News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by jacobn on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:45AM (#24133194)
We’re legally unequipped to deal well with gig workers.

They’re arguably neither contractors nor employees, and shoe horning them into either category will inevitably lead to some absurdities.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by zjaffee on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:02PM (#24135540)
We need to end employer based health insurance, every other major problem is easily solvable within the gig worker framework (you can have people accrue PTO and other standard benefits based on hours worked).
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by cactus2093 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:20PM (#24135703)
Strongly agree. I'll never understand the argument of forcing people to give up the benefits they already have as gig-economy workers and become full-time employees. Despite all the issues with the current situation, there are still a lot of obvious benefits that these workers do get like the ability to set their own hours, not having to work exactly 40 hours every week, and being able to work on multiple platforms.

There is a very obvious solution that gives them the best of both worlds, and also helps millions of other unemployed, part-time employed, and entrepreneurial Americans. Let's make it easier for people to get by and meet their basic needs without tying their well being to long-term full-time employment at a large corporation.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by rileymat2 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:07PM (#24137601)
> Despite all the issues with the current situation, there are still a lot of obvious benefits that these workers do get like the ability to set their own hours, not having to work exactly 40 hours every week, and being able to work on multiple platforms.

None of those are linked to being an employee or contractor.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by ytpete on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:55PM (#24138510)
I think they are in some cases. An employee can forbid you from working for a competitor at the same time, for example. This is usually a good thing - e.g. Apple doesn't want their Siri engineers moonlighting on the Alexa team after hours. I don't think contractors can be subject to the same sweeping restrictions.

I believe for employees paid by the hour, the employer can also dictate the number of hours per week and even the specific schedule.

Employers have much more control over their employees -- that's at the heart of the contractor-employee distinction.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by rileymat2 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:25PM (#24139070)
What I am saying is that all those are up to the employer.

So it is disingenuous, when the company talks about additional benefits of being a contractor because those are all self imposed.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by cactus2093 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @11:57AM (#24144727)
I am not "the company", just a spectator that is observing what companies are actually doing in practice.

Yes, companies could always choose to give employees better perks out of the goodness of their heart. That's not really relevant, what's relevant is what they're actually doing. And if a company like Uber were to pay all the extra overhead to bring on all drivers as full-time employees, it would be crazy for them not to set their hours much more tightly so they would absolutely do that.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by victoro on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:50PM (#24133945)
I'm wildly out of my depth, but why couldn't Uber drivers be regulated effectively as micro-franchises? The dynamics seem pretty similar -- drivers benefit from the Uber marketing, brand (which brings trust which is necessary in a business as personal as getting into a stranger's car) and "secret sauce" (the dispatch network and app experience). Uber wants to control some aspects of each "franchise" like the cleanliness of vehicles, making sure that they don't discriminate against customers in unappealing areas, and, to some extent pricing. This is necessary to maintain the Brand and keep customers coming back. Uber doesn't want to get into all aspects of running the franchise (setting hours, making sure drivers are only driving for them etc), because it would un-profitable to do at such scale -- just like McDonalds doesn't want to get deal with the management of individual restaurants.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by SamReidHughes on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:36PM (#24134545)
AB5 is hitting such franchises pretty hard too.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:22PM (#24135091)
There obviously needs to be a new class of workers. I've seen the phrase "Dependent Contractor" tossed around here on HN and I think it'd do quite well.

If you work for an employer who sets your hours, pay, etc., you'd still be designated as an employee.

If you sell your labor to multiple entities, and/or you set your own pay rate, you're an independent contractor.

If you do not set your pay rate, you'd be a "dependent contractor", and entitled to at least some basic worker protections, but not necessarily things like mandatory paid 15-minute breaks. Those should continue to be required for employees whose hours are set by the company for them, but it feels silly to regulate a thing like this when an Uber driver is completely free to just turn the app off if they need a break.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:38PM (#24135276)
A "dependent contractor" is literally what an employee is, except that in your scenario it would just be an employee without the decades of hard-fought labor protections like bathroom breaks.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:28PM (#24137207)
If a grocery store cashier could punch out an hour into their shift, take a day off on a whim, or switch between 3 different grocery stores depending on which is paying better, I'd be inclined to agree with you, but you have to admit that gig work is quite different than traditional employer-employee relationships (which is why they're classified as independent contractors in most of the U.S.). They're not paid a salary or hourly; they're paid per gig, and they're under no obligation to accept any gig.

