News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by lmilcin on Saturday August 15, 2020 @08:31PM (#24173705)
The trouble seems that there aren't many people that get software AND electronics AND mechanics AND on top of that marketing, right.

It is rare enough to find people with good electronics and software skills.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dbcurtis on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:54PM (#24174161)
After working in robotics for a few years, I came to the realization that people (applies especially to managers) don't recognize when they are bringing the wrong instincts to a problem. If you come up through software, you develop one set of instincts, EE another, and ME yet another set of instincts. When making a decision, step one must be identifying the appropriate set of instincts to bring to the problem.

Once upon a time I worked for a manager who could only bring software instincts to any problem. He was dismissive, even, of ME problems. But not every problem can be solved in two-week sprints and pushed over LTE to the fleet. (Actually, if you want a good start-up idea, find a way to push a field update to a 5 kilo aluminum casting over LTE -- I'd invest in that.)

But here is the thing -- unless you can synchronize the release of software + electronics + mechanics, you don't have a robot. That means design, validation, component tracking, field updates, maintenance. You always need to take a step back and ask yourself what instincts to bring to a problem, and if you are weak in one/some of those areas, learn who's instincts you can trust and bring them in.

I am presumptuous enough to believe this applies to IOT mechatronics as well as robots. (Actually robots need more than SW+EE+ME, but this rant is already long enough.)

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dhosek on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:17AM (#24175055)
This is one of the cool things about the Harvey Mudd College Engineering major. Rather than doing Mechanical Engineering, or Electrical Engineering or Cheese Engineering or whatever, you just do Engineering. Graduates leave with a full toolbox of skills. I kind of wish when I was an undergrad, I hadn't had such an aversion to practical knowledge (I started out majoring in Physics/English, then Math/English then dropped out of college to eventually get a BA in English).
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by ascar on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:50AM (#24177044)
That might be a start, but higher education only scratches the surface of on-the-job skills in engineering. You learn the basic tools, the way of thinking and the skill of acquiring additional knowledge. You get near to zero experience on real engineering problems as encountered in business.

So in the good case this degree might broaden your horizon and teaches you that you don't know enough and in the bad case it might make you overconfident in even more areas while having even less knowledge than from a more focused degree.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by lmilcin on Sunday August 16, 2020 @01:57PM (#24179739)
That's right. So I see a lot of mechatronics students that actually, instead of trying to develop all their skills, settle in either electronics or software development.

Students should understand that what they learn at uni is as far from real world product development as possible. Uni does not have incompetent coworkers, unreasonable, conflicting or entirely missing requirements, scaling issues, vendors trying to screw you, procurement processes trying their best to prevent you from doing anything, faulty materials, etc. Knowing a bunch of mechanic formulas or software development patterns does not an engineer make.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Animats on Sunday August 16, 2020 @02:44PM (#24180120)
Uni does not have incompetent coworkers, unreasonable, conflicting or entirely missing requirements, scaling issues, vendors trying to screw you, procurement processes trying their best to prevent you from doing anything, faulty materials, etc.

MIT students have complained, after graduation, of finding companies that worked like soap operas.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by CarbyAu on Monday August 17, 2020 @12:12AM (#24183881)
I suspect it is the same everywhere.

At Uni you are taught many things including "things NOT to do"; some seeming quite obvious. I thought:

"Well, I shouldn't encounter those "things NOT to do" in the Real World TM, because professionals in the workplace have had 10 years to learn these lessons."

Ah, the naivety of youth...

Professionals are just people who convince someone to pay them for what they do. What they do doesn't have to include competence.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Animats on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:29PM (#24180479)
Now, here's a good project for someone into mechatronics. There are many videos of machines for making N95 masks on Youtube. Watch them, and try to design a better one. Things to note:

- They're all running at a rather leisurely pace, about 1 mask per second. That's very slow for a simple low-cost product. Compare textile machinery, progressive stamping presses, bottle making machines, and printing equipment. That's probably because demand for these things wasn't high until recently, and nobody designed a high-speed machine.

- The bottleneck seems to be attaching the elastic loops. The rest of the process is all roll to roll and could easily be 3x as fast. Is there some better way to do that?

- Can you get wider rolls of the source materials and build machines that make more masks at a time?

- At the output end, most machines just dump the finished masks into a bin. That loses order and count. They then need a separate packaging operation. They come out of the machine in a consistent position and orientation, which can be exploited. A better machine would put 10 or 20 masks put into a printed poly bag and heat-seal the bag. Then it would drop the bag into a waiting cardboard carton. When the carton is full, switch to a new carton. The filled carton gets a shipping label and rolls down a roller conveyor headed for shipping.

