News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @09:49AM (#24157885)
Wow - top posts are conspiracy theories. "The only reason to do this..." "This is a security issue..."

Google has millions / billions of users. From a security standpoint the focus should be entirely on the root domain, that is the only really meaningful root of trust.

If you are talking about a security issue - the KEY security issue is ANY lack of clarity around root domain.

"Showing the full URL may detract from the parts of the URL that are more important to making a security decision on a webpage." is a statement they have around this change.

I think I agree - I suspect other browsers will have to copy chrome (again) in de-emphasizing the leading URL (often used for fishing).

Folks seem to miss the fact that google chrome was a minor competitor initially it IE - and their focus on things like ... security ... helped them become absolutely dominant. A fair number of enterprises have (finally) started slow slow switch to mandating chrome.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by badwolf on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:31AM (#24158409)
My first thought when reading this was relief... For my mother.

I've spent most of my adult life trying to teach my parents to look at the address bar to make sure they're on bankofamerica.com and not some random phishing domain. That kind of falls apart though when it's... bankofamerica.comm.phishingdom.com/{random filler}/bankofamerica/user/login

HN users are fantastic at thinking all technologies should revolve around their niche use case.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by dgb23 on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:09PM (#24160461)
The root domain is highlighted in FF. This must be enough for visual testing.

If you want a more reliable approach then you need to work with a whitelist and clear warnings.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by summerlight on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:57PM (#24161048)
I wouldn't assert it without strong evidence. This URL comprehension problem is probably more complex than what people usually think. There are a number of studies about this issue, if you're interested.

https://storage.googleapis.com/pub-tools-public-publication-... https://kumarde.com/papers/urls.pdf

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by dgb23 on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:13PM (#24161297)
Thank you for those! Side question:

I don't have a formal education in CS, but I really enjoy reading papers on programming (languages), architecture, data-engineering and web related things among others, especially when they have a practical focus/impact.

Is there a good way for me to find or rather discover resources like these?

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by automatoney on Friday August 14, 2020 @03:10PM (#24162021)
Not sure about filtering for practical focus/impact but https://arxiv.org/ is an amazingly useful and informative repository of papers that you might like. Also google scholar is good, but more general.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by Corrado on Saturday August 15, 2020 @03:48AM (#24166874)
> The root domain is highlighted in FF. This must be enough for visual testing.

I've been using Firefox for years and never realized this. Looking up at the top of my browser, I can see that "ycombinator.com" is highlighted and the rest of the URL is a darker grey. To me, this seems like a good compromise; you still get the full URL but the important parts stand out a bit more.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:07PM (#24164709)
Exactly - also if you do any penetration testing of your staff side - the key to get something through is have the name of the company it seems anywhere in the URL. Literally - lkjljkdfskjfsd.com/bankofamerica/securelogin.do etc.

Part of the issue I've noticed is some sites actually do outsource things to other sites (microsoft has a lot of redirects on logins so you used to end up on passport.com I think to login, and then to something with azure, then office... etc). Combine this with subdomains and trailing urls and internationalization efforts and you are in trouble.

This must be just because of how we scan / read things? Ie, a quick cross check. A lot of people maybe don't parse all the elements properly (,.:?& etc).

The other issue - let's say just 2-5% of chrome users are confused. That still is a HUGE number that are confused.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by p7hwfizeONj on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:42PM (#24160127)
It looks like non-trivial subdomains will still appear and those seem to me to be the most problematic.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by MaxBarraclough on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:01AM (#24158055)
> their focus on things like ... security ... helped them become absolutely dominant

I don't think Chrome's security features had anything to do with its ascension. Chrome took off because it was fast and had a good UI (iirc it had the ability to drag a tab from one window to another, a while before other browsers did).

The average user knows nothing of the security features of their browser.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by chillfox on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:10AM (#24158164)
Also you couldn’t use google search in a different browser without constantly getting harassed to install chrome
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by acheron on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:25AM (#24158339)
Chrome took off because Google leveraged their position in another area (search engine) in order to push it. Exactly what people were concerned about with Microsoft and Windows/IE.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by MaxBarraclough on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:31AM (#24158408)
That's not the whole story. Plenty of people moved from Firefox to Chrome, because they found Chrome to be the better browser.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by badwolf on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:32AM (#24158425)
Even Microsoft thought that with Edge.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by kd913 on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:04AM (#24158832)
I think Microsoft at the time probably thought it's own engine was also better in many ways. It was in several regarding power efficiency and things like pen/pdf support.

Reason Chromium was chosen was more because they already had a bunch of developer experience with the engine.

That and more importantly it would cause Google to lose some control over Chrome and the web. Now Google can't exactly do further anti-competitor shenanigans like the whole shadowDOM fiasco and youtube. In this case adding random features to chrome, implementing them and causing other browsers to have a bad experience.

That and because edge is as fast as chrome (if not faster), there is less of an incentive to switch to chrome.