True, they're not nearly as empowered as a traditional independent contractor like a plumber who can set his own prices, but they're not as powerless as a traditional employee who has no control over their hours either. They're something in between, and their work should be regulated as such.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by accountinhn on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:26PM (#24136500)
I disagree. Every Uber driver, also drives for Lyft and some format of gig on-demand services (like Postmates, Uber eats) during the same hours. If there is a ride from Uber they pick up that ride, if not they switch to Lyft and pick up their rides. I'm yet to see an employer who will be okay with their employee doing it.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by GhostVII on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:03PM (#24135552)
No, a "dependent contractor" is completely different from a regular employee. As an employee you are generally required to work certain hours, or at the very least do a certain amount of work in a week, and are paid either hourly or salaried. A dependent contractor, in this example, can set their own hours, start or stop working whenever they want, and gets paid per job rather than per hour or month.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:15PM (#24135664)
Today I learned from the internet that I have been wrong about the advice I have been providing clients for the past decade... /s

Employees have contracts, too.

Everything you have described as supposed features of dependent contractors are features of independent contractors. Indeed, that last point is one of the biggest historical factors (in the US, and most of Europe) for determining whether a worker is an employee or a contractor. Historically what made a worker an independent contractor instead of an employee was that a worker was economically independent from an employer for their livelihood because they had other clients paying them for the same work. The work independence factors are an outgrowth of that analysis.

As to your other points:

Many employees can set their own hours. Most white collar employees can (and now do, as a result of COVID). It is hourly workers that can't chose when they work, because they are paid on the basis of time work rather than labor performed. Generally, whether a contractor can set their own hours is determined by the contract.

I'm not aware of any contractors that can simply start and stop working during a contracted job without violating their contract, so in that respect your point isn't valid for any worker, employee or otherwise.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by GhostVII on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:29PM (#24137226)
Current classifications are irrelevant because the parent was laying out a new system, in which you could either be an employee, an independent contractor, or a dependent contractor. Under that proposed system, there is a significant difference between a dependent contractor and an employee, because the dependent contractor can choose to stop working whenever they want, and can work for multiple companies, while an employee could not do that.

And regardless, I don't know of any hourly employees who can choose to stop working for several weeks without notice, and then start working again whenever they want. That is a major difference between something like Uber, and a normal hourly job. Also hourly people are paid by the hour, while with Uber you are paid by the job.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:32AM (#24140859)
A dependent contractor is an employee (if they are an individual). This has been the actual state of the law for decades in the US and EU. Redefining existing terms doesn't change that, and the parent's comment doesn't create a meaningful distinction between the existing classifications.

Worse, it creates distinctions that are based on factors that are largely irrelevant to the employee-contractor classification.

Today, employees are free to choose to stop working whenever they want (the US has at-will employment) and can work for multiple companies (indeed, most American workers work for multiple companies, especially those who work multiple part-time jobs to make ends meet).

I don't know of any contractor that can choose to stop working for several weeks without notice during a contract and get rehired by the client they walked out on. They'd have to find a new client. This is no different from an employee getting terminated for not showing up for several weeks.

And with respect to getting paid by the job: while this is one of the big factors for independent contractors, it is not exclusive to them. Employees in the entertainment industry get paid per job (game programmers get paid per game, members of the Hollywood guilds and unions get paid per project, union musicians get paid per recording or tour, etc.)

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by abeppu on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:15PM (#24135669)
How would you compare a "dependent contractor" to a restaurant worker who is largely paid in tips, and where management changes their working schedule frequently and erratically?
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by GhostVII on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:34PM (#24137267)
The dependent contractor can stop working without facing reprocussions, the restaurant worker has to work the shifts that they are scheduled or they will get fired.

Also the restaurant worker is guaranteed minimum wage, while the dependent contractor is not, since they are not paid hourly.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by HPsquared on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:16PM (#24137674)
Uber drivers can't take bathroom breaks?
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by tedajax on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:20PM (#24135704)
Or they can just be employees because that's what they are...
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by bpfrh on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:58AM (#24133348)
In austria we have something in between called "Neue selbständige".

They are basically a contractor but are not required to register as a company.

They are still forced to have a accident, health and pension insurance but not a unemplyoment insurance(like employees have).

