News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by fizwhiz on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:19PM (#24122883)
> Are $500k+ yearly salaries in SV really that usual?

Salaries? Not at all. Total compensation? Well, it depends.

Software engineers with < 10yrs of experience routinely make this much at FAANG. The total compensation number usually includes the following:

* Salary

* Bonus (anywhere between 15-25% of salary)

* Initial grant that vests over 3-4yrs

* Stock "refreshers" that you get annually

* General equity appreciation due to a bull market

For senior engineers, the equity portion of their compensation far outweighs their salary.

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:25PM (#24122964)
I wouldn't count the equity appreciation as compensation. you already own the capital, its your own capital gain, not income from employer at that point.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by conro1108 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:33PM (#24123089)
I'd argue that if we're talking about unvested equity, counting appreciation as a comp increase rather than capital gain is reasonable.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by blawson on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:36PM (#24123132)
Yes and no. When your RSUs are granted at 100k and then vest a few years later at 300k, from yours and the IRS' perspective you made whatever + 300k.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by vkou on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:57PM (#24123468)
Yes, but you should value them at 100k, because it is the functional equivalent of getting a 100k cash bonus, that you (instead of diversifying) foolishly spent on buying a single company's stock.

You don't actually need to work at Facebook to sink 100k into buying Facebook stock (That you then forbid yourself from selling for 4 years).

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by stale2002 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:06PM (#24124493)
> that you (instead of diversifying) foolishly spent on buying a single company's stock

So, it is actually a bit more complicated, and better than that, and long term stock grants act as a psuedo stock hedge.

This is a simplification, but imagine that there is stock worth X, that hs a 50% chance of the stock doubling in value, and a 50% chance of it crashing to 0$. You might think that this would be equivalent in expected value to X, but that is not true.

It is not true, because if the stock goes way down, you don't have to "accept" those losses. Instead, you can jump to another company, mid way through, and get back your previously high salary.

In that way you can capture the upside potential, while also being protected against the downside losses, in that if the stock goes down, you just jump ship, and get a high salary somewhere else.

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @07:01PM (#24126970)
hedging is not arbitrage. There is no free lunch.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by stale2002 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:13AM (#24128788)
In this case it is free arbitrage.

This is because if the stock goes way down, and you are 1 year into your 4 year vest, then you can leave the company, and get a high compensation package somewhere else.

Do you understand how this makes it so you have free downside protection, from those other 3 years, because you can leave and get the high salary somewhere else, if the stock crashes?

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by vkou on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @04:21AM (#24129699)
Since RSUs vest over time, the penny-for-penny equivalent financial transaction for receiving $100K worth of RSUs over 4 years, would be for me to receive $100K of cash compensation over 4 years, and using it to buy stock (That I can't sell for X months).

There's no advantage to RSUs. Cash is better in every way, because, at worst, you can invest it in the exact same allocation that your RSUs are invested in. Any gain from them rising in price could have been realized by investing cash. Any loss from them falling in price is a real, not a paper loss. [1]

I'll take $100 of cash over $100 of RSUs any day. I probably wouldn't take $80 of cash over $100 of RSUs, though.

[1] Unless for some weird reason, you are accounting your personal finances, where a 4-year stock grant is realized in year 1. If you are doing this, you should stop, because it is not an accurate way to do accounting.

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by stale2002 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @02:57PM (#24135488)
> the penny-for-penny equivalent financial transaction for receiving $100K worth of RSUs over 4 years, would be for me to receive $100K of cash

You still dont understand. Let me work this out for you, year by year.

Lets say that the stock grant is 25k a year, over 4 years. But there is a 50% chance, after year 1, of the stock doubling and staying there, and a 50% chance of it going to 0. IE, it will be worth 50k or 0$, which is an expected value of 25k.

So you have 100k of stock, and 25k vests on year 1.

Situation 1: you win the coin flip, and the stock doubles. Your 25k that you received, is now worth 50k. BUT, you now have an ADDITIONAL 150k that is unvested. The unvested stock has increased in value! If you stay for 3 more years, you get 200k in total.

Total value: 200k, over 4 years.

Now, lets look at situation 2.

In situation 2, the stock crashes to 0, after 1 year. Your 25k vest, is now worth 0$. As is, the next 3 year vest is also worth 0.

But here is the trick. What you do now, is that you quit your job. You do not stay at the company for 3 more years, to get the 0$ of stock. Instead, you get different job with stock that vests at 25k a year.

Total value: 0$ for the first year, + 25k/year at job 2. Which equals 75k.

Do you see how this is different?

You absolutely could NOT get the same value as this, if you were paid in cash. Because if you were paid in cash, then you would realize the full losses of situation 2.

> Any gain from them rising in price could have been realized by investing cash

No, actually. In situation 1, I receive 200k, and in situation 2 I receive 75k, because I am protected by the downside risk, by the fact that if the stock crashes to 0, I can leave the company and get my salary higher again.

This is not possible by investing 100k from the beginning.

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by vkou on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:38PM (#24135904)
Yes, you're right, RSUs are better as a signing bonus, in a bull market. (In a bear market, plus a harder job market, you would have been better off locking cash in for your comp - if switching jobs after a year would not get you an equivalent RSU/cash grant)

Once the four year vesting cliff is done, though, the annual top-ups aren't much different from cash (Because if the stock inflates fantastically, you will get fewer RSUs next year).

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:44AM (#24157140)
Agree. It comes down to if you think equity is underpriced. If you think its underpriced, take the equity. If it later becomes worthless, you jump ship, unless they offer more cash to compensate. So, yes you have some extra value tied up in your option to just leave before vesting. If its overpriced from the beginning, ask for cash in the beginning.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:34AM (#24131392)
The advantage if you are definitely going to invest the cash in the same company is you get to invest pretax with rsu’s probably.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by vkou on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @01:46PM (#24134684)
No, I don't, I pay income tax on my RSUs when they vest. And then I pay cap gains taxes I sell.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:36AM (#24157075)
you are right. Even ISO options are subject to AMT in exercise year: https://carta.com/blog/stock-options-tax/
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @08:31AM (#24131355)
High package elsewhere is not free money... Also leaving the company isn’t free (you lose unvested shares, atleast). this isn’t arbitrage. even arbitrage usually has some carrying risk in between the two transactions.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by naveen99 on Friday August 14, 2020 @08:47AM (#24157169)
Never mind, see sibling threads.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by logicslave12 on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:34PM (#24123091)
It’s basically guaranteed at this point. And you don’t own the capital, you don’t start getting the massively appreciated grants until you are a few years in
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by opportune on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @03:55PM (#24125209)
You actually do not own the capital until it vests, and the amount that vests (which could have greatly appreciated) is all taxed as income.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by MagnumOpus on Wednesday August 12, 2020 @03:43AM (#24129544)
That's just accounting treatment. Doesn't change the financial fact that it can be replicated with a cash bonus the same size as the original grant.
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by opportune on Thursday August 13, 2020 @09:35PM (#24152179)
No, it can't because you lose unvested shares if you leave before they vest. Have you ever been granted RSUs?
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by tigershark on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @02:44PM (#24124164)
I guess that when the market will finally correct because of all the mess that we are having in 2020 their salary may get quite a downturn if they are including the increasing values of the stock market as part of their compensation..
Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by Phlarp on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:28PM (#24123005)
>* General equity appreciation due to a bull market

This one can theoretically cut both directions

Re:Developer won’t get hit by a bus, they’ll get hired by Ne... by outworlder on Tuesday August 11, 2020 @01:51PM (#24123396)
Theoretically. In practice, for the past century, there has been only one direction, provided you are patient.