Oh and Microsoft is one of the few companies to be able to maintain a hostile fork of chrome and have it competitive. Largely because they have enough resources to match google for Chromium.

This is one of those cases where Microsoft can subtly claw back marketshare by playing the strength of chromium against Google. They wouldn't be able to do the same at all with Gecko/Firefox.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:12PM (#24164741)
It did in a domain I'm familiar with.

I think they were the first to have separate processes for tabs (?) which you could really see add robustness - when flash could blow up your session etc you could much more easily close out the offending tab.

They were stricter and more prompt in blocking things like activex controls, they'd remove features tabs would use to try to take control of your session or confuse you. All these enhanced security and usability.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by MaxBarraclough on Saturday August 15, 2020 @07:09AM (#24168009)
There's no disagreement here. Chrome brought lots of good security enhancements, and raised the bar for other browsers, but security isn't the reason people made the switch.

Yes, Chrome was the first to do process-isolation. As for ActiveX, I believe that's generally only available through Internet Explorer (not Edge), I don't think Chrome ever supported it. [0]

[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ActiveX#ActiveX_in_non-Interne...

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by mrmcd on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:05AM (#24158108)
The degree to which HN is obsessed with AMP is hilarious at times. You'd think every single one of the 100k engineers that work there do nothing but dream up ways to trick people into using AMP for some secret illuminati end goal.

If you don't like AMP, that's fine. If you don't like this UX change that's fine too (and I suspect will be easily fixed with an extension). But maybe consider for a moment that not every single UX change to a product with a billion users is part of the vast AMPiracy.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by davidu on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:24AM (#24158330)
You say this as if those engineers (and it's not 100,000) are all voting in a democratic decision-making process on feature direction. It's a very small number of senior leaders who make these calls.

Remember, Sundar used to be in charge of the Google Toolbar. That was his claim to fame inside of Google before Chrome.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by maest on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:21AM (#24158298)
I'm all for balanced debate, but strawmanning doesn't help anyone.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by thethethethe on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:13PM (#24159795)
How this this a straw man? Parent is just agreeing with gp that a lot of HN users are obsessed with AMP and it’s supposed evils

Disclaimer: googler opinions are my own

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by maest on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:46PM (#24160167)
Nobody is claiming the following ridiculous statements:

> every single one of the 100k engineers that work there do nothing but dream up ways to trick people into using AMP for some secret illuminati end goal.

> every single UX change to a product with a billion users is part of the vast AMPiracy.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by thethethethe on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:32PM (#24160744)
First of all, parent is not arguing with anyone, they are building on gp’s comment.

Parent is using hyperbole as a rhetorical tool to make a point, not to distort or discredit a particular persons statements

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by izacus on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:12AM (#24158938)
The strange part there is that this is mobile Chrome following the mobile Safari UX which has never been criticised like this. It's just bizarre.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by untog on Friday August 14, 2020 @12:31PM (#24159980)
Even desktop Safari does this by default! And yet no one was outraged.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by andrekandre on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:03PM (#24161144)
i think its because apple isnt trying to mitm your web browsing with some amp-style service (yet)
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by jsnell on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:23PM (#24161413)
But Apple does blatantly MITM urls into their own proprietary walled garden! Just a few days ago there was a HN post about Safari On iOS 14 redirecting from certain articles to Apple News. It was, of course, quickly flagged away from the front page.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24113056

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by andrekandre on Friday August 14, 2020 @05:59PM (#24163801)
> It was, of course, quickly flagged away from the front page.

what does that imply?

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by themacguffinman on Friday August 14, 2020 @07:29PM (#24164489)
That the HN audience in aggregate has a hypocritically lower appetite and interest in Apple's web shenanigans, given that a moderator never identified anything actually wrong with the submission and given that Google would be crucified for a similar action in Chrome for Android.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by asddubs on Saturday August 15, 2020 @05:12AM (#24167311)
i always thought it was kind of strange how apple somewhat gets a pass for still releasing it's browser according to basically the IE6 model and worse (since you can't even install competing engines)
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by marcosdumay on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:21PM (#24162775)
Apple users choose to get a system that does different things that restrict them in non-obvious ways. Those people are not going to complain much.

Chrome is the default option for browsers. People don't really choose it anymore.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by baby on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:53PM (#24163131)
Considering most techies have iphones and macbooks I can’t make sense of your comment.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by unethical_ban on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:33PM (#24160755)
They could emphasize the FQDN without removing the URL.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:17PM (#24164766)
People (at least some %) just trigger on see the company name in the bar - if I gave a pop quick to all your relatives do you think they could accruately manager to describe all the separators and what they mean? ?&/: etc?

They've wanted to remove the URL for AT LEAST 6 years - it's been a well known issue inside google that URL's dont' do a good job showing orgin info.

Didn't they have the origin chip idea way back?