Doesn't apply to uber though afaik.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by ghaff on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:02PM (#24133391)
Any classification of people accepting money for work is pretty much a creature of tax and employment law and big buckets don't really handle cases at the edges very well. For example, freelance writers can write for whoever they want but they also tend to have clients who they do work for regularly--which has caused some to run afoul of the recent California rules. But that looks a lot different from a full-time Uber driver which, in turn, looks a lot different from someone who drives for Uber now and then to puick up some beer money.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by yaur on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:10PM (#24134217)
I think it's more like "gig workers" were created to try to do an end run around hard won protection for workers. The idea that someone driving (or waiting for pickups) 40+ hours a week is somehow different is different than somehow different than someone (e.g.) doing tech support for 40+ hours a week is absurd.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by GhostVII on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:07PM (#24135582)
It is entirely different, since you can start or stop your work at any time, can choose to only work when the pay is good enough, and are not committed to a single company. I don't think a job where you can start working by just installing and app, and get paid by the job, should be treated as the same as one where you are required to work some amount each week and get paid the same every week.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by maerF0x0 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:17PM (#24134315)
The number 40 (sometimes 30) has become this arbitrary standard with large binary differences on each side of the fence. This makes it very difficult for people to negotiate time off, less than full time schedules, partial retirement etc.

Laws written in the past often are deeply tied to the assumption of one american lifestyle and dream, which is no longer the reality, and thus is very inefficient for many many people. Laws written to instead capture the concepts and algorithmically scale them would be much more effective. Something like $EMPLOYER must pay N/40ths of the healthcare cost where N is the number of hours worked. People with 2 jobs could get full healthcare premiums covered.

People who want to scale back to 1/2 time would know what to expect and it wouldnt be a binary decision factor.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by julienb_sea on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:03PM (#24136950)
That is objectively not true. Most of the "gig economies" were previously done by employees who did not have the kind of benefits you are implying. Taxi drivers almost uniformly do not receive any health insurance benefit at all.

Gig economy was designed to circumvent overburdening regulation and supply restrictions, making the service cheaper, more available and more effective for users. The benefits of this are very obvious in the case of taxis versus uber.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by emiliobumachar on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:19PM (#24135072)
Consider someone doing tech support for zero to 60 hours per week, at their own discretion, and getting paid for ticked solved.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by throw_m239339 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @11:51AM (#24133250)
> We’re legally unequipped to deal well with gig workers.

Yes we are equipped to deal well with gig workers, it's just that Uber doesn't want to play by the rules and want to have it both ways. Let drivers set their own fare, for starter. "Gig workers" aren't a new category of workers just because you use some corporate newspeak to describe these workers.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by JumpCrisscross on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:00PM (#24133369)
> Let drivers set their own fare, for starter

Uber has allowed this since June [1].

[1] https://www.uber.com/blog/california/set-your-fares/

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by frenchman99 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:47PM (#24133892)
Looking at this page, it seems like they can't set their fares, but only a "fare multiplier", so effectively, Uber still decides.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by thinkharderdev on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:38PM (#24134577)
Are there any restrictions on what the multiplier can be? If not then they can effectively set the fare. The "standard" fare is $X per mile and I want $Y per mile. I just set the multiplier to Y/X
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by icebraining on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:24PM (#24135111)
They say the "fare multiplier can range from 0.5x to 5.0x in increments of 0.1". Not fully free, but being able to set over 5x the regular price seems mostly academic.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by Pfhreak on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:03PM (#24136217)
That's interesting, because there's much, much more granularity above 1.0 than below it if you enforce increments of 0.1.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @12:45PM (#24133872)
Why wouldn't they fit squarely into the category of contractors? They set their own hours and use their own equipment. The fact that the platform sets dynamic prices doesn't change this. Contracts to do work in times with more demand command higher prices in plenty of other industries. Caterers probable charge more during the holidays, right?
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by jonahhorowitz on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:02PM (#24134118)
The requirements for contractors are (known as the ABC test)[0][1]:

1) Part A of the test requires that the worker is free from the control and direction of the hiring entity in connection with the performance of the work, both under the contract for the performance of the work and in fact; and

2) Part B of the test requires that the worker performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity’s business; and

3) Part C of the test requires that the worker is customarily engaged in an independently established trade, occupation, or business of the same nature as the work performed.

4) The contractor must actually be in business for themselves.

[0] - https://www.californiaemploymentlawreport.com/2019/03/unders...

