This works to the extent that it works. But one of the big applications for a sufficiently cheap grid battery would be to store generation from solar to be used at night.
A large fraction of the nighttime load is for heat and light, because night is when it's cold and dark. It can't really be shifted into the daytime.
And another obvious use for a grid battery is to take advantage of that same demand pricing by buying power when it's cheap and selling when it's not.
The heat can be. Heat can be stored in the thermal mass of the house itself, and thermal mass can be added in the form of rocks.
With the advent of LED lights, the lighting bill isn't that much anymore.
They felt out of fashion because apparently they were hard to use as you cannot control how the heat is released. Charge them too much and you will have to open windows the next day wasting energy, charge them too little and you will have to turn them on during the day when the electricity is expensive.
Far as I get the actual price of electricity varies a lot, so there potentially a lot of arbitrage to exploit. There's a dozen ways to store energy with varying amount of round trip efficiency, capital costs, and operating costs. Some set of technologies will win out in that space.
I suspect one reason these technologies aren't well developed is because historically the cheapest is baseload power produced by coal and nuke plants. Economically the price is actually subsidized. So utilities did not want knuckleheads buying their cheap power at night and selling it during the day.
I'm quoting from a memory of an article I read about 6 months ago, sorry.
googling for "specific heat high energy storage material" seems to indicate that rock-type materials are used where air heat is required.
So I'm not doubting you, just wondering why an intermediary heat storage medium is preferred in practice. Maybe for some of the same reasons as the sauna.
Have one large industrial factory like an aluminium smelter or steel plant that is redesigned in a way that it can shift its electricity use a little bit? That's probably having an effect larger than a lot of personal users.
I guess there's a political issue here, as industry often pays very little for electricity to begin with. I know at lesat in Germany most large industries are excluded from a lot of fees that normal customers pay. Providing "cheap and reliable electricity" to industry is often almost a political mantra. I guess it would make sense to say at some point: "Dear industry, you can have cheap electricity, you can have reliable electricity, but you can't have both. If you want to have it cheap you have to support the grid by providing flexibility."
It isn't some mustache twirling plot to make the consumer pay more while some abstract industrial fat cat pays more or anything - real economics are at play.
The prevailing obvious alternative to competitive pricing that tries to roll in other expenses would be direct generation by industrial scales running their own fossil fuel turbines or direct thermal alternatives. Which result in worse performance at scale from everyone mid-sized and up rolling their own separate systems and worse pollution control as instead of having four great smokestacks to put scrubbers on and regulate there are now four thousand small ones. Economies of scale have been here for centuries.
Aluminum smelters and steel plants while they may use a lot of power also cannot be just neglected and cut off mid-cycle without wasting a very large batch slag in a way that is very expensive to clean up.
Both need to hold their temperature as long as possible and get up(or down) to temperate at some balance point between speed and efficiency. I want my provider to even it out and set a reasonable price between the variable extremes so I don't have to think about it.
The advantages are a lower rate and a guaranteed 8 hours straight on-time per day.
Of course, the actual implementations can (and in many cases have) been a lot worse than that.
You're not thinking capitalistically enough.
The fact that IoT is still a running joke and just a tolerated parasite to lower the sticker price at best is proof that the data is garbage because none of them are making much money off of it. Until they have an actual monetiziation plan for the data it is plain magical thinking.
"People mostly increase demand on their hot water heater in the early morning, evening, and night for showers dishwashers, and laundry on a semi-weekly, weekly, or bi-weekly basis."
"Well I could have told you that without spending six to seven figures on unnecessary expenses on a product line!"
Call it what it is: exploitation.
Greet and fraud are encouraged, if not idealised.
That’s not capitalism fault though.
Every other form of economic policy has the same problem, so it can’t be those systems in and of themselves that are the sole issue.
Might.
And probably trivially more, especially when you factor in a software update bricking your fridge and the manufacturer has conveniently disappeared / gone bankrupt / changed hands so many times no one knows who supports it.
You’re assuming an ideal world, which can’t possibly happen.
This was more of a method of managing peak load, however, still seems applicable.
So whether it's a tank of 80°C water or a tank of 65°C water make no difference to the 38°C water coming out of the thermostatic mixer in your shower.
I don't have the regulations to hand but it's enough to bring it to a high temperature once every few days for some period of time (to kill the bacteria that cause legionnaires disease).
Don't things like water heaters and fridge compressors run many times a day. Is shifting all that to night hours even feasible simply because the appliance is smart?
Even still, wouldn't randomly fuzzed automation times be easier to implement than an fully connected system?
I suspect in this area they would get more flies with honey by letting them use power cheaper when they want to get rid of it. A "free/cheap power" signal essentially that tells any device which wants it to disregard efficiency - any utility is better than nothing.
Power banking batteries are the trivially obvious way to exploit and monetize it while fortunately stabilizing the grid as a side effect but well the infastructure costs are expensive.
Fuzzing would be easier to implement assuming the fuzz period is meaningful on a time scale without causing other problems like "power cycle it if it doesn't come on in twenty five seconds" because the end user/technician rightfully thinks it isn't working and when it rolls 5 second delay next time it gets a faster end boot.
Somebody correct me if im wrong
What do you mean? Fridges generally run at the highest reasonable temperature. Are you proposing adding more thermal mass to them?
That's a very narrow range. You might be able to pre-cool the freezer, and use some of its cold to keep the fridge where it needs to be.
But I suspect you would pay for that in lower efficiency, because the colder you need to go the less efficient the cooling is.
Electricity prices would have to be dramatically lower to make it worth taking your freezer extremely low to store cold.
I suppose you could make a freezer with a special water storage compartment (filled at home to reduce weight), then use that to store cold. But with the extra complexity, and lower efficiency.... just how much lower electrical prices are we talking?
“Receive SMS alerts whenever prices drop below zero, or use our API to program your smart devices.”
The way stuff like this works, is that with a fairly simple set of end-point power controland some pretty simple monitoring, and then some central smart software, you can effect pretty dramatic improvements.
For example, the smart controller allows the fridge temperature to drift (just a little), similarly with central heating, and geyser, and the net effect is that power draw is temporarily reduced during peak times.
Multiply this over your whole year and you have some cost savings.
Multiply it over a whole neighbourhood, and the utility can dramatically reduce their cost of maintenace, and their cost of deployed capital.
(Because of reduced power/thermal swings in their equipment, and reduced peak carrying capacity of the network)
Your home is a "battery" as you can run the temperature of your hot water heater higher when electricity is cheaper, and let it "coast" when electricity is more expensive. You still have hot water on demand.
The same goes for the refrigerator, heating system and the cooling system. This can be made even more effective by increasing the thermal mass of the house, for example, with a pile of rocks. Pretty cheap for a battery, don't you think?
And, of course, there's charging your car when electricity is cheaper.
At last, we actually have a use for the Internet-of-things - an internet device on your hotwater heater to query the current price of electricity.
Pretty darned cheap for a grid battery.