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by tbodt on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:32PM (#24162900)
They've been doing this (showing the rest in grey) for a long time.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by coronadisaster on Friday August 14, 2020 @10:46AM (#24158582)
> Folks seem to miss the fact that google chrome was a minor competitor initially it IE - and their focus on things like ... security ... helped them become absolutely dominant.

Security is a very small factor, if a factor at all, for Chrome to have become dominant. The main reason is because they keep/kept pushing everyone to install Chrome when you visited https://google.com (by showing you a small popup window).

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:15PM (#24164759)
Microsoft had IE as the DEFAULT - and did plenty of pushing itself.

Across almost all dimensions chrome was better when it came out - people seem to forget how horrible browsers were historically (and how easily abused). I know ages ago of an entity that just got tired of dealing with the problems folks caused not using chrome (whether it was chrome's website blacklists or whatever - folks using chrome were less likely to get ransomeware - period). Literally - EVERY install of crap seemed to be coming from IE users, except one case I know of where someone had a chrome extension change hands and go rouge.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by hu3 on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:23PM (#24162801)
Do you have evidence?

Because I remember trying Chrome and immediately switching because it was miles ahead. So did my friends. It was faster and had slicker UI.

Nobody keeps using a shittier browser no matter how many times you shove it on their faces.

Btw Chrome is still faster than Firefox for stuff that matters and often by a considerable amount:

https://www.phoronix.com/scan.php?page=article&item=chrome83...

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by coronadisaster on Saturday August 15, 2020 @07:00AM (#24167972)
I don't really have any evidence (hopefully Google will be required to release that evidence in a monopoly probe) besides what I recall from advertising but security certainly doesn't seem to be the primary factor. Speed certainly brought in a lot of users, but by the time Firefox caught up, I am not sure what the market share was (at first there was a huge difference in performance, I don't think that today's difference in performance is comparable).
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by coronadisaster on Saturday August 15, 2020 @09:03AM (#24168553)
By the way, where is the evidence for your claims that a small change in performance equals large market share?
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by kevingadd on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:10AM (#24158914)
Domains are only a meaningful root of trust if they're tightly controlled by a small set of people. A piece of content being on 'news.ycombinator.com' or 'github.com' literally tells me nothing about how trustworthy it is. In the case of yc, i have to look at the poster, and the actual content, and the replies to it. For github, I have to look at things like who posted the code and which repository it's in - both things that are displayed in the URL, oddly enough...

Google's URLs are of course long strings of useless hex/base64 garbage, so it's natural that they want to hide them.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by donor20 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:19PM (#24164773)
100% false. If you login to news.ycombinator.com it's unlikely you are logging into a fishing site for ycombinator. If you login to github.com - again, very unlikely github is running a phishing scam on you.

Do folks not understand the importance of this?

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by CptCrunch on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:29AM (#24159170)
Google has not only become dominant because their product is good. First and foremost, they leveraged their market power through android and their search engine to get people to use chrome.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by buttersbrian on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:43AM (#24159387)
As another said -- chrome was dominant before Android was a player.

Firefox blew a hole in the IE wall. Then chrome came along and was more acid compliant, leaner (Ux/ui), faster, and it's approach of per-tab processes was superior to a lock-up prone Firefox, or IE.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by marcosdumay on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:24PM (#24162814)
Firefox required admin rights to install on Windows, what locked most of the user base out of its reach.

Chrome got his market by silently installing as the IE rendering engine, and by being bundled with other software.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by buttersbrian on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:33PM (#24162913)
I don't think there was anything silent, IMO.

The other biggest factor IMO Chrome greatly focusing on developer tools --> eventually stealing away firebug dev, and in turn taking the throne as the developer browser of choice.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by marcosdumay on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:50PM (#24163092)
Chrome was already very popular by the time it became any good (compared to Firefox).

But even sooner than they investing in dev-tools, they made a killing from tab isolation right at a time when Firefox had most of its stability problems.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by mav3rick on Friday August 14, 2020 @11:33AM (#24159234)
Lol ? You do know Android was nascent when Chrome became dominant.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by ric2b on Friday August 14, 2020 @02:31PM (#24161524)
They could just color it differently or show it in bold text.

Hiding the rest is clearly motivated by something else.

Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by trekrich on Friday August 14, 2020 @09:59AM (#24158024)
at what point is not any longer? Once the URL bar has gone?!
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by paulnechifor on Friday August 14, 2020 @01:50PM (#24160960)
"Conspiracy theory!" has become a term for dismissing genuine concerns.
Re:Google resumes its attack on the URL bar, hides full addr... by exclipy on Friday August 14, 2020 @04:09PM (#24162657)
So the theory is that this is part of Google's evil plan to make it impossible to tell the difference between an AMP page and the real page because the next step is to remove the URL bar.

Given that this change makes it plainly obvious what domain you're on... Now tell tell me if this is a genuine concern or a conspiracy theory.