[1] - https://www.dir.ca.gov/dlse/faq_independentcontractor.htm

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:15PM (#24134288)
1) Uber drivers are totally at liberty to set their own hours, and drive in location of their choice ( destination are chosen by Uber, but a worker is at liberty to drive in San Jose one day and San Francisco the next).

2) The drivers are outside of Uber's business. Uber is a software and technology company, not a taxi service.

3) Drivers are independent workers, in business for themselves.

4) Same as above.

With these criteria it unambiguously seems to be the case that ride share drivers are independent contractors. I struggle to see how one could make the case that they are employees.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:49PM (#24135417)
1) True. But until about 1 month ago, Uber drivers didn't get to set their own rates, and they were punished for not accepting rides. Moreover, a key issue for this test is that Uber matches drivers to riders, so the normal independence that would be expected from a "platform" does not exist.

2) I laughed so hard I scared my neighbor's dog. Uber is a transportation service that happens to use technology (in the form of software) to provide it's service. Have you read their SEC filings or any of their other legal documents? In their own legally binding filings, they describe their primary business as providing transportation and food delivery services, not as a "platform" for whatever.

3 and 4) This is false, but it's a tricky point. Under AB5, it's not enough to just drive for multiple companies; a driver must satisfy certain legal formalities related to being in business for themselves, like setting up a legal entity, getting their own insurance, etc., to prove they are "customarily engaged" in the business. (Note that points 3 and 4 were distinct in the case law but were combined in AB5.) Most drivers haven't done this.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:03PM (#24136209)
So now Craigslist needs to be regulated as an automobile dealer because it hooks up people selling cars to each other? Is Apple in the business of recording music because it runs iTunes? Does DoorDash need to have their offices inspected for food safety because they run a market for food delivery. No. Craigslist operates a platform for selling cars, it doesn't actually sell cars itself. Apple doesn't actually make music (unless they runs studio they I don't know about), they run a market for artists and record companies to sell their own music. DoorDash operates a platform for restaurants to sell food, it doesn't actually sell food itself. Contrary to your insistence otherwise, running a platform that connects buyers and sellers of something is not the same thing as actually providing that good or service yourself. People say that it takes mental gymnastics to arrive at this conclusion. I see the opposite: how do you manage to convince yourself that people writing code at Uber are in the same line of business as getting behind the wheel of a taxi? How do people convince themselves that a PM at DoorDash works at a restaurant?

Also, you misstate (or rather, only partially state) the description of their business in SEC filings. They describe themselves operating a market for food delivery and personal transportation. They are in the business of transportation and food delivery, but they are a in a different layer than the people actually driving cars. This is akin to saying Expedia is in the airline business. Yes, but they sell airline tickets they don't fly planes. Calling Uber a taxi company makes a out as much sense as saying Expedia is an airline.

And for 3 & 4 this could easily be resolved by having driver set up their own LLCs. But I'm not convinced this is actually a requirement. Plenty of people are contractors and fill out 1099s without operating their own LLC or partnership or some other type of company.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:52PM (#24138019)
No, not sure how you even got there with Craigslist, and even if AB5 was relevant there's an exception for direct sales that would exempt craiglist and similar sites like ebay.

AB5 doesn't apply outside of the worker classification context, so your rambling about Doordash and food safety regulations is just bizarre. You're right that DoorDash is in the food delivery business and so its delivery drivers would be its employees under AB5 (and thats what the underlying case decided). Door Dash is not in the food preparation business, so restaurant workers wouldn't be treated as DoorDash's workers.

Contrary to your insistence otherwise, running a platform that connects buyers and sellers of something is not the same thing as actually providing that good or service yourself. People say that it takes mental gymnastics to arrive at this conclusion. I see the opposite: how do you manage to convince yourself that people writing code at Uber are in the same line of business as getting behind the wheel of a taxi? How do people convince themselves that a PM at DoorDash works at a restaurant?

I agree that running a platform that connects buyers and sellers in a marketplace is not the same as providing that good/service itself, which is why Amazon Marketplace and eBay don't run afoul of AB5. But UBER/LYFT DOES NOT RUN A MARKETPLACE. They would have to make significant changes to their apps to be considered "marketplaces" by any reasonable or historic definition of the term.

This is akin to saying Expedia is in the airline business.