Compare [1], an N95 mask making machine, and [2], a paper cup making machine. The paper cup machine is doing a tougher job at 5x the speed. It has a flying paster, like a big printing press, so you can change rolls without a shutdown. The cups are shot out through a pneumatic tube to the cup stacking and packaging machine. That's why paper cups are so cheap.

[1] https://youtu.be/SdCBKB4DhdA

[2] https://youtu.be/x3Vx5y0Yg3Q

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dhosek on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:30AM (#24178115)
The capstone of the engineering major is the engineering clinic project which has students working on “real engineering problems as encountered in business”. Companies pay the college to have teams of senior engineering majors solve a problem they face. Two of the sexier projects were Disneyland hired HMC to come up with an anti-collision system for autopia and West Dorm had a clinic team refurbish a beloved vintage pinball machine.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by PascLeRasc on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:31PM (#24183314)
My university had a student club doing that and it's probably my fondest memory of engineering. It was so inspiring and almost addicting to work on projects that actual people would use or have their lives improved by. And you got to have a hand in writing firmware, machining parts/enclosures, meeting the customer (mostly doctors, which was super cool), and researching the market fit for if it were a real project. It was so much fun.

I really wish my post-college engineering experience could be anything like that. I miss making useful things.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dhosek on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:49PM (#24183737)
My wife, after she finished her MS in Software Engineering, ended up in a job where one of her first tasks was writing DOS .BAT files.

On the other hand, her first asp.net page was demonstrated by Steve Ballmer at CES, so she did advance in the world.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by lmilcin on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:09AM (#24176839)
This is even worse with managers. Managers have whole lot of other problems to deal with and what they frequently fail to recognize is the need to separate areas where it is up to manager do act on their "instincts" (which I call experience) and where it is up to engineer to do their job.

Unfortunately, the power assymetry between managers and engineers frequently manifests itself as you have described:

-- managers trying to understand everything through the lens of their past experience,

-- engineers trying to conform to managers (ie. using manager's language to formulate problems and solutions)

-- managers dismissing/prioritizing down areas, ideas, problems that they are not familiar, promoting/prioritizing up where they feel they have good understanding,

-- engineers responding by doing the same (ie. focusing on where they feel they will be rewarded by manager).

-- managers hiring/promoting based on their assessment of the candidates/employee competency in the area of expertise of the manager, because it is easier to rate candidate/employee competency if it is in your area.

-- managers failing to improve in areas where they are completely new. Maybe because people in general tend to want to improve in areas they already know. Maybe because they don't want to be seen as noobs making silly mistakes with experts around, and so trying shun entire area as less important so that the discussion can focus on where they are comfortable talking to experts.

-- so on...

So where a team works on a product that requires software/electronics/mechanics, the team, regardless of its initial composition, will over time get skewed in the area of expertise of its top manager.

Same goes for startup -- duo of guys who know software and electronics will inevitably look for products in the areas they know best. Not being able to quickly rate how difficult something is, mechanically, is definitely scaring a lot of people away.

I also noticed people dealing with software and electronics rarely mingle with mechanics/material experts which I think might also explain a little bit why there aren't too many enterprises that join those areas well.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by accurrent on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:55AM (#24176794)
I'm in robotics and I agree with this. ME people are 100 times more thorough in checking things are done correctly than EE or SWE. Its very hard to make changes in ME. Also people heavily underappreciated the difficulty of the field.

From a SWE perspective, Robotics Engineers need to know physics and math than the average SWE learns.

Interestingly almost all the successful robot projects I've worked on seem to follow a waterfall process. You keep working on it till it works. After its ready don;t change anything.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by ptx on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:30AM (#24177233)
> waterfall process ... keep working on it till it works

I thought waterfall was to plan it out in detail, then do all the work according to the plan despite realizing that the plan is wrong, then finally, after disbanding the development team, test it to see if it works?

That's obviously a caricature, but if you have the feedback loop to see if it works while you're working on it, you might also call it agile.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by jki275 on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:55PM (#24182750)
You’ve described waterfall accurately, but waterfall is kind of an anti-pattern. Nobody actually uses it.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by lmilcin on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:07PM (#24183470)
You mean there are no places where managers tell their teams the scope and deadlines and then tell the team to go play "agile"?
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by jki275 on Monday August 17, 2020 @08:14AM (#24186467)
That's not waterfall.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by lmilcin on Monday August 17, 2020 @09:43AM (#24187124)
From that point of view I would say no project is waterfall. In any sufficiently complicated project requirements MUST change over development if only for the fact it is not feasible to specify absolutely everything absolutely precisely before development starts.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by jki275 on Monday August 17, 2020 @01:53PM (#24189807)
I agree. Waterfall is primarily a discussion point on why Agile is the way to go -- hence an anti pattern. Nobody actually does waterfall.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dmytroi on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:05AM (#24176342)
I like your use of the instinct concept, similar to experience/seniority yet very different.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dbcurtis on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:00PM (#24180244)
I was pretty terse about my definition of instinct in my original post, because I thought the post had gone on long enough. But the idea I that am trying to get at is grounded in the concept that emotion and gut feel drive more decisions than we would like to admit, with logic applied to back-justify the decision. Then part two is that by the time someone has risen to the level of decision authority that SW/EE/ME are all answering up through their portfolio, they probably have baked in a lot of intuition about the branch they came up through. That intuition informs their decisions -- but may not be reliable outside of their comfort zone.

