News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by helsinkiandrew on Saturday August 15, 2020 @02:36PM (#24171159)
> the tool automatically scans the faces of people pictured in other users' posts, even if they don't use Instagram and didn't agree to the terms of service.

This suggests to me that the number of people affected is much more than the 100 million Instagram users, and the potential fine much higher.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by clement_b on Saturday August 15, 2020 @03:13PM (#24171433)
Sort of related. I always wondered how people in my photos would react knowing Google Photo was essentially scanning their face without their approval. I am sure this is covered by Google Photos T&Cs somehow, nevertheless, it's a real problem. Should I disclose anyone I snap about this? Even someone walking in the background?
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by djeiasbsbo on Saturday August 15, 2020 @04:26PM (#24172097)
Not sure what you "should" do but I suppose it would be more ethical to use an alternative service than google photos.

Somewhat similar to what you describe, the "Access Contacts" permission usually present in mobile operating systems essentially leaks the contact information of everyone stored in ones contact, if permitted.

The names and associated phone number can be used to build advertising/tracking profiles by apps.

The problem is that even if someone does not use those apps and instead chooses privacy-respecting alternatives, it only takes another person who does use these apps to have their information saved in their contacts.

I would imagine it to be quite similar with these photos and also with the facebook case.

It seems unethical to put other people who might not be on facebook and have not read the terms of service or privacy policy through these algorithms.

I think the contacts example illustrates how hard of a problem this is, I definitely don't have a viable solution. Even if you ask someone for permission, they might change their mind or not fully understand.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by stevesearer on Saturday August 15, 2020 @10:06PM (#24174233)
I was thinking about this on a visit to a major tourist spot I had visited years previously. Because I had been before I decided to go with no camera or phone to just look around.

As I was walking around I realized that so many other people were taking photos where I was in the background that it felt like Facebook or Google knew I was there even though no one else did.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by izacus on Saturday August 15, 2020 @06:18PM (#24172911)
I'm guessing the easiest way to fix this would be to just disable the feature?

According to documentation, Google mentiones that face groups are deleted when you turn the feature off: https://support.google.com/photos/answer/6128838?hl=en

(And if they're not, winning a lawsuit against Google should be trivial.)

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by m463 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @06:35PM (#24173026)
I wonder if they are deleted from generated machine learning models?
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by 3763282827 on Sunday August 16, 2020 @02:16AM (#24175670)
It'd be nice if the article explained how either itself or Illinois were arriving at that 100 million number considering that the population of Illinois is only 12.67m according to a cursory google search.
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by meowface on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:04PM (#24173873)
A 4 billion-plaintiff class action lawsuit would be pretty interesting to watch.
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by rtlfe on Saturday August 15, 2020 @05:23PM (#24172522)
Since this is an Illinois state law, would the number be limited to people who have used Instagram while in Illinois?
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by dheera on Saturday August 15, 2020 @04:20PM (#24172035)
> scans the faces of people pictured in other users' posts

Why is this wrong? You're just scanning a bunch of pixels, and the data was given to you, so any liability or violation of use of someone's likeness is on the person who gave you the data.

Autonomous cars scan the poses and faces of people even if they didn't agree to any ToS, to try to determine what those people are about to do based on their physical expression. Autonomous cars track the movements of strangers over a short time as well by re-identifying a person that moved behind an obstacle and emerged on the other side. It would be silly and unsafe to say they are not allowed to do that, because human drivers do exactly that.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by 0134340 on Saturday August 15, 2020 @04:58PM (#24172349)
Autonomous cars do so when you're in a public space. And by pixels, you could make that same reductive argument when violating anyone's private space via digital or physical, that it's only pixels, bits, molecules, etc. Don't forget laws and ethics work on scales.
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by akersten on Saturday August 15, 2020 @05:10PM (#24172420)
People are tripping over the reductive part of your post, but ignoring what is the strongest argument:

> so any liability or violation of use of someone's likeness is on the person who gave you the data.

That's what I feel too. Presumably, by uploading a picture to FB you are giving your consent for it to be processed however their terms outline. And representing that you have the consent of others in the photo too. Otherwise, what are you doing uploading the photo, if you do not agree with the terms by which it will be used?

The liability for irresponsibly handling someone else's biometric data (per BIPA) to me makes more sense to pin on the person who actually uploaded the data to a known data processing application, rather than blaming the tool.

I gather that that's not a popular opinion here though, and the Illinois law is written in a way that it targets the corporation that winds up with the data.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by mannykannot on Saturday August 15, 2020 @06:24PM (#24172951)
The problem with this argument is that it would be self-servingly naive for the recipient of the images to assume that the source of the data had obtained the appropriate permissions. Of course, the people creating this policy are not that naive; they are simply adopting the attitude cynically, as cover for what they know to be unethical.