This is not at all like saying Expedia is in the airline business. Expedia operates like a marketplace. It buys inventory from airlines and hotels and resells them to customers. The ultimate commercial relationship is still between the customer and the airline/hotel. That is not the case with Uber/Lyft as they are currently structured: both the rider and the driver have the commercial relationship with Uber and it only exists through Uber.

And for 3 & 4 this could easily be resolved by having driver set up their own LLCs. But I'm not convinced this is actually a requirement. Plenty of people are contractors and fill out 1099s without operating their own LLC or partnership or some other type of company.

AB5 provides a lot of exemptions, so it's not necessary in every context. Rideshare drivers aren't one of the exemptions.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:14PM (#24138184)
You're applying double standards here. If Expedia is not an airline, then Uber and Lyft aren't taxi companies. Uber and Lyft buy the services of independent drivers and resells them to customers. If the ultimate commercial relationship is between you and the hotel or airline when you book through Expedia, then it's just as fair to say that the ultimate commercial relationship is between the passenger and Uber/Lyft driver. Just like how Expedia's role is connect a customer with an airline and handle the payment transaction, Uber/Lyft's role is to connect a passenger with a driver and handle the payment transaction.

Crucially, your statement that the commercial relationship only exists through Uber is patently false. Drivers can, and do, driver for different ride sharing companies. A passenger could hire a driver through Uber on one day, and hire the same driver through Lyft on the next.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by james-mcelwain on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:35PM (#24138780)
> If the ultimate commercial relationship is between you and the hotel or airline when you book through Expedia, then it's just as fair to say that the ultimate commercial relationship is between the passenger and Uber/Lyft driver.

When I book a flight through Expedia I enter a contract of carriage with the airline, not Expedia. This is a contractural matter, not just an abstract concept of "commercial relationship."

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @10:53PM (#24139512)
And when you take an Uber, you enter a contract of carriage with the Uber driver. Uber drivers have to have contract of carriage permits for this reason.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:25AM (#24140816)
You do not enter into a contract of carriage with the Uber driver. At no point in using Uber or Lyft does the app have you agree to a specific contract with the driver, which is required for the contract of carriage to apply...

(In contrast, with taxis, signage in the vehicle indicates that proceeding with a ride does indicate acquiescence to the standard terms locally governing taxi services.)

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:40PM (#24147558)
So Uber requires it's drivers to have contract of carriage permits for no reason at all? No, you are entering a contract of carriage with Uber driver when you schedule a ride.

Taxi services and medallions specifically allow drivers to be hailed from the street. Uber and Lyft drivers don't get hailed Dr the street and thus don't need taxi medallions. This isn't something new, services like Super Shuttle operate in the same way. Uber drivers don't have such signage because they're not taxis, they're like super shuttle. You didn't hail them from the street you booked a ride through a service.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by nrmitchi on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:52PM (#24134757)
> 2) The drivers are outside of Uber's business. Uber is a software and technology company, not a taxi service.

This seems like _quite_ a stretch. With that logic you can make any modern company a "technology business" or a "logistics business", and suddenly everything a company does is outside of their core business.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by nostoc on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:36PM (#24134549)
> The drivers are outside of Uber's business. Uber is a software and technology company, not a taxi service.

That is some serious mental gymnastic.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:07PM (#24134934)
No, it's not. Is Apple in the business of producing records because it runs iTunes? No, it's in the business of software (and hardware), and some of that software is used to sell music.

Trying to claim that a software service to run a marketplace to sell X is the same thing as actually running a business of building or doing X takes some mental gymnastics.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:03PM (#24135559)
It takes some seriously bizarre mental gymnastics to call Uber/Lyft "marketplaces" when they don't provide any of the hallmarks of a marketplace, such as the option to select between multiple "stores" (aka drivers) or let drivers compete by offering their own prices.

Even more importantly, with an actual marketplace, you don't transact with the marketplace--you transact with the stores.

And with respect to your Apple analogy: Apple doesn't claim to be in the business of making music, just selling it. Uber/Lyft do claim to be in the transportation/food delivery businesses, and it's literally all over their legally binding SEC filings that the provide to investors every few weeks.

If it quacks like a duck, and it walks like a duck, and it swims like a duck, you can call it a digital platform all you like but it's still a duck.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:12PM (#24136307)
No, the Apple analogy is entirely accurate. Apple is in the music business. But it's not in the business of making music, it's in the business of selling music. Apple is in the music business in the same vein that a record shop is in the music business.