Someone who came up through software intuitively knows that while "it is only a 3 line change in each of 4 files", making the change in master is only the beginning. Also on deck are: back-porting and validating in the 4 release branches still running on the 4 hardware versions in the field, and pushing the update reliably, oh, and it changes the log format so our log monitor query needs to be updated and validated.

EE -- yes, it is just changing out one connector -- but we need the latching version and only two latching variants are available, and one requires moving a mounting hole which would require chassis rework, the other is expensive and has a 12 week lead time... and in any case we need to update the test fixtures. And we need to keep some of the old test fixtures around for the old rev, and while we could save some money by reworking some of our old test fixtures, who has time to write and validate the engineering change order for the test fixture rework?

ME -- yes it is only moving two mounting holes, but both the chassis and the skins need to move, so we either have to rework the fleet to accept new skins, or do two sets of expensive tooling for the skins, or do some kludge adapter that allows new skins on old chassis, but we need to vibration test that.

Intuition and instinct are about understanding the implications and the unarticulated risks buried with decisions.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by PragmaticPulp on Saturday August 15, 2020 @08:38PM (#24173748)
Very true.

Having worked in this space, the failures usually come from lopsided teams. Too many startups try to treat these products as technology products with a side of building materials, assuming that the technology is the hardest part.

In reality, the technology part is easy. The most difficult part is manufacturing and shipping reliable mechanisms at low cost. It can be done, but the mechanisms and mechanical parts need to be treated as the primary product, not an afterthought.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Retric on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:09PM (#24173911)
Just as important is people are generally quite capable, so stuff people find annoying tends to be genuinely difficult.

A mass market automated pill dispenser you can just dump your prescriptions in seems like an obviously viable product. But, building something that’s easy enough to use, reliable enough to be safe, and cheap enough to be affordable is a pipe dream.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by ghaff on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:34PM (#24174393)
Turning on a set of lights is not actually very high on the list of annoyances for most people. Putting dishes in the dishwasher and then putting them away, ditto for clothes, wiping down the kitchen counters and cleaning the floor much more so. Dealing with various yard work a bigger PITA still. Guess which one consumer IoT can actually somewhat address.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by tomatotomato37 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:32PM (#24174383)
You know I'll be actually surprised if that isn't a product, because that seems "As seen on TV" level amount of effort. Have some hopper with 7 compartments, put a disk with a hole underneath it, and hook it to some 3 cent digital clock module such that spins it around 50 degrees or so everytime it rolls over. Build the whole thing out of plastic, throw it at some factory in China, and before you know it you'll be selling in every walmart in middle America.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Retric on Saturday August 15, 2020 @11:44PM (#24174848)
Plenty of devices have little bins you fill, some then automatically open those bins on the correct days.

However, pills are of wildly different shapes and sizes, which invalidates most of the seemingly obvious sorting solutions. Prescriptions can also call for multiple pills in the same day.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by tfigment on Sunday August 16, 2020 @01:00AM (#24175289)
Very much this. Last time my dad visited he had 4 pill boxes: 7am,10am,2pm,6pm. We had to color code so he knew which ones at which hour. They had to be portable, at least 10 and 2 did. He had slight dementia so he would get confused about colors and sometimes the day. Even worse was trying to decipher the instructions for each medicine to refill the boxes especially after some would change doses after initial couple of weeks. Really hard to automate that correctly even if you had a sorting machine.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by mjevans on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:45AM (#24176032)
It's really sad, but the automation for this is a pharmacy that creates custom plastic sealed single-dosing packets. Some people, most older people, are on THAT many meds and just need to take the next one off the roll.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Broken_Hippo on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:19AM (#24176647)
I've seen this for a nursing home in Norway. I'm not sure if folks get this at home or not. I'd guess that some that get a home nurse at least once a day gets them. And honestly, they would usually seem to be a good solution.

