mouse or no, and has been there since forever.

But I'm no expert!

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by melling on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:59AM (#24210397)
Emacs is an editor construction kit.

Use your imagination and build a different editor.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by Koshkin on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @10:15AM (#24210559)
Building and maintaining an “emacs distribution” (even for a single user like yourself) is a huge effort which is rarely worth it.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by waluigi on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @02:50PM (#24214496)
I would push back against this. There is definitely a pretty steep learning curve, but once you are over it you really start to reap the benefits of being able to rapidly add niche functionality that exactly fits your workflows.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by figgyc on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:42AM (#24210252)
The file browser on the left and the general design of it makes me lean towards the author intending this to replace VS Code and other modeless, less keyboard focused editors, not regular Emacs, which I can see the value in because Emacs being written in C and Lisp is probably a lot more performant and lean, plus a lot of people are opposed to Electron apps in general.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by sn41 on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:31AM (#24210155)
I have Emacs pinkies - I see the value in similar efforts. I will try this out for some time to see if it actually helps. But muscle memory is a thing for me, it is hard to undo 20 years of Emacs habits.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by cobbzilla on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:10AM (#24211144)
I always remap Caps-Lock to be an extra Control key; this has really helped me avoid repetitive stress injuries over the years.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by mrspeaker on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @02:47PM (#24214434)
A weirder one for me that I like now: my RIGHT pinky has been hurting recently. Not sure if it's emacs fault, but I've been using "Enter/return key as CTRL when held"... When you hit return it's normal return key, but if you just hold down return it acts like control! It was weird at first, but now it's awesome - especially useful on a Mac lappy that has no right ctrl key.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by stragies on Thursday August 20, 2020 @04:05AM (#24220991)
Take it a step further: Remap CapsLock to be 'Escape' when pressed&released, and 'Control' when held.

Easily configurable under Linux with xcape, and (iirc) karabiner for Mac. For Wayland there is also a tool.

Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by trey-jones on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @09:03AM (#24209929)
Yeah, the main reason I started using Emacs was to try and eliminate (or reduce, I suppose) mouse usage.
Re:Mousemacs – A mouse-driven Emacs by kleiba on Wednesday August 19, 2020 @11:45AM (#24211639)
Yes, I've been running Emacs in the terminal almost exclusively for pretty much the same reason.