Uber is in the personal transportation business, at a broader high level. It's in the business of operating a market for rides. Just like how a record store doesn't actually compose and record the music it sells, Uber isn't in the business of actually driving people around. That task is fulfilled by independent workers, who use the platform Uber and Lyft operate to find customers.

Can you point out in said SEC filings where Uber says, "our company's primary business is operating motor vehicles to transport customers"? As in, actually driving their own cars? Because from what I've read they're very careful about describing their business as operating a marketplace for drivers to conduct their own businesses.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:37PM (#24137892)
We agree that Apple is just selling music, not making it. We disagree on how analogy that applies to Uber.

On its 10K, Uber identifies "gross bookings" as its primary revenue stream. Not "net bookings" or "commissions" or "marketplace fees." Gross bookings. Meaning that it treats all of the income from a ride as its own income, meaning that it's primary business activity is providing transportation services. The same is true for Lyft.

If they want to claim to be technology companies that only make their money from marketplace fees/commissions, they're free to do so but they'll need to change their financial and legal filings to match (and possibly their fare structures as well, since there's a mismatch between what riders pay and what drivers actually get). The reason they haven't done so is because that amount would be a lot smaller than the gross bookings number, but they can't have it both ways.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @07:21PM (#24138242)
What impact does this have on the classification of drivers? When Uber takes $10 from a passenger for a ride, and contracts out a driver to transport the passenger for $8 then Uber has a booking for $10 and an expense of $8 for contracting out that ride. This doesn't change the fact that the driver is a contractor who sets their own hours and can drive for competitors.

Yes, Uber and Lyft are involved in providing transportation services but their involvement is in connecting customers with transportation providers. Calling Uber and Lyft taxi companies makes about as much sense as calling an Expedia an airline. Expedia provides air transport, but through reselling the services of airline companies like Delta or Alaska. Uber and Lyft provide transport by reselling the services of independent contractors. Uber and Lyft are taxi companies as much as Expedia is an airline: they're not.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by gamblor956 on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:18AM (#24140770)
It's a basic principle of contract law that parties can't agree to a valid contract if they don't know the basic fundamental financial terms of the contract, like say, the price.

A driver does not know how much a passenger is paying for the ride. The passenger does not know how much the driver is receiving for the ride. Ergo, they cannot have formed a valid contract with each other. On the other hand, the passenger knows how much they are paying Uber, and the driver knows how much Uber is paying them. This indicates that the common relationship is Uber, and that the driver is acting as Uber's agent with respect to the driving services. This is supported by Uber/Lyft treating gross booking as their revenue. It is a long-standing principle of GAAP that if you are collecting money on someone else's behalf as their agent, it's not your revenue. If you are treating the money as your revenue, and their services as an expense, that indicates they are acting as an agent on your behalf with respect to the services/whatever that gave rise to the revenue. Because the driver is acting as Uber's agent, AB5 comes into play to determine whether they are an employee or independent contractor.

I don't know why you're fixated on Expedia. Expedia is a reseller, which is a thing that has existed as a legal construct for over a century and has an actual meaning and requirements defined by law. Expedia doesn't resell services, it sells reservations/tickets/etc provided by third parties that represent a right to a specific performance of a specified service at a specified time and place by that third party. Importantly, once a transaction is completed on Expedia, the customer must generally seek customer service from the third party, not Expedia, because Expedia's role in the transaction is completed, and Expedia only provides relief if the third party will not, and that relief is limited to refunding the customer for the amount they paid Expedia.

UberLyft don't sell services provided by third parties, they sell a service (transportation or food delivery), and it happens to be performed by third parties on UberLyft's behalf. In contrast to Expedia, none of the participants in the transportation or food delivery service get to select their putative counterpart to the transaction, or the financial terms of the transaction, and after the driver's part is concluded they usually have no further interaction with the passenger as customer service service issues are provided by UberLyft, not the driver. IOW, there are no hallmarks of a business relationship between the driver and customer.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:48PM (#24147680)
Expedia is a perfect example because they're doing in essence the same thing that Uber and Lyft are doing: reselling transportation services. When you book an Uber what you're doing is informing Uber that you want to go from point a to point b. The Uber finds a third party willing to fulfill that task, and resells this service to the customer at a markup. It's exactly the same thing Expedia does, only in real time.

> UberLyft don't sell services provided by third parties, they sell a service (transportation or food delivery), and it happens to be performed by third parties on UberLyft's behalf.

