News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by nexuist on Sunday August 09, 2020 @11:29AM (#24100207)
This could be solved by a carbon tax. If the company lied about their emissions and got caught, you could retroactively charge them to make up for the difference, and then any profit they would have gained from skirting the regulations would be nullified. Other businesses would see this new environment and adapt or die.

American businesses don't avoid (domestic) child labor because it's illegal, they avoid it because the potential charges for getting caught make the whole endeavor unprofitable.

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by toast0 on Sunday August 09, 2020 @06:23PM (#24103471)
> This could be solved by a carbon tax. If the company lied about their emissions and got caught, you could retroactively charge them to make up for the difference

In this case, they were emitting less carbon than advertised. Should we pay them a refund?

Details: outside of test scenarios, the engine control system ran the engine hotter and with less diesel emissions fluid which resulted in better fuel efficiency (less carbon) and more conversion of atmospheric nitrogen and oxygen to Nitrogen Oxides (bad for people).

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by the_gipsy on Sunday August 09, 2020 @12:10PM (#24100556)
But ze Arbeitplätze! (Jobs). German government is extremely entrenched with the automobile industry. Only slaps on the wrist, but it's probably profitable to risk breaking the law.

Maybe these executives should be prosecuted hard for their decisions.

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by amelius on Sunday August 09, 2020 @12:31PM (#24100714)
> This could be solved by a carbon tax. If the company lied about their emissions and got caught, you could retroactively charge them to make up for the difference, and then any profit they would have gained from skirting the regulations would be nullified.

Yeah, but what if the CEOs moved on? Or secured their profits?

I think carbon tax is the way to go, but on top of that we need criminal justice.

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by JumpCrisscross on Sunday August 09, 2020 @12:35PM (#24100748)
> Or secured their profits?

What does this mean within the context of tax evasion?

> we need criminal justice

There is a reason Al Capone was booked on tax evasion. Showing an executive wilfully defrauded a test is difficult. Responsibility is too diffuse. Proving tax fraud is much easier—executives personally sign off on books.

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by xiphias2 on Sunday August 09, 2020 @02:12PM (#24101604)
Only criminal cases are usually prosecuted on the personal level.

Imagine if somebody proposed taxing terrorist organizations for killing people. When they get caught, the CEO would get his bonus and retire, the organization would either go bankrupt or bailed out by the government because of its importance, and a VP could register the next company, hiring all his ex-colleagues who were just executing company orders.

Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by yadco on Sunday August 09, 2020 @04:51PM (#24102804)
Such a tax would affect the poor the most.
Re:Former VW Executive Is Arrested in Croatia in Emissions Case by 0xdeadb00f on Sunday August 09, 2020 @05:03PM (#24102882)
How?

I imagine the money from taxing power companies and such could go back into helping pay a portion of the bills of those who've had their rates increased.