To be clear, this does not absolve the supplier of the data for their responsibility, but the supplier’s culpability does not absolve the recipient.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by 3763282827 on Sunday August 16, 2020 @02:30AM (#24175731)
Why should the recipient/platform be culpable if the supplier is already acknowledged as being both culpable and dishonest as far as the ToS? It might be sexier in a David vs. Goliath sense to go after Facebook but Facebook isn't the party creating and uploading all of this content. If the risks of supplying a platform without consent aren't sufficiently high then suppliers will never have an incentive to verify consent. And if the suppliers were already verifying for consent then this would be a non-issue because consent would be implied as far as the platform was concerned.
Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by labawi on Sunday August 16, 2020 @09:07AM (#24177446)
The ToS might as well force people to promise away their firstborn and people would still upload photos.

Platforms have ToS that are non-negotiable and almost nobody reads them. The plaform knows this and that users upload photos without proper permissions and instead of warning users, they make it very convenient to agree (or even preselect it), otherwise it couldn't use the data in an almost-cover-your-ass way.

Note: I don't use these services, please correct me if I'm wrong.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by mannykannot on Sunday August 16, 2020 @11:06AM (#24178397)
In any worthwhile system of ethics, willfully ignoring very reasonable doubts about the provenance of something is itself unethical, separately from what was done by others. Similarly, it is unethical in itself to take advantage of another’s indifference to a third party’s rights in order to do to that third party something they would object to.

As for the question of what the platforms can do, it is simple: treat third parties as if they have refused permission. There’s nothing difficult about it once you filter out the self-serving attitude of the platforms. This has nothing to do with what’s “sexy” and everything to do with what’s right.

Re:Instagram faces $500B in fines alleging it harvested biom... by rubyn00bie on Saturday August 15, 2020 @06:25PM (#24172963)
> Autonomous cars

Let me stop you right there, because that's the difference.

An autonomous car, one would presume, or its builder would find themselves here too, is not permanently scanning every object it finds, tagging it, coalescing it into a giant database, and cross referencing that with an enormous amount of individually identifying information.

The autonomous car doesn't know you're "Jonaldo Stevensmith of Braunschweiger, Texas, 28 years old, working for Brogrammer Inc" nor what you've been doing for the last ten years. Its capability goes only as far as knowing you're one of ten living (human) things it must not run over.

Instgram/Facebook do know who you are. Fb/I have shown time and time again that they aren't capable of securely managing user data. Nor do they make it explicit what they will do with your data long-term, because they themselves do not know.

Let me illustrate the problem further, if I understand things correctly Instgram works primarily on phones. Mobile phones for the last five years by and large have amazing cameras, with sensors ranging from 8 megapixels all the way up to "100 megapixels" in some current flagship models. Instagram, if I understand things correctly, allows you to upload any resolution of photo and stores the original in perpetuity BUT it will only show you very low resolution versions (even of your own photos).

Meaning, Instagram will not show users their original upload and only offers scaled down versions; all the while, performing biometric analysis on the originals. I don't think most people would upload photos if they knew, that their faces were being scanned at in extremely high resolutions and permanently attached to an already unfathomably deep profile. Even if they were okay with a few I don't think most folks would be okay once they realize the scale and true size. It's very likely every photo anyone has taken of you (and uploaded), whether you've been tagged or not (or as someone just in the background) Fb/I will know you're in it. I'm sure that wasn't clearly stated by their terms of service.

Truly, what's happening here could only end even worse for everyone, with an even larger lawsuit(s) than this... I'd wager a even a near company shattering fine of $150bn now would be a deal. Why?

An unfettered quest for growth would leave them blind to what they're creating. By Identifying people using biometric and superficial data and then attempting to predict human behavior combining them-- they will end up creating a fucking racist machine. The machine won't be based on science as a result of its dataset; it's going to be based on "AI" trained from incomplete bullshit data. It will be asked to predict things it is unable to, but the researchers will not be able to discern fact from fiction because there's too much noise. "It fits the curve, it must be right."

The more opaque the machine stays, the longer it will remain hidden, and the more racist it will be become feeding off of itself.

The lawsuit to stop that devil would be end-game for Facebook. I suspect, there would be no recovery, because the dual passage of antitrust and discrimination laws preventing, dismembering, and disemboweling such a wretch would leave only an unrecognizable corpse.

Do I think it's Facebook's intention to create a giant racist fucking machine? Fuck no. I do think it's entirely possible to repeat history, stupidly, and accidentally. The road to hell is paved with good intentions.