Which is exactly why the drivers are contractors. You seem to understand that the drivers are third parties, yet are fixated on irrelevant things like revenue from bookings to try and distract from this fact. That Uber treats all of the money paid by the passengers as revenue does not alter the fact that it's drivers are contractors that set their own hours and can drive for competing services.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by solidasparagus on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @05:27PM (#24137202)
Yes, Apple is absolutely a music publishing company (among other things) because it runs iTunes.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @06:00PM (#24137528)
It's a music publishing company as much as DoorDash is a restaurant. You use DoorDash to get food, but DoorDash is not the person actually making the food. Likewise Apple sells music, but said music is actually recorded and published by some other entity.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by solidasparagus on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:10PM (#24139000)
Apple has Apple Music, a publishing division, where the head of it has the title Global Director of Music Publishing. It's kind of absurd to say that Apple isn't in the business of music publishing.
Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @09:26PM (#24139080)
If Apple has actually started publishing its own music then indeed Apple would be a music publisher.

But has Uber done the same? Can you charter a car actually driven by Uber employees? As far as I am aware, Uber exclusively builds a platform to link passengers with independent drivers - who can and often do drive for competing services. Akin to what iTunes was before Apple started publishing its own music.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by solidasparagus on Thursday August 13, 2020 @12:10AM (#24139861)
Your argument is circular. Uber drivers aren't employees because they are contractors. They are contractors because driving isn't Uber's core business. Uber's core business isn't driving because they don't have any drivers as employees.

Uber buys cars and leases them to drivers, it offers full-time professional drivers through Black, it invests billions of dollars into self-driving cars, it offers delivery as a B2B service. Look at the Uber Eats advertising[1] - they aren't claiming to connect you to drivers, they are claiming to connect you to your customers.

Uber's core business is clearly driving.

[1] https://www.ubereats.com/restaurant/en-US/signup

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Thursday August 13, 2020 @03:25AM (#24140815)
No, the logic isn't circular at all. Uber drivers set their own hours, crucially, and are free to work at competitors. Someone can drive for Lyft 5 hours one week, and drive for Uber 5 or 15 hours the next. And Uber doesn't tell them when they need to work.

You say that I Uber offers full time drivers through black. Do you mean that Uber assign drivers to work at a specific time frame for a significant duration? All I can tell about Uber Black is that it offers drivers with more stringent requirements (more licensing, more permits), I don't see any advertisement of having someone chauefer you around for a week. If Uber does offer that kind of service, then drivers rendering that service should be employed.

> Look at the Uber Eats advertising[1] - they aren't claiming to connect you to drivers, they are claiming to connect you to your customers.

Yes! This is entirely the point. The driver is a fairly minimal component of an Uber Eats order. Deliver usually amounts to less than a third of a delivery at least where I live and easily under a fifth. And for that reason Uber contract out this part of delivering an Uber Eats order. Simply asking the public "who wants to take this order to the delivery address?" and creating a market for labor is a more effective solution than making hiring decisions, trying to schedule people fairly across the day.

If object to the contractor model as a whole that's its own criticism. But it is exceedingly hard to claim that Uber's relationship with drivers who participate in the market it runs is that of an employer to employee.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by hundchenkatze on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:16PM (#24135671)
> 2) The drivers are outside of Uber's business. Uber is a software and technology company, not a taxi service.

What good is all that software and technology if a driver doesn't pick me up when I request a ride. Uber very much depends on drivers to perform their core function.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by manfredo on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:17PM (#24136375)
Absolutely. This actually a type of relationship that many businesses have. Most hair salons don't actually employ any hairdresser. They employ the people that clean the shop, and run the register. But the hairdresser themselves are independent and lease a stall in the shop. The salon very much depends on the independent hairdressers to function.

Pointing out that Uber would cease to function without independent contractors is entirely correct, but does nothing to demonstrate that that these workers should be categorized as employees rather than contractors.

Re:Uber CEO says its service will probably shut down tempora... by jacquesm on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:57PM (#24136150)
We're very well equipped, we just don't use the laws we already have. If we did the gig economy would die overnight. Just class all of them as employees and be done with it. Gig workers existed in the past. Many harbors used them. You got paid for every piece removed or stowed in the hold of a ship. Governments the world over realized this led to all kinds of bad outcomes and outlawed the practice. Containerization did the rest. So we already know this particular demon and the solution was to make it illegal and to make all such people employees.