I think the main weakness is that for a few folks, medicine changes would be difficult because they often are mid-week or mid-month and for some, they would really need their medicines re-packaged. I'm not sure this is as big of a problem in nursing homes and whatnot because the nurse is dispensing the meds, while some folks at home have bad memories or the beginnings of undiagnosed dementia and just won't remember.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Simon_says on Sunday August 16, 2020 @10:39AM (#24178185)
That's what all pharmacies in South Korea do.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by WWWWH on Sunday August 16, 2020 @01:55AM (#24175568)
This and how stable are the active ingredients to oxygen? Are they stored under inert gas in the blister pack?
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by taneq on Sunday August 16, 2020 @05:40AM (#24176469)
Sounds great until someone loads it wrong it doesn’t set the date correctly or something, gets the wrong dosage, and dies. The risk seems too high for the potential reward.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by distances on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:37AM (#24176726)
I'm no market expert, but wouldn't a pill dispenser be a very niche product? Most people aren't on any medication and thus won't need one, at least until reaching old age.

Though the number of old folks is getting larger, so maybe that's a market by itself.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by disgruntledphd2 on Sunday August 16, 2020 @08:40AM (#24177276)
Basically every person over 70 takes some pills in the West.

I know for a fact that my parents and my wife's parents would all love this.

My mother was a nurse, so she handles it better than most, but she still spends an hour a week on it.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by ljm on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:02AM (#24176563)
Reminds me of the Juicero, which took a fairly basic concept (validating a QR code and squeezing a packet of mushed up fruit pulp so juice would come out) and still comically failed because, even with all their meticulously machined gears and cogs, it did a much inferior job to a human hand and a few conveniently shaped kitchen utensils.

Never mind that an internet connected, custom-engineered juice press was a bad idea in the first place. It was still out-manufactured by simple tools like a garlic press, or a little metal thing you twist your fruit on top of. Or a blender.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by nogabebop23 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:14PM (#24174275)
it's kind of interesting that places like University research groups (including MIT in the early days of computing in the 50's/60's) recognized this need and had dedicated machinists to build a lot of the mech that they needed. If you've ever watched a talented smith work a lathe - wow, they are the true wizards!
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by eru on Sunday August 16, 2020 @07:09AM (#24176838)
These days you can scratch that itch on youtube.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by raverbashing on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:15PM (#24173950)
Also see: every "smart lock" startup around.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by dsr_ on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:34PM (#24174395)
I have a great smart lock. The secret is, it's dumb. It has a keypad and a keyhole and a 9V battery that lasts about five years. About three months before the battery wears out, it starts beeping and blinking every time you open it, so you know it's time to replace the battery.

You have to look in the manual to add or remove a code, but it remembers at least a dozen codes. It doesn't talk to a smartphone. It doesn't have a network connection. It doesn't store a log of openings, and it doesn't violate your privacy.

What it does is solve the two biggest problems with door locks: not having your key, and getting a key to a friend so that they can get into your house.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by bigiain on Sunday August 16, 2020 @12:40AM (#24175180)
That sounds like it’s solved half the problem, at least it’s not another outdated Linux 2.7 machine with a nodejs app with no rate limiting listening to unencrypted http sessions over WAP “secured” wifi.

But I wonder how it’d fare if someone like the lockpicking lawyer reviewed it’s mechanical lock design? Is it actually a good lock?

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by Broken_Hippo on Sunday August 16, 2020 @06:25AM (#24176677)
Is it actually a good lock?"

I'm not convinced it matters as long as it seems, to the layperson, to be a lock of average quality. No one really wants a lock to feel insecure if it is held in the hand, for example. And sure, if tests say you can just hit it and open it, you'll pass. But as long as it doesn't have obvious defaults... It is good.

Most locks really just keep out crimes of opportunity. Few folks have locks that will keep out folks that would destroy your front door or break your windows and few are real challenges to lockpicks. And the shouldn't be challenges to lockpicks! Otherwise, how would a locksmith do their work? It doesn't matter, though. Most folks simply aren't lockpicks - and a good number of folks that can* pick locks well do not have desires to break into homes.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by montereynack on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:03AM (#24175852)
Which lock is it that you’re using? I’m kind of in the market atm.
Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by analog31 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:30PM (#24174047)
A big problem is that anybody from those fields who can program well enough to do it exclusively for a living, eventually does so. This could be due to higher pay, and more mobility within the job market.

There's also a perception that software is more valuable than hardware, which can affect the workplace culture in a negative way.

Re:To the future occupants of my office at the MIT Media Lab by OJFord on Sunday August 16, 2020 @03:55AM (#24176070)
> It is rare enough to find people with good electronics and software skills.

That should be my niche (if it's small enough to be called one), but I've worked firmly in software since graduating a few years ago, and I'm increasingly worried that I'm unhirable for anything else, even if I brushed up with some hobby electronics at home, despite it being electronics that got me into CS.

Is there any truth to that? Would I have to start over in a grad role for anyone to hire me for hardware? (I'm not actually looking, I just don't like the thought that the road's closed, my next